Choosing your next slice in Hurley isn’t just about feeding a craving—it’s about navigating a small map of tradition, secret sauce recipes, and crisp crust rivalries. Living in the Hudson Valley for years, I’ve spent more hours debating toppings with friends than I care to admit. Late one winter night, dodging icy sidewalks, I found myself in a heated (and, let’s be honest, partly cheesy) discussion about who, exactly, makes the best pizza in town. That led to a months-long quest: different pies, different people, and a search for consistency. Some had sauce best described as a hug in tomato form, others a crust that dared you not to finish the whole thing.
This guide pulls together those experiences, the recommendations locals swear by, and the notes I scribbled on napkins whenever a slice earned special praise. Whether you’re after late-night delivery, a classic New York fold, or an old-school pie you’d swear Nonna made, Hurley’s got you covered. Reading on, you’ll skip the mediocrity and head straight to the ovens with the most flavor and personality. Trust the list—your next favorite slice might be on it.
Where to find the best pizza in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Hurley, NY:
- Pie-Sano’s Pizza and Deli
- 440 Pizzeria
- Picnic Pizza
- Tony’s Pizzeria
- Kings Pizza Restaurant
- Savona’s Plaza Pizza
- Di Bella’s Pizza Shop
- Altomare’s Pizzeria
- Papis Pizza & Wings
- K & G Pizzeria
1. Pie-Sano’s Pizza and Deli
(845) 338-4976Call
Pie-Sano’s Pizza and Deli sits right on Hurley Ave and feels comfortably no-nonsense. Step inside and find a spot where thick slices, friendly chatter, and the irresistible aroma of fresh dough fill the room. My first bite of their plain cheese pizza was a revelation—stretchy cheese, a sauce with just enough tang, and a crust that doesn’t flop or disappoint.
What makes Pie-Sano’s different is the balance: every slice seems crafted, not rushed. The pepperoni pie brings crisp-edged slices that snap with flavor, and their veggie toppings keep their snap without flooding the crust. For something special, ask about their white pizza—it’s rich and garlicky, with a base so creamy you almost forget about red sauce.
If you like a local spot with big flavor and zero pretense, Pie-Sano’s should top your list for pizza in Hurley.
2. 440 Pizzeria
(845) 514-2364Call
If you wind up on Broadway with a pizza craving, 440 Pizzeria is where crisp meets comfort. With easy parking and a warm, no-fuss setting, it’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your favorite slice. My go-to order is their classic Margherita—a thin, charred crust, fresh basil scattered over molten cheese, and bright tomato sauce that tastes like summer in every bite.
Their Sicilian pie rewards anyone hunting for a thicker, chewy base with those crusty corner edges. Specialty slices rotate, but don’t skip the white pizza, which pairs a lush ricotta spread with a perfect dusting of herbs. Stop by hungry and leave with a new favorite go-to spot for pizza in Hurley’s orbit.
3. Picnic Pizza
Picnic Pizza has the charm of a neighborhood institution and a menu that pulls in loyal fans every week. The atmosphere is relaxed, the staff friendly, and you’ll always spot regulars grabbing a quick lunch or picking up family dinner. The parking is easy, too, so there’s no stress before you sink into a hefty slice.
I gravitate toward their Grandma pizza—square, slightly saucy, and finished with a sprinkle of fresh basil and olive oil. It’s done with a soft, chewy base and a robust sauce that sets it apart from the usual lineup. The regular cheese slice is a crowd-pleaser, but the real story here is how fresh everything tastes, from crust edge to last bite of tomato.
Pizza in Hurley doesn’t get more approachable than Picnic—no fuss, no shortcuts, just honest pies made right.
4. Tony’s Pizzeria
Eating at Tony’s Pizzeria feels like stepping into a slice of local history. The family-run vibe and steady hum of conversation set the perfect stage for classic, no-nonsense pizza. I still remember my first slice here—thin crust, bubbling mozzarella, and a sauce that tastes like someone’s been perfecting it for generations.
The standout at Tony’s is their old-school NY-style slice—crisp enough to fold, but never dry. Their Margherita is a must-try, with fresh tomatoes and basil that give it a pop of color and flavor. For those with an appetite, their large pies deliver good value and quality. Tony’s is the kind of spot where a craving for authentic pizza never goes unanswered.
5. Kings Pizza Restaurant
Kings Pizza Restaurant delivers that hard-to-find mix of classic Italian comfort and a welcoming Kingston vibe. It’s a spacious, family-friendly spot where you can linger, unwind, and actually enjoy your food. My first visit happened on a rainy afternoon, and their piping hot cheese slice hit the mark—simple, satisfying, and no stingy toppings in sight.
Their Chicken Parm pizza turns heads, fusing tender breaded chicken with a generous layer of bubbly cheese. For a lighter touch, the veggie supreme is always fresh and never soggy. The crust here walks the line between crisp and chewy. If you want a sit-down pizza night near Hurley, this is where you can relax and dig into a quality pie.
