Finding the best pizza in Jefferson, WI isn’t just about a slice; it’s a quest. This small Wisconsin town doesn’t brag, but its pizzerias serve up some of the finest dough, sauce, and cheese combinations you’ll ever meet. Over the years, I’ve wandered Jefferson’s streets with one mission: sample every pizza joint I could find—even those tucked behind gas stations or disguised as family diners. It’s hard work, but no one can say I haven’t conducted thorough (and delicious) research.
If you’ve ever argued about thin crust versus deep dish, or you have a favorite cheese blend you’d fight for, this list is tailored for you. You’ll get details on each spot, from forgotten gems to big-name chains, ranking flavors, crust, atmosphere, and creativity. Hungry yet? Trust this guide as you hunt down your next great pizza, whether you crave classic pepperoni or a pie with a twist.
1. Towne Inn
Towne Inn has the cozy charm of a hometown pizzeria with the sort of satisfying pizza you remember long after you leave. Located in the heart of Jefferson, it feels like a place where everyone knows your name—or at least your favorite topping. The staff keeps things friendly and efficient, whether you’re eating in or carrying out.
My last visit ended with a debate at the table over which crust to get. The thin crust edged out as the favorite, with its golden edges and just the right crunch. The classic sausage and mushroom remains a local legend, with sausage that’s seasoned perfectly and slices that hold form but never skimp on cheese.
Order their supreme pizza for the full Towne Inn experience. It’s piled high, never soggy, and always fresh. This pizza stands as proof that simple ingredients, in good hands, can deliver pure comfort.
2. Gordy’s Pizza & Italian Food
Gordy’s Pizza & Italian Food feels like the kind of spot you hear about first from a local—then confirm for yourself with every bite. Tucked along Racine Street, Gordy’s keeps the menu tight and the focus sharp. There’s no fuss, only honest, well-made pizza that keeps regulars loyal.
I remember trying the pepperoni on a gray afternoon. The cheese was stretchy, the crust just thick enough to be satisfying, and every slice had that savory char along the edges. Gordy’s doesn’t drown the pizza in extras; they let the flavors shine through.
Sample their cheese pizza or their veggie special. Both show off the sauce, cheese, and dough working in perfect sync—no distractions, just classic, crave-worthy comfort.
3. Pammy’s Pizzeria
Pammy’s Pizzeria has a loyal following, and after one visit, it’s easy to see why. The space is unpretentious and inviting—more like sitting in a friend’s dining room than a commercial restaurant. There’s an unmistakable focus on scratch-made quality, with each pizza assembled by hand and baked to order.
Their sauce really caught my attention: fresh, a touch sweet, and perfectly seasoned. I tried their classic cheese on one trip and loved the chewy crust with just the right amount of crisp at the base. Even when things get busy, Pammy’s never rushes your pizza—each one emerges hot with gooey cheese and balanced toppings.
Try their deluxe pizza if you want the true Pammy’s experience. Loaded but never overwhelming, it showcases the pizzeria’s commitment to flavor and freshness in every bite.
4. Rosati’s
Rosati’s is a familiar name in the region, and even though it’s just outside Jefferson, plenty of pizza seekers make the short drive for its well-loved Chicago-style pies. There’s a satisfying bustle inside and the scent of baked dough and herbs greets you right at the door.
I’ve stopped in for their thin-crust pizza on more than one occasion. It’s crisp, cut into those classic party squares, and loaded with melty cheese and tangy sauce. Their consistency is remarkable—every visit brings the same comforting flavors.
Go for their classic Italian sausage pizza or the veggie supreme. These selections capture what Rosati’s does best: flavorful toppings, quality cheese, and that doughy foundation that makes each bite memorable.
5. Pizza Pit
Pizza Pit has a fan base built on speed without sacrificing taste. Right on Main Street, this spot dials in familiar flavors and fast service, perfect for a lunch break or family dinner. The retro signage has a way of catching your eye, and the smell of baking pizza draws you in.
I’ve stopped here when craving something filling but unfussy. Their pizzas always have a crisp crust that holds up under piles of cheese. The sauce leans tangy, and toppings go generous, never shy.
The Super Pizza is a must if you want the “full Pit” experience. Loaded with veggies and meats, it’s hearty and built to satisfy a group. Slices hold up well, ideal for sharing or for next-day leftovers.
6. Little Caesars
(920) 674-9001Call
Little Caesars on Collins Road does fast pizza with no surprises, which is sometimes exactly what you need. The orange-and-white storefront promises hot, ready-made pies that you can grab and go, making it a local go-to for busy evenings. You know what you’re getting before you even walk in.
