Looking for the best pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY is a quest worth savoring. This isn’t your average town with pizza joints on every corner; it’s a local battleground where fervent fans will defend their favorite slice like a family secret. I remember biting into a hot, thin-crust slice after a chilly day at the lake—the tangy tomato sauce and perfectly stretchy cheese told me I wasn’t just anywhere. I was in a town where pizza matters.
If you crave the difference between dough tossed by hand or spun by a machine, you’re in the right place. Even after countless tastings, I still look forward to discovering a new twist—maybe a sauce that’s just the right shade of zesty or a crust that crackles when folded. Each spot has its own story, personality, and fanbase. What follows is a carefully curated list, based on personal experiences and plenty of local opinions. If you want Lake Ronkonkoma’s standouts—from classic New York slices to real-deal brick oven mastery—keep reading.
Where to find the best pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY:
- Little Vincent’s Pizzeria
- Gino’s Pizza
- Pizza Stop
- Royal Pizza
- Due Paisano’s Pizza and Catering
- Morellis Pizza & Gyros
- Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
- San Marzano
- La Capannina
- Papa Johns Pizza
1. Little Vincent’s Pizzeria
Little Vincent’s Pizzeria has the vibe of an old-school New York pizza shop, right at 324 Smithtown Blvd. This spot stands out with its chewy, flavorful crust and the kind of tangy sauce that only comes with experience. I still remember the first time I tried their slice—the cheese stretched longer than I expected, and the crackle of that thin crust was just right.
Little Vincent’s “cold cheese slice” is a local legend. If you’ve never had mozzarella piled on a hot slice to melt as you eat, now’s your chance. Their plain pie is classic, capturing the heart of what Lake Ronkonkoma pizza means. If you want a no-fuss, tasty, and satisfying meal that draws both locals and late-night snackers, this is your place.
2. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza draws a loyal crowd on Portion Rd, not just for its convenience but for its genuine approach to pizza. The dough here is always fresh, the pie crusts golden and crisp without being greasy. My go-to memory involves their veggie slice—layers of peppers, onions, and mushrooms that actually taste like they were chopped that morning.
Gino’s is a haven for those who want options, thanks to plenty of vegetarian and vegan-friendly choices. Their “Grandma Pie” stands out—square, thin, and layered with fresh basil and a rustic tomato sauce. Don’t skip the classic Margherita, either. This is the place to taste fresh ingredients and real care in every slice.
3. Pizza Stop
Pizza Stop sits at the crossroads of comfort and tradition in Lake Ronkonkoma. It’s a spot I always return to when I want a hearty, foldable New York slice that never disappoints. The crust here has this balance—sturdy enough to support toppings, yet light enough for that classic pizza fold.
The Sicilian pie at Pizza Stop is a real showstopper. It’s thick, airy, and has a caramelized bottom that keeps every bite interesting. I’m also partial to their white pizza, which is loaded with ricotta and seasoned garlic. Every pie here feels made for sharing with friends or family after a long day. If you crave straightforward, satisfying pizza, this local staple delivers.
4. Royal Pizza
Royal Pizza is the kind of neighborhood spot that makes you feel at home as soon as you step inside. Every time I order from here, I can count on friendly service and pizza that arrives steaming, with toppings still bubbling. The experience is reliable, which is rare these days.
Their specialty lies in a classic New York-style pie—thin, wide, and easy to fold. I’m partial to their plain cheese slice for its perfect balance between crisp and chewy. The sauce is savory with a hint of sweetness, giving each bite a well-rounded flavor. If you prefer a little variety, try a vegetable slice or grab a specialty pie for your next dinner gathering. Royal Pizza keeps things simple, and that’s exactly why it works.
5. Due Paisano’s Pizza and Catering
Due Paisano’s Pizza and Catering feels like a slice of Italy tucked away on Portion Road. There’s warmth in the air, and the kitchen always smells of fresh dough and roasted garlic. I remember my first visit—a generous slice, the cheese gooey and the edges just crisp enough to savor every bite.
Their “Paisano Special” pizza captures what they do best—plenty of fresh veggies, a robust tomato sauce, and a base that never wilts under toppings. If you want something for a group, their pies come out piping hot and loaded. Ordering a classic Margherita or the Paisano Special means tasting the heart of Lake Ronkonkoma’s pizza culture—simple, friendly, and reliably delicious.
