Looking for the best pizza in Holtsville, NY can feel like a quest for buried treasure. This town holds enough pizzerias to satisfy every craving, from that thin, crisp slice at midnight to a pillowy crust that dares you to eat just one more piece. I’ve lost count of the times I ducked into a Holtsville pizza shop on a rainy evening, comforted by the aroma of fresh dough and tangy tomato sauce. The subtle competition between classic institutions and upstart pizzerias keeps the local scene vibrant, and while opinions can get intense, the search for the top spot is half the fun.
There’s no shortage of opinions about where to find the ultimate slice, but you don’t have to wade through online reviews or secondhand tips. I’ve walked the tiled floors, tasted the fresh mozzarella, and traded banter with pizzaiolos who treat dough like a science. This guide covers the standout spots—the cozy family joints, the modern grills with surprising pies, and even the chain favorites that always deliver. If you’re hungry for a slice of Holtsville’s finest, you’re in the right place. Let’s find your new favorite pizza together.
Where to find the best pizza in Holtsville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Holtsville, NY:
- Ciao Bella Pizzeria
- La Famosa
- La Capannina
- La Famos Pizzaria
- Giuseppe’s Pizza
- Sonoma Grill
- Sbarro
- Gianna’s Pizzeria
- Gino’s Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
1. Ciao Bella Pizzeria
Ciao Bella Pizzeria feels like a slice of Italy right in Holtsville. The aroma greets you from the parking lot, promising something classic yet bold. On my first visit, the owner chatted tableside about their family recipes and urged me to try the margherita.
Each pizza here is a proof of tradition and creativity. The crust is both airy and crisp. I love how fresh basil, quality cheese, and gently tangy tomato sauce come together in every bite. For anyone seeking variety, the menu offers plenty—think white pizza with ricotta or a veggie pie stacked with roasted peppers.
Ciao Bella’s charm is its heart and focus on real flavors. If you’re undecided, start with their classic cheese pizza or the margherita. Each is made to emphasize Ciao Bella’s careful attention to authenticity and balance. It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back.
2. La Famosa
La Famosa draws a loyal crowd with classic pizza that doesn’t try too hard. It’s the kind of spot where you find locals on their lunch break, grabbing a quick slice and swapping stories by the counter. My own first bite here was on a busy evening, and I was struck by the balance of flavors—the pizza never felt heavy or overdone.
The crust deserves a special mention: golden, crisp at the edge, and foldable in true New York style. Toppings stay fresh and well-portioned, letting the cheese and sauce speak for themselves. La Famosa nails that balance between satisfying and unpretentious.
If you’re visiting for the first time, try the classic cheese slice or add in a pepper and onion topping for a kick. Both showcase what makes La Famosa a staple for pizza in Holtsville—simple, honest pies made with care.
3. La Capannina
(631) 569-4524Call
La Capannina feels comfortably tucked away on Morris Ave, making it a favorite for regulars who prefer low-key spots with memorable pizza. I stopped by on a chilly afternoon and was greeted by warm lights, the gentle hum of conversation, and the inviting scent of baking bread.
Their pizzas have a rustic touch—airy, chewy crust and a sauce that leans bright and just sweet enough. The kitchen goes beyond the basics, delivering pies that celebrate classic Italian roots while still feeling unmistakably local.
If you want a recommendation, their margherita or veggie pizza stand out for freshness and balance. Both highlight what makes La Capannina special: skilled preparation, quality ingredients, and a genuine love of the craft. This is where tradition quietly shines.
4. La Famos Pizzaria
(631) 207-2055Call
La Famos Pizzaria might not have the flashiest sign, but the steady stream of customers says plenty. I first wandered in after a long day, tempted by the scent of bubbling cheese and fresh dough wafting out the door. Inside, it’s cozy, with a counter you’ll want to linger at while your pizza is made.
The slices at La Famos Pizzaria are crisply baked and dotted with generous toppings, never skimping on flavor. Their sauce avoids being too sweet or too sharp, while the cheese stretches perfectly from plate to mouth.
If you’re unsure where to start, order a plain cheese or a classic veggie slice. Both reveal the pizzeria’s attention to balance and classic technique. For a reliable taste of Holtsville, this spot delivers every time.
5. Giuseppe’s Pizza
(631) 207-2166Call
Giuseppe’s Pizza is one of those places where every visit feels familiar, even if it’s your first time through the door. I stopped in on a lazy Sunday, drawn by the promise of classic pizza done right. The staff are friendly and efficient, keeping the line moving and the pies hot from the oven.
The crust at Giuseppe’s hits that perfect midpoint between crisp and chewy, supporting a vibrant, tomato-forward sauce. Cheese is layered just thick enough to satisfy but never overwhelm, and toppings stay fresh to the last bite.
If you’re in the mood for something simple, their cheese or mushroom pizza highlight the best of what they do. Giuseppe’s shows how tradition, a good oven, and steady hands can still win over any pizza lover.
6. Sonoma Grill
Sonoma Grill isn’t your typical pizza joint—it’s a spacious spot where you can catch a game, gather friends, and enjoy surprisingly memorable pies. My first time here was a group dinner that quickly turned into a lively pizza taste test, and Sonoma Grill held its own against more traditional pizzerias.
They serve up artisan-style pizzas with creative toppings and a crust that’s perfectly blistered. The pies land at your table hot, with edges just charred enough for extra flavor, and toppings piled on fresh.
If you’re in the mood for something different, go for the balsamic-glazed veggie pizza or the classic margherita. Both showcase Sonoma Grill’s blend of local comfort and bold twists. It’s a winning option whether you’re a purist or ready to experiment.
7. Sbarro
Sbarro needs no introduction to most pizza fans, but every location brings its own local twist. I wandered into their Holtsville spot one afternoon and found it bustling with families and commuters grabbing something fast but filling. The display case showed off those signature oversized slices that Sbarro is famous for.
Sbarro’s appeal is in the consistency—thick, doughy crusts baked golden and topped with plenty of cheese and sauce. It’s exactly the kind of pizza you crave after a long day, satisfiying and easy to grab on the go.
If you’re there, the classic cheese or white pizza are the safest bets. They showcase what Sbarro does best: hearty, honest New York–style slices that deliver comfort and quick satisfaction. For a reliable bite, Sbarro nails it.
8. Gianna’s Pizzeria
Gianna’s Pizzeria sits just outside Holtsville in Medford, but locals know it’s worth the short trip. On my first visit, I noticed regulars chatting comfortably with the staff—always a sign of a well-loved spot. The atmosphere is warm, with an inviting buzz that makes you want to linger.
Their pizza stands out for the quality of the crust—light, chewy, and just crisp underneath. Toppings are always fresh and the sauce has a gentle, herby sweetness that never overpowers.
If you’re not sure where to start, try the Sicilian or grandma slice. Both highlight Gianna’s focus on tradition and the balance that comes from careful preparation. For a reliable, satisfying pizza in the Holtsville area, Gianna’s is a strong bet.
9. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza in Ronkonkoma might be a short drive from Holtsville, but the trip is easily justified once you’ve tasted a slice. My first visit was on a friend’s recommendation, and I ended up taking home extra slices for later—always a good sign.
Gino’s has mastered the art of the traditional New York–style crust—thin, foldable, and dusted with just the right amount of cornmeal. Their sauce is savory with a hint of sweetness, and they don’t hold back on the cheese.
If you’re looking to try their best, the plain cheese or the white pizza bring out the simple quality ingredients. For affordable, authentic pizza with a loyal following, Gino’s holds its own in the area.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns in Selden may be a chain, but this location stands out for its consistent quality and fast, friendly service. I’ve grabbed takeout from here on busy nights, always impressed by the even bake and fresh feel of every pizza. The staff make sure your pie is piping hot, and the experience is reliably hassle-free.
Papa Johns is known for its soft, chewy crust and balanced tomato sauce, finished with a dusting of garlic on the edges. The cheese melts smooth, and they offer customizable options for every eater.
If you’re not sure what to order, start with the classic cheese or their garden fresh veggie pizza. These highlight Papa Johns’ commitment to good ingredients and easy comfort, standing up well against local favorites in Holtsville.
More Things to Try in Holtsville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Holtsville, NY?
Top local favorites include Ciao Bella Pizzeria, La Capannina, Giuseppe’s Pizza, and Gianna’s Pizzeria. Each spot has its own loyal following and signature slice.
Are there options for vegetarian pizza in Holtsville?
Absolutely. Most pizza places here, like Ciao Bella and Sonoma Grill, make veggie pies loaded with fresh toppings. You’ll usually find margherita, veggie, and white pizzas as well.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Holtsville?
Several local spots offer gluten-free crusts—just ask when you call ahead. Chains such as Papa Johns and Domino’s are often reliable choices for gluten-free options.
What’s the average price for a large pizza in Holtsville?
Most large pizzas range from $15 to $25, depending on the toppings and type of crust. Specials and lunch deals are pretty common, so it’s worth checking out menu boards or websites.
Which pizza spots offer delivery around Holtsville?
Nearly all pizzerias in Holtsville offer delivery, including Ciao Bella, Papa Johns, Sbarro, and Domino’s. Delivery areas can vary, so double-check before you order.
Are there late-night pizza options in Holtsville?
Yes, a handful of spots, especially well-known chains like Domino’s and Papa Johns, stay open later for those after-dark cravings. Call ahead or check online for hours.