When you think of Harford County, a few things probably come to mind: rolling farmland, Main Street charm, and that unmistakable aroma drifting from a pizza oven somewhere nearby. I still remember my first slice here—a thin, crisp crust eaten leaning over a picnic table, tomato sauce tangy and cheese still bubbling hot. That bite convinced me that pizza in Harford County isn’t just food. It’s local culture served by the slice.
Choosing the best pizza spot can feel like picking a favorite song—personal, sometimes surprising, and always a debate starter. Some places cling proudly to old-school family recipes, while others dare to reinvent the wheel, one creative topping at a time. If you’re searching for the standout pizzerias in Harford County, MD, you’re in the right place. I’ve uncovered the places that locals crave and visitors rave about, keeping everything straightforward and trustworthy. Hungry yet? Let’s dig in.
1. Tutto Fresco
Tucked just off Bynum Road, Tutto Fresco brings together the classic warmth of an Italian eatery with the comfort of a small-town gem. The scent hits you before you open the door—a promise of real-deal pizza done right. My own go-to here is the Margherita, a balance of thin, chewy crust and bright tomato sauce. It’s proof that basics, when perfected, never get old.
What sets Tutto Fresco apart is their devotion to fresh ingredients and family recipes. You’ll notice the care in every bite—crust with just enough crunch, cheese that stretches, and toppings that taste garden-fresh. If you’re looking for something distinctive, their Veggie Pizza is a colorful hit and absolutely satisfying.
Tutto Fresco isn’t about fuss or flash—it’s about flavor, hospitality, and quality you can always count on. Find them at 5 Bynum Rd, Forest Hill, MD, or learn more on their website.
2. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Newport Drive might be a chain, but it’s the sort of place where a Friday night pizza feels like a neighborhood tradition. There’s a comfort in the familiar smell of their signature crust wafting through the air when you pick up your box. For me, there’s nothing quite like biting into a classic Pan Pizza—thick, golden crust and plenty of gooey cheese.
This spot stands out for its consistency. The Original Stuffed Crust delivers on that warm, cheesy satisfaction every single time. The Meat Lovers® pizza is hearty, while the Veggie pizza is fresh and perfectly balanced, making it friendly to every palate.
Pizza Hut knows how to deliver classic flavors, reliable service, and enough choices to please any group. Try their Pan Pizza if you’re after a local staple for any casual gathering.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
When I think of Papa Johns Pizza in Forest Hill, I think of game nights at home, laughter, and their unmistakable garlic sauce. The dough here is always fresh, and you can honestly taste the difference in the crust—it’s got just the right mix of chew and crispness.
What sets this Papa Johns apart is its commitment to consistency and fresh ingredients. The tomato sauce bursts with a sweet, tangy flavor, while the cheese keeps everything classic and comforting. Their The Works pizza is my pick. Loaded with veggies and beef, it showcases Papa Johns’ style of pizzeria generosity and big flavor.
Papa Johns is reliably delicious and perfect for both solo cravings and family meals. Their approach is straightforward: good ingredients make good pizza. Try The Works or a simple cheese, and you’ll see why locals return.
4. Enotria Restaurant & Grill
Enotria Restaurant & Grill feels like a slice of Italy settled right in Forest Hill. The aroma of their brick oven pizza immediately pulls you in. I love visiting for family dinners—the warm, golden light and bustling dining room set the perfect mood for comfort food. Each pizza is shaped by hand, and you can tell the dough rests just long enough for true flavor.
What makes Enotria stand out is their attention to tradition. Their Margherita Pizza balances silky mