There’s something magnetic about the scent of pizza wafting down a street in Ithaca, pulling you in on a crisp afternoon or after a long day. Finding the best pizza in Ithaca, NY is less of a quest and more of an open invitation to savor both nostalgia and discovery. Whether you’re a college student out late or a local looking for your next favorite slice, Ithaca’s pizzerias promise layers of flavor and personality within each pie.
I’ve spent more than a few evenings sampling slices from shop counters and bustling dining rooms. I still remember a cold winter walk ending with a piping hot Margherita that made me rethink everything I knew about pizza. This list is built from hands-on experiences and good old-fashioned taste tests across town. If you’re serious about pizza—or even just hungry—these spots will help you discover Ithaca’s most memorable pies, slice by slice.
Where to find the best pizza in Ithaca, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Ithaca, NY:
- Thompson & Bleecker
- Pizza Aroma
- Franco’s Pizzeria
- Sal’s Pizzeria
- Italian Carry Out
- Eta Pie: Infinite Pizzabilities
- Casablanca
- Sicilian Delight Ithaca
- Sammy’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Ned’s Pizza NY
1. Thompson & Bleecker
Thompson & Bleecker feels like a hidden gem carved out for true pizza fans. The vibe is airy yet cozy, with walls that echo laughter and the quiet hum of people tucking into stellar pies. More than once, I’ve lingered over a late lunch here, thinking the crust alone might be Ithaca’s best.
What makes Thompson & Bleecker special is their dedication to the craft. Their Neapolitan-style pizzas are baked in a blazing hot oven, arriving with blistered edges and toppings that sing.
If you’re unsure where to start, the Margherita is a classic—light, fragrant, and bursting with balance. I also recommend their artichoke or mushroom creations, which prove you don’t need meat to achieve deep, satisfying flavor.
2. Pizza Aroma
Pizza Aroma has a loyal following for a reason. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the aroma—a heady blend of dough, garlic, and bubbling cheese—hinting that good things are coming. I’ve popped in here during quick lunch breaks and left impressed each time.
What sets Pizza Aroma apart is its commitment to flavor and simplicity. There are no frills, just solid pies with crisp crusts and generous toppings. Their menu favors classic combinations, all executed with care.
For a real taste of what they do best, order the veggie pizza. The vegetables are always fresh, the cheese never overpowers, and the crust holds it all together beautifully. It’s proof that straightforward can still be great.
3. Franco’s Pizzeria
Franco’s Pizzeria delivers that classic, no-nonsense vibe you hope for in a local pizza shop. It’s the kind of place where you feel instantly at ease, whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for dinner with friends. I’ve enjoyed more than one casual night here, watching slices disappear faster than the clock changes.
Their New York-style pizza is the star of the menu. Thin crust, a slight chew, and a bold tomato sauce—it’s the real deal, crafted with care and attention to detail. Franco’s doesn’t skimp on toppings or quality either.
If you’re searching for something tried and true, the plain cheese or veggie slice is a strong start. Their white pizza also stands out—creamy, herby, and just the right level of indulgent.
4. Sal’s Pizzeria
Sal’s Pizzeria has been an Ithaca mainstay since 1989, offering a slice of tradition on every plate. Walking in feels a bit like visiting an old friend—familiar, relaxed, and always enjoyable. I’ve ducked in on rainy afternoons, only to have a classic cheese slice turn my whole day around.
Sal’s signature is its stone oven, which gives each pizza a crisp, flavorful crust that stands up to generous toppings. Their sauce is fresh and zesty, tying everything together in one unforgettable bite.
Their Margherita pizza is a must if you want to taste the essence of Sal’s approach—simple ingredients, skillfully balanced. If you’re sharing, their veggie pizza piles on the goodness without weighing you down.
5. Italian Carry Out
Italian Carry Out brings hearty, comforting Italian flavors right to your doorstep or picnic table. The first time I tried their pizza was after a long drive; one bite and I was hooked on their no-fuss, flavor-forward style. There’s a steady stream of takeout orders, always a good sign for a spot a little off the beaten path.
Their pizzas stand out for fresh dough and a lightly crisped crust that holds every topping in place. The sauce is robust without being overwhelming, and the cheese-to-topping ratio is spot on.
Their veggie pizza is a crowd-pleaser, packed with fresh ingredients and just enough herbs. If you’re hungry and planning to share, go for the Sicilian—it’s generous, thick, and full of classic comfort.
