Pizza cravings have a way of finding you at the oddest times. Whether you’re sneaking out for a quick slice after work or planning a weekend with friends, Irmo’s pizza scene has a personality all its own. I found myself in Irmo at the tail end of an endless road trip, bleary-eyed and hungry, only to discover local gems with ovens that make magic every night of the week. Each spot left its mark: thin crusts snapping with every bite, cheese stretching like it had something to prove, and sauces balanced just right. Some pies smiled at tradition, others dared to color outside the lines, but all shared one goal—to satisfy even the fussiest pizza lover.
Picking the best pizza in Irmo is a delicious challenge. If you like classic pepperoni, like a loaded veggie, or prefer crust stuffed to its optimistic edges, Irmo has a place for you. The following guide rounds up the standout pizzerias, from family-run favorites to those household names with serious staying power. Ready to narrow the field and find your new go-to? Keep going. You might leave hungry now, but you’ll know exactly where to satisfy that craving by the end.
1. Brooklyn Express Pizza and Pasta
Brooklyn Express Pizza and Pasta delivers big-city flavor with small-town warmth. Walk in, and the kitchen’s aroma tells you they treat dough with the respect it deserves. The crust here snaps on the edge and folds with just the right chew, a genuine nod to New York roots.
What sets this place apart is the attitude toward quality and generosity. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, whether it’s a quick lunch crowd or lingering families at dinner. The staff is ready with a smile, and every pie feels like it’s made for you.
Try a classic cheese slice or their loaded works pizza. The ingredients sing—gooey cheese, savory sauce, and toppings that actually taste fresh. Add a side of their garlic knots and you’ll understand why locals recommend this spot for the best pizza experience in Irmo.
2. Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders
Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders brings a fresh twist to pizza night in Irmo. Walk in and catch the subtle scent of freshly baked bread—a direct result of dough made from scratch each day using a recipe that dates back to 1959. The pride in tradition shows from the first bite to the last crumb.
Their pizzas stand out for their ultra-fresh crust and inventive toppings. While their menu runs deep, the pizza section remains the highlight. The veggie pizza balances color and flavor, and the Margherita, with its zesty tomato sauce and aromatic basil, feels both simple and elevated.
For something different, locals love pairing pizza with Bellacino’s signature grinders. Every visit here reminds you why classic methods never go out of style. Grab a pie and a grinder, and you’ll see what all the fuss is about.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Irmo guarantees consistency when cravings hit. You can count on their pizzas to land at your door hot and loaded, thanks to that recognizable garlic aroma that signals dinner is on the way. The original dough has a subtle sweetness and a chewy bite that sets it apart among national chains.
What keeps folks coming back is the reliability of every order. Whether you’re after a classic cheese pizza or want to pile on the veggies, each slice comes dressed with a tangy sauce and generous toppings. It’s predictable in the best way—perfect when you’re looking for comfort food that never disappoints.
Order the Garden Fresh pizza or the thin-crust option for a meal that walks the line between indulgence and freshness. The included pepperoncini and dipping sauces give you plenty of extra flavor in every bite.
4. Papa Gio’s
Papa Gio’s feels like that neighborhood spot everyone wishes they had. It’s tucked away but easy to spot once you know where to look. The inviting, cozy dining room makes it as good for a sit-down meal as for a quick takeout run.
Their pizza has a handmade edge that larger chains just can’t touch. The crust is light yet sturdy, supporting a sauce that brings the perfect mix of tang and sweetness, and cheese that bubbles irresistibly.
Order the Supreme pizza if you want a bit of everything—fresh peppers, onions, mushrooms, and classic toppings that let the dough and sauce shine. Papa Gio’s also does a solid veggie pizza for those chasing a lighter, flavor-packed option.
5. Little Caesars
Little Caesars in Irmo is the go-to for pizza on a budget and a tight schedule. There’s something satisfying about walking in and picking up a fresh, hot pie with barely a wait. For those moments when patience is thin but your appetite isn’t, this spot steps up every time.
The magic is in their no-frills approach. The pizzas are simple, but the crust always arrives golden and chewy, with just enough sauce and cheese to keep things interesting. There’s a reason their Hot-N-Ready pepperoni and cheese pies never go out of style.
Order the ExtraMostBestest cheese or veggie pizza if you like a bit more topping for your money. It’s proof that good pizza doesn’t need to be complicated, only dependable.
6. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Irmo taps into that feeling of nostalgia with every box you open. The scent of freshly baked crust and savory tomato sauce instantly brings back memories of pizza nights that never went out of style. This location keeps that tradition alive with prompt service and friendly faces.
