Finding really good pizza in Jeffersonville, Indiana is both a quest and an adventure. Having spent countless evenings in pizzerias across Southern Indiana, I’ve tasted slices that range from the boldly original to the comfortingly classic. Jeffersonville offers a surprising variety—deciding where to get your next pizza hit is never straightforward, but that’s half the fun.
If you’re interested in more than bland chains and cardboard crusts, this list delivers. Whether you favor bubbling cheese, loaded toppings, or sauce that’s made fresh, every place below offers something unique. My honest take, drawn from real-life, cheese-stained outings and plenty of debates with friends, should save you from indecision. The best slice in town? You’ll want to keep reading and find out for yourself.
1. Parlour
Parlour snags attention the moment you spot its brick exterior and relaxed patio scene. Inside, the vibe is lively but never too loud—a perfect spot to settle in with friends or family. I’ve lost count of how many times their wood-fired pies have lured me back.
Their crust is no afterthought: airy, just smoky enough, and made to share. Parlour’s veggie-forward pizzas offer bright flavor without feeling like an after-school project gone wrong. If you want to see what they do best, try the Margherita; it’s classic, with a sauce so fresh you’ll taste summer in every bite.
Not just for pizza purists: their creative specials, gluten-free, and vegan-friendly crusts mean nobody is sidelined. Whether for a lunch break or a long dinner, Parlour sets the bar high in Jeffersonville’s pizza scene.
2. Boombozz Pizza & Watch Bar
Boombozz Pizza & Watch Bar raises the bar for pizza nights in Jeffersonville. The atmosphere is a lively blend of sports bar energy and family-friendly charm. I’ve claimed a booth during a championship game and couldn’t help but cheer with a slice in hand.
This place is all about bold, inventive pies. The Boom Bozz pizza, loaded with peppers, onions, and plenty of cheese, is a favorite for good reason. It’s hearty without being overwhelming and strikes the right balance of crispy crust and gooey toppings.
Prefer something different? Boombozz shines with gluten-free and vegan pizza options. Don’t skip their appetizers or the signature Pollotate pizza—it’s decked out with potato slices, roasted garlic, and plenty of cheese, making for a memorable experience in every bite.
3. Derby City Pizza
Derby City Pizza is that Jeffersonville staple you hear locals swear by. Walking in, there’s an ever-present aroma of fresh dough and tomato sauce—a sign you’ve chosen wisely. I’ve swung by after a long week more times than I can admit, because their pizza simply hits the spot.
Their thin crust has crunch without sacrificing flavor. Derby City doesn’t drown their pies in sauce; instead, the flavors are balanced so every ingredient gets its moment. I’m partial to the Derby Supreme, stacked with fresh veggies and a generous helping of cheese. It’s the kind of pizza that tastes homemade, but with that pizzeria magic you just can’t replicate.
If you crave classic comfort and crave it quickly, Derby City is an easy winner in Jeffersonville’s pizza lineup.
4. Jet’s Pizza
Jet’s Pizza is the spot you hit when you want big flavor and zero fuss. Stepping inside, you’ll notice the buzz of people who know exactly what they’re craving. I stopped in on a whim during a road trip, and it turned into a repeat destination for its consistency alone.
The magic starts with their Detroit-style deep dish—a golden, crunchy crust that somehow stays perfectly soft in the middle. The 8 Corner Pizza is a must for groups, with those coveted crispy edges everyone fights over. If you want the ideal bite, go bold with their Turbo Crust for a garlicky kick.
Value meets variety here, making Jet’s a great option when you want a sturdy, crave-worthy square delivered fast.
5. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza knows how to win you over with its blend of classic and creative pies. I first stumbled on Marco’s late one evening when most spots had closed, and their friendly staff made the whole place feel inviting, like a reliable neighborhood haunt.
Their dough is made fresh daily, which makes every bite soft yet chewy. The Pepperoni Magnifico is a favorite, loaded edge-to-edge with crispy pepperoni and Marco’s signature sauce—it’s simple, but that’s the charm. For something different, try their White Cheezy pizza, which has a creamy garlic sauce and a blend of four cheeses.
Speedy delivery and generous portions help Marco’s stand out, especially when a pizza craving hits out of the blue.
6. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza often ends up on my table during late study nights or movie marathons. There’s a certain comfort in knowing your pizza will taste the same every time, no surprises—just that familiar aroma and cheesy goodness.
