There’s something a little thrilling about searching for the best pizza in Jefferson Valley, NY. Maybe it’s the memory of sharing a perfectly crisp slice with friends on a lazy Saturday, or the joy that comes from finding your go-to spot on a rainy night. Jefferson Valley might look tame on the map, but step into one of its pizzerias and it’s clear: creativity and tradition are alive (and bubbling in the oven).
You could call me obsessive, given how many pizzas I’ve tasted within these city limits—folded, square, thin-crusted, and wood-fired varieties have all passed my taste test. Even after dozens of pies, I’m convinced the right slice can completely change your day. If you crave authentic flavors, chewy crusts, bright sauce, and inventive toppings without any fuss, you’re in the right place. Let’s slice into the top pizza spots in Jefferson Valley, each bringing their own twist to an old favorite.
Where to find the best pizza in Jefferson Valley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Jefferson Valley, NY:
- Gigi Pizza & Wedges
- Frankie and Augie’z
- Calabria Pizza & Pasta
- Vittoria’Z On The Lake
- Frankie & Augie’z
- Cafe Pizzazz
- La Villetta Pizza & Pasta
- My Favorite Pizza Place
- Three Boys Pizzeria
- Rocco’s Pizzeria
1. Gigi Pizza & Wedges
+1 914-962-3355
See Menu
Gigi Pizza & Wedges feels like that under-the-radar spot you hope never gets too crowded. Walk into DeCicco Family Markets and the aroma from Gigi’s corner tells you you’re in the right section. Their slices lean classic, big on flavor, and always hot—never waiting long on the rack.
My first visit started with a plain cheese slice. The crust was chewy, the sauce bright, and the cheese didn’t overwhelm. That first bite meant instant loyalty. But it’s the signature wedges that spark curiosity; locals rave about their hearty, oversized portions.
Don’t skip the Margherita or their Sicilian squares. These highlight the kitchen’s confidence in simple, balanced flavors. If you want a laid-back spot where quality is predictable, Gigi delivers exactly that in Jefferson Valley.
2. Frankie and Augie’z
Frankie and Augie’z blends family-friendly warmth with serious pizza chops. Nestled right on Hill Blvd, its dining room buzzes with regulars who always seem to greet the staff by name. A friend first brought me here for lunch—I ended up lingering well past a second slice, drawn in by both the food and the vibe.
The menu is packed, but **the Grandma slice and the classic thin-crust cheese pizza** set the bar. Both showcase a steady hand with sauce and cheese. The crusts stay crisp, even under thick layers of toppings, making every bite balanced.
If you seek a place that feels like an extension of your own kitchen—just with way better pizza—Frankie and Augie’z is the move in Jefferson Valley.
3. Calabria Pizza & Pasta
Calabria Pizza & Pasta edges out the competition with a menu that makes you linger both at the counter and over the phone. The first time I tried their pizza—fresh from a friend’s recommendation—it arrived at my doorstep piping hot, the crust still managing that crackle you only get from real attention to detail.
This spot shines for its commitment to freshness. Each bite of the Vegetarian Pizza is a masterclass in balance: thin, crisp base, topped with plenty of vegetables, and never greasy. Their white pizza also gets rave reviews for its creamy texture and subtle garlic flavor.
If you want takeout or just a family meal in, Calabria delivers that classic, no-shortcuts flavor that keeps regulars coming back for another slice.
4. Vittoria’Z On The Lake
(914) 245-0630Call
Vittoria’Z On The Lake is a spot you hear about from locals who know where to find reliable, well-prepared pizza. Tucked along Hill Blvd, it has the charm of a neighborhood fixture where folks gather over thick, cheesy pies. My visit here ended with the kind of satisfied quiet only a good meal delivers.
The standout at Vittoria’Z has to be their classic cheese pizza. The crust has that ideal balance of chewy and crisp, while the sauce tastes like it was made in-house that very morning. Pair it with one of their veggie-topped pies for extra color and flavor.
If dependable, no-frills pizza in Jefferson Valley is what you’re after, this spot is a worthy contender.
5. Frankie & Augie’z
Frankie & Augie’z holds a well-earned reputation for both hospitality and steady, comforting pizza. Nestled in the Lourdes Shopping Center, it feels like the place students, families, and coworkers all claim as their own. My last visit turned into a lesson on the magic of a classic pizzeria—welcoming, not rushed, and with the kind of pies that keep the whole table happy.
This kitchen never skimps on tradition. Their Old-Fashioned Pizza, with a crackling thin crust, is a lesson in balance: fresh tomato, just the right amount of cheese, and a crust that holds up without becoming too dense. The vegetarian pie impresses even non-vegetarians with its well-chosen toppings and bright flavors.