6. Eta Pie: Infinite Pizzabilities
Eta Pie: Infinite Pizzabilities lives up to its name with a menu that’s all about creative freedom. The first time I visited, I spent longer building my own pizza masterpiece than actually eating it. The staff seem to enjoy the possibilities as much as the customers do, tossing out ideas and encouragement.
This place stands out for its blend of whimsy and quality. You can pick from dozens of toppings, crusts, and sauces, or try one of their inspired combinations if you’re feeling indecisive.
The Margherita remains a reliable choice, but the real fun is crafting your own or sampling a chef’s combination—think unexpected veggie blends and bold flavor pairings. Eta Pie is proof that pizza can be both playful and seriously satisfying.
7. Casablanca
Casablanca offers a downtown retreat with old-school charm and a menu that keeps regulars coming back. I remember ducking in during a sudden rainstorm and finding comfort in a warm, friendly space that felt worlds away from the bustle outside. The menu keeps things simple but consistent, and that’s part of the appeal.
This spot shines thanks to its classic approach and generous portions. Pizzas here have a chewy crust and are loaded with fresh toppings, which land somewhere between Italian tradition and local comfort food.
The veggie pizza is a standout—colorful, hearty, and never stingy on cheese or veggies. If you’re craving something with a bit of crunch, their thin crust options hit the spot while letting the fresh ingredients take center stage.
8. Sicilian Delight Ithaca
Sicilian Delight Ithaca offers comfort food with a smile and a welcoming, local atmosphere. My first visit was on a lazy afternoon when I stumbled across their shop inside the mall, and the inviting display of oversized, square slices caught my attention right away. The service is fast, making it easy to drop in for a casual meal or a quick bite between errands.
Sicilian Delight stands out for its signature thick, airy crust and generous toppings, bringing a slice of classic Sicilian tradition to Ithaca.
The veggie Sicilian slice is a highlight—it’s light, pillowy, and loaded with vegetables. Their white pizza also deserves a mention, delivering creamy flavor and just enough garlic to keep things interesting.
9. Sammy’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Sammy’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is an Ithaca staple, known for its casual vibe and an impressively broad menu. I’ve ended more than one late night here, pie in hand, surrounded by a lively mix of locals and students. The atmosphere is unpretentious and friendly, making it easy to relax and dig into a satisfying meal.
The real draw at Sammy’s is their classic New York-style pizza, with oversized slices, crispy edges, and sauce that taps into just the right note of tangy and sweet. They take pride in their ingredients and it shows, bite after bite.
The plain cheese slice is a must, but don’t skip their veggie or white pizzas—both pack a punch of flavor and showcase Sammy’s knack for great toppings layered onto a perfect crust.
10. Ned’s Pizza NY
Ned’s Pizza NY feels like a genuine neighborhood find with a low-key charm that always draws you back. My first visit was on a whim, quick dinner plans that turned into a delightful surprise. There’s no fuss—just straightforward, flavorful pizzas and a warm welcome, whether you’re there for lunch or grabbing a pie to share with friends.
Ned’s stands out for its well-executed Sicilian-style pizzas. The crust is perfectly thick, with a textured, golden surface that holds toppings in place. The sauce leans rich and herby, never overpowering, and the cheese always feels just right.
Their Sicilian pizza is a must-try, but the veggie pizza makes a strong case with its generous heap of fresh vegetables. If you lean classic, the plain cheese captures everything Ned’s does best.
More Things to Try in Ithaca, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for pizza in Ithaca, NY?
Some favorites include Thompson & Bleecker for Neapolitan-style pies, Sammy’s Pizzeria for classic New York slices, and Ned’s Pizza NY for Sicilian-style options. Each spot offers its own twist on the classics.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Ithaca?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, like Pizza Aroma and Thompson & Bleecker, offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas. Just ask about plant-based cheese and topping choices when you order.
Can I get pizza delivered in Ithaca?
Yes, most places on this list offer delivery and takeout. Popular choices like Sammy’s, Pudgie’s, and Domino’s make it convenient to enjoy pizza anywhere in town.
What styles of pizza can I find in Ithaca?
You’ll find a variety of styles in Ithaca, including Neapolitan, New York thin crust, Sicilian thick crust, and creative build-your-own options, thanks to places like Eta Pie.
Where can I get late-night pizza in Ithaca?
D.P. Dough and Sammy’s Pizzeria are known for late-night hours, making them go-to spots after evening events or study sessions.