The real standout here is the crust, pillowy soft and brushed with a slight hint of garlic. Their Cheese Pizza is my standard order, but the Garden Fresh is my go-to when I crave more veggies without losing that signature Papa Johns flavor. The tangy sauce ties it all together.
Fast delivery and consistent pies make this spot a no-brainer when you don’t want to risk dinner on a gamble. Papa Johns keeps it simple, but always hits the right notes for pizza night.
7. Little Caesars
Little Caesars delivers on speed and value, especially when hunger strikes out of nowhere. I’ve stopped here more than a few times on the way home, knowing the “Hot-N-Ready” sign never lets me down. If you’re in a hurry and want pizza without a wait, this is the spot.
The Deep! Deep! Dish is where Little Caesars shines. It has a crunchy, caramelized crust and generous cheese that you just can’t rush. For classic cravings, their ExtraMostBestest offers extra cheese and pepperoni layered edge-to-edge, without breaking the bank.
Simplicity and convenience rule here. Little Caesars doesn’t try to be fancy, but sometimes that’s exactly what the moment calls for—a solid, satisfying slice on your terms.
8. Pizza King
Pizza King feels like a throwback, and that’s a big part of its charm. Step inside and you’ll see regulars chatting over classic pies and baskets of fries. I first tried their pizza during a lunch break and remember how surprisingly crisp the crust was—simple and perfect with every bite.
Pepperoni lovers should try their signature round pizza cut into party squares. The toppings reach the edge, giving every square bite a satisfying crunch. Their garlic cheese bread is worth adding to any order—golden, garlicky, and impossible to share.
If you want a no-nonsense, nostalgia-packed pizza experience, Pizza King has it down to an art. The friendly, fast service doesn’t hurt either.
9. Godfather’s Pizza Express
Godfather’s Pizza Express proves you don’t need a full-scale restaurant to serve up memorable pizza. It’s quick, efficient, and delivers that familiar Godfather’s flavor I remember from childhood road trips. Grab-and-go never tasted this good or felt this easy.
Their classic combo pizza is loaded with veggies and beef, each slice generously layered and not shy on cheese. The crust strikes a nice balance—soft in the middle, crispy at the edges, and just the right thickness to hold up toppings.
If you crave hearty, traditional pies in a hurry, Godfather’s offers satisfying slices without the wait. Stop here for dependable taste and zero frills; sometimes that’s all you really want.
10. Jeffersonville Pizza
Jeffersonville Pizza has that classic neighborhood pizzeria atmosphere—easy, friendly, and full of regulars who know their order by heart. I dropped in on a rainy afternoon, and the welcoming vibe paired with the smell of baking pizza made me feel right at home.
Their signature is the square-cut pizza loaded with edge-to-edge toppings. Every bite balances crisp crust and stretchy cheese; nothing soggy here. The veggie pizza really delivers, stacked with mushrooms, onions, and peppers that keep each slice fresh and far from boring.
If you’re after a side, the garlic cheese bread is always a crowd-pleaser, golden and gooey in equal measure. Jeffersonville Pizza keeps their menu classic and the quality high, which explains why so many locals swear by it for pizza night.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places for dine-in in Jeffersonville, IN?
Parlour, Boombozz Pizza & Watch Bar, and Derby City Pizza are popular spots known for tasty pizza and comfortable dine-in settings.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Jeffersonville?
Try Parlour or Boombozz Pizza & Watch Bar for strong vegetarian and vegan menus. Jet’s Pizza also offers dairy-free and gluten-free choices.
Which place serves Detroit-style or square-cut pizza?
Jet’s Pizza is known for authentic Detroit-style deep dish. For square-cut classics, Pizza King and Jeffersonville Pizza both deliver.
Who has the fastest pizza delivery in Jeffersonville?
Papa Johns, Marco’s Pizza, and Domino’s are consistently quick with delivery, offering reliable service and fresh pies.
Are there any local, non-chain pizza restaurants worth visiting?
Absolutely—Parlour, Derby City Pizza, and Jeffersonville Pizza stand out with homemade touches and original recipes.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Jeffersonville?
Boombozz Pizza & Watch Bar, Parlour, and Jet’s Pizza each have gluten-free options that don’t skimp on flavor.
Do any pizza places offer take-and-bake options?
Papa Murphy’s specializes in take-and-bake pizzas for fresh-from-your-oven results at home.
Which pizza spot is best for large groups or families?
Try Parlour or Derby City Pizza for spacious seating and party-sized pies that keep everyone happy.