There’s something oddly comforting about a place where “Hot-N-Ready” really means you’ll walk out with dinner in hand within minutes. My go-to has always been their classic cheese pizza, mostly for the gooey stretch of mozzarella and the soft, pillowy crust underneath.
If you want a little more bite, try the ExtraMostBestest pizza. This pie stacks on extra pepperoni and cheese, creating a heartier version of the classic flavor that put Little Caesars on the map in Jefferson.
7. Buddha Belly Pizza
(608) 977-3358Call
Buddha Belly Pizza is one of those off-the-beaten-path places you hear about through word of mouth. Tucked along Business 26, it brings a creative spark to Jefferson’s pizza scene. The atmosphere is no-frills, but the menu has a playful attitude with options that go beyond the ordinary.
During my last stop, I tried one of their specialty veggie pies. The crust was perfectly toasted, the vegetables crisp and fresh. They don’t shy away from experimenting with toppings and flavors, which gives everything a distinctive kick.
Check out their Buddha’s Garden pizza. It’s a colorful, veggie-packed option that sets Buddha Belly apart. Expect fresh ingredients, a bold flavor profile, and a pizza that feels a little different in the best possible way.
8. Casey’s General Store
Casey’s General Store offers more than your average gas station stop, and the locals know it. The surprise is the pizza—made from scratch, not pulled from a freezer, and always hot. Don’t let the convenience store vibe fool you; this is a favorite for grab-and-go dinners that taste homemade.
On days when I’ve been in a hurry, Casey’s has saved dinner with their reliable, chewy crust and rich, zesty sauce. The slices are thick, generously topped, and filling enough to fuel whatever comes next.
Their cheese or veggie pizza is worth trying for classic flavor done well. Fresh, hot, and satisfying, Casey’s pies remind you that comfort food can sometimes show up in the most unexpected places.
9. Diels Leland L Pizza Villa
(920) 563-6646Call
Diels Leland L Pizza Villa is a Fort Atkinson classic that’s just a short drive from Jefferson. This old-school spot has a retro charm—think checkerboard floors and no-nonsense service. It’s the kind of pizzeria where the recipes haven’t changed in decades because they don’t need to.
I’ve found their crust is what anchors the experience: thin but sturdy, toasted just right, and packed with flavor. Topping choices are abundant, and you can taste the pride in each ingredient. The atmosphere feels like a throwback in the best way possible.
The deluxe pizza deserves a spot on your table. Loaded with all the favorites, it delivers the house’s signature style: balance, tradition, and substance in every bite.
10. Brickhouse Pizza Pub
Brickhouse Pizza Pub brings a lively, pub-style vibe to the area and is worth the trip from Jefferson. The open, bustling dining room pairs well with its menu of crowd-pleasing pizzas and creative starters. There’s always energy here, and perfect timing if you want to watch a game with friends.
I’ve enjoyed their hand-tossed crust, hearty and slightly chewy, serving as the perfect base for layers of cheese and fresh toppings. Every visit is punctuated by friendly banter from staff who know the ins and outs of the local scene.
Their Brickhouse Combo is a standout, showcasing classic flavors with a generous hand—think plenty of green peppers, onions, and fresh mushrooms. It perfectly reflects the casual, welcoming spirit of this local favorite.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for pizza in Jefferson, WI?
Some local favorites include Towne Inn, Pammy’s Pizzeria, Gordy’s Pizza & Italian Food, and Pizza Pit. Each place offers unique crusts and toppings, so it’s worth trying a few to find your favorite.
Are there pizza places in Jefferson, WI that offer takeout or delivery?
Most pizzerias in Jefferson, such as Towne Inn, Little Caesars, and Pizza Pit, offer takeout. Many also provide delivery options—check with each location for current services.
What styles of pizza can I find in Jefferson, WI?
You’ll find a variety—from classic thin crust and hand-tossed to deep-dish and party-cut tavern style. Local spots and chains all bring something different to the table.
Can I get vegetarian pizza options in Jefferson, WI?
Absolutely. Many pizza places offer veggie options, and spots like Buddha Belly Pizza and Casey’s General Store craft pizzas loaded with fresh, colorful ingredients.
Which pizza places in Jefferson, WI are best for families?
Family-friendly choices include Towne Inn, Pammy’s Pizzeria, and Brickhouse Pizza Pub. These spots offer casual atmospheres, plenty of seating, and pizzas that appeal to kids and adults alike.