Discovering a great slice of pizza can feel like an adventure, especially in a town as vibrant as Harrisonburg, VA. Over the years, I’ve sampled everything from cozy family-run spots to bustling pizzerias that seem to have a special recipe for making every bite memorable. Harrisonburg’s pizza scene isn’t just about quick bites; it’s about authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and a passion for crafting perfect pies. Whether you’re craving a thin-crust classic or a gourmet creation, this city offers options that cater to every taste bud.
There’s something uniquely satisfying about finding a place that feels like a hidden gem. My personal favorite experiences involve spots that combine quality with a touch of creativity. As you explore this list, you’ll see that Harrisonburg’s best pizza spots aren’t just about satisfying hunger—they’re about creating moments worth sharing. Stand by for a guide to the top eateries that turn pizza into an art form, promising each visit a delicious journey.
Where to find the best pizza in Harrisonburg, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Harrisonburg, VA:
- Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza
- Vito’s Italian Kitchen
- Benny Sorrentino’s Pizza
- Ruby’s Arcade
- Vinny’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria
- Brothers Italian
- Little Italy Pizza
- Ciro’s Lasagna House
- Vocelli Pizza Harrisonburg
- Pizza Hut
1. Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza
Nestled in the historic Livery Building, Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with a focus on authentic, handcrafted cuisine. Watching chefs craft pizzas in their massive, 900-degree wood-fired oven feels like witnessing a culinary dance rooted in tradition. Every bite captures the essence of Naples, thanks to high heat and live flames that develop unique textures and flavors.
What truly sets Bella Luna apart is their commitment to quality. From fresh seasonal salads to made-from-scratch pastas, each dish reflects attention to detail and the use of local, sustainable ingredients. For pizza lovers, opting for their signature Neapolitan-style pies — especially the Margherita or a seasonal specialty — promises an unforgettable experience that perfectly embodies Harrisonburg’s best pizza scene.
2. Vito’s Italian Kitchen
Vito’s Italian Kitchen blends old-world charm with casual comfort. From the moment I first stepped onto their outdoor patio, the warm ambiance and aroma of oven-baked dough made it feel like a place worth lingering. It’s clearly a spot designed for gatherings, with a spacious dining area and menu that’s generous in every sense.
What elevates Vito’s beyond typical pizza places is their attention to balance — generous portions without sacrificing freshness. Their pizzas lean classic but refined, with well-seasoned sauces and thoughtfully selected toppings. I recommend starting with their White Pizza or Veggie Pizza, both rich in flavor yet simple enough to showcase the quality of the crust and cheese. That’s the kind of detail that makes Vito’s a standout in Harrisonburg’s pizza lineup.
3. Benny Sorrentino’s Pizza
Benny Sorrentino’s Pizza is where size meets simplicity in the best possible way. Tucked just off South Mason Street, this spot is known for its massive, foldable slices that practically demand two hands. The first time I walked in, I was struck by the no-frills vibe — just good pizza, served fast, with zero pretense.
What makes Benny’s stand out is its unapologetic focus on the basics: a crisp-yet-chewy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and cheese that stretches just right. It’s the kind of place you go when you want a slice that satisfies without overcomplicating things. The classic Cheese or Pepperoni slice is the move here — bold, balanced, and big enough to be a meal on its own.
4. Ruby’s Arcade
Ruby’s Arcade in Harrisonburg, VA, is more than just a place to eat—it’s a full-on experience. Tucked along South Main Street, this local gem blends family-friendly fun with a lively, laid-back vibe. Whether you’re into duckpin bowling, foosball, or simply relaxing with friends, Ruby’s offers something for everyone.
What really sets Ruby’s apart is its woodfired pizza oven and meat smoker, delivering bold, smoky flavors you won’t forget. I once spent a rainy afternoon there—bowling with friends while savoring a hot, crispy pizza fresh from the oven. The atmosphere was relaxed, the service warm, and the food unforgettable.
Be sure to try the Margherita Pizza or the Veggie Supreme—both are vegetarian-friendly and showcase Ruby’s commitment to quality and freshness.
5. Vinny’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria
+1 540-564-0105
See Menu
Vinny’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria, tucked beside Qdoba in the Walmart shopping center, is a cozy spot where classic Italian comfort meets small-town charm. Since 1998, it’s been a go-to for locals craving hearty, homestyle meals in a relaxed setting.
What makes Vinny’s stand out is its commitment to tradition. The dough is hand-tossed, the sauce is rich and balanced, and the cheese melts just right. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your name—and your favorite slice.
If you’re unsure what to order, start with the Vinny’s Special Pizza. It’s loaded with fresh veggies and savory toppings, all on a crisp, golden crust. The White Pizza is another standout—simple, garlicky, and deeply satisfying.
