Finding the best pizza in Louisville, KY is a personal quest—one that rewards a curious palate with surprises tucked into hidden corners, bustling city blocks, and unassuming neighborhood spots. This city defies pizza stereotypes, bringing New York slices, Neapolitan masterpieces, local legends, and creative new toppings under one skyline. My own adventure began with a slice shared at the bar of a brick-lined pizzeria: warm, perfectly blistered crust, a sauce with just the right tang, and the kind of cheese stretch that signals you’re in the right place. Louisville fascinated me with how every pizza spot has its own story, flavor, and loyal following.
Navigating this pizza wonderland, I tried classics on buzzy Friday nights, sought out dough rising in the back rooms of family-run shops, and even debated with locals on which smoky edge or airy crumb reigns supreme. If you’re craving that just-out-of-the-oven flavor, or want to explore Louisville’s rich pizza culture, this guide has you covered. I’ve gathered not just menus but local favorites, secret specialties, and honest reviews—so you can slice through the hype and find the pizza that fits your cravings perfectly.
Where to find the best pizza in Louisville, KY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Louisville, KY:
- Garage Bar
- Coals Artisan Pizza
- The Post
- Sicilian Pizza and Pasta
- The Original Impellizzeri’s Pizza
- Wick’s Pizza Parlor (Baxter Ave.)
- Coals Artisan
- Impellizzeri’s Pizza
- Hometown Pizza
- Luigi’s Pizzeria
1. Garage Bar
Garage Bar sits right on East Market Street and brings city charm into a relaxed, quirky setting. The first time I visited, the buzz of conversation and the open-air patios made the wait for a pie almost enjoyable. What really sets Garage Bar apart is their wood-fired oven—every pizza comes out crisp and lightly charred, with toppings that truly pop.
If you love a classic with a twist, the Margherita pizza shows off fresh basil and creamy mozzarella on tender, flavorful dough. For something bolder, try their seasonal specials. Their crust—a little chewy, a little crisp—is a signature detail you’ll crave long after.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options add to the appeal, so no one misses out. Garage Bar’s creative pies and rooftop energy make it a must-try for any Louisville pizza hunt.
2. Coals Artisan Pizza
Coals Artisan Pizza nestles in the cozy Vogue Theater promenade, spinning up some of Louisville’s most distinctive pies. My first visit drew me in with the aroma from their coal-fired oven, promising a crisp yet airy bite. The dough is hand-kneaded and cold-fermented for days, giving each crust a depth of flavor that stays with you.
What sets Coals apart is their American spin on Neapolitan style—thin crust, a soft puffy edge, and a beautiful char. Toppings lean seasonal and local, so there’s always something new to discover. The St. Matthews pizza, with its blend of cheeses, roasted mushrooms, and truffle oil, is the very definition of comfort.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free diners get real choices, not afterthoughts. Coals Artisan Pizza continues to raise the bar on what pizza in Kentucky can be.
3. The Post
The Post makes its home in a former post office, serving up slices that keep people coming back for late nights and weekend hangs. My first slice here was the kind you remember—big, sturdy, and perfectly foldable, just like the best New York-style pies. Locals fill the tables with friends, and the energy always feels just right.
What makes The Post a standout is consistency. The crust walks the line between chewy and crisp, ready to hold up to whatever combination you choose. The Anchorage Pie is a personal favorite. Piled with fresh veggies and a blend of cheeses, it’s a colorful, satisfying pick that still lets the tangy tomato sauce shine through.
Vegetarian and vegan options are part of the regular menu, making it an easy pick for groups. If you crave an authentic slice in Louisville, The Post is hard to beat.
4. Sicilian Pizza and Pasta
Sicilian Pizza and Pasta keeps things simple and inviting, with a menu full of hearty comfort food in the heart of downtown Louisville. My first stop here was on a rainy day, and the aroma of baking dough alone felt like a warm welcome. The pizza is cut thick, offering a fluffy, chewy base that sets it apart from the city’s thinner pies.
Sicilian-style pizza is their claim to fame, and it’s worth every bite. The cheese melts into the sauce and crust, making for that iconic, layered experience. The vegetarian deluxe, stacked with fresh veggies, offers great color and crunch without overpowering the classic tomato flavor.
Both vegetarian and vegan guests will find solid options, perfect for lunch breaks or family takeout. Sicilian Pizza and Pasta delivers old-school comfort every time.
5. The Original Impellizzeri’s Pizza
The Original Impellizzeri’s Pizza has been a Louisville staple for decades, blending tradition and flavor in each hearty slice. My first visit was a group affair, and sharing one of their giant pies was almost a ritual—there’s plenty for everyone and it always draws a crowd.
This spot stands out for its thick, cheesy layers and a crust with just the right golden crunch. The sauce is rich and savory, making every bite satisfy on its own. If you’re new, try the vegetarian special; loaded with peppers, onions, and mushrooms, it captures the spirit of the kitchen’s generous, no-shortcuts style.
Vegetarian-friendly and great for gatherings, The Original Impellizzeri’s proves that classic pizza done well never goes out of style.
6. Wick’s Pizza Parlor (Baxter Ave.)
Wick’s Pizza Parlor on Baxter Ave. is where Louisville’s pizza cravings often lead, especially if you’re hungry for bold flavors and generous portions. I first came here on game night, and the lively, quirky buzz had me planning a return before my first slice was gone. The dough is made fresh in-house daily, and you can taste the difference—pillowy on the inside, crisp around the edges.
The signature at Wick’s is the “Big Wick,” loaded with veggies, cheese, and a mountain of toppings that challenge even the hungriest group to finish. For something lighter, the vegetarian pies showcase just how bright and satisfying a loaded veggie pizza can be.
Vegetarian and vegan diners will find plenty to enjoy. Wick’s stands out for its big energy, even bigger pizzas, and a come-as-you-are attitude that keeps locals loyal.
7. Coals Artisan
Coals Artisan on Shelbyville Rd. feels inviting from the moment you walk in—there’s a comfort in seeing the crackle of the coal-fired oven and the careful attention paid to each pie. My first bite here was a revelation, thanks to their hand-kneaded, cold-fermented dough that develops rich, satisfying flavor in every airy crust.
The pizza style falls somewhere between classic Neapolitan and bold American, giving the crust its signature chew and a soft yet blistered edge. I recommend the Anchorage pizza, showcasing local cheeses, veggies, and that unmistakable smoky finish only a coal oven can provide.
Vegetarian and vegan options are far more than token add-ons, making it easy to find something for every taste. For an elevated yet unfussy pizza experience, Coals Artisan delivers.
8. Impellizzeri’s Pizza
Impellizzeri’s Pizza on Brownsboro Rd. is a Louisville classic—where families linger over big, cheesy pies and the scent of baking crust fills the air. My first visit was pure nostalgia, greeted by a friendly buzz and a menu that’s all about hearty, satisfying pizza.
What makes Impellizzeri’s stand out is the sheer generosity—each pizza is layered with sauce, a thick blanket of cheese, and a sturdy, golden crust that holds up to every topping. Their signature vegetarian pizza, generously stacked with peppers, olives, onions, and mushrooms, is a bright counterpoint to that savory foundation.
Perfect for breakfast through late-night cravings, this location nails the feel of a reliable neighborhood staple. Vegetarian options feature prominently, making it a crowd-pleaser for all.
9. Hometown Pizza
Hometown Pizza brings a sense of comfort that only comes from years of perfecting recipes and building community. Walking in, you’re greeted with the smells of baking dough and the warmth of a true local favorite. My first meal here reminded me of classic pizza nights—simple, relaxed, and satisfying.
What sets Hometown Pizza apart is its thick, chewy crust and generously topped specialty pies. The veggie pizza, brimming with fresh mushrooms, peppers, onions, and black olives, balances a bright sauce with gooey cheese that hits all the right notes.
It’s a great spot for families or anyone wanting a comfortable, crowd-pleasing stop. Hometown Pizza has earned its loyal following in Louisville with consistent quality and a friendly, homey vibe.
10. Luigi’s Pizzeria
Luigi’s Pizzeria is a no-frills gem tucked into downtown Louisville, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed break from work. My first visit brought instant nostalgia—classic red-checkered tables, friendly chatter, and the scent of baking dough.
What gives Luigi’s its charm is the balance between a crisp crust and a tender interior. Slices here are big and foldable, New York–style, yet always served piping hot and topped with plenty of cheese. The veggie pizza is a standout: fresh bell peppers, mushrooms, and onions come together perfectly on their signature thin crust.
Vegetarian choices are always on hand, and pizza here feels both classic and comforting. Luigi’s keeps things simple—and sometimes, that’s all you need.
More Things to Try in Louisville, KY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Louisville, KY?
Some local favorites include Garage Bar, Coals Artisan Pizza, The Post, Impellizzeri’s, and Wick’s Pizza Parlor. Each spot brings something unique, from coal-fired crusts to classic New York–style slices.
Where can I find the best vegetarian or vegan pizza in Louisville?
Many pizza spots like Coals Artisan, The Post, and Wick’s Pizza offer strong vegetarian and vegan menus. You’ll find plenty of fresh veggie toppings, plant-based options, and even gluten-free crusts.
Which Louisville pizza places offer takeout or delivery?
Most pizzerias, including Sicilian Pizza and Pasta, Hometown Pizza, and Luigi’s, offer takeout and some provide delivery as well. It’s usually fast and convenient—perfect for a cozy night in.
Are there any family-friendly pizza restaurants in Louisville?
Absolutely. Hometown Pizza, Wick’s Pizza Parlor, and Impellizzeri’s Pizza are known for their welcoming atmospheres and generous portions, making them ideal for family meals or gatherings.
What pizza styles are most common in Louisville?
Louisville is home to a mix of styles: New York–style, Sicilian, Neapolitan, and coal-fired American pies all have a devoted following here. Each has its own signature crust and toppings, so there’s plenty to explore.