Iowa City slices up its pizza scene with more personality than you’d guess. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic crust or something wild topped with local flair, this town understands pizza cravings on a truly deep level. Having tasted my way through its pizzerias over late-night study sessions and after long walks downtown, I’ve come to appreciate how many distinct ways this city answers the question: “What’s for dinner?”
From piping-hot tavern pies to cheesy deep-dish comfort, each spot serves up its own attitude alongside the slice. Choosing the best can be tricky, but there’s a kind of joy in the search. This guide brings together both beloved icons and lesser-known gems, so you can trust you’ll find what you’re hungry for—without settling for bland or boring. Prepare for cravings.
1. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns on Gilbert Street leans into its “Better Ingredients, Better Pizza” motto and actually delivers. Late one Friday, I grabbed a fresh pepperoni pie after a long day and the crust—pillowy and warm—was the perfect reward. Consistency is their secret sauce. The pizzas always arrive with stretchy cheese and clean edges, never greasy or soggy.
The Hawaiian BBQ Chicken is a highlight, with tangy sauce and balanced, smoky flavor. If you’re feeling classic, their original crust pepperoni remains an Iowa City staple. Don’t miss the garlic sauce. It’s the dip you never knew you needed with every bite of crust.
Between the reliable delivery, customizable pies, and friendly staff, Papa Johns keeps itself locked in as a go-to for pizza that works just as well for solo nights as for group orders.
2. Gumby’s Pizza
(319) 354-8629Call
Gumby’s Pizza on South Gilbert feels like Iowa City’s unofficial meeting place after midnight. I first stopped in after a concert, drawn by the buzzing crowd and the scent of fresh dough. Their standout is the famous Pokey Stix—cheesy breadsticks that people order just for the stretchy strings of cheese and the addictive garlic butter.
The pizza here leans hearty, with a soft crust and generous toppings. Try the Supreme if you’re after variety—lots of veggies and a satisfying crunch from the crust’s edge. Late-night hours and affordable prices seal the deal.
Gumby’s thrives on being both dependable and a little quirky, a true campus tradition that never skimps on flavor or fun.
3. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars on Hollywood Blvd delivers fast, wallet-friendly pizza when you need it most. I’ve dashed in between errands, grabbed a Hot-N-Ready pepperoni, and walked out in under two minutes. Speed and value keep this spot buzzing, especially with students and families on the go.
The Crazy Bread is the sleeper hit—soft, buttery, and perfect for dipping. Their Detroit-style Deep!Deep! Dish surprises with a crisp, caramelized crust and sturdy toppings, making for a convenient, filling meal.
If you want reliable flavor and quick service without the wait, Little Caesars delivers every time. It’s comfort food designed for busy Iowa City days.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on South 1st Avenue is that classic stop where cravings and nostalgia meet. I remember splitting an Original Stuffed Crust with friends after finals—the stringy cheese center made it feel more like a reward than a meal. The crust always steals the show, but the—Meat Lovers remains a consistent crowd-pleaser for its hearty toppings and meaty richness.
The menu here lets you mix things up. Try the Veggie Lover’s for a fresh, colorful bite or the thin-crust options for a crispier experience. Order a side of breadsticks to round things out; they’re soft, golden, and perfect for sharing.
Quick service, reliable delivery, and the unbeatable combo of variety and value make Pizza Hut an Iowa City comfort staple.
5. A & A Pagliai’s Pizza
A & A Pagliai’s Pizza on East Bloomington is where Iowa City tradition lives on a plate. My first visit was a revelation—classic checkerboard floors, the warm chatter of regulars, and pizza that tastes like it’s made with care. Their thin crust is legendary; golden at the edges and substantial enough to hold a generous layer of toppings.
The Special, loaded with fresh vegetables and zippy pepper, is a must-try. If you like a little extra, request double crust for more chew and crunch. Every pie comes with their signature, slightly sweet sauce that sets it apart from the crowd.
Fast pickup and a family-friendly vibe make it a favorite for those who want real, classic pizza in a welcoming space.
