Searching for the best pizza in Lansing, MI can feel a bit like trying to choose your favorite song—almost impossible but incredibly fun. I’ve found myself in the middle of spirited debates around Lansing’s tables, listening to passionate opinions on crust thickness, cheese melt, and the perfect sauce. The city offers an impressive variety, from vintage taverns serving up nostalgia with every bite to new spots that dare to put a twist on tradition.
If you love the simple joy of a great slice, Lansing is packed with hidden gems and local legends to fuel your cravings. Whether you’re drawn to a wood-fired masterpiece or a crispy pan pizza, there’s a place in this city that seems to speak your culinary language. Let’s dig into the spots that locals and visitors agree manage to stand out—each for their own reasons. Hungry? Good. This list is built to help you land your next favorite pie.
Where to find the best pizza in Lansing, MI
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lansing, MI:
- The Cosmos
- Zoobie’s Old Town Tavern
- Blaze Pizza
- Art’s Pub
- EagleMonk Pub and Brewery
- Sir Pizza – Old Town
- Cottage Inn Pizza
- Boston’s Pizza Restaurant & Sports Bar
- Tony M’s Restaurant
- Marco’s Pizza
1. The Cosmos
If you think pizza can’t be cosmic, The Cosmos might change your mind. Tucked just off Old Town, it draws you in with a funky vibe and a design that feels both cool and cozy. The standout wood-fired pizzas are crafted with playful creativity and undeniable skill.
During my last visit, I ordered the Thai Battista pizza. The zing of fresh cilantro and the gentle heat from the sauce hit the perfect note—a balanced, bold experience. Other favorites include the King Brussel and classic Margherita, each showing off inventive toppings on perfect crusts.
With lots of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, The Cosmos makes sure everyone gets a seat at the table. It’s always worth a visit if you want Lansing’s most imaginative slices.
2. Zoobie’s Old Town Tavern
Zoobie’s Old Town Tavern turns any regular night into something memorable. This spot blends vintage charm with a touch of Lansing’s quirky side, making it perfect for both pizza purists and adventurous eaters. The pizza here comes straight from The Cosmos kitchen next door, so every slice is wood-fired and full of flavor.
I like to drop by after work for their signature pies, and the difference is clear—they use fresh toppings and get the crust just right every time. The Hot Honey Pizza is a standout. The sweet heat, every bite, feels balanced and craveable. Pair your pizza with one of their local craft brews or a boutique glass of wine for a complete experience.
It’s an easy pick when you want good pizza and a laid-back local vibe.
3. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza makes waiting for your meal almost unnecessary. Step up, choose from over 30 fresh toppings, and watch as your custom creation slides into the blazing hot oven. Minutes later, you’re biting into a crisp, personal pizza built just for you.
The quick service and artisanal choices set Blaze apart in Lansing’s pizza scene. The staff move with a pizzaiolo’s confidence, keeping everything moving while making sure you get the exact bite you want.
I usually go for a classic build with roasted garlic, fresh spinach, and dollops of ricotta. But the Vegan Spicy Chopped Veggie is another stellar pick—loaded with flavor and surprisingly satisfying. You get speed without sacrificing taste or quality, and that’s why Blaze keeps drawing a crowd.
4. Art’s Pub
Art’s Pub greets you with the kind of warmth only a neighborhood spot can offer. The mix of friendly staff, cheerful chatter, and local art on the walls sets a laid-back mood. The real star of the show? Their pizza—baked ‘til the cheese bubbles and the crust gets that perfect crunch.
Every time I visit, I lean toward the Veggie Supreme. Generous toppings, a well-seasoned sauce, and a crust that holds up without going dense—that’s the Art’s Pub difference. You can build your own if you prefer something more personal, with plenty of vegetarian and vegan options to keep your choices wide open.
If you’re searching for pizza with personality and a side of genuine Lansing charm, you’ll fit right in here.
5. EagleMonk Pub and Brewery
When it comes to mixing great pizza with local flavor, EagleMonk Pub and Brewery never misses. The ceiling lined with mugs catches your eye as you walk in, and the scent of house-made dough lets you know you’re in the right place. Their pizzas come with a side of laid-back vibe and friendly service that makes families and friends linger longer.
I always choose the Veggie Delight, loaded with fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms. The crust is airy and crisp, with just enough chew to keep every slice interesting. Pair your pizza with their signature craft sodas for a unique combination that hits the spot.
