Pizza in McCall, Idaho is more than just a quick dinner after a day on the lake or slopes; it’s practically a rite of passage. The first time I bit into a gooey, wood-fired slice on a chilly mountain night, I realized it’s not hype—locals here have strong opinions, and for good reason. Every pizzeria puts its own stamp on the classics, blending small-town creativity with serious craftsmanship.
If you’re searching for the best pizza in McCall, you’re not alone. There’s a hidden pizza culture thriving behind rustic storefronts and friendly banter, and it’s worth exploring. This guide cuts through the tourist chatter to spotlight where your next favorite slice is waiting. Whether you’re after a family-friendly dinner or the perfect pie to fuel your next adventure, you’ll find the answers here.
1. Hometown Pizza
Hometown Pizza sits quietly on Deinhard Lane, but there’s nothing subtle about the flavors here. The dough is baked just right: chewy in the middle, crisp on the edges. When I visited, the scent of baking garlic and cheese pulled me in before I’d even read the menu.
The real standout is their “McCall Special”—a hearty pie stacked with tangy tomato sauce, bell peppers, mushrooms, and a generous layer of mozzarella. Their veggie options are fresh and loaded, ideal if you want something lighter but still full-flavored.
The staff bring a warmth that makes you feel like a local by the time you leave. For a true taste of McCall, order a classic Margherita or the Veggie Delight. Every bite feels like comfort—simple, really good pizza, the way it should be.
2. Growler’s Pizza Grill
Growler’s Pizza Grill is the kind of place where everyone finds something to love, even early risers. I remember cozying up by the wood stove on a frosty morning, working through a slice of their legendary breakfast pizza. Every bite tasted homemade and distinctly local.
The crusts here are crisp but never dry, and toppings are piled high with confidence. Their Garden Veggie Pizza is bright and colorful, layered with thoughtful touches like artichoke hearts and roasted peppers.
If you prefer your lunch with a bit of a twist, stop by for their signature breakfast hash or gluten-free crust options. For a true Growler’s experience, the Veggie or Margherita pizzas pair perfectly with the mountain views and relaxed vibe.
3. Toll Station Pizza
Toll Station Pizza brings a dose of old-school charm to McCall with its hand-thrown crusts and no-frills approach to quality. Stepping in feels a bit like uncovering a cozy, time-honored secret—and after a lively afternoon outdoors, nothing beats sitting down to a warm, custom-made pie.
The crust is always made to order—chewy, golden, and lightly crisped. Their veggie pizza layers on bell peppers, ripe tomatoes, and mushrooms for a fresh, balanced bite that never feels heavy.
Don’t skip their salad bar, packed with crisp greens and a casual, all-you-can-eat attitude. Round out the meal with their cookies and milk dessert, a small touch that feels like someone looking after you. The blend of familiar flavors with a welcoming spirit is where Toll Station truly shines.
4. Crusty’s Pizza
Crusty’s Pizza is the kind of hidden gem that tourists might walk right past if they aren’t paying attention. My first visit involved a sun-drenched patio, a laughter-filled crowd, and a slice that surprised me with generous toppings and plenty of heart.
What sets Crusty’s apart is the ultrathin, crispy crust and their willingness to load pies with bold flavors. The Veggie Lover’s Pizza combines fresh mushrooms, peppers, and onions with a tangy tomato sauce that never overshadows the vegetables.
With outdoor seating that invites casual lingering, Crusty’s becomes an easy place to unwind after a day exploring town. For a signature taste, order the Margherita or their House Veggie. Simple, unfussy, and always satisfying.
5. Home Town Pizza
(208) 634-2596Call
Home Town Pizza stays true to its name with a no-fuss, down-to-earth vibe that feels instantly familiar. When I dropped in, the staff treated me like a regular and the space buzzed with local energy. This is the kind of spot where pizza is made to satisfy, not just impress.
The dough comes out soft in the middle with an edge that adds just the right bite. Their Veggie Supreme stands out, loaded with fresh bell peppers, olives, and gooey cheese—every topping easily identifiable in both flavor and color.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick takeout or settling in for a slow evening meal, Home Town Pizza delivers comfort in every box. For a classic experience, try their Margherita or the Garden Special. Here, you get honest pizza that’s all about quality and consistency.
6. Danielle’s Blue Moose Pizza
(208) 634-8646Call
Danielle’s Blue Moose Pizza charms with a quirky name and a reputation for creativity that’s easy to taste. My first slice was bursting with personality—think crisp vegetables and cheese that stretches for days, all piled onto a dough that stays light and airy.
What really makes this place special is their local flair and commitment to freshness. The Veggie Moose pizza is a local legend, featuring a rainbow of peppers, ripe tomatoes, and just enough garlic to keep things interesting.
Whether you’re in for a whole pie or just a quick slice on the go, Danielle’s Blue Moose is welcoming and fast. For first-timers, the Margherita is always a strong choice. Here, every pizza feels like it’s crafted with real care and a sense of fun.
7. Brown’s Mountain Market
Brown’s Mountain Market may look like your average roadside stop, but locals know it hides some of the area’s best pizza surprises. My pit stop here turned into a full meal, with a slice that tasted far fresher than I ever expected from a market.
Their pies are thick, cheesy, and always baked to a golden finish. The Veggie Pizza is noteworthy: crisp bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and ripe tomatoes layered over a bubbling cheese blend. Every bite has a hint of that home-baked flavor.
If you’re passing through New Meadows, don’t pass up their takeout counter for an easy, tasty dinner. Brown’s proves that even a market can serve up memorable pizza, perfect for road trips or easy picnic fare.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in McCall are vegetarian friendly?
Most local pizzerias, such as Hometown Pizza, Growler’s Pizza Grill, and Toll Station Pizza, offer vegetarian pizza options loaded with fresh, flavorful toppings.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in McCall?
Yes, several spots including Growler’s Pizza Grill and Toll Station Pizza offer gluten-free crusts. Call ahead to confirm availability if you have dietary needs.
Is there takeout or delivery pizza available in McCall?
Takeout is widely available at nearly every pizza shop in McCall. While most focus on takeout, delivery options may be limited—check with each place or consider local delivery apps.
Which McCall pizza place is best for families?
Hometown Pizza and Toll Station Pizza are popular for groups and families, thanks to their comfortable seating and relaxed atmosphere.
Where can I find unique pizza flavors in McCall?
Danielle’s Blue Moose Pizza and Crusty’s Pizza are known for creative combinations, including their signature veggie blends and playful toppings.