When it comes to the quest for the perfect pizza, Jefferson City, MO, is a hidden gem. This charming capital city has an impressive array of pizzerias that cater to every palate. Whether you crave the traditional flavors of a classic Margherita or the adventurous twist of specialty toppings, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings. On more than one occasion, I’ve discovered that the best evenings often revolve around sharing a delicious pizza with friends, swapping stories, and enjoying the local vibe. It’s in these places that the crust’s perfect crisp meets rich sauce and melty cheese, creating a symphony of flavors.
This article dives into some of the best pizza spots in Jefferson City, each with its unique flair. From cozy establishments that make you feel right at home to contemporary joints where the ambiance is just as good as the food, you’ll find options that are both exciting and satisfying. Countless locals have their favorites, and as we explore this list, you might just discover your next go-to pizza place. Ready to indulge? Let’s embark on this delicious journey.
Where to find the best pizza in Jefferson City, MO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Jefferson City, MO:
- Arris’ Pizza Palace
- Prison Brews
- Pizza Underground
- Obie’s Pizza
- West Main Pizza
- Theo’s Midtown
- Imo’s Pizza
- The Pizza Company
- Little Caesars
- Papa Johns Pizza
1. Arris’ Pizza Palace
Arris’ Pizza Palace in Jefferson City is a delightful spot known for its extensive menu, catering to various dietary preferences with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Located at 115 W High St, it provides a cozy atmosphere perfect for both lunch and dinner.
A visit to Arris’ is a memorable experience. I remember savoring their signature Greek-style pizza, a true standout, with its perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings. This dish showcases their commitment to quality and tradition.
For a must-try, order the Arris’ Special, which combines fresh ingredients like peppers, onions, and olives, offering a taste of their unique style. Arris’ dedication to flavor and quality makes it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Jefferson City.
2. Prison Brews
Prison Brews is not just a brewpub; it’s a unique experience in Jefferson City. Located at 305 Ash St, this nostalgic spot features an 1895 brick warehouse that adds character while you enjoy their delicious offerings. The ambiance is relaxed, perfect for unwinding after a long day.
During my last visit, I was captivated by the blend of craft beers and an enticing food menu. Their House Specialty Pizza is a highlight, boasting fresh toppings and a robust flavor profile that reflects the quality of their ingredients.
If you’re in the mood for something different, try their Veggie Pizza, which is a hearty combination of seasonal vegetables and cheese. This dish truly showcases how Prison Brews balances flavor and creativity, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers.
3. Pizza Underground
Pizza Underground in Jefferson City, MO, is a delightful spot for pizza enthusiasts. Located at 202 E High St, this eatery offers a cozy setting with both lunch and dinner options. Their table service and takeout make it convenient whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick meal.
What sets Pizza Underground apart is its commitment to quality and service. They accept a variety of digital payments, including all major credit cards, ensuring a hassle-free experience. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff create a welcoming environment for all guests.
When visiting, try their signature Margherita pizza. It’s a local favorite, showcasing fresh ingredients and perfect seasoning. The crust is crisp and pairs wonderfully with their house-made sauce, making it a must-try in Jefferson City.
4. Obie’s Pizza
+1 573-893-6020
See Menu
Tucked away on the south side of Bus 50 W in Jefferson City, Obie’s Pizza is a local gem that delivers both flavor and friendliness. This family-owned spot has a warm, laid-back atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, the staff always serve with a smile.
What makes Obie’s stand out is their commitment to quality and consistency. Their crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the sauce has a rich, savory kick that sets it apart. I still remember my first bite of their Classic Veggie Pizza—loaded with fresh toppings and gooey cheese, it hit all the right notes.
For a local favorite, try the Obie’s Special—a hearty, flavor-packed pizza with beef, turkey pepperoni, and fresh vegetables. It’s a must-try for pizza lovers in Jefferson City.
5. West Main Pizza
West Main Pizza is a must-visit spot in Jefferson City, located at 1931 W Main St. With a menu that caters to everyone, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, it’s ideal for those with dietary preferences. The atmosphere is casual yet inviting, perfect for family dinners or a quick lunch.
What truly sets West Main Pizza apart is their dedication to using fresh, local ingredients. I fondly recall trying their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which struck a perfect balance of heat and flavor, topped with house-made ranch dressing that elevated the dish.
Don’t miss out on their Vegan Special, loaded with seasonal vegetables and vegan cheese. It showcases West Main’s creativity and commitment to quality, making it a standout in Jefferson City’s pizza scene.
6. Theo’s Midtown
Theo’s Midtown is a charming eatery located at 620 W McCarty St in Jefferson City, well-known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional menu. With a focus on vegetarian-friendly meals, it caters to a variety of dietary needs while providing a comfortable space for both lunch and dinner.
