Discovering the best pizza in Hattiesburg, MS, is a quest that promises delicious surprises at every turn. Over the years, I’ve explored the local pizza scene, and each visit offers a new flavor adventure — from crispy crusts to inventive toppings. The city’s diverse options make it clear that Hattiesburg takes its pizza seriously, blending traditional recipes with creative twists that satisfy every craving. Whether you’re searching for a cozy spot for a family dinner or a quick slice on the go, there’s something here for everyone.
What sets Hattiesburg’s pizzerias apart is their dedication to quality and flavor. I’ve personally found that the best pizza isn’t just about the ingredients but about the passion behind each dish. This list compiles the top spots that consistently deliver exceptional pies — places that know how to turn simple ingredients into memorable meals. Read on to find your next favorite slice, and trust that these recommendations are grounded in experience and a genuine love for great pizza.
Where to find the best pizza in Hattiesburg, MS
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Hattiesburg, MS:
- Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar
- Mercury Pizza Co.
- Pyro’s Fire Fresh Pizza
- Fox’s Pizza Den
- Pizza Hut – Wing Street
- Chuck E. Cheese
- Domino’s Pizza
- Fat Boys Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Little Caesars
1. Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar
Nestled at 122 Carlisle Drive, Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for savoring authentic Sicilian cuisine. From my visits, it’s clear that their homemade dishes are crafted with care, highlighting fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. The welcoming vibe makes every meal feel like a special occasion, and the attentive service adds to the experience.
What truly sets Mario’s apart is their dedication to quality and detail. Their pizza, in particular, is a standout — featuring a crisp crust, rich cheeses, and flavorful toppings that reflect genuine Italian craftsmanship. For a true taste of Italy in Hattiesburg, I recommend trying their Margherita or Sicilian-style pizza — simple, yet bursting with authentic flavor. It’s a spot that never disappoints.
2. Mercury Pizza Co.
Located at 6481 US Highway 98, Mercury Pizza Co. is a favorite for pizza lovers seeking quality and variety in Hattiesburg. Visiting this spot, I was impressed by the vibrant atmosphere and the welcoming staff. Their menu offers something for everyone, including vegetarian and vegan options, making it accessible for diverse dietary needs.
Their signature pizzas, with crisp crusts and inventive toppings, truly stand out. I especially enjoyed the Veggie Delight and Supreme, which showcased their commitment to fresh ingredients and bold flavors. For a satisfying and authentic pizza experience, Mercury Pizza Co. embodies a perfect blend of quality and creativity that keeps customers coming back.
3. Pyro’s Fire Fresh Pizza
At 3002 Hardy Street, Pyro’s Fire Fresh Pizza redefines fast-casual dining with an artisan approach. During my visit, I was struck by the build-your-own concept, which lets you customize your pizza from scratch — perfect for anyone with specific tastes. The atmosphere is modern, yet relaxed, and the service was genuinely attentive.
Pyro’s pizzas stand out for their fire-fresh preparation and balanced flavors. I recommend the Fresh Basil & Mozzarella or the Spicy Veggie, both of which reflect their attention to freshness and texture. The crust has just the right bite, and the toppings are vibrant. It’s a go-to spot if you’re looking for creative combinations and quick service without sacrificing quality.
4. Fox’s Pizza Den
Located at 5266 Old Highway 11, Fox’s Pizza Den offers a casual yet satisfying pizza experience. During my visit, I appreciated the friendly staff and the inviting, no-frills atmosphere. It’s a solid choice for a quick lunch or dinner that won’t compromise on taste.
Their signature pizzas are crafted with quality ingredients and a focus on flavor. I recommend trying the Meat Lovers or the Veggie Supreme, both featuring generous toppings and a crispy crust that holds up well. Fox’s Pizza Den stands out by delivering consistent quality and reliable service, making it a dependable option for those craving classic, well-made pizza in Hattiesburg.
5. Pizza Hut – Wing Street
At the corner of Hardy Street and 37th in Hattiesburg, Pizza Hut – Wing Street combines classic pizza with a focus on wings for a complete meal. My experience there was swift and satisfying, thanks to friendly service and a clean, inviting environment. It’s an ideal stop for a familiar, comforting pizza craving.
Their pizza selection offers consistent quality, with favorites like the Supreme or Pepperoni. Their wings are what make Wing Street stand out—crispy, flavorful, and perfectly paired with classic sauces. If you’re seeking a dependable spot to enjoy well-made pizza and wings, this location hits the mark in Hattiesburg.
6. Chuck E. Cheese
Situated at 1000 Turtlecreek Drive, Chuck E. Cheese is more than just a pizza place — it’s a family fun center. During a recent visit, I enjoyed watching kids laugh and play while parents relaxed with a slice of pizza. The lively atmosphere makes it a great spot for birthday parties and family outings.