The highlight here is variety, with a menu that covers every craving. The pan pizza comes with a golden, buttery crust that’s equal parts crispy and pillowy. You’ll also find their famous Stuffed Crust for cheese lovers who want a bit of surprise in every bite.
Order the Veggie Lover’s or the Original Stuffed Crust pizza. These pies offer a comforting mix of flavors and textures that explains why Pizza Hut remains an easy favorite in Irmo.
7. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza carves out a flavorful spot in Irmo’s pizza lineup. Walk in or call ahead, and you’ll notice the focus is on freshness and robust flavor. The signature dough, made daily, brings each bite to life with its airy inside and crispy edge.
This place prides itself on customizable options and bold, zesty sauce. The pizzas are consistently hearty and packed with fresh toppings that don’t skimp. It’s a great spot for families or anyone who wants classic tastes with a hint of something extra.
Try the White Cheezy or the Garden pizza if you’re looking for standout flavor combinations. The blend of cheeses and generous veggie toppings make these pies memorable, highlighting Marco’s core strengths in both craftsmanship and taste.
8. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Dutch Fork Rd. in Irmo serves up more than just dependable pizza. Each visit brings the familiar aroma and warmth you’d expect, echoed by staff who know how to make folks feel at home. It’s a spot where pizza night turns into a family ritual or an easy solo treat.
What gives this Pizza Hut an edge is the consistent quality and a menu that leaves no one behind. Their pan pizza remains iconic, with a soft, airy base that’s always perfectly cooked, and the toppings come generous every time.
Go for the Veggie Lover’s pizza or try the Original Pan style if you want the true house experience. Each pizza leaves you full and satisfied, earning its place as a staple in Irmo’s pizza scene.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Lake Murray Blvd in Irmo makes convenience feel like a treat, not a compromise. Orders go out fast, but the attention to detail remains, from a well-baked crust to toppings that hit every corner. The team strikes a balance between speed and flavor, a rare combo that keeps regulars coming back.
Customization is where Domino’s shines. From thin, crispy crusts to thick, Hand Tossed or Handmade Pan styles, there’s a perfect base for every pizza lover. The Parmesan Stuffed Crust brings an extra cheesy pull that’s hard to resist.
The Pacific Veggie or the Wisconsin 6 Cheese pizza are top picks—each pie is robust, layered with flavor, and reflects why Domino’s continues to hold its own in the Irmo pizza scene.
10. Tonella’s Pizza Kitchen
Tonella’s Pizza Kitchen is where local charm meets Italian craftsmanship in Irmo. The cozy spot feels like a hidden find, but word spreads quickly once you’ve tasted their handmade pies. Every pizza showcases careful technique, from the gently blistered crust to the fresh, flavorful toppings layered in just the right balance.
Tonella’s specializes in crusts that strike the perfect middle ground—chewy yet crisp. Here, tomato sauce isn’t just a base; it’s lively and full of depth, designed to highlight every topping.
The Margherita or Veggie pizza stand out for their simplicity and rich taste. These classics reveal the kitchen’s dedication to doing simple things very well—proof you don’t need flashy tricks for pizza to steal the show in Irmo.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Irmo for takeout or delivery?
Popular options for takeout and delivery include Papa Johns Pizza, Domino’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Marco’s Pizza. Each offers fast service, online ordering, and reliable quality, making dinner easy when you’re on the go.
Are there any local, non-chain pizzerias in Irmo worth trying?
Brooklyn Express Pizza and Pasta, Tonella’s Pizza Kitchen, and Papa Gio’s are beloved by locals for their house-made dough, creative toppings, and close-knit, friendly service.
Which pizza places in Irmo have vegetarian options?
Nearly every pizzeria on this list features at least one veggie pizza or a build-your-own option. Brooklyn Express, Marco’s, Bellacino’s, and Pizza Hut all offer standout vegetarian pies.
Who serves New York-style pizza in Irmo?
Brooklyn Express Pizza and Pasta is the go-to for classic New York-style pies—thin, foldable, and packed with big city flavor.
Where can I find pizza in Irmo with gluten-free options?
Domino’s, Marco’s Pizza, and Mellow Mushroom in nearby Lexington offer gluten-free crust alternatives, so everyone can join in on pizza night.
What’s the best place in Irmo for pizza on a budget?
Little Caesars and Pizza Hut regularly run deals and offer Hot-N-Ready pizzas, making them top picks for affordability without sacrificing taste.
Do any pizza places in Irmo offer dine-in service?
Yes, most local shops, including Tonella’s Pizza Kitchen, Bellacino’s, and Papa Gio’s, have dining rooms where you can enjoy a fresh pie right out of the oven.
Which Irmo pizzerias are family-friendly?
Marco’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Bellacino’s have plenty of seating and kid-friendly menus, making them favorites for family outings.