Finding great pizza in Indianapolis sometimes feels like hunting for hidden treasure. The city pulses with all sorts of flavors, from pies tossed in bustling downtown kitchens to classic slices served in cozy neighborhood joints. After many casual slices and serious taste tests across Indy, I’ve realized the city’s pizza game is far more creative—and competitive—than I ever expected.
Whether you crave the golden crunch of hand-tossed crust or are on a mission for deep-dish comfort, this guide covers the spots that actually deliver on taste, freshness, and experience. Each one brings something special to the table. If you’re ready to try a slice that just might become your new favorite, keep reading. This journey through the best pizza in Indianapolis may just surprise you.
1. Bazbeaux Pizza
Bazbeaux Pizza pulls crowds to Mass Ave with its imaginative toppings and crisp, airy crust. The space gives off a relaxed, artsy vibe—perfect for lingering over a pie with friends. I once lost track of time sampling slices here on a rainy afternoon, surprised by how much flavor they pack into every bite.
The Quattro Formaggio captures Bazbeaux’s approach best: a cheese quartet melting into a golden, savory masterpiece. If you prefer something lively, try the Mexican Pizza, layered with black bean sauce and jalapeños. There are also plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options, so everyone finds a slice to love. It’s tough to leave Bazbeaux without planning your next visit.
2. Brozinni Pizzeria
Brozinni Pizzeria feels like a slice of New York tucked away in Indy. The smell hits you as soon as you walk in—yeasty dough, toasty cheese, and that big-city attitude. After countless visits, I always end up craving their signature garlic knots just as much as their pizza.
The “Big Apple” pizza brings together the classic foldable crust and balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio that makes New York style so beloved. For something a bit punchier, the Buffalo Chicken pizza is a spicy crowd-pleaser. Vegetarian and gluten-free options round out the menu, making it easy for groups to share. Brozinni is the place to go when you want generous slices that don’t need fuss—just plenty of napkins.
3. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza anchors East Washington with a contagious neighborhood energy and a menu that’s easy to trust. The restaurant’s cozy booths and crush of regulars say a lot, but what wins me over every time is their knack for inventive pizzas and the little touches—like fresh-shredded cheese—that set them apart.
The Slaughterhouse Five pairs a mix of peppers with rich cheese and a just-right crust, turning up the flavor without overdoing it. But if you’re into lighter fare, the Mean Green with pesto sauce and artichokes hits a fresh note. Jockamo is always friendly to vegans, vegetarians, and the gluten-sensitive, so no one feels left out. Their pizza has a way of making even a regular Tuesday feel like a treat.
4. Giorgio’s Pizza
Giorgio’s Pizza stands at the heart of downtown, drawing locals and visitors with comforting aromas and tried-and-true recipes. This spot feels like an old-school pizzeria, the kind you remember from childhood, with slices that taste even better than they look. I first stopped in while rushing between meetings, only to find myself lingering for “just one more” bite.
The Margherita pizza puts fresh basil and ripe tomato front and center, keeping flavors clean and classic. For those after something heartier, the Vegetarian Deluxe packs generous veggies on a crisp base. Giorgio’s proves that straightforward, well-made pizza always wins. It’s the spot that turns a quick lunch into a highlight of your day.
5. Giordano’s
Giordano’s brings a taste of Chicago’s boldest style to Indianapolis—deep, cheesy, and unapologetically satisfying. The atmosphere feels welcoming whether you’re celebrating or grabbing a quick bite downtown. My first visit turned into a full event, with friends debating just how much cheese can fit in a single slice.
The Stuffed Deep Dish Cheese pizza is a rite of passage here. Each forkful delivers silky cheese and tangy sauce layered inside a golden crust. Craving something lighter? The Super Veggie balances hearty classic flavors with plenty of freshness. Giordano’s nails the art of comfort food, with service and quality that keep people coming back for another bite of that legendary pie.
6. Ale Emporium
Ale Emporium feels like an Indy classic, drawing crowds for its mix of neighborhood warmth and big-game energy. It’s the place where you settle in for serious food, not just a snack between innings. Every pizza comes loaded with fresh toppings and melts together with a crust that somehow manages both crunch and chew.
