Finding the best pizza in Lubbock, TX shouldn’t feel like picking a random box off a grocery store shelf. Every spot in this city serves up a personality as distinct as the flavors on your plate. During my latest trip, I mapped out slices across town, determined to separate the hype from the truly irresistible. I was greeted by bubbling cheese, friendly faces, and crusts that somehow made waiting for the next bite more exciting than actually finishing the slice.
If you’re someone who reads an online menu for sport or debates thin versus thick crust like it’s a life choice, you’re in the right place. This guide brings you the lowdown on the pies you need to try, from old-school favorites to creative newcomers. No marketing fluff, no unnecessary drama—just Lubbock’s pizza landscape through the eyes of someone who takes every slice seriously. Ready to explore the tastiest corners in town?
Where to find the best pizza in Lubbock, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lubbock, TX:
- One Guy From Italy University
- Orlando’s Italian Restaurant
- Italian Garden
- Dario’s Pizza And Calzone
- Pie Five Pizza
- Capital Pizza
- Dion’s Pizza
- Giorgio’s Pizza
- Papa V Pizza
- One Guy From Italy Family Restaurant
1. One Guy From Italy University
One Guy From Italy University has a neighborhood feel with a slice of Italy right in the heart of Lubbock. The aroma of freshly baked dough greets you before you even reach the door, hinting at what’s inside. My last visit turned a simple dinner into a ritual—eating here puts you in the pizza zone.
Their cheese pizza dances between chewy and crispy, striking that crave-worthy balance. For something heartier, the veggie pizza piles on the toppings without overwhelming the crust. If you like variety, try the pizza by the slice—each wedge comes piping hot and feels made just for you.
One Guy From Italy University is also known for being vegetarian- and vegan-friendly, making it a place almost everyone can enjoy. Call ahead or drop in, but always come hungry.
2. Orlando’s Italian Restaurant
Orlando’s Italian Restaurant brings its signature Tex-Italian flavor to Lubbock, and you can taste the experience that comes with decades in business. This place dials up comfort and nostalgia—the kind of spot where families linger and conversations stretch out over second slices. My visits here have always ended with a satisfied sigh and a mental note to return soon.
Orlando’s stands out for its creative twist on the classics. Their “Tex-Italian” supreme pizza is a conversation starter: loaded with fresh veggies, classic cheese, and a zesty sauce that sets it apart from the usual lineup. The gluten-free and vegan pizza options aren’t afterthoughts—they’re full of flavor and care.
Order the pepperoni and jalapeño pizza if you’re curious about local flavor. One bite and you get that Lubbock spirit, warm and bold, on a thin yet sturdy crust. This is a pizza that proves tradition and adventure can share a table.
3. Italian Garden
Italian Garden offers a warm, brick-walled retreat in downtown Lubbock, perfect for anyone serious about their pie. This family-run spot feels like a friendly secret locals want to keep to themselves. Each time I’ve visited, the friendly buzz of regulars and the scent of herbs set the mood right.
What makes Italian Garden stand out is their focus on classic quality—no shortcuts, just well-made food. Their Margherita pizza deserves bragging rights, thanks to a thin, crackling crust and a light touch of homemade sauce. The veggie pizza bursts with color and freshness, ideal for a cozy lunch or easy dinner.
If you want a custom touch, try building your own pie. They’re generous with toppings and cater to vegetarian and gluten-free needs, so every pizza gets personal attention. Italian Garden is all about honest flavors in a relaxed setting.
4. Dario’s Pizza And Calzone
Dario’s Pizza And Calzone feels like a best-kept secret for anyone craving handcrafted pies on Lubbock’s west side. There’s an inviting, no-rush vibe that makes every meal here memorable. I stopped by on a quiet afternoon, only to discover their pizza lives up to its steady word-of-mouth reputation.
The standout at Dario’s is the hand-stretched dough, baked to chewy perfection with just the right char along the edges. Their classic cheese pizza highlights the quality of their ingredients, while veggie lovers should try the garden vegetable pizza, loaded with colorful produce.
For something different, order a calzone—its golden crust and gooey center are as comforting as pizza, only with a pocket twist. Dario’s delivers solid, reliable pies worth coming back for, bite after bite.
5. Pie Five Pizza
Pie Five Pizza brings a fast-casual twist to pizza in west Lubbock. You build your own personal pie from the ground up, choosing from a buffet of fresh toppings and sauces. My last visit reminded me how fun pizza can be when you call the shots—you get exactly what you want every single time.
The Urban Veggie pizza is a highlight, featuring a crisp, thin crust and a colorful mix of toppings. If you have dietary needs, Pie Five easily accommodates gluten-free or vegan requests without sacrificing flavor.
