Lynchburg, VA, is not just a charming college town; it’s also a hidden gem for pizza lovers. With a variety of pizzerias offering everything from classic slices to gourmet creations, there’s something to satisfy every craving. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite after a day exploring the scenic trails or a cozy dinner spot with friends, Lynchburg’s pizza scene has you covered. Having sampled many of these local delights, I can assure you that each slice tells a story and caters to diverse tastes.
From fire-roasted flavors to artisanal crusts, the options are endless. Perhaps you’re craving the bold toppings of a wood-fired pie or the comforting familiar taste of a classic cheese pizza. Whatever your preference, this list of the best pizza joints in Lynchburg will help you navigate the delicious choices available. Let’s dive into the pizzerias that have earned the hearts (and appetites) of locals and visitors alike.
Where to find the best pizza in Lynchburg, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lynchburg, VA:
- Waterstone Fire Roasted Pizza
- Blaze Pizza
- La Villa Da Toto
- Rivermont Pizza
- Benny Scarpetta’s
- Vinny’s Italian Grill
- Upper Crust Pizza Company
- Ledo Pizza
- Mellow Mushroom Lynchburg
- Jo Jo Pizza Lynchburg
1. Waterstone Fire Roasted Pizza
Nestled in the heart of historic Lynchburg, Waterstone Fire Roasted Pizza offers a warm, inviting experience that goes beyond your typical pizza night. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of wood-fired crust and fresh herbs sets the stage for an unforgettable meal.
What truly sets Waterstone apart is its commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their pizzas are fire-roasted to perfection, with a crisp yet chewy crust that’s hard to beat. I vividly remember the first bite of their Margherita Pizza—simple, elegant, and bursting with flavor.
For something bold, try the Mediterranean Pizza—a vegetarian favorite that showcases their creativity. Paired with a side of their gluten-free pasta, it’s a meal everyone can enjoy.
Whether you’re vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free, Waterstone’s inclusive menu ensures no one is left out.
2. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is a game changer for pizza lovers seeking quality without the wait. Located on Wards Road, this fast-casual spot impresses with its unique assembly-line style, allowing diners to craft their own personal pizzas loaded with over 30 toppings. On a recent visit, I was struck by the vibrant atmosphere and the friendly staff, each one a dedicated “pizzasmith” ready to bring your pizza vision to life.
What sets Blaze apart is their lightning-fast process—each pizza spends just 180 seconds in a blazing hot oven, resulting in a perfectly crisp crust. I highly recommend trying the White Top Pizza, which combines cheeses and garlic for a deliciously rich flavor.
With options for gluten-free crusts and vegan toppings, Blaze Pizza ensures everyone can join the feast, making it a top choice in Lynchburg.
3. La Villa Da Toto
Located on Timberlake Road, La Villa Da Toto is a hidden gem that elevates the Italian dining experience in Lynchburg. Stepping into this inviting restaurant, you instantly feel the warmth of genuine hospitality. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere create a perfect backdrop for a delightful meal.
What distinguishes La Villa Da Toto is its ability to blend traditional Italian recipes with a modern touch. Their pizzas are crafted with care, featuring fresh ingredients. On my last visit, I enjoyed the Truffle Pizza, drizzled with truffle oil and topped with savory mushrooms, creating a rich, luxurious flavor.
With options for vegetarians and gluten-free diets, La Villa Da Toto ensures everyone can indulge in their delicious offerings.
4. Rivermont Pizza
Rivermont Pizza, located on Rivermont Avenue, offers a laid-back vibe that perfectly complements its delicious menu. This spot is a favorite among locals not just for its pizza, but for the welcoming atmosphere that makes it a great hangout for friends and family. With options for lunch, dinner, and even late-night cravings, Rivermont ensures you’re never too far from a good slice.
What makes Rivermont Pizza stand out is the balance of classic and unique offerings. Their Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a must-try; it’s spicy, savory, and truly satisfying. Plus, the crispy crust pairs perfectly with the tangy sauce.
With vegetarian and vegan options available, Rivermont Pizza caters to diverse dietary preferences, ensuring everyone walks away happy.
5. Benny Scarpetta’s
Benny Scarpetta’s sits quaintly on Main Street, offering a taste of authentic Italian cuisine amidst Lynchburg’s bustling atmosphere. The cozy setting, combined with welcoming service, makes you feel right at home. I had the pleasure of visiting during a lunch break, and the vibrant energy in the restaurant instantly lifted my spirits.
What sets Benny Scarpetta’s apart is their attention to detail; each dish is crafted with care. Their Margherita Pizza is a delightful blend of fresh mozzarella, basil, and a perfectly baked crust, embodying simplicity and flavor.
With options for vegetarian diners, this spot ensures everyone can enjoy a satisfying meal. Takeout is also a breeze, making it a great choice for any occasion.
6. Vinny’s Italian Grill
Vinny’s Italian Grill in Lynchburg, VA, is a charming eatery that offers a delightful blend of Italian classics and modern culinary twists. Conveniently located at 4018 Wards Rd, this restaurant is beloved for its vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free options, catering to a variety of dietary needs.
A visit to Vinny’s is always a memorable experience. The warm, inviting atmosphere, coupled with exceptional service, makes it a perfect spot for both lunch and dinner. The staff’s dedication to customer satisfaction is evident in every interaction.