The Honest Pizza is a personal favorite, loaded with cheese, peppers, and savory sauce. If you want to sample something popular, the Deluxe Pizza doubles down on freshness and balance. Vegetarians have plenty to pick from, too. Ale Emporium keeps things real and straightforward—the kind of spot where the pizza stands out as much as the atmosphere.
7. Bazbeaux Pizza
Bazbeaux Pizza in Broad Ripple serves up inventive flavors with a side of charm. The cheerful buzz of the neighborhood mixes with the aroma of fresh-baked dough, making this spot tough to bypass on a weekend stroll. One rainy Saturday, I ducked in to escape the weather and wound up staying for a long lunch, completely pulled in by their creative pies.
The Garden pizza bursts with fresh veggies and gooey cheese—an easy pick for anyone who loves vibrant flavors. For a bolder choice, The Tchoupitoulas offers a blend of peppers and cheeses for something a bit out of the ordinary. With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, Bazbeaux keeps the menu open to everyone and never skimps on quality.
8. Some Guys Pizza
Some Guys Pizza fits perfectly into the patchwork of Allisonville Road, known for spinning classic pies with a nearly artistic touch. The first time I wandered in, the friendly staff and lively kitchen chatter set the tone. The pizzas arrived piping hot, and each crisp crust crackled invitingly at the first bite.
The Mediterranean pizza is a standout, layered with spinach, feta, and tomatoes for a bright, tangy finish. For a local favorite, the Barbecue Chicken pizza balances smoky sauce with melted cheese for something both bold and comforting. Some Guys keeps it simple but never boring, and the vegetarian crowd will find plenty to enjoy as well. Every slice feels handcrafted, showing why they’re a neighborhood mainstay.
9. Pearl Street Pizza
Pearl Street Pizza feels like a hidden gem snugged between downtown’s busy blocks. When I visited for the first time after work, I landed in a booth with friends and immediately noticed how every table seemed filled with regulars—a clear sign of a loyal following. The vibe is unfussy and relaxed, but the pizza? Exceptionally crafted.
The Margherita pizza stands out with its robust tomato sauce and perfect hit of fresh basil. If you want to branch out, the Pearl Street Special loads the crust with veggies and cheese for a balanced, flavorful slice. Pearl Street knows how to keep pizza simple, honest, and delicious. There’s a comfort here that keeps people coming back again and again.
10. Arni’s River Ridge
Arni’s River Ridge captures a slice of Indiana tradition with its welcoming vibe and loyal following. This family-run restaurant knows how to serve nostalgia and quality in every pie. My first meal here felt like joining a happy neighborhood table, surrounded by laughter and the aroma of fresh-baked crust.
The Deluxe pizza is a local legend, topped with sliced mushrooms, crisp green peppers, and savory cheese—a combination that’s rich but never overwhelming. If you like something with a bit of crunch, their thin crust pies deliver. Vegetarians and those eating gluten-free find lots of choices here, too. Arni’s keeps things classic, proving that good pizza and hospitality can turn any day into a family occasion.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are popular in Indianapolis?
Indianapolis features a mix of styles, from New York-style thin crust to Chicago-inspired deep dish. You’ll also find classic hand-tossed and creative gourmet pies on menus across the city.
Are there good vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Indianapolis?
Yes, many local pizzerias offer vegetarian and vegan pizzas, plus gluten-free crusts. Spots like Bazbeaux and Jockamo Upper Crust stand out for their variety of plant-based and allergen-friendly menus.
Do Indianapolis pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza?
Most top pizza places in the city provide gluten-free crusts as an option. Ask ahead or check menus if you have specific dietary needs.
Which pizza spot is best for large groups or parties?
Places like Giordano’s, Brozinni Pizzeria, or Ale Emporium are known for their spacious seating and ability to handle groups. Reservations can help guarantee a spot during peak hours.
Can I order pizza delivery late at night in Indianapolis?
Several pizzerias offer late-night delivery or carryout, especially downtown and in busy neighborhoods. Check hours before ordering to make sure your favorite spot is still serving.