Vinny’s doesn’t try to be trendy. It just does pizza right—authentic, flavorful, and made with care.
6. Brothers Italian
Brothers Italian is a family-oriented restaurant located on South High Street, known for its warm atmosphere and classic Italian dishes. I once enjoyed a lively dinner here, surrounded by friendly staff and fellow diners, which made the experience feel authentic and inviting.
What makes Brothers Italian stand out is its commitment to quality and variety. From hearty pasta to flavorful salads, every dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and care. Their pizza features a crispy crust topped with rich sauces and generous toppings, capturing the essence of traditional Italian style.
If you’re visiting, try the Margherita Pizza or the Veggie Lovers’ Pie. Both reflect the restaurant’s dedication to simple, honest flavors that truly satisfy every pizza craving in Harrisonburg.
7. Little Italy Pizza
Located at 1469 S Main St, Harrisonburg, VA, Little Italy Pizza is a local gem offering a delightful selection of pizza, pasta, salads, and wings. Known for its friendly service and warm atmosphere, it’s a perfect spot for both lunch and dinner, whether dining in or taking out.
What sets Little Italy Pizza apart is its commitment to quality and flavor. The menu is vegetarian-friendly, ensuring that everyone can find something they love. Their online ordering system makes it easy to enjoy a meal at home with convenient delivery or takeout options.
If you’re looking for recommendations, try their Margherita Pizza. The perfect blend of fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce truly showcases the authentic Italian essence that Little Italy Pizza is known for.
8. Ciro’s Lasagna House
Located at 778 E Market St, Harrisonburg, Ciro’s Lasagna House is renowned for its hearty Italian classics served in a cozy, inviting setting. I remember visiting during a family dinner; the fragrant aroma of freshly baked lasagna filled the air and created a welcoming atmosphere.
What makes Ciro’s stand out is their focus on authentic, made-from-scratch dishes. While their specialty is lasagna, their pizza offerings also reflect a dedication to quality—crispy crusts topped with flavorful ingredients that resonate with true Italian craftsmanship.
If you’re ordering, try the supreme pizza, which pairs beautifully with their rich, savory sauces. It’s a perfect example of how Ciro’s combines tradition and taste to deliver memorable meals in Harrisonburg.
9. Vocelli Pizza Harrisonburg
Vocelli Pizza Harrisonburg at 1326 Hillside Ave offers an inviting dining experience with options to dine-in, take-out, or have your favorite pizza delivered. With a convenient location and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s a go-to spot for lunch, dinner, or brunch.
I recently visited and was impressed by the friendly service and delicious food. The Garlic Spinaci Pizza stood out with its perfect blend of spinach, garlic, and cheese, encapsulating the essence of Vocelli’s quality and flavor.
Vocelli Pizza Harrisonburg is known for its diverse menu, including pizza, subs, and wings. For a true taste of Harrisonburg, try the Chicken Pesto Pizza—it’s a delightful combination of tender chicken, pesto sauce, and fresh ingredients that highlight their commitment to quality.
Visit their website at harrisonburgpizza.com or call +1 540-217-0031 to place your order today!
10. Pizza Hut
Located at 2485 S Main St, Harrisonburg, Pizza Hut is a household name known for delivering comfort with its iconic pizzas. I’ve ordered from here during busy nights, always appreciating the consistency and flavor of their classic offerings.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is its Original Stuffed Crust® pizza, a true game-changer for cheese lovers. Their Meat Lovers® pizza is hearty and satisfying, perfect for sharing or a solo indulgence.
With options for delivery, curbside, or takeout, it’s easy to enjoy their signature dishes anytime. For a taste of familiar, go for their personal pan pizzas or the Buffalo Wings to complement your meal.
More Things to Try in Harrisonburg, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Harrisonburg, VA?
A: The best pizza spot depends on your taste, but options like Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza and Benny Sorrentino’s Pizza are highly recommended for their quality and authentic flavors.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Harrisonburg?
A: Yes, many pizza places such as Vito’s Italian Kitchen and Little Italy Pizza offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly pizzas made with fresh, local ingredients.
Q: Do restaurants in Harrisonburg offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most places, including Pizza Hut, Vocelli Pizza, and Ciro’s Lasagna House, offer both delivery and takeout services for convenience.
Q: What are some unique pizza styles available in Harrisonburg?
A: You can find wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas at Bella Luna and classic New York-style slices at Benny Sorrentino’s.
Q: Are there gluten-free pizza options in Harrisonburg?
A: Yes, several restaurants, such as Vito’s Italian Kitchen and Brothers Italian, provide gluten-free crusts for those with dietary restrictions.