6. Morellis Pizza & Gyros
Morellis Pizza & Gyros mixes tradition with a bit of Lake Ronkonkoma personality. Every order feels like it was made for you alone, whether you’re in for lunch or grabbing dinner for a crowd. My first slice here had a golden crust and fresh, hand-cut toppings you could actually taste.
The “Morellis Special” is a clear standout—layers of veggies and cheese, with a crust that stays crisp until the last bite. If classic pizza’s what you crave, their regular cheese slice always lands in that perfect spot between gooey and crisp. The menu ranges beyond pizza, but the pies keep people coming back for that hometown flavor that never disappoints.
7. Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant
Branchinelli’s Pizza & Restaurant knows how to balance tradition and comfort. Walking into their restaurant, the smell of classic Italian flavors always brings a wave of nostalgia. I first tried their hand-tossed pizza after a recommendation from a friend, and the blend of chewy crust and bright sauce got me hooked.
The Sicilian pizza is famous here—airy, thick, and strong enough to carry a generous layer of cheese and sauce. Their menu stretches far beyond pizza, but the pies are the heart of it all. For a cozy dinner or a big gathering, their pizzas shine with top-quality ingredients and a welcoming feel that locals love.
8. San Marzano
San Marzano offers a modern take on pizza, yet never ignores tradition. I was intrigued by their approach during my first visit. You can taste the difference when you take that first bite—each pizza uses quality ingredients, and the crust is both pillowy and crisp in the right places.
The “San Marzano” pie itself is a must-try, featuring the namesake tomatoes known for their sweet, rich flavor. Their thin crust holds up well to loaded toppings without becoming soggy, which is a skill in itself. Try the Margherita for a classic, or venture into any seasonal special if you’re feeling adventurous. If you’re seeking pizza that respects both freshness and flair, San Marzano delivers every time.
9. La Capannina
(631) 569-4524Call
La Capannina is the little neighborhood place that feels like a well-kept secret just outside Lake Ronkonkoma. The inviting setting and friendly staff make every visit memorable. I recall grabbing a slice on a rainy day—fresh herbs atop a hot, chewy crust; simple yet deeply satisfying.
Their brick oven pizzas are a highlight, offering authentic texture and flavor that’s hard to find elsewhere. Order their classic Margherita or a veggie-loaded pie to see their focus on freshness and balance. The attention to detail in every pizza, from the dough to the finish, shines through and earns devoted fans. If you like your pizza crafted with care, La Capannina is worth seeking out.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza is the reliable choice for classic, no-nonsense pizza near Lake Ronkonkoma. I’ve stopped by more times than I can count for a quick slice that never disappoints. The crust stands out—light, airy, and with a subtle flavor that doesn’t overpower the toppings.
Ordering their “The Works” pizza is my favorite way to cover all the bases—fresh vegetables and cheese layered over their signature sauce. Their thin crust delivers a satisfying crunch, and even a simple cheese slice hits the mark for consistency and taste. For those looking for something familiar that arrives fast and hot, Papa Johns serves up exactly what you expect every time.
More Things to Try in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Lake Ronkonkoma, NY?
Some favorites include Little Vincent’s Pizzeria, Gino’s Pizza, Pizza Stop, and Due Paisano’s. Each spot brings something unique to the table, from classic New York slices to special pies piled high with fresh toppings.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Lake Ronkonkoma?
Yes, several pizzerias like Gino’s Pizza offer vegetarian and vegan menus, making it easy to find meat-free options without sacrificing taste.
Do local pizzerias offer delivery and takeout?
Most pizza places in Lake Ronkonkoma, including Royal Pizza and Papa Johns, provide delivery and takeout. It’s a convenient way to enjoy your favorite pies at home or on the go.
Which place is known for a unique or signature slice?
Little Vincent’s is famous for its “cold cheese slice,” and Pizza Stop is known for a standout Sicilian pie. These specialty slices keep locals coming back.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Lake Ronkonkoma?
Some pizzerias in the area offer gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead and confirm depending on your needs.