There’s something magic about the search for the best pizza in Johnson City, TN. One week you’re trying hand-tossed crust at a bustling pizzeria on Roan Street, the next you’re splitting a bubbling pie at a neighborhood spot where the regulars know your name. Over the years, I’ve eaten enough slices to confirm that pizza here is more than just a meal—it’s a glue that holds together ballgames, late-night study sessions, and family catch-ups.
Locals each have their sworn favorites, but newcomers can rest easy: Johnson City’s pizza landscape has layers of flavor, creativity, and genuine character. You’ll find every style, from classic New York slices to bubbly wood-fired creations. For anyone craving the real deal, or simply hunting for a place that feels like home, this guide slices through the options. Whether you like your pizza thin, thick, or loaded with cheese, there’s a table waiting for you.
1. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den is a classic staple for students and locals alike, sitting right between ETSU and downtown. Walking in, you’re hit with the aroma of fresh, hand-tossed dough—made even better by the generous piles of toppings.
What sets Fox’s apart is the family-run atmosphere and the passion for top-quality ingredients. Seth Righi’s focus on freshness shows in every bite, whether you opt for a traditional pie or a loaded veggie option. It’s the kind of spot where you feel like a regular after one visit.
If you can’t decide, their Big Daddy Pizza is a crowd-pleaser—impossibly big, cheesy, and perfect for sharing. A slice from Fox’s is reliably hearty, comforting, and proof that good pizza brings people together.
2. Cootie Brown’s N. Roan St.
Cootie Brown’s N. Roan St. feels a bit like stepping into a quirky art gallery—with a side of irresistible pizza. The bright, creative vibe makes every meal feel special, no matter the occasion.
Cootie Brown’s stands out for its inventive pizzas and attention to dietary needs. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options mean that everyone at the table gets their slice just right. You’ll always spot regulars swapping recommendations with first-timers.
When I visited, the Garden Pesto Pizza was the real star—laden with fresh veggies and drizzled with pesto, it’s both light and satisfying. Cootie Brown’s is where local flavor meets creativity, and every pizza tells its own story.
3. Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza
Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza pulls off that classic city flavor in the heart of Johnson City. The dough is fresh, the sauce is tangy, and every bite takes you straight to a bustling New York street corner.
What makes Johnny Brusco’s memorable is their commitment to hand-tossed, brick-oven baked pies. You’ll taste that extra depth—crust that’s both soft and crispy, topped with premium cheese and fresh-cut veggies.
I keep coming back for the Johnny’s Deluxe Pizza. The balance of cheese, peppers, onions, and mushrooms nails what a loaded New York pizza should be. Their gluten-free and vegan options mean no one misses out, making it a crowd-pleaser for any group.
4. Mellow Mushroom Johnson City
Mellow Mushroom Johnson City looks and feels like nowhere else, with murals splashed across the walls and a laid-back atmosphere that encourages you to take your time. The energy is as vibrant as their pizza menu.
Their hand-tossed, spring water crust is the game-changer, giving each pie that perfect chewy bite. Fresh toppings and vegan or vegetarian alternatives ensure every pizza comes with personality and plenty of color.
The must-try here is the Kosmic Karma Pizza, a blend of mozzarella, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and a swirl of pesto. It’s a slice that showcases both their creative flair and their commitment to quality ingredients—and will have you planning your next visit before the last bite.
5. Rocks Wood Fired Pizza & Grill
Rocks Wood Fired Pizza & Grill brings a cozy yet refined touch to the pizza scene, especially with its spacious patio and glowing stone fireplace. There’s something almost meditative about watching a pizza bubble up inside a real wood-fired oven.
The main draw here is clear: the bold, smoky flavor you only get from true wood-fired pies. The crust arrives crisp at the edges and tender within, never overwhelming the balance of sauce and cheese.
The Margherita Pizza is a must-try. Fresh basil and gooey mozzarella meet a charred, blistered crust—simple yet deeply satisfying. For anyone searching for artisan pizza in Johnson City, Rocks is a flavorful stop that delivers on atmosphere and taste.
6. Italian Pizza Pub
Italian Pizza Pub is as unfussy as it gets—just cozy booths, friendly faces, and slices that hit the spot. It’s the kind of place you stumble into with friends and leave with a new go-to pizza order.