Vinny’s stands out for its authentic Italian pizzas. One must-try is the Margherita Pizza—a harmonious blend of fresh mozzarella, basil, and a perfectly seasoned tomato sauce. For a unique twist, the Pesto Chicken Pizza offers a delightful combination of flavors that’s sure to impress.
For an authentic taste of Italy in Lynchburg, Vinny’s Italian Grill is the place to be. Don’t miss out on their exquisite pizzas, a testament to their commitment to quality and tradition.
7. Upper Crust Pizza Company
Upper Crust Pizza Company is a beloved spot located at 102 Hexham Dr, perfect for satisfying your pizza cravings. The inviting ambience and friendly staff make it an enjoyable place for lunch or dinner. I remember stopping by after a long day and being greeted with warm smiles and delicious aromas wafting from the kitchen.
What sets Upper Crust apart is their commitment to quality ingredients and customer satisfaction. Their pizza is made from scratch, ensuring a fresh and flavorful experience. One standout option is the BBQ Chicken Pizza, which combines tangy barbecue sauce with perfectly grilled chicken, red onions, and cilantro.
For convenience, they offer both delivery and takeout options, making it easy to enjoy their delicious offerings wherever you are. If you’re in Lynchburg, be sure to check out Upper Crust Pizza Company; it’s a local favorite for a reason.
8. Ledo Pizza
Ledo Pizza in Lynchburg, VA, is a must-visit destination for lovers of delicious, handcrafted meals. Known for its signature square pizza, Ledo Pizza offers a unique take on traditional pies with its flaky, thin crust and perfectly balanced sauce. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, or catering a special event, this spot guarantees a memorable experience for every occasion.
What sets Ledo Pizza apart is its diverse menu—from hearty subs and flavorful wings to fresh salads, soups, and pasta dishes. Families will appreciate their kid-friendly options, and vegetarians will find plenty to enjoy as well. Ledo Pizza is the perfect choice for everything from casual dinners to big celebrations, thanks to their exceptional catering services.
If you’re visiting, be sure to try their iconic Pepperoni Pizza, topped with crispy, edge-to-edge pepperoni slices. Their Veggie Pizza is another standout—a colorful medley of fresh vegetables layered over their signature crust. Each bite reflects Ledo’s commitment to quality and flavor, making it a local favorite in Lynchburg.
Ledo Pizza isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience. With warm service, a welcoming atmosphere, and dishes crafted to perfection, it’s a place where great food creates lasting memories.
9. Mellow Mushroom Lynchburg
Mellow Mushroom Lynchburg at 1220 Greenview Drive offers a unique dining experience with creatively inspired stone-baked pizzas, wings, fresh salads, burgers, craft beers, and cocktails. Whether you prefer dining in, ordering online, or catering for an event, Mellow Mushroom ensures a delightful meal.
During my visit, I was struck by the cozy yet vibrant atmosphere. The staff’s friendliness and the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza made for an unforgettable experience.
What sets Mellow Mushroom Lynchburg apart is their commitment to quality and creativity. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients and a touch of innovation, making every bite a flavorful journey.
Must-try dishes include the classic Mighty Meaty Pizza and the Holy Shiitake Pie. These pizzas showcase Mellow Mushroom’s dedication to bold flavors and high-quality ingredients. For a true taste of Lynchburg, these dishes are a must.
10. Jo Jo Pizza Lynchburg
Jo Jo Pizza Lynchburg, located at 1400 Lakeside Dr, has been a staple of the local pizza scene since 1977. Known for their generous portions and commitment to high-quality ingredients, this restaurant excels at delivering a satisfying dining experience. It’s a place where families and friends gather to enjoy classic Italian fare.
What makes Jo Jo Pizza stand out is its rich history and dedication to customer satisfaction. The friendly staff ensures that each guest feels valued, contributing to a warm and inviting atmosphere.
A must-try here is the Jo Jo Special Pizza, loaded with a variety of toppings that reflect the local flavor. Pair it with their fresh garden salad for a well-rounded meal that’s sure to satisfy.
For convenience, Jo Jo Pizza offers delivery and takeout options, making it a great choice for those on the go. If you’re in Lynchburg, this pizzeria should be at the top of your list.
More Things to Try in Lynchburg, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are some popular pizza places in Lynchburg, VA?
Some of the most popular pizza spots include Waterstone Fire Roasted Pizza, Blaze Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Jo Jo Pizza. Each offers a unique menu and atmosphere that cater to different tastes.
2. Is there vegetarian or vegan pizza in Lynchburg?
Yes, many pizzerias in Lynchburg, such as Blaze Pizza and Mellow Mushroom, offer vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a delicious meal.
3. Can I find gluten-free pizza options in Lynchburg?
Absolutely. Several restaurants, including Waterstone Fire Roasted Pizza and Blaze Pizza, provide gluten-free crust options on their menus for those with dietary restrictions.
4. Do any pizza places in Lynchburg offer delivery?
Yes, many pizzerias like Domino’s, Jo Jo Pizza, and Mellow Mushroom offer delivery, making it easy to enjoy your favorite pizza at home.
5. What is the best pizza sauce in Lynchburg?
Preferences for pizza sauce vary widely among individuals. However, many locals rave about the house-made sauces at places like La Villa Da Toto and Mellow Mushroom, noting their rich flavors and freshness.
6. Are there any pizza places in Lynchburg for large groups or events?
Yes, many pizzerias, including Ledo Pizza and Benny Scarpetta’s, offer catering services and are well-suited for larger gatherings or events.