The right pizza can turn a routine Tuesday into something worth talking about. Hendersonville, TN sits quietly on the map, but ask around and you’ll hear murmurs about pies worth skipping dinner plans in Nashville for. Whether you like your slice dripping with cheese and attitude, or you lean toward wood-fired crunch and fresh basil, this town’s pizza scene delivers plenty of surprises.
I’ve lost count of how many times I intended to eat “just one slice” here, only to walk out clutching a warm box home for later. There’s real passion in these kitchens—sometimes it’s the crust that wins you over, other times it’s a sauce that tastes like a family secret. This guide sorts through the talk and the toppings, giving you a genuine map to the best pizza in Hendersonville. Ready for something that makes decision-making a little easier—and a whole lot tastier?
1. Ny Pie
If you crave pizza with a New York attitude, Ny Pie is where you make that happen in Hendersonville. The hand-tossed, brick-oven crust is thin yet sturdy, never floppy—perfect for folding, just like they do on the streets of Manhattan. Each bite gives you that sought-after balance of crackle and chew.
I still think about the time I tried their classic cheese pie and realized how much difference real, homemade dough makes. The dough and sauce are crafted fresh daily, which gives every slice a straight-from-the-oven authenticity.
If you’re indecisive, start with a simple Margherita or try the Veggie Lovers, where crisp vegetables meet a generous layer of Grande cheese. It’s the sort of pizza that feels both familiar and genuinely original, setting Ny Pie apart from the usual options.
2. Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
+1 615-590-7892
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar delivers the kind of pizza that makes an ordinary evening feel like a small celebration. The wood-fired oven does wonders, giving every crust a smoky char with a pleasingly tender bite. Their approach to pizza is modern, but the flavors are classic and memorable.
I remember being pleasantly surprised by their Gluten-Free Margherita, topped generously with basil and gooey mozzarella. The menu caters to all preferences, offering vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free choices without skimping on taste or creativity.
Start with the Wild Mushroom pizza or the basic Margherita to taste the effect of that wood-fired oven. It’s a place that invites you to linger a little longer with friends or family, thanks to their comfortable setting and rotating craft drinks list.
3. Sanders Ferry Pizza And Pub
Sanders Ferry Pizza And Pub has the aura of a neighborhood staple—friendly faces, a relaxed vibe, and pizza that keeps people coming back. The place is known for thick, cheesy pies with a golden crust that feels substantial in your hands, making each slice both hearty and satisfying.
I’ve stopped in for lunch and found the Veggie Pizza especially impressive. Fresh vegetables sit atop a base that strikes just the right balance between chewy and crispy. There’s a sense of care in how each pizza comes out of the oven: never rushed, always well-made.
It’s an ideal spot to settle in, catch up with friends, and share a pie or two. Don’t miss their cheese pizza if you want to taste the fundamentals done right.
4. Jolly Ollie’s Pizza & Pub
Jolly Ollie’s Pizza & Pub gives off the kind of hometown energy where everyone feels like a regular, even on their first visit. The pizza here is unmistakably comforting—thick, golden crusts with flavorful sauce and a robust cheese blend. The pies have that “extra-slice-for-later” quality you’ll appreciate long after you leave.
The first time I tried their Supreme Pizza, the freshness of the veggies and zing of their homemade sauce stood out. Each pizza is generously topped, with flavors that layer rather than compete, and a crust that manages to be hearty but not heavy.
It’s tough to go wrong with a basic Cheese or Veggie pizza here if you want something classic and satisfying. Social atmosphere and attentive service help make Jolly Ollie’s a place that’s easy to recommend for a casual dinner or a night out with friends.
5. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den is a straightforward spot that understands the beauty of a reliable, crowd-pleasing pizza. Portion sizes here lean generous, with thick, fluffy crusts that soak up every bit of their tangy sauce. This is pizza that feels like comfort after a long day.
On my last visit, the Veggie Pizza was the surprise standout—crispy edges, a good layer of cheese, and plenty of fresh toppings. They don’t hold back with the cheese, making every bite indulgent but never overwhelming.
Their traditional Cheese or the customizable Build Your Own Pizza are both safe bets. Whether you’re feeding a few or a full table, Fox’s hits all the right notes for classic pizza in Hendersonville.
