Cravings tend to hit hardest when the scent of fresh dough and bubbling cheese is in the air. There’s something about pizza in Lexington, KY that’s hard to match—whether you find yourself wandering the quaint neighborhoods, or searching for a slice after a day downtown. I’ve sampled, chewed, debated, and even gotten lost in Lexington’s pizza scene more times than I can count. Each spot offers its own spin, and honestly, I still find myself surprised by new twists on old classics.
Lexington’s pizza roster is nothing short of a gold mine for anyone willing to taste their way through. From wood-fired thin crusts to huge New York-style slices, the city is stacked with pizzerias that hit all the right notes. Forget generic chains; this guide focuses on the best places for that perfect crust, robust sauce, and cheese that stretches for days. Curious to find your next favorite slice? The following lineup is ready when you are.
Where to find the best pizza in Lexington, KY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lexington, KY:
- Pies & Pints
- Joe Bologna’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mill St.
- Smashing Tomato
- Smashing Tomato
- Goodfellas Pizzeria – Distillery
- MOD Pizza
- PieTana
- Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta
- Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders
1. Pies & Pints
Pies & Pints has a way of making pizza feel fun without losing its edge. Nestled right in the heart of downtown, it’s always buzzing, especially when the UK Wildcats are playing. I first visited after a long walk at Triangle Park—the aromas alone were enough to lure me inside.
Their specialty pies pack a punch, especially the Black Bean or Margherita pies. Each bite shows off their knack for thoughtful combinations and quality ingredients. With plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options, pretty much everyone can dig in.
The tap list is just as impressive as the menu, so grab a slice and a cold draft while swapping stories with friends. Pies & Pints keeps the vibe light, local, and just different enough to stand out.
2. Joe Bologna’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
Joe Bologna’s Restaurant and Pizzeria is a true Lexington institution, nestled in a historic former synagogue. Walking in for the first time, you can’t help but notice the enormous stained-glass window and the steady buzz of lively conversaion. It’s a favorite where families, students, and old friends gather for hearty, comforting slices.
The Sicilian-style pizza is the one to try—thick, pillowy, and topped with a house-made tomato sauce that’s both tangy and rich. Garlic breadsticks are legendary here, often arriving at the table before you’ve even decided what to order next.
Plenty of gluten-free and vegetarian options make sure everyone’s covered. At Joe Bologna’s, each pizza feels like it’s made with genuine care, never rushed.
3. Goodfellas Pizzeria – Mill St.
Step into Goodfellas Pizzeria on Mill Street and you’ll feel like you’ve landed in a real New York slice joint, but without the Manhattan rush. The glow of pizza ovens, the unmistakable scent of fresh dough, and that snap of the first bite—it all adds up. I’m always impressed by the crisp yet chewy crusts; that’s no easy feat.
The classic cheese slice is unbeatable for purity, but their veggie-loaded combinations also hit the spot. If you show up hungry, order a whole pie and see just how thin, yet sturdy, their crust can get.
Goodfellas makes each pizza with a special attention to freshness, from the hand-tossed dough to the locally sourced toppings. Late-night cravings or lunch with friends, it stays satisfying every time.
4. Smashing Tomato
Smashing Tomato delivers authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, and the aroma of wood-fired crust alone convinced me to stick around on my first visit. The open kitchen lets you watch each pie form, from hand-stretched dough to the final bubbling cheese.
Their Margherita is a star, with fresh basil and a light, tangy tomato sauce that really shines. Try the Four Cheese if you want a richer, more indulgent bite; the flavors melt together brilliantly. Crispy on the edges, soft in the center—just as it should be.
Plenty of veggie and gluten-free options mean no one misses out. Whether you’re a pizza purist or love to experiment, Smashing Tomato brings honest, wood-fired flavor to Lexington’s pizza scene.
5. Smashing Tomato
This Smashing Tomato location proves that lightning does strike twice, especially when wood-fired pizza is involved. Just off War Admiral Way, it carries the same laid-back charm and dedication to quality as its sibling spot. You smell the crust before you see it, and instantly, you know you’re in for something good.
Their Roasted Vegetable pizza stands out, loaded with colorful veggies and perfectly blistered edges. A simple Arugula & Tomato pie offers a fresh, peppery twist that never disappoints.
Everything is made to order, so your pizza arrives hot and crisp every time. Grab dinner here after errands or settle in with friends—Smashing Tomato makes it easy to feel right at home.
