The ultimate hunt for the best pizza in Medford, NY is not for the faint of heart—or for anyone who thinks all slices are created equal. Anyone with a fondness for gooey cheese or the perfect crackle of a crispy crust understands that a quality pie is memorable. My own initiation into Medford’s pizza scene happened on a cold evening, when a local sent me to a family-run spot tucked next to a laundromat. The pizza was nothing short of a revelation. Every detail—from the faint char on the edge to the balanced sauce—had a story to tell. If you have ever savored a slice that forced you to pause mid-bite, then you know the feeling.
Medford’s pizza places are as diverse as their patrons. Some pay homage to classic New York styles, while others put a creative spin on tradition. Whether your taste leans toward a no-nonsense Margherita or something a little more daring, there’s a destination here that fits. If you’re lost in indecision or simply hungry for the right spot, settle in. Each pizzeria on this list brings a unique flavor to the table—and by the time you finish, you’ll have a reliable hit list for your next craving.
Where to find the best pizza in Medford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Medford, NY:
- Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
- Medford Pastaria
- La Margherita Pizzeria
- Tony’s Pizza
- Victorious Pizzeria & Ristorante
- Mama Bella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Gianna’s Pizzeria
- Pizza Corner
- Genova’s Pizza & Pastaria
- Pizza Hut Express
1. Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta strikes a balance between timeless charm and inventive flair. Tucked on Patchogue Yaphank Road, this spot feels like a spirited family kitchen with staff who remember your order and neighbors trading stories over dinner.
My first encounter here involved a piping hot Margherita pie. The crust—crisp and slightly smoky—set the foundation, but it was the tangy sauce and generous layer of cheese that kept me reaching for another slice. Their menu highlights both classic and signature pizzas, and the Sicilian slice stands out for its thick, airy base and unmistakable homemade taste.
Those who appreciate fresh ingredients will enjoy Cafe Gia’s commitment to quality. Go for their Margherita or Sicilian slices to taste what sets this neighborhood pizzeria apart.
2. Medford Pastaria
Medford Pastaria brings a classic Italian touch to Horseblock Road, blending warmth with unfussy, homestyle flavors. The moment you walk in, the hum of conversation and the aroma from the ovens make it clear this is a beloved local haunt.
My first visit left a mark—the thin-crust Margherita was bright and fresh, with basil that tasted like it had just been picked. Their pizza dough is light and crisp, yet sturdy enough to hold their generous toppings. It’s the kind of slice you finish before you realize you’ve picked up another.
Try their white pizza or a traditional Margherita. Both showcase Medford Pastaria’s knack for delivering simple, honest flavor and consistent quality in every bite.
3. La Margherita Pizzeria
La Margherita Pizzeria is the sort of place you find by word of mouth—and then wonder why you didn’t sooner. The setting is casual but inviting, and there’s a homey buzz about the place. My own initiation came with their namesake pie, a classic Margherita.
Each slice is a lesson in balance—cheese to sauce, crust to toppings— handled with obvious care. Their gluten-free options actually taste like pizza, not an afterthought, so everyone gets to enjoy the experience.
Order the Margherita or their signature veggie pie. Both represent what La Margherita does best: fresh flavors, attention to detail, and an unmistakable neighborhood warmth in every slice.
4. Tony’s Pizza
Tony’s Pizza on Route 112 has that uniquely New York energy: it’s both fast-paced and friendly, where you can grab a pie on a busy night or linger over a few slices with friends. My first night at Tony’s involved a late pick-up, and I remember how the air crackled with the smell of baking dough, hinting at something good ahead.
Their crust hits the sweet spot between crisp and chewy, making every bite satisfying, but never heavy. The attention to sauce ratio is well judged, and the cheese always tastes fresh and layered, not greasy.
Go straight for the plain cheese or veggie pie. Both showcase Tony’s respect for quality ingredients and unpretentious, traditional pizza flavors that have kept loyal customers coming back for years.
5. Victorious Pizzeria & Ristorante
Victorious Pizzeria & Ristorante has quietly built a loyal following on Route 112, thanks to over thirty years of tradition and a warm, no-nonsense atmosphere. From my first visit, it felt like a place where regulars are genuinely greeted and newcomers get immediate, friendly service.
This spot blends Italian and Greek influences, but pizza is front and center. The dough here is airy but sturdy, with just the right amount of chew. Their sauce holds a subtle tang, enhancing every fresh topping without overpowering anything.