6. Jet’s Pizza
Jet’s Pizza is where you go when you want your pizza experience kicked up a notch, thanks to their signature deep-dish style. Their square-cut pies come out cheesy, golden, and delightfully crispy along the edges—each slice has that satisfying crunch as you bite in.
Their 8 Corner Pizza has become a personal favorite. It guarantees every piece delivers plenty of crust, layered sauce, and a smooth stretch of cheese. You’ll notice a real focus on consistency here: every order arrives just as you expect, piping hot and fresh.
If you haven’t had their veggie or classic cheese options, start there. Jet’s is the place for comfort food with a twist, especially for those who appreciate a sturdy, satisfying crust.
7. Roma Pizza & Pasta
Roma Pizza & Pasta feels like the kind of spot you might stumble into on a busy weeknight and quickly add to your regular rotation. Their New York-style thin crust pizzas are consistently crisp at the edges, with just enough chew—simple, but never boring.
Last time I visited, the Veggie Pizza impressed me with its fresh toppings and well-balanced flavors. The homemade sauce has a little tang without overpowering the ingredients, and the portions are generous, whether you’re eating solo or with friends.
If you want to get a sense of their style, try the cheese or a classic Margherita. Roma’s menu leans traditional, making it solid for anyone craving straightforward, high-quality pizza in Hendersonville.
8. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch brings a buffet-style approach to pizza in Hendersonville, making it easy to sample a bit of everything without overthinking your order. The standout here is the ability to try several classic and creative pizza varieties hot from the oven, always replenished and never stale.
The first time I dined in, the Veggie Pizza and classic cheese slices disappeared fast from my plate. It’s the kind of place where you’re tempted to return for “just one more slice”—especially when everything tastes fresh and homemade.
If you have a group or family, Pizza Ranch’s spacious setting and variety make it a popular choice. Be sure to try the dessert pizza for a sweet finish if you have room left.
9. Main Street Pub And Pizza
Main Street Pub And Pizza gives off that friendly, lived-in vibe you want from a neighborhood hangout. The pizza menu leans classic, yet every pie comes out with a golden crust, bubbling cheese, and a pleasantly robust sauce. It’s the sort of spot where the food tastes as relaxed as the atmosphere feels.
On my first visit, I tried the Veggie Pizza and was pleasantly surprised by the harmony between the crisp crust and generous toppings. You get the feeling every pie is made for sharing, whether you’re there for a quick meal or stretching out the evening with friends.
If you’re unsure where to start, go with a Cheese or Margherita pizza—they showcase the kitchen’s knack for simple, well-executed flavors. It’s a reliable spot for honest, satisfying pizza in Hendersonville.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Hendersonville is about convenience and reliability—just what you need when a craving hits or you’re feeding a crowd. Consistency is their calling card: every order delivers a familiar, hot, cheesy pizza, whether you go thin crust or deep-dish.
I once ordered their Thin Crust Veggie Pizza on a busy night, and it arrived fast, crisp, and properly loaded with toppings. Customization is easy, so you can dial in your order just how you like it, from sauces to crust style.
If you want something classic, go for the Handmade Pan Cheese Pizza. Domino’s never pretends to be gourmet, but they always satisfy your pizza expectations—hot, timely, and tasty, every single time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best place for pizza in Hendersonville, TN?
The “best” depends on your style. Ny Pie is loved for its classic New York thin crust, while Jet’s Pizza stands out with its square, deep-dish slices. For wood-fired flavor, Brixx is a top choice.
Are there any pizza spots with vegetarian or vegan options?
Absolutely. Brixx, Ny Pie, and Jolly Ollie’s all offer veggie pizzas, and some feature vegan or gluten-free crusts. Always check menus, since options do vary.
Who delivers pizza in Hendersonville?
Domino’s, Jet’s Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars all deliver. Many local favorites like Roma Pizza & Pasta and Fox’s Pizza Den also offer delivery or convenient takeout. Third-party apps can help too.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Hendersonville?
Yes, places like Brixx, Domino’s, and Jet’s Pizza have gluten-free crusts or specialty pies. Ask about preparation if you have specific dietary needs.
Where can I eat late-night pizza in Hendersonville?
Domino’s and Little Caesars tend to stay open late, but hours change by location and season. Check websites or call ahead for current info.