Searching for the best pizza in Kutztown, PA? You’re not alone. I’ve spent plenty of late afternoons chasing the scent of bubbling cheese and crisping dough on Main Street. One moment you’re ducking into a cozy, family-run spot; the next, you’re debating toppings with someone who claims their great-uncle invented the white pie. Good luck proving them wrong—half the fun is testing their theory, slice by slice.
Whether you crave a classic margherita or feel drawn to bold, creative combinations, Kutztown’s pizza scene is full of surprises. The options here stretch from old-school favorites to bold newcomers, each with a loyal local following. Ready to cut through the doughy confusion? Here’s a guide designed to make your next pizza decision a little easier, and a lot tastier.
1. Demarco’s Italian Restaurant
A visit to Demarco’s Italian Restaurant feels like joining a big family meal, even if you walk in solo. Tucked along Old 22, this spot balances small-town warmth with old-world recipes. The moment I bit into their Sicilian slice, layered thick with robust sauce, it felt like the sort of pizza you enjoy without saying a word—just a knowing smile between friends.
Demarco’s stands out for its hearty crust, generous cheese, and a sauce that doesn’t shy away from flavor. If you’re looking to taste what they do best, start with their classic margherita or the pepperoni—each baked until the edges are just right.
Pull up a chair, settle in, and enjoy. Their pizza speaks for itself.
2. Camillo’s Italian Restaurant & Bar
Camillo’s Italian Restaurant & Bar invites you in with the buzz of conversation and the glow of the pizza oven. The first time I stopped by, I was drawn to their outside patio, where the scent of fresh basil drifted on the air. The setting is casual, perfect for long dinners with friends or family.
Camillo’s excels at marrying tradition and comfort. Their pizzas, especially the margherita and veggie varieties, deliver crispness and full flavor right from the oven. The homemade sauce and thoughtfully chosen toppings shine through in every bite.
If you’re seeking pizza that’s hearty yet not heavy, order their thin-crust options. The balance of texture and taste is what makes Camillo’s a Kutztown staple.
3. Valentino’s
Pulling off Kutztown Road to find Valentino’s feels like uncovering a local secret. The warm atmosphere is matched only by the staff’s easy smiles. My first meal here was a late lunch, and I ended up staying much longer than planned, torn between one more slice and calling it a day.
Valentino’s pizza stands out for its pillowy crust and generous, melty cheese. The sauce leans just the right side of tangy. Their plain cheese pizza lets the quality shine, but those in the know often go for their veggie pie—colorful, fresh, and satisfying each time.
This is the place where simple ingredients get the attention they deserve, every bite proof that pizza doesn’t need to be complicated to be memorable.
4. Tommyboy’s Pizza And Cafe
Tommyboy’s Pizza And Cafe is the kind of place you find yourself returning to, even without planning it. Tucked on Main Street, Tommyboy’s pulses with a laid-back, unpretentious energy—order at the counter, and you might catch the staff kneading dough right in front of you.
Their pizza has a familiar, nostalgic charm. The crust hits the sweet spot between soft and crisp, supporting rich, well-seasoned sauce and a generous spread of cheese. I still remember the first slice I tried—plain cheese, straight from the oven, so good I ordered another on the spot.
While the menu covers classics, the white pizza is a standout. It’s creamy and comforting, without overcomplicating things. Tommyboy’s keeps it real, and the pizza here does the same.
5. Folino Estate
Folino Estate feels like a European escape tucked into Kutztown’s rolling countryside. My first time dining here, the sprawling vineyard view competed with the earthy aroma drifting from their open kitchen. It’s the kind of place that turns a casual meal into a small celebration.
What makes Folino Estate’s pizza unique is its rustic, wood-fired crust. Light charring, chewy edges, and perfectly blistered cheese make every bite a blend of smoky and fresh. Go for the margherita if you’re after classic simplicity, or try their primavera for a medley of vibrant vegetables atop silky mozzarella.
With options for vegetarians, vegans, and those eating gluten-free, it’s a rare spot where everyone at the table finds something to love—pizza included.
6. Mamma Delight Pizza Restaurant
Mamma Delight Pizza Restaurant wears its name well. I stopped by one chilly evening, drawn in by the scent of baking crust that lingered outside. Inside, the space was alive with the sizzle of pizza pans and friendly small talk between staff and regulars. Grab a seat and you’ll feel like a local fast.
Mamma Delight makes pizza with a generous spirit. Their pies arrive piled high—cheese stretching, sauce with a subtle sweetness, crust never too thick or too thin. For the full experience, try their veggie pizza, where the toppings spill over with color and flavor.
If you appreciate a pizza that takes classic traditions and turns the comfort dial up, this spot promises a satisfying slice every time.
7. Camillos Italian Restaurant
Stepping into Camillos Italian Restaurant feels like joining a favorite family gathering. There’s always a buzz of energy from tables scattered with conversation and laughter. My first slice here set a high bar—the crust had that golden finish, with a sauce both bright and rich.
Camillos takes pride in balancing tradition with generous hospitality. Their pizzas stand out with bold flavors and plenty of cheese. The margherita is a must for anyone chasing that classic, fresh-herb finish. If you want something even more robust, try their veggie pizza with its garden-fresh toppings.
With options from thin to traditional crust, Camillos offers a memorable Kutztown pizza experience. There’s a warmth here that lingers long after your last bite.
8. Giovanna’s Pizzeria
(484) 641-5200Call
Giovanna’s Pizzeria is the kind of place where locals greet the staff by name and out-of-towners are quickly made to feel welcome. Tucked in the Weiss Plaza, it keeps things simple—pizza first, always. I remember stumbling in on a busy Friday, and leaving impressed by how every table had their own go-to order.
Affordability meets quality at Giovanna’s. Their classic cheese and veggie pizzas are favorites, with a sauce that’s bright and distinct, and a crust that walks the line between crisp and pillowy. Generous toppings cover every inch of the pie, never skimped.
Order a medium for yourself or share a large—either way, you’ll see why so many keep this spot on their regular rotation. Familiar, tasty, and budget-friendly, Giovanna’s delivers on its promise.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Kutztown is where cravings meet convenience. Many nights studying or working late, I’ve relied on their online ordering to keep everything easy and predictable. The delivery’s quick, and the pizza always arrives piping hot.
What sets Domino’s apart is the range of crust options—from classic hand-tossed to crunchy thin or thick pan. If you’re going for pure comfort, order the Hand Tossed Veggie or the thin crust option. Everything comes with that familiar, gooey cheese pull that defines Domino’s everywhere.
With regular specials and custom toppings, it’s a practical choice for group munchies or solo indulgence. Consistency, speed, and plenty of options make Domino’s a Kutztown go-to.
10. Uncle Joe’s Authentic Ny Pzzr
(484) 648-2720Call
Uncle Joe’s Authentic NY Pzzr is where you go in Kutztown for that real-deal New York slice. You know the kind—wide, almost too big for a paper plate, and just the right amount of fold. I dropped in on a whim one rainy day and knew right away I’d found something special.
The dough sets Uncle Joe’s apart—thin, chewy, with a crisp bottom that bends but never busts. The plain cheese slice is bold with tomato flavor, topped with enough cheese to make it satisfying but not heavy. People who know their pizza argue gently by the counter about ‘best in town.’
If you’re the type who judges pizza by its crust, start with a classic cheese or veggie slice. Uncle Joe’s delivers that unmistakable city flavor, no train ride required.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Kutztown, PA?
Some favorites include Demarco’s Italian Restaurant, Camillo’s Italian Restaurant & Bar, Valentino’s, Tommyboy’s Pizza And Cafe, Folino Estate, and Mamma Delight Pizza Restaurant. Each offers its own style, from classic crusts to wood-fired specialties.
Are there gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Kutztown?
Folino Estate and several other spots provide gluten-free and vegan choices. It’s always best to call ahead if you have food allergies or preferences.
Who delivers pizza in Kutztown?
Most local pizzerias, including Domino’s, Camillo’s, and Giovanna’s Pizzeria, offer delivery. Check individual restaurant sites or call for details and delivery areas.
What is the most popular style of pizza in Kutztown?
You’ll find thin, New York-style slices as well as classic hand-tossed crusts. Some places like Folino Estate specialize in rustic, wood-fired pies, while others stick to tradition with crisp, chewy slices.
Is it easy to find vegetarian pizza options?
Absolutely. Nearly all pizzerias serve vegetarian pies loaded with fresh toppings. Try veggie options at Valentino’s, Demarco’s, or Folino Estate for extra variety.