Their classic Margherita and veggie pies reflect the kitchen’s commitment to quality and flavor. For a taste of what long-standing Medford locals love, start with these slices.
6. Mama Bella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Mama Bella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is the sort of place that feels like a neighborhood staple the moment you walk through the door. The vibe is relaxed, with friendly chatter drifting over the scent of bubbling cheese and fresh herbs. My first visit involved sliding into a booth and being greeted with genuine warmth—a refreshing touch that carries through every visit.
The pizza here has a loyal following for good reason. Each pie has a crust that manages to be both crisp and tender, never floppy or dull. The sauce is well-balanced and the toppings taste like they’ve just been chopped to order.
Consider their Margherita or a classic veggie slice. Each bite is hearty, flavorful, and exactly what you’d hope for from an old-school pizzeria with a modern twist.
7. Gianna’s Pizzeria
+1 631-207-0981
Gianna’s Pizzeria is easy to miss if you’re speeding down Route 112, but locals know its sign as a signal for hot, satisfying pizza. My visit here came on a rainy afternoon, when the craving for a comforting slice was impossible to ignore. The warm greeting and the unmistakable aroma invited me to settle in for something special.
The pizza here is classic and straightforward, done right every time. The dough is always fresh, delivering a sturdy base for well-seasoned tomato sauce and a satisfying stretch of cheese. There’s no fuss, just good flavor and consistency you can trust.
Try their plain cheese or white pizza. Both are reliable choices that reveal Gianna’s dedication to quality ingredients and the timeless comfort of a well-made pie.
8. Pizza Corner
Pizza Corner anchors the end of a shopping strip on Route 112, and it’s the kind of reliable spot you find yourself craving after a long day. On my first stop, a quick lunch order turned into an unexpectedly satisfying meal. The staff moved quickly, but not at the expense of being friendly or attentive.
Pizzas come out piping hot, with a crust that manages crisp edges and a soft center—a tough balance to strike. The tomato sauce is bright, layered with just enough basil and oregano to keep every bite interesting. This place is also easy for groups, so it’s a favorite for sharing with friends.
Order their Margherita or veggie pie to sample how Pizza Corner delivers time-tested flavors while focusing on freshness and a satisfying bite every time.
9. Genova’s Pizza & Pastaria
Genova’s Pizza & Pastaria has a loyal following for its inviting atmosphere and consistent pies. The corner location on Route 112 makes it an easy stop, whether you’re winding down after work or rounding up friends for a casual meal. On my first visit, the aroma of baking dough greeted me before the door even closed behind me.
The pizzas here balance classic flavors with a little extra heart, thanks to fresh mozzarella and a smooth, well-seasoned sauce. It’s the kind of pizza you remember long after the last slice is gone.
The plain cheese or Sicilian pie showcases Genova’s strength: a comforting, reliable pie that never skimps on quality or taste—always served hot, with just the right amount of crunch.
10. Pizza Hut Express
Pizza Hut Express at Kings Medford C-store offers a familiar stop for when you need a quick slice on the go. It’s convenient, reliable, and there’s a certain comfort in knowing exactly what to expect—even when you’re far from home. My first visit was on a road trip, when a fast yet satisfying bite was all I needed to keep going.
This spot shines for straightforward, classic pizzas that are ready in minutes. The crust is soft, the cheese pulls just right, and every slice is exactly the same every time. If consistency is what you’re after, Pizza Hut Express delivers with no fuss.
Stick with the personal pan cheese or veggie pizza. Their familiar flavor is perfect for a no-surprises, satisfying meal when you’re in a hurry or just craving the classics.
More Things to Try in Medford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Medford, NY?
Most pizzerias in Medford serve classic New York-style thin-crust pizza, though you’ll also find Sicilian squares and specialty pies at several spots.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Medford?
Yes, several places offer vegetarian or even vegan options. You’ll find veggie-loaded pies at most local pizzerias and dedicated vegan cheese at a few.
Which pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza in Medford?
Some spots, like La Margherita Pizzeria, feature gluten-free crusts. It’s always best to call ahead to make sure, as offerings can change.
Can I get pizza delivered in Medford?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias in town provide delivery, including Medford Pastaria, Tony’s Pizza, and others. Delivery areas and minimums may vary.
What’s the best pizza for a large group or party?
Sicilian pies and large cheese pizzas are crowd-pleasers at places like Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta and Genova’s Pizza & Pastaria. They’re easy to share and travel well.