What makes Theo’s stand out is their creative approach to pizza. During my last visit, I enjoyed their Mediterranean Pizza, boasting vibrant flavors with fresh vegetables, olives, and feta cheese. The crust was perfectly baked, demonstrating their commitment to quality.
For an unforgettable experience, try the Build-Your-Own pizza, featuring a wide selection of toppings. It’s a fun way to customize your meal and reflects Theo’s dedication to satisfying every palate in Jefferson City.
7. Imo’s Pizza
Imo’s Pizza, located at 706 Missouri Blvd, is a staple in Jefferson City known for its unique St. Louis-style pizza. With both lunch and dinner offerings, it’s a convenient option whether you’re dining in or enjoying delivery.
What truly sets Imo’s apart is its signature thin crust and the delicious blend of cheeses, which I found to be an absolute game changer during my first visit. The pizza is light yet satisfying, making it easy to enjoy multiple slices.
When you go, don’t miss their Deluxe Pizza, loaded with fresh toppings and that iconic cheese blend. It perfectly encapsulates the quality and taste that Imo’s is celebrated for in Jefferson City.
8. The Pizza Company
+1 573-632-4287
See Menu
The Pizza Company, situated at 1508 E McCarty St, is a vibrant addition to the Jefferson City pizza scene. Formerly JC Pizza Company, this local favorite offers a cozy atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for both lunch and dinner.
This restaurant stands out due to its creative menu and a commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients. During my visit, I was impressed by their BBQ Chicken Pizza, perfectly seasoned and topped with generous amounts of chicken and cheese, all on a delicious crust.
When you stop by, be sure to try their Cheese Lover’s Delight, a feast for cheese aficionados that truly showcases the quality The Pizza Company brings. It’s a satisfying experience that keeps locals coming back for more.
9. Little Caesars
Little Caesars, located at 2407 Missouri Blvd, is a go-to spot for those seeking delicious pizza at an affordable price. Known for its quick service, it offers both lunch and dinner options, making it ideal for busy days or a casual family meal.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their Hot-N-Ready pizzas, which ensure you can grab a fresh, hot pizza without the wait. My personal favorite is the Pepperoni Pizza, loved for its generous toppings and cheesy goodness.
For a special treat, consider their Crazy Bread. It’s a perfect side that complements any pizza order, showcasing Little Caesars’ dedication to satisfying customers in Jefferson City.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza, located at 2103 Missouri Blvd, Suite B, is a beloved choice in Jefferson City for anyone seeking quality pizza. With a mantra of “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza,” this establishment is dedicated to excellence. They focus on using fresh, original dough and signature sauces that make a difference in taste.
My favorite experience at Papa John’s was when I ordered the Pepperoni Pizza—the balance of toppings and the signature sauce was delightful, making it a hit at our game night.
For a satisfying meal, don’t miss the Cheesy Breadsticks; they complement any pizza and show the restaurant’s commitment to quality sides. Whether you’re dining in or enjoying delivery, Papa John’s doesn’t disappoint in Jefferson City.
More Things to Try in Jefferson City, MO
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Jefferson City, MO?
Some of the top pizza spots include Arris’ Pizza Palace, Prison Brews, and Theo’s Midtown. Each offers a unique take on pizza, from traditional styles to creative toppings.
2. Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Jefferson City?
Yes, many pizzerias in Jefferson City cater to vegetarian and vegan diets. Restaurants like West Main Pizza and Obie’s Pizza offer a variety of options to ensure everyone can enjoy a slice.
3. Can I order pizza for delivery in Jefferson City?
Absolutely! Many local pizzerias, such as Papa John’s Pizza and Little Caesars, offer delivery options, ensuring you can enjoy your favorites from the comfort of your home.
4. What is St. Louis-style pizza?
St. Louis-style pizza is characterized by its thin crust and uses a unique blend of cheeses, traditionally Provolone. Imo’s Pizza is known for serving this regional specialty in Jefferson City.
5. Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
Yes, several pizzerias, including Arris’ Pizza Palace and Pizza Underground, offer gluten-free crust options, making it easy for those with dietary restrictions to enjoy pizza.
6. What are the best toppings for pizza in Jefferson City?
Popular toppings in Jefferson City include pepperoni, sausage, and a variety of fresh vegetables. Many places also offer unique toppings like barbecue chicken or goat cheese for those looking to try something different.
7. Do pizzerias in Jefferson City have dine-in options?
Yes, many local pizzerias offer dine-in services. Places like Prison Brews and Theo’s Midtown provide a comfortable atmosphere for enjoying your meal on-site.