The menu offers classic pizza that appeals to all ages, along with wings, salads, and sweet treats like cupcakes. I recommend the cheesy pepperoni pizza, which is reliably tasty and perfect for sharing. What sets Chuck E. Cheese apart is its blend of kid-friendly entertainment and hearty comfort food, making it a hit for families in Hattiesburg seeking fun and flavor.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Located at 6136 Hwy 98 W, Domino’s Pizza is a go-to spot for reliable, tasty pizza in Hattiesburg. During my order, I appreciated their quick delivery and the wide variety of options. Whether you prefer thin New York-style slices or a hearty pan pizza, Domino’s caters to every craving with consistency and care.
Their cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust is a standout, adding a flavorful twist to classic pizza. For a complete meal, their wings and pasta options provide great complements. Domino’s commitment to quality, value, and speedy service makes it a trusted choice for satisfying pizza cravings anytime in Hattiesburg.
8. Fat Boys Pizza
Located at 6168 U S Highway 49, Fat Boys Pizza offers a laid-back atmosphere with consistently delicious pies. My experience there was memorable, thanks to the friendly service and their generous toppings. The pizzas are crafted with quality ingredients, making each slice satisfying and flavorful.
Fat Boys Pizza stands out with its hearty, handcrafted crust and inventive topping combinations. I recommend trying the Meat Lover’s Special or the Veggie Deluxe for a taste of their fresh and bold flavors. Whether for lunch or dinner, this spot delivers a fulfilling pizza experience that reflects their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.
9. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza at 2902 Hardy Street delivers what it promises—reliable flavors wrapped in quality ingredients. My visit stood out for the crisp service and the fresh aroma of baking dough that greeted me at the door.
What makes Papa Johns distinctive in Hattiesburg is their commitment to simplicity done right. The sauce isn’t too sweet, the cheese has a clean pull, and the crust holds its own without being overly chewy.
If you’re dropping by, go for the Original Pepperoni or their Garden Fresh Pizza. Each reflects their “Better Ingredients” mantra and lands the right balance of comfort and flavor. It’s a spot where consistency matters and shortcuts aren’t taken.
Whether you need a quick lunch or dinner that’s reliably good, Papa Johns Pizza fits the bill without fuss.
10. Little Caesars
Little Caesars at 3602 Hardy Street is that no-nonsense pizza spot where speed doesn’t sacrifice quality. Walking in, I was greeted with that signature oven warmth and left with a box of hot, satisfying pizza in minutes.
What sets Little Caesars apart in Hattiesburg is its commitment to value without cutting corners. The crust has a gentle crunch, the sauce leans savory, and the cheese delivers a solid melt—nothing overwhelming, just clean balance.
I’d recommend the Classic Cheese or their Veggie Pizza. Both speak to their strength: bold simplicity. It’s ideal for lunch or a low-fuss dinner that doesn’t feel skimpy. Service is quick, the food is consistent, and the price feels right.
If you’re nearby and craving something dependable, Little Caesars is a solid pick every time.
More Things to Try in Hattiesburg, MS
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best pizza in Hattiesburg, MS?
If you’re after bold flavors and reliable service, check out Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar for a sit-down experience or grab a pie at Mercury Pizza Co. for something more modern. Both are local favorites with distinct styles.
Are there any halal or vegetarian-friendly pizza options?
Many places like Little Caesars, Domino’s, and Papa Johns offer vegetarian options such as classic cheese, veggie, and mushroom-based pizzas. For halal options, it’s best to inquire at the restaurant directly as sourcing may vary.
What pizza spots are good for families?
Chuck E. Cheese and Fox’s Pizza Den are popular for their family-friendly setups, casual atmosphere, and kids’ activities. They offer kid-sized portions and simple toppings that appeal to younger diners.
Which pizza place offers late-night service?
Chains like Domino’s Pizza, Papa Johns, and Little Caesars usually stay open past 10 PM. Local delivery options may also vary depending on the day and demand, so it’s worth checking hours online before placing an order.
Is there a local pizza restaurant with unique toppings?
Pyro’s Fire Fresh Pizza stands out with their build-your-own concept and creative topping choices like roasted corn, artichokes, and spicy jalapeños. It’s ideal for adventurous eaters.
Do any Hattiesburg pizza places offer gluten-free crust?
Yes, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Domino’s offer gluten-free crusts on select pizzas. Be sure to check nutritional info or ask staff for details on preparation to avoid cross-contamination.
What’s the most affordable pizza option in Hattiesburg?
Little Caesars leads the pack with their Hot-N-Ready deals, especially the Classic Cheese or Veggie Pizza—great value without sacrificing taste.
Which pizza place has the best dine-in atmosphere?
For a more refined experience, try Mario’s Italian Restaurant & Bar. It offers table service, warm lighting, and Italian-inspired decor that makes for a relaxed dinner.