What makes Italian Pizza Pub stand out is its old-school approach: classic recipes, no shortcuts, just good food made right. Portions are generous, and there’s a sense of tradition in every dish that keeps regulars coming back.
Order the Super Deluxe Pizza for a real sampler of their best—each bite is layered with melty cheese and fresh-picked toppings. Perfect for sharing, but you might not want to. Italian Pizza Pub is a reminder that comfort and quality never go out of style.
7. Greg’s Pizza
Greg’s Pizza is a local legend, with a no-frills dining room and pies that have drawn crowds for decades. It’s the sort of spot where families gather after a game and share stories over a giant, bubbling pizza.
The charm here is all about consistency and local loyalty. People return not just for the food, but for the taste of tradition that Greg’s serves up with every slice. The dough is pillowy, the cheese stretch is real, and service comes with a smile.
If you’re new, try the House Special Pizza. Loaded with cheese and crunchy veggies, it’s the local favorite for a reason. Greg’s keeps things simple—letting fresh ingredients and trusted recipes do all the talking.
8. Giovanni’s Boones Creek
Giovanni’s Boones Creek is one of those places where small-town hospitality meets big Italian flavors. The intimate setting and friendly staff make you feel like you’ve stumbled onto a family secret.
What sets Giovanni’s apart is its dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients and homemade dough—you’ll taste the difference in every bite. Vegan and vegetarian guests also get solid options, making everyone feel welcome at the table.
For a taste of Giovanni’s craft, grab the Veggie Supreme Pizza. It’s packed with fresh vegetables on a perfectly baked crust. No frozen shortcuts, just well-made pizza and a sense of belonging. When you’re looking for comfort with a side of character, Giovanni’s is a worthy stop.
9. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza brings a dependable slice to Johnson City’s ever-growing pizza lineup. It’s the reliable pick for those weeknights when nothing but classic comfort food will do—order in, settle down, and enjoy.
Consistency is the watchword here—every pie comes out with the same balance of sauce, cheese, and chew. Whether you grab it to-go or for delivery, Marco’s delivers the same quality each time. It’s not flashy, but it’s satisfyingly familiar.
If you’re new, the White Cheezy Pizza is a safe bet—offering rich, creamy cheese atop that signature golden crust. There’s a quiet satisfaction in knowing exactly what you’ll get, and Marco’s lets the classic flavors shine without distraction.
10. Simms Pizzeria
Simms Pizzeria feels like the type of place where every pie is a personal project. Step inside and you’ll spot regulars swapping stories, and staff that treat every customer like a guest at their own table.
The appeal here is freshness from start to finish. Whether you’re a vegan, vegetarian, or classic pizza fan, Simms puts care and flavor into every order. No shortcuts. Every slice is made with intention.
For something that captures Simms’ style, try the Spinach White Pizza. Creamy, garlicky, and loaded with fresh greens, it’s both distinctive and comforting. Simms shines through its community feel and unpretentious, consistently tasty pizza.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most popular pizza style in Johnson City?
New York-style is the go-to for many, but wood-fired and thick crust pies have strong followings as well. Each pizzeria puts its own spin on classic favorites.
Are there good vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Johnson City?
Yes. Spots like Cootie Brown’s, Mellow Mushroom, Simms Pizzeria, and Giovanni’s Boones Creek offer creative and satisfying plant-based pizzas.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Johnson City?
Mellow Mushroom, Cootie Brown’s, and Johnny Brusco’s have gluten-free crusts, so you’ll have no trouble finding a safe—and tasty—option.
Do any pizza places in Johnson City deliver?
Many do, including Marco’s Pizza, Fox’s Pizza Den, and the national chains. Delivery coverage is solid across town, convenient for busy nights or gatherings.
Which pizzeria is best for families or groups?
Fox’s Pizza Den, Greg’s Pizza, and places like Italian Pizza Pub are popular for family meals and larger groups, thanks to big tables, shareable pies, and a relaxed vibe.
Is it easy to find a quick lunch pizza spot in Johnson City?
Absolutely. Spots like Simms Pizzeria, Giovanni’s, and Little Caesars offer speedy service for a fast and filling meal.