6. Savona’s Plaza Pizza
Savona’s Plaza Pizza sits tucked away in Kingston Plaza, but it’s rarely a secret for long. The vibe is easygoing and welcoming, pulling in everyone from office lunch crowds to families catching up over dinner. My most memorable moment here was sharing a giant pie with friends after a hike—everyone agreed the flavor balance stood out.
Try their signature Grandma pizza: square, thin, and layered with a zesty sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Their Margherita slice is another winner, boasting a perfectly blistered crust and garden-fresh basil. All the pies come out piping hot and crisp around the edges. If you’re seeking pizza that captures both comfort and just a little creativity, Savona’s delivers every time.
7. Di Bella’s Pizza Shop
(845) 339-9900Call
Di Bella’s Pizza Shop feels like a neighborhood staple—the kind of spot where you can count on friendly faces and consistent pies. The layout is unpretentious and welcoming, which only adds to its comfort-food appeal. My visits here always end with the same conclusion: their pies nail that golden balance between crispy crust and cheesy goodness.
The classic plain pizza is a local favorite, baked to just the right shade and loaded edge to edge with mozzarella. I find their veggie pizza fresh and satisfying, with a good variety of colorful toppings that never drown out the sauce. If you want your pizza simple, honest, and satisfying, Di Bella’s quietly delivers quality every time.
8. Altomare’s Pizzeria
(845) 339-6025Call
Altomare’s Pizzeria seems to fly under the radar, but anyone who eats here knows it holds its own. The interior is simple, but the pizza comes out with a rustic edge that signals real attention to detail. On my first visit, I was convinced by a regular to try their plain slice—and it didn’t disappoint. The crust is chewy with a gentle char, and the sauce leans tangy rather than sweet.
Altomare’s shines for its specialty pies, especially the veggie pizza, which is loaded but never soggy or overdone. Their traditional cheese pizza is my rainy-day pick: comforting, balanced, with each ingredient pulling its weight. If you’re exploring pizza around Hurley, this spot deserves a dedicated stop.
9. Papis Pizza & Wings
(845) 331-2123Call
Papis Pizza & Wings is the epitome of quick comfort in Kingston. The space is casual and built for speedy takeout, but the pies are always made with care. Drop in at lunchtime and you’ll see locals queuing up for slices—always a good sign. My first bite here was their classic cheese pizza, which struck the right chord between gooey and crisp, leaving me plotting my next visit.
The standout is their Supreme pizza: loaded with veggies, it’s colorful, hearty, and balanced, never overwhelming. Their crust strikes the rare balance between sturdy and light, making every bite satisfying. When you need a fuss-free pizza fix near Hurley, Papis delivers on taste and reliability.
10. K & G Pizzeria
(845) 339-8000Call
K & G Pizzeria doesn’t make a fuss, yet it’s one of those places you remember after the first slice. The shop feels tucked away and homey, and that sense of comfort comes through in every pie they serve. My introduction here was their classic cheese—a slice that gets better as you go, with stretchy mozzarella and a mellow, flavorful sauce.
If you’re adventurous, their White Pizza comes highly recommended: creamy ricotta, garlic, and just enough herbs for balance. The crust is crisp but not too thick, making it perfect for fold-and-go eating. Every ingredient tastes fresh, and each pie feels crafted just for you. For pizza in Hurley with reliable quality, K & G is worth knowing.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are popular in Hurley, NY?
You’ll find a mix of New York-style thin crust, Sicilian, Grandma, and specialty pies. Most spots stick to the classics but also get creative with fresh toppings and white sauce options.
Are there any pizza places with gluten-free options?
Yes, a number of local pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts. It’s smart to call ahead to confirm and check if additional accommodations are available.
Do Hurley-area pizzerias deliver?
Most local spots offer delivery and takeout. Some are available through popular delivery apps, while others handle orders directly over the phone.
Which local pizzerias are good for families or groups?
Many pizzerias in the area are family-friendly with spacious seating—try Kings Pizza Restaurant, Savona’s Plaza Pizza, or Tony’s Pizzeria. They’re great for sharing large pies and offer casual atmospheres.
Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Hurley?
Absolutely. Almost every pizza shop offers cheese and veggie pies, with fresh ingredients like roasted peppers, spinach, mushrooms, and more.
What’s the price range for pizza in Hurley, NY?
Prices vary, but you’ll find everything from affordable slices to larger pies in the mid-range. Most pizzerias offer lunch specials for extra value.
Can I find truly authentic New York pizza in Hurley?
Definitely. Plenty of local spots—like Tony’s Pizzeria and Picnic Pizza—are praised for their authentic NY-style thin crust and classic flavors.
Which pizzeria is the best for a quick lunch?
Picnic Pizza, Papis Pizza & Wings, and K & G Pizzeria are known for fast service and good quality slices, making them go-to lunch stops.
Do any pizza places have outdoor seating?
A few spots, especially in the warmer months, set up outdoor tables. It’s always worth calling ahead to ask about current seating options.
Where can I find the best specialty pizzas in Hurley?
Savona’s Plaza Pizza and Altomare’s Pizzeria are known for their creative specialty pies with unique toppings and great flavor combinations.