6. Goodfellas Pizzeria – Distillery
Goodfellas Pizzeria at the Distillery District is a slice lover’s dream with a little extra swagger. Tucked among old brick warehouses, it combines the spirit of Lexington’s past with the energy of a modern hangout. My first experience was all about the vibrant buzz—late-night crowds swapping stories over massive, foldable slices.
The New York-style cheese slice nails that elusive balance: chewy crust, zesty sauce, and a generous blanket of cheese. Custom pies let you pile on fresh veggies or experiment with bold flavors.
The setting, with its speakeasy vibe and welcoming staff, keeps you coming back. For real New York flavor in Lexington, this Goodfellas location stays top of mind.
7. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza brings a custom touch to Lexington’s pizza scene. Here, you walk in craving pizza—and leave feeling like you created your own signature dish. My favorite visits happen when I bring friends, and we each pile on our choice of unlimited toppings. The experience makes you feel a bit like a pizza artist.
Try the Caspian with BBQ sauce and roasted veggies, or build your own for something unique. The cauliflower and gluten-friendly crusts are also excellent if you want a lighter option.
Every pizza comes out fast, perfectly crisped, and hot. Whether you go classic or bold, MOD’s open topping policy means every flavor combination is fair game.
8. PieTana
PieTana feels like one of Lexington’s best-kept secrets, tucked away in a cozy spot on Rosemont Garden. The first time I wandered in, the aroma of baking dough greeted me at the door—and I was hooked before even tasting a slice. It’s welcoming, with a relaxed vibe perfect for regular pizza nights.
The Farmhouse pie is a true standout, loaded with seasonal veggies and just the right amount of cheese. It’s the sort of pizza you want to savor slowly, bite after bite. Their Margherita is a classic pick, fresh and balanced every time.
Service feels like visiting a favorite friend’s kitchen. If you want a laid-back spot with creative, quality pizzas, PieTana delivers in all the right ways.
9. Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta
Puccini’s Pizza & Pasta brings a creative flair to Lexington’s pizza scene. Whenever I’m craving something beyond the usual, this spot is my escape. The menu is broad, but pizza remains at the heart of everything. It’s family-friendly, with a cozy atmosphere that always feels inviting.
The twice-baked crust on the Campfire pizza is unforgettable—crispy, smoky, and topped with loads of flavor. If you lean vegetarian, the Spinoccoli pizza combines broccoli and spinach in a way that’s surprisingly satisfying. Gluten-free eaters have ample choices, which is refreshing.
Every pizza arrives piping hot and loaded with creative toppings. Puccini’s nails that balance between classic comfort and thoughtful innovation.
10. Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders at Meadowthorpe Shopping Center is a little off the main drag, but well worth the detour. My first visit was out of curiosity—the name alone promised something different, and the variety here doesn’t disappoint. It feels like a neighborhood favorite, with a casual, welcoming atmosphere.
Their veggie pizza, piled high with olives, mushrooms, and peppers, is a standout for flavor and freshness. The crust is thin, golden, and just crispy enough to hold up under all those toppings. Don’t skip a grinder sandwich if you’re extra hungry; both the pizza and sandwich sides are strong suits.
Friendly service and value-driven combos keep me coming back. Mancino’s is a great choice when you want classic pizza with generous toppings, made right every time.
More Things to Try in Lexington, KY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Lexington, KY?
Lexington offers everything from New York-style thin slices to authentic Neapolitan, Sicilian deep-dish, and even inventive specialty pies. There’s something for every kind of pizza lover.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Lexington?
Absolutely. Many local pizzerias have vegetarian and vegan pizzas, plus gluten-free crusts. Places like Smashing Tomato and MOD Pizza are great for plant-based options.
Where can I get late-night pizza in Lexington?
Goodfellas Pizzeria and Joe Bologna’s stay open late. You can grab a giant slice or a whole pie even after most places have called it a night.
Do Lexington pizzerias offer gluten-free options?
Yes, several spots, including Puccini’s and MOD Pizza, make gluten-free crusts. Be sure to ask when you order for best options and safe preparation.
Is delivery available from most pizza restaurants in Lexington?
Most pizzerias offer delivery through their website or third-party apps. Pick-up and curbside are also easy to find if you’re nearby.
Which pizza places are best for families or groups?
Joe Bologna’s and GattiTown are top picks for groups, offering big tables, fun atmospheres, and menu choices to please all ages.