It’s the place to go when you want handcrafted taste in both your glass and on your plate.
6. Sir Pizza – Old Town
Sir Pizza – Old Town keeps things simple but never dull. It’s a spot locals rely on, thanks to its long history and straightforward approach. The pizza here stands out for its party-cut slices and toppings that reach edge to edge.
When I visit, I order the Royal Feast. Every bite is packed with flavor, and the signature thin crust gives you a fun crunch without weighing you down. If you like your pizza loaded—with no bare crust corners—this is your place.
Fast service and a menu that stays true to its roots make Sir Pizza – Old Town a Lansing favorite. It’s no-frills, honest pizza made for sharing with good company.
7. Cottage Inn Pizza
Cottage Inn Pizza is that place where every appetite finds its match. I remember the first evening I tried their Gourmet Veggie pizza—loaded with roasted veggies, rich sauce, and a golden, chewy crust—and understood the loyalty of their regulars.
What makes Cottage Inn stand out is the sheer variety. Thin crust, deep dish, and gluten-free options all come with a promise of fresh ingredients and care in each bake. Their staff is tuned in, always ready to customize.
If you want a taste of how creative Lansing pizza can get, try their Feta Bread or a build-your-own pie. Their quality and convenience keep Cottage Inn in the Lansing pizza conversation.
8. Boston’s Pizza Restaurant & Sports Bar
Boston’s Pizza Restaurant & Sports Bar covers the sweet spot between a great slice and a game night hangout. With screens everywhere, it’s easy to catch every play while digging into a fresh pie. The atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for meeting friends after work or cheering for your team.
The menu isn’t shy about variety. I’m a fan of their Mediterranean veggie pizza—loaded with artichokes, olives, and fresh spinach on a thin, flavorful crust. It’s tasty enough to forget the outside world for a while. Their staff makes everyone feel at home, even on busy nights.
If you’re after gourmet pizza without the pretense, paired with plenty of other good choices, Boston’s is an easy win in Lansing.
9. Tony M’s Restaurant
Tony M’s Restaurant feels like crossing the line between family gathering and local favorite. The menu is packed, but the pizza quietly steals the show with classic Italian care in every slice. My go-to is the Veggie Deluxe—loaded with peppers, olives, and mushrooms—the sauce has that unmistakable homemade touch, never too sweet or salty.
It’s easy to see why Tony M’s remains a Lansing staple. The dough is made fresh and the portions make sharing almost a necessity, so you’re never left hungry. Their welcoming service rounds out the experience—there’s always a friendly face to greet you.
If you’re after hearty, traditional pizza in a setting that feels like home, Tony M’s delivers.
10. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza is a steady favorite for anyone craving comfort in a box. Their signature dough is made fresh every day, giving each pizza that satisfying bite you only get from a good rise and a hot oven. My favorite order is the Garden Pizza—piled high with fresh veggies, just enough cheese, and a tangy tomato sauce.
Marco’s stands out for its attention to detail and consistently friendly service. Every pizza arrives loaded from edge to edge, and nothing feels skimpy or rushed. The value is strong, especially when you’re in the mood to feed a crowd.
If you want consistent, classic pizza that tastes just as good at home as it does on-site, Marco’s is an easy pick in Lansing.
More Things to Try in Lansing, MI
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Lansing for dine-in?
Many locals recommend The Cosmos, Art’s Pub, and EagleMonk Pub and Brewery for a sit-down pizza experience with a cozy vibe.
Where can I find vegan or gluten-free pizza in Lansing?
The Cosmos, Blaze Pizza, and Art’s Pub offer several vegan and gluten-free options, so everyone can enjoy their own slice.
Which Lansing pizza spots are family-friendly?
Try EagleMonk Pub and Brewery or Art’s Pub—they both have relaxed atmospheres and menus that cater to kids and adults alike.
Is there a place for fast, customizable pizza in Lansing?
Blaze Pizza shines here, giving you the option to build your own pizza from dozens of fresh toppings and have it cooked in minutes.
Do any Lansing pizza shops deliver late at night?
Sir Pizza – Old Town, Marco’s Pizza, and several national chains like Domino’s and Jet’s Pizza all offer late-night delivery.
Where can I grab pizza with a local craft drink?
Pair your pizza with house-made sodas or local brews at EagleMonk Pub and Brewery or Ellison Brewing Co. – both worth a visit for more than just the pizza.