6. The Airliner
The Airliner, perched on Clinton Street, is where the city’s history and the college buzz blend under one roof. My first time there, I snagged a window seat and caught the half-price pizza night—a true local favorite. Their crust won me over—soft, chewy, and hand-tossed to perfection.
Try the Margherita for a fresh, herby bite or the classic Cheese pizza for a pure, nostalgic experience. The place hums with energy from regulars, students, and families, and big screen TVs add to the lively vibe.
With friendly service and a menu that doesn’t break the bank, The Airliner delivers comforting slices in a spot perfect for making memories.
7. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch on Sycamore Street is the buffet spot for anyone who can’t pick just one slice. I stopped in with friends and the variety on display—fresh pies, salads, and sides—felt endless. The Potato Crust pizza is a signature; fluffy potatoes atop golden dough create a warm, filling bite you won’t soon forget.
Buffet style means you get to sample everything. The Veggie pizza stacks up crisp peppers and mushrooms, offering a lighter counter to the cheesy classics. Friendly staff keep the buffet stocked and inviting, which is a real plus when you arrive hungry.
For group outings or family dinners, Pizza Ranch nails value, variety, and a chance to discover new favorites under one roof.
8. The Wig & Pen Pizza Pub
The Wig & Pen Pizza Pub is Iowa City’s answer to quirky British charm thanks to its London-inspired heritage. Walking in, I was greeted by the buzz of loyal regulars and the aroma of yeasty dough. Their famous Chicago-style “Flying Tomato” pizza is the true standout—fluffy, golden crusts finished with a rich, tangy sauce layered on top.
For something different, try the Union Jack, loaded with fresh veggies and a blend of cheeses. The pub’s cozy booths and wood-paneled ambiance make it feel like a hidden gem, inviting you to linger just a little longer over each slice.
With an award-winning reputation, attentive service, and menu variety, Wig & Pen is a must for serious pizza fans hunting for a memorable pie in Iowa City.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on South Gilbert offers that familiar, satisfying bite whether you’re ordering late or feeding a crowd. I’ve grabbed plenty of late-night Thin Crust Veggie pies from here, and each time, the crust comes out crispy and fully loaded with fresh toppings. Consistent quality and quick delivery are their calling cards; you know exactly what you’re getting every time.
If you want something decadent, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza is a must-try, oozing with cheesy flavor in every edge. Their Handmade Pan pizza delivers a soft, buttery base with just the right chew. Frequent deals mean you rarely walk away without a bargain.
Domino’s takes the guesswork out of ordering with custom options, easy pickup, and fast service perfect for busy Iowa City schedules.
10. Casey’s General Store
Casey’s General Store on Broadway Street proves that gas station pizza can punch above its weight. One morning after an early drive, I grabbed a fresh slice by the register and realized why word travels about their pies. Their breakfast pizza is a true Iowa City classic: chewy dough, creamy cheese, and just the right combo of eggs and veggies.
Classic cheese and veggie options hit the spot if you want traditional, hot-out-of-the-oven satisfaction. Casey’s stands out with its handmade approach and quick convenience, perfect for anyone on the run or craving a casual bite any time of day.
More than a pit stop, Casey’s is a low-key favorite for students, commuters, and locals who appreciate pizza that’s both fast and fresh.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top local pizza places in Iowa City?
Favorites include A & A Pagliai’s, The Wig & Pen Pizza Pub, and Mesa Pizza. Each brings unique crusts, creative toppings, and plenty of local history to your table.
Who delivers pizza late at night in Iowa City?
Gumby’s and Domino’s are well-known for late-night orders, especially popular with students after midnight. Many chains also have extended hours on weekends.
Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Iowa City?
Absolutely. Most places offer veggie pies and allow custom builds. Mesa and Blaze Pizza are especially friendly for plant-based eaters.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Iowa City?
Yes, check out Pizza Ranch, Pagliai’s, and Domino’s for gluten-free pizza bases, along with plenty of topping choices.
What’s the most unique pizza in Iowa City?
The Wig & Pen’s Flying Tomato pizza, Casey’s breakfast pizza, and Gumby’s Pokey Stix all stand out for flavor and originality.