Frankie & Augie’z delivers consistency, generous portions, and flavor-forward slices that make it a favorite among Jefferson Valley’s pizza crowd.
6. Cafe Pizzazz
(914) 743-1055Call
Cafe Pizzazz lives up to its name—a cozy spot where the pizza has as much personality as the staff. It’s tucked away on East Main Street, making it easy to miss but hard to forget once you’ve tasted a slice. My first visit here started out of curiosity and ended with a new weeknight ritual when I’m craving a quality pie.
Their veggie slice gets all the love—fresh, abundant toppings set on a crisp but fluffy crust. The margherita pie also captures the cafe’s approach: straightforward, bright, always flavorful. You won’t find overcomplicated pizzas cluttering the menu, just honest fare done well.
If you like unfussy spots that don’t compromise on taste, Cafe Pizzazz brings all the right flavors to Jefferson Valley’s pizza scene.
7. La Villetta Pizza & Pasta
(914) 526-0394Call
La Villetta Pizza & Pasta feels like a family gathering spot, full of easy chatter and plates stacked high. My first meal here stretched longer than planned; staff checked in without hovering, the kitchen sent out hot pies, and there was always something interesting passing by on its way to another table.
What makes La Villetta stand out? Generous portions, a varied menu, and a real sense of value. Regulars know that the veggie pizza and their classic cheese pie both nail crispness and toppings. The thin, golden crust holds up under plenty of sauce and cheese—never soggy, always crisp.
For those who love options but want to stick with great pizza, La Villetta is the perfect place to find a new favorite in Jefferson Valley.
8. My Favorite Pizza Place
(914) 528-8200Call
My Favorite Pizza Place is a name that sets the bar high—and somehow, it meets expectations every time. This spot has a comfortable, lived-in feel, like the kind of pizzeria you grew up with. I discovered it on a whim, lured in by the aroma on E Main Street, and ended up making a weekly habit out of their pies.
Their classic cheese pizza delivers nostalgia in every bite: gooey cheese, lively sauce, and a crust that’s both soft and crisp at once. For something with a bit more flair, try the margherita or veggie options, both of which showcase freshness and balance.
If you’re searching for the quintessential neighborhood pizza in Jefferson Valley, this spot promises familiar flavors with a little extra heart.
9. Three Boys Pizzeria
(914) 245-4811Call
Three Boys Pizzeria offers up the kind of small-town charm you hope for in a pizza place. From my first visit, the staff treated me like an old friend, and every slice was crafted with care. It’s the sort of spot where the pizza is never rushed and the regulars are always in the know.
The highlight here is their plain cheese slice—golden, slightly chewy crust and just enough tang in the sauce. The consistency makes it a local staple. If you’re after variety, their spinach and veggie pizzas stand out, layered with fresh ingredients and baked just right.
Best for classic, no-fuss pizza with a welcoming atmosphere, Three Boys offers simple pleasures, done well, to the Jefferson Valley crowd.
10. Rocco’s Pizzeria
(845) 621-1215Call
Rocco’s Pizzeria is the kind of place you recommend to friends when they ask where to find pizza that feels like home. Tucked along Route 6, it’s run with an old-school energy—every order feels like it’s made just for you. I dropped by on a rainy evening, and the smell of fresh dough had me convinced I’d made a good call.
What’s special here? The classic plain and white pizzas both score big for their crisp crusts and the right amount of cheese. The sauce, always zesty, never overpowers. If you’re feeling adventurous, the veggie pizza is bursting with freshness and color.
For those who value tradition and a friendly vibe, Rocco’s is a genuine slice of the Jefferson Valley pizza scene.
More Things to Try in Jefferson Valley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top pizza spots in Jefferson Valley, NY?
Popular choices include Frankie & Augie’z, Gigi Pizza & Wedges, Calabria Pizza & Pasta, and Vittoria’Z On The Lake. Each brings their own twist to the classic pizza experience.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Jefferson Valley?
Yes, many local spots—like Calabria Pizza & Pasta, Three Boys Pizzeria, and Cafe Pizzazz—offer a variety of vegetarian pies packed with fresh toppings.
Can I get pizza delivery in Jefferson Valley?
Most pizzerias in Jefferson Valley, including Calabria Pizza & Pasta and La Villetta, offer delivery services. You can call directly or use popular delivery apps.
Which places are good for a family pizza night?
Frankie & Augie’z and My Favorite Pizza Place are both known for their friendly, welcoming atmosphere and generous portions—great for groups of all ages.
Where can I find pizza with a thin, crispy crust?
If you’re after a signature thin crust, try Frankie & Augie’z Old-Fashioned Pizza or a margherita pie from Cafe Pizzazz for a cracker-like base and light, fresh toppings.