Watching your custom pizza bake in minutes is part of the appeal. Pie Five is all about customization, speed, and quality you can taste with each bite. It’s pizza your way, without the wait.
6. Capital Pizza
Capital Pizza is where creative pies meet neighborhood charm in Lubbock’s historic district. The mismatched art on the walls and the welcoming hum of conversation make you sit back and relax. My last experience included a quirky pizza pairing I never expected to want a second time—and then I did.
The Pesto Primavera pizza is what I recommend here. Its vibrant sauce and roasted veggie toppings set it apart from the crowd, delivering big flavor without feeling heavy. Capital Pizza leans into topping combinations, making even the classics taste new.
Vegetarians have plenty of choice, and the kitchen is happy to accommodate customizations. For a pizza spot that feels unique—with a crust that’s satisfyingly crisp—Capital Pizza brings something special to the table.
7. Dion’s Pizza
Dion’s Pizza wins points for being a reliable spot where friends and families can gather without a fuss. The open dining room and easygoing pace make you want to stay a little longer. Every visit I’ve made has been about low-stress comfort—perfect for laid-back evenings.
The pizza here doesn’t try too hard, which is a strength. Their classic cheese and veggie pizzas strike a balance between airy crust and generous toppings, never feeling overdone. I keep coming back for their Greek salad on the side—it’s a fresh companion to a hot pie.
If you like dressing things up, try their house ranch drizzle. Dion’s serves up satisfying, crowd-pleasing pizza in Lubbock without overcomplicating things.
8. Giorgio’s Pizza
Giorgio’s Pizza has a casual downtown vibe and doesn’t bother with frills—it’s all about the food. There’s something satisfying about grabbing a fresh slice after a long day, and Giorgio’s always delivers on that craving. The counter service is quick, and you’re usually out the door with a piping-hot box before you know it.
Their New York-style cheese pizza is the real star; the crust bends but never breaks, with a chewy bite that’s unmistakable. For a heartier meal, try the veggie slice, loaded with bright, crisp vegetables on a thin, golden base.
Giorgio’s makes uncomplicated, fulfilling pizza that people return for week after week. Sometimes, simple is exactly what you want.
9. Papa V Pizza
+1 806-317-1213
Papa V Pizza is a hidden gem tucked into a quiet corner of southwest Lubbock. The unpretentious setting puts all the attention on what’s coming out of the oven. My last visit left me surprised by just how much care goes into each pie—the flavors are genuinely homey and comforting.
Their cheese lover’s pizza stands out with a melty, golden layer that has a rich, satisfying pull with every slice. The classic veggie pizza is bright and flavorful with a crunchy crust, perfect for lunch or dinner.
Papa V doesn’t try to reinvent pizza. Instead, they keep it classic, letting fresh ingredients and a well-crafted crust do the talking. It’s a neighborhood spot you’ll want to keep coming back to.
10. One Guy From Italy Family Restaurant
One Guy From Italy Family Restaurant is a local staple, serving up old-school Italian comfort with a side of nostalgia. The dining room has that friendly, chatty energy that makes you feel like part of the family. Each visit is its own little celebration of good food and laid-back company.
The stuffed crust pizza here is a star attraction—plush, cheesy, and perfectly browned on the outside. If you want a satisfying balance of flavor and texture, try the veggie deluxe or classic cheese. Both showcase a hand-tossed crust that’s anything but ordinary.
This spot excels at consistency; every pizza comes out hot, bubbling, and generously topped, just as you’d hope. For pure comfort and authenticity in Lubbock’s pizza scene, One Guy From Italy Family Restaurant always delivers.
More Things to Try in Lubbock, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Lubbock, TX?
Some of the most popular spots include One Guy From Italy, Orlando’s Italian Restaurant, Capital Pizza, and Dion’s Pizza. Each offers signature styles, from traditional to creative twists.
Which Lubbock pizza restaurants offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Lots of pizza shops in Lubbock have you covered. Check out Italian Garden, Pie Five Pizza, and Orlando’s for a good range of plant-based or vegetarian-friendly pies.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Lubbock?
Yes. Pie Five Pizza, Orlando’s Italian Restaurant, and Italian Garden serve gluten-free pizza crusts. Always call ahead to double-check availability.
Is there good pizza for takeout or delivery?
Absolutely. Nearly all the major pizzerias—Giorgio’s, Dario’s, Domino’s, and more—offer both takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Where can I get a quick slice of pizza in Lubbock?
Giorgio’s Pizza and One Guy From Italy (University location) are known for their by-the-slice service. Great for anyone in a hurry or indecisive about toppings.
Who serves the best classic cheese pizza in town?
Favorites for a classic cheese pie include One Guy From Italy, Papa V Pizza, and Dion’s Pizza, all known for consistent quality and flavor.