Best Pizza in Kingston, PA

There’s a secret to Kingston, PA that smells like bubbling cheese and crisp, golden crusts. It isn’t just the hum of glowing pizza ovens or the sauces simmering behind counter windows. In Kingston, hunting for great pizza is almost a competitive sport. I still remember the first time I slid a piping hot slice from a battered takeout box—edges dusted with a gentle crunch, cheese stretching like a dare. That single bite was enough to start a personal quest.

I’ve tasted my way through the town, from small, family-owned gems tucked into quiet corners to lively spots where every table is claimed by loyal fans. Finding the best pizza in Kingston isn’t just about the biggest name or the fanciest toppings; it’s about discovering that rare combination of rich flavor, perfect texture, and local pride. If you’re ready to embark on a slice-by-slice adventure, let’s get right to the real contenders—because every spot on this list has earned its place, and you’re about to find out why.

1. Tommy’s Pizza Corner

Tommy’s Pizza Corner sits right on Market Street and feels like a neighborhood fixture from the moment you step inside. The air carries that unmistakable scent of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. Tommy’s isn’t about flash, but about nailing the classics.

My visits always start with a plain cheese pizza. The crust is crispy, yet soft enough to fold. The sauce is tangy, never overwhelming, and the cheese melts into a perfect golden layer. If you want something special, try the white pizza—creamy, garlicky, and a local favorite.

What truly sets Tommy’s apart is the comforting, unpretentious vibe combined with fast, friendly service. This is pizza the way locals like it: hot, honest, and impossible to eat just one slice.

2. Sizzle Pi Pizza

Walking into Sizzle Pi Pizza on Pierce Street feels like catching on to a local secret. This place leans into the “legendary” claim, and delivers it without fuss. I once stopped in after hearing buzz from regulars and was handed a slice that meant business—thin, crispy, with a punchy sauce you remember long after.

The menu is straightforward, but the classic round pizza is where Sizzle Pi shines. Each bite offers a delicate crunch and bold flavors that let the quality do the talking. If you’re curious, the plain slice is the right place to start. Big eaters often go for the double cheese or a half-and-half to sample the style.

Cash only keeps the vibe old-school, but the pizza is anything but dated. For pure, signature Kingston taste, Sizzle Pi quietly leads the pack.

3. Pizza Bella

Pizza Bella on Wyoming Avenue feels like one of those reliable spots you stumble onto and then recommend to everyone. The kitchen buzzes with energy, and their pizza boxes are a familiar sight at neighborhood get-togethers. My favorite memory? Sharing a Bella Supreme with friends—the generous toppings made every bite stand out.

What sets Pizza Bella apart is consistency and that home-cooked spirit. The crust is always just right, thin enough to let the toppings shine but sturdy enough for a proper fold. The sauce leans a bit sweet, mixing well with gooey cheese and fresh veggies.

If you’re looking for something extra, try the Sicilian slice. It’s thick, soft, and loaded without being heavy—a unique local take that keeps people coming back for more.

4. Antonio’s Pizza Deluxe

Antonio’s Pizza Deluxe inside the West Side Mall offers a little taste of Italy with a local flair. The scent of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce hits you before you even reach the counter. On my last visit, I was handed a slice that felt straight from a family kitchen—crisp edges, generous cheese, and a sauce that lingers in the best way.

Antonio’s excels at pan pizzas, perfectly golden underneath and delightfully chewy. Try the Deluxe Pizza, loaded with veggies and just enough cheese to keep each bite interesting. Their Margherita is another worthy pick, standing out for its simplicity and freshness.

This spot’s commitment to quality makes it a stand-out for both quick lunches and casual family dinners.

5. Lino’s Quality Pizza

Lino’s Quality Pizza lives up to its name, tucked along Wyoming Avenue with a warm, inviting feel. The pizzas are made fresh, with hand-stretched dough and sauces that taste like someone’s Nonna whipped them up. My first experience here involved a classic round pizza, and I was struck by the balance—golden crust, zesty sauce, and cheese that pulls away in long, satisfying strings.

Lino’s excels with their specialty pizzas. The Veggie Lovers and White Broccoli pies pack fresh toppings and flavor you can taste in every bite. The Margherita is a great pick if you lean simple but want bold, rich tomato and basil notes.

A little old-school, a little modern, Lino’s is the go-to for anyone wanting real ingredients and a true Kingston pizza experience.

