Finding truly great pizza in Kissimmee, FL can feel like a quest. You wander vibrant streets, tempted by the aroma of garlic, melted cheese, and that unmistakable whiff of crispy crust. It took me more than a few attempts (and the occasional disappointment) to narrow down the spots that really do pizza right—each with a signature twist, from bubbly thin crusts to gooey deep-dish.
Kissimmee’s pizza scene has personality. You’ll find cozy family-run counters, buzzing bar-and-grill hangouts, and local legends with a devoted following. After exploring these kitchens bite by bite, it’s safe to say your next perfect pizza could be just around the corner. The list ahead isn’t hyped-up tourist fare—these are the ones locals keep coming back for, and after one slice, you’ll understand why.
1. Flippers Pizzeria
Flippers Pizzeria charms with its buzzing, friendly vibe and a menu that feels fresh yet classic. I still remember sinking my teeth into a Margherita pie here—the crust was blistered just right, and the basil popped with flavor. This place knows how to strike a balance between old-school pizza comfort and a dash of creativity.
What makes Flippers stand out? Quality. Every pizza comes out of a brick oven, with genuine mozzarella and zesty sauce that tastes anything but generic. Whether you swing for a thin, crispy crust or something a bit more hearty, there’s no compromise.
I’d say go for the Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza or their signature Key West Chicken—each bite broadcasts why locals recommend them. Plenty of gluten-free and vegan options, too, so nobody misses out.
2. Pizzeria Uno Chicago Bar & Grill
Pizzeria Uno Chicago Bar & Grill brings a slice of Chicago to Kissimmee, stepping up the pizza game with its iconic deep-dish. I remember my first visit—watching the cheese pull stretch a mile as I lifted a slice was as satisfying as it sounds. That buttery, thick crust is proof they still make dough fresh each morning.
What sets Uno apart is choice. Whether you’re chasing that classic deep-dish or curious about their Detroit-style, bold flavors headline every pie. The Chicago Thin Crust, loaded with toppings, is a great pick for crunch lovers.
Order the Numero Uno Deep Dish for the full experience—layered with chunky tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and a medley of vegetables. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free pizza fans will find something here, too.
3. Giordano’s
Giordano’s is the place you go when you’ve got a serious craving for Chicago-style deep dish in Kissimmee. The first time I tried it, the molten layers of cheese and sauce made it more of an event than a meal. This isn’t just pizza—it’s a fork-and-knife affair, hearty and unforgettable.
What makes Giordano’s stand out is their commitment to tradition. Every deep dish is hand-crafted, with a flaky, golden crust that tastes as good as it looks. The atmosphere is both family-friendly and relaxed, so it’s great for gatherings or low-key nights out.
Order their Classic Deep Dish. The blend of cheeses, chunky tomato sauce, and crisp yet tender crust set the standard for deep dish in the area. Vegetarian and gluten-free options let everyone join in.
4. Flippers Pizzeria
This Flippers Pizzeria location feels like a local staple, with a thirty-year history and a steady stream of satisfied regulars. I visited on a busy afternoon, and the buzz inside matched the sizzling ovens at the back. The menu features brick-oven pies made with pure, fresh ingredients—a standout in a world of shortcuts.
Flippers’ strength is its variety. Signature pizzas like the Buffalo Chicken and California Classic show off their knack for layered flavors and just the right dose of crunch and chew in each crust. You can taste the difference with every bite.
If you’re curious, opt for the Brick-Fired Breadsticks and a specialty pizza for the full experience. Vegans and vegetarians are covered, making it a top pick for groups with different tastes.
5. Cicis
Cicis offers a pizza buffet that draws in families, friends, and anyone who loves options. My last visit was with a group of friends eager to try a little bit of everything—plates were stacked high, and nobody left hungry. The appeal is real: unlimited pizza at a single flat price, and you can sample as many varieties as you want.
What sets Cicis apart is the sheer casual, come-as-you-are comfort and value. The pizza stays hot and fresh, with plenty of veggie-topped choices always making the rounds.
If you’re curious, start with the classic cheese or spin through their loaded veggie pie—both keep regulars coming back. This spot is great for groups with different tastes, and dessert pizza is a fun, sweet finish.
6. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza on W Irlo Bronson Memorial Hwy is a go-to for anyone craving variety without breaking the bank. I remember stopping in after a long day at the parks—walking into a buffet of hot pizzas felt like an instant reward. There’s something for everyone here, with options that keep coming out fresh all day.
This location stands out for its quick service and extra-friendly staff. The atmosphere is laid-back, perfect for families or anyone who wants a casual meal with plenty of choices.
Try their Veggie Pizza for a flavorful bite, or create your own—there’s always plenty of toppings to experiment with. Finish things off with a slice of cinnamon dessert pizza for the ultimate buffet finale.
7. Upper Crust Pizza
+1 407-566-1221
Upper Crust Pizza on Market Street is an easy favorite when you want a straightforward, delicious pizza. My first slice here reminded me of classic pizzeria slices—chewy, with a crisp edge and plenty of bold flavor. They focus on the essentials, delivering quality with every order, whether you dine in or get it delivered.
Upper Crust stands out for consistency. The menu is tight, with pizzas, wings, and calzones made the traditional way. They also offer vegan and vegetarian options, making it easy for anyone to find a favorite.
The Margherita is a must for its vibrant sauce and fresh basil, while the Veggie Supreme packs in color and crunch. Generous portions and outdoor seating give it a local charm that regulars love.
8. Pienezza Pizza
Pienezza Pizza is where the spirit of New York lands right in Kissimmee, served up by a family who takes their craft seriously. I first tried their classic round pie on a laid-back afternoon; the chewy crust and zesty sauce sang with every bite. This place feels personal and genuine, with options far beyond your standard slice.
What really sets Pienezza apart is the range—Sicilian, classic, vegan, and gluten-free pies, all made to order. It’s clear they believe good pizza should bring people together, no matter your flavor or dietary preference.
Treat yourself to a slice of their classic cheese or go big with the Sicilian if you’re after that perfect, pillowy thickness. The friendly service and creative specials make each visit feel like a find.
9. Broadway Pizza Bar
Broadway Pizza Bar has a way of turning a casual pizza night into something memorable. I grabbed a table with friends one evening, and the conversation kept circling back to the excellent crust—just the right crisp outside and chewy within. You can tell they take pride in doing the classics right, while keeping the menu interesting.
The atmosphere leans friendly and comfortable, perfect for groups or low-key dinners. Each pizza feels thoughtfully made, with fresh toppings and plenty of veggie-friendly options for anyone skipping the meat.
Their Veggie Supreme and Margherita pizzas are standouts: bursting with flavor and color. If you want to try something with a bit of personality, Broadway’s pies deliver every time.
10. Via Capri Pizzeria
Via Capri Pizzeria brings a piece of Italy to Kissimmee, with a cozy space and pizzas that taste truly authentic. I dropped by after hearing locals rave, and the first bite of their Margherita told the whole story—simple, fresh, and deeply satisfying. The dough is airy with just the right chew, and you can tell everything is made with care.
Via Capri stands out for their devotion to tradition. The pizzas are baked to order, and the ingredients—like San Marzano tomatoes and creamy mozzarella—really make each pie sing.
The Quattro Formaggi is a must if you love cheese, and their Margherita is a classic, always served bubbling and hot. Plenty of vegetarian options give everyone a reason to come back.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Kissimmee?
You’ll find almost everything—New York–style, deep dish Chicago, classic hand-tossed, Sicilian, and even Detroit-style. Whether you love a thin, foldable slice or a thick, cheesy pie, there’s something for every preference.
Are there halal, vegetarian, vegan, or gluten-free pizza options in Kissimmee?
Yes, many pizzerias offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas, plus gluten-free crusts. You’ll want to check with each spot for specific options and preparation methods that meet your dietary needs.
Which pizza places in Kissimmee are best for families or groups?
Cicis, Broadway Pizza Bar, and Flippers Pizzeria are all family favorites, thanks to their comfortable settings and menu choices for all ages.
Can I order pizza for delivery or takeout in Kissimmee?
Most places offer both delivery and takeout. Many also have online ordering for extra convenience.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Kissimmee?
Spots like Giordano’s, Via Capri, and Broadway Pizza Bar serve late, so you can grab a slice or a whole pie after most other places have closed.
Do these pizzerias accommodate large parties or offer catering?
Several, including Flippers Pizzeria and Pienezza Pizza, provide catering and group pricing—ideal for celebrations or events.