Long Beach, NY, is a small coastal town with a big passion for pizza. Having explored its streets and talked with locals, I’ve discovered that the town’s pizza scene is both vibrant and genuinely diverse. Whether it’s a quick slice after a day at the beach or a sit-down meal with friends, Long Beach offers options that satisfy every craving. The best pizza spots here combine fresh ingredients, authentic techniques, and a local touch that keeps residents coming back.
Over the years, I’ve had the chance to try many of these establishments firsthand. From thin-crust classics to inventive pies, each place brings its own flavor to the table. What sets apart the top contenders is their dedication to quality and consistency. If you’re searching for the best pizza in Long Beach, NY, this guide will steer you toward the most dependable and delicious options, ensuring your pizza experience is memorable.
Where to find the best pizza in Long Beach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Long Beach, NY:
- Gino’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Sorrento’s
- East End Pizza
- West End Pizza
- Brixx Barley
- Borrelli’s Taproom
- Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Long Beach
- Franks Trattoria Pizza Restaurant
- The Pizza Guys
- Domino’s Pizza
1. Gino’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
Located at 16 W Park Ave, Gino’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a long-standing favorite for pizza lovers in Long Beach. I visited Gino’s on a quiet weekday evening and was instantly impressed by their warm, inviting atmosphere. Their menu balances classic favorites with innovative flavors, making it a versatile spot for any pizza enthusiast.
What sets Gino’s apart is their commitment to quality and fresh ingredients. I highly recommend ordering their prosciutto and arugula pizza—a perfect blend of savory toppings and crisp greens. For a traditional choice, the margherita showcases their skill with fresh basil and a perfectly baked crust. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, Gino’s consistently delivers authentic, satisfying pizza in Long Beach.
2. Sorrento’s
Sorrento’s, located at 255 Park Avenue in Long Beach, is a cozy spot renowned for its authentic Italian flavors. During a recent visit, I found its welcoming atmosphere perfect for both a casual lunch and a relaxed dinner. The menu emphasizes fresh ingredients and traditional techniques, making each pizza memorable.
Sorrento’s stands out for its flavorful, well-crafted pizzas. I suggest trying their vegetarian pizza with fresh vegetables, which highlights the quality of their produce and sauce. The Margherita is a simple yet flavorful option, showcasing their dough-making expertise. Sorrento’s dedication to taste and freshness makes it a top choice for pizza lovers in Long Beach.
3. East End Pizza
East End Pizza, located at 647 E Park Ave, is a go-to spot for pizza and more in Long Beach. During a recent visit, I appreciated its inviting atmosphere and quick service. Their varied menu includes pizza, pasta, heroes, and salads, perfect for satisfying diverse cravings.
What sets East End Pizza apart is their generous portions and fresh ingredients. I recommend trying their classic pepperoni and cheese pizza, which exemplifies their commitment to quality. For a heartier meal, their sub heroes are packed with flavor and made with fresh bread. East End Pizza’s consistent quality makes it a reliable choice for a casual, delicious meal in Long Beach.
4. West End Pizza
West End Pizza, nestled at 918 W Beech St, is a family favorite in Long Beach for Italian and pizza dishes. During a visit, I was struck by the inviting, no-frills atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Their menu balances classic pizza with authentic Italian flavors, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
What makes West End Pizza stand out is their crispy, flavorful crust and generous toppings. I highly recommend their plain cheese pizza for a pure, satisfying taste or the specialty Sicilian slice for a heartier, rich flavor. Their commitment to quality ingredients and consistent baking makes West End Pizza a top choice for locals craving true pizza in Long Beach.
5. Brixx Barley
Brixx Barley, located at 152 W Park Ave, is a lively spot known for its creative pizza options in Long Beach. When I visited, I enjoyed the vibrant atmosphere that’s perfect for both a casual lunch and late-night outings. The menu offers a variety of vegetarian and gluten-free choices, catering to diverse preferences.
What makes Brixx Barley stand out is their inventive toppings and quality ingredients. I suggest trying their vegetarian pizza with fresh vegetables or the gluten-free crust for a lighter option. Their commitment to flavor and accommodating different diets makes Brixx Barley a go-to for pizza lovers seeking something unique in Long Beach.
6. Borrelli’s Taproom
Borrelli’s Taproom, at 912 W Beech St, brings a fresh vibe to Long Beach with its wood-fired brick oven pizza and inviting atmosphere. During my visit, I enjoyed watching a game at the bar while savoring their flavorful pies. The blend of traditional Italian staples with modern favorites makes their menu stand out.
What sets Borrelli’s apart is their commitment to quality and authenticity. I recommend trying their margherita pizza with crispy crust and fresh basil, or the specialty Italian sausage pizza for a satisfying, flavorful experience. Their warm, family-friendly environment makes it a perfect spot for casual dinners or a relaxed evening out.
7. Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Long Beach
Located at 157 E Park Ave, Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant in Long Beach is a go-to spot for authentic, flavorful pizza. During my visit, I appreciated the warm atmosphere and the aroma of freshly baked dough. The focus here is on quality ingredients and classic techniques, ensuring every slice is satisfying.
Francesco’s stands out for its thin-crust pizza with a perfect balance of crispness and chewiness. I highly recommend trying their Margherita pizza for its fresh basil and ripe tomatoes, or the meat lovers’ special for a hearty, flavorful experience. Their consistency and dedication to traditional pizza make Francesco’s a reliable favorite for locals and visitors alike.
8. Franks Trattoria Pizza Restaurant
Located at 1085 W Beech St, Franks Trattoria Pizza Restaurant is a cozy spot known for its authentic Italian and pizza offerings. During a recent visit, I was welcomed by the warm, inviting atmosphere and the smell of freshly baked pies. Their focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes shines through in every dish.
What makes Franks Trattoria stand out is their commitment to craftsmanship and flavor. I recommend trying their margherita pizza, featuring fresh basil and ripe tomatoes, or their classic pepperoni pie, which offers a perfect balance of crunch and gooey cheese. Their dedication to authentic, satisfying pizza makes it a top choice for locals seeking genuine Italian flavors in Long Beach.
9. The Pizza Guys
+1 516-992-2927
Located at 212 New York Ave, The Pizza Guys is a popular stop for pizza enthusiasts in Long Beach. I visited during a busy evening and was impressed by their quick service and flavorful slices. Their focus on fresh ingredients and classic techniques ensures a satisfying experience.
What sets The Pizza Guys apart is their crispy crust and generous toppings. I recommend trying their specialty margherita pizza for a simple yet flavorful bite, or the meat lover’s pizza for a hearty option. Each pie reflects their dedication to quality and authentic flavor, making it a reliable choice for a quick, delicious meal.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Located at 269 W Park Ave, Domino’s Pizza is a trusted name for quick, satisfying pizza in Long Beach. I once ordered during a busy weekend and appreciated their reliable delivery service and warm, fresh slices. They offer a variety of styles to suit every preference.
What makes Domino’s stand out is their versatility and quality. I recommend trying their Thin Crust Pizza for a foldable, classic experience or their Handmade Pan Pizza for a hearty bite. Their flavorful toppings and consistent quality make it a go-to for convenient, delicious pizza whenever cravings strike.
More Things to Try in Long Beach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Long Beach, NY?
A: Many locals recommend Gino’s Restaurant and Pizzeria for its authentic flavors and quality ingredients. Other popular options include Francesco’s Pizzeria and East End Pizza, each known for their flavorful, well-crafted pies.
Q: Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Long Beach?
A: Yes, several places like Brixx Barley offer vegetarian pizza options. Many pizzerias provide customizable pies with fresh vegetables and dairy-free cheese upon request.
Q: Do these pizza spots offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most top pizza places, including Domino’s and Sorrento’s, offer both delivery and takeout services to suit your convenience.
Q: Can I find gluten-free pizza in Long Beach?
A: Yes, some restaurants like Brixx Barley feature gluten-free crust options, catering to dietary preferences without compromising on flavor.
Q: Are there late-night pizza options in Long Beach?
A: Borrelli’s Taproom and other spots often remain open late, making them perfect for late-night cravings.