6. Januzzis Pizza

Januzzis Pizza is where I learned how a humble pizza shop can quickly become your go-to dinner solution. Located right on Wyoming Avenue, this spot has a loyal following for a reason. The pies are classic, straight to the point, and never skimpy with the cheese.

My first time, I tried a simple pepperoni and was impressed by the even bake and punchy sauce. The crust here is thin, airy in the middle, and golden at the edge, ready to please any pizza purist. If you want something extra, their veggie-topped pizza is loaded and never soggy.

Januzzis balances speed with flavor, making it perfect for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner. It’s a staple for anyone looking for straightforward, satisfying pizza in Kingston.

7. Papa V’s

Papa V’s on Northampton Street serves up pizza with a homey, old-school vibe that’s easy to love. This is the kind of place where familiarity and great service go hand in hand. My first visit was the result of a friend’s recommendation, and it immediately turned into a regular craving.

The standout here is their hand-tossed crust—soft inside, golden and crackly on the outside. Go for the plain cheese or the veggie pizza if you want the best of what Papa V’s does. Their sauce has a nice tang, and the cheese hits the right savory notes every time.

For a reliable slice that never disappoints, Papa V’s holds its own in Kingston’s crowded pizza scene. It’s a small spot big on taste.

8. Costello’s

Costello’s on South Wyoming Avenue is that cheerful neighborhood pizzeria where the staff remembers your order if you visit twice. Every pizza is made to order, and you can taste the difference in the crust—always that perfect middle ground between chewy and crisp. It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back.

I’ve enjoyed many lunches here, but the standout for me has to be their classic round pie with extra cheese. The sauce at Costello’s is bright and flavorful, blending just right with generous layers of creamy cheese. If you’re sharing, try the veggie or pepper pizza—they hit all the savory cravings.

Fast service and a reliably great slice make Costello’s a must-try for any Kingston pizza lover.

9. Domino’s Pizza

Domino’s Pizza on Market Street is the go-to for anyone who values speed and consistency. This chain has a knack for delivering hot, reliable pies whether you’re picking up or ordering in. I’ve turned to Domino’s more than once for late-night cravings or quick group meals.

What makes Domino’s stand out here is variety. Try the Handmade Pan pizza for a pillowy, buttery crust, or opt for the thin-crust if you like more crunch. Their Vegetarian pizza is a safe bet, loaded with fresh toppings and satisfying cheese pulls.

Domino’s doesn’t try to be fancy, but it nails the essentials every time. When you want simple, customizable pizza fast, it’s hard to go wrong.

10. Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut on Wyoming Avenue has become one of those comfort spots when you want familiar flavors and easy choices. This is where I grab a Stuffed Crust when the craving for melty cheese and a buttery rim strikes. The menu is classic and crowd-pleasing, with plenty of variety to keep everyone happy.

The Meat Lovers® is a perennial favorite for those wanting a loaded pie, but the Veggie Lover’s hits that balance between fresh and hearty. I’ve also enjoyed their Pan Pizza, which stands out for its soft center and crispy edges.

Whether you order for a family dinner or a quick solo lunch, Pizza Hut delivers reliability and no-frills, comforting pizza—a dependable choice in the Kingston pizza lineup.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top-rated pizza places in Kingston, PA?
Locals love places like Tommy’s Pizza Corner, Sizzle Pi Pizza, and Lino’s Quality Pizza for their unique flavors and consistent quality. Big names like Pizza Hut and Domino’s offer easy takeout and delivery, but the independent spots win for personality.

Is there any spot known for vegetarian pizza in Kingston?
Most pizzerias offer excellent vegetarian options. Try Lino’s Veggie Lovers, Domino’s Vegetarian, or the veggie pizza at Papa V’s for generous veggie toppings done right.

Can I find gluten-free pizza options in Kingston?
Domino’s and Pizza Hut both have gluten-free crust options, but it’s always wise to call ahead for details. Independent shops may offer alternatives by request.

Which pizza spot has the fastest service?
Chain locations like Domino’s and Pizza Hut offer some of the fastest delivery. For quick local eats, Costello’s and Januzzis Pizza are known for speedy pickup orders.

What’s the best pizza style unique to Kingston?
Kingston’s signature often leans toward pan and Sicilian styles. Don’t miss Pizza Bella’s Sicilian slice or Antonio’s famed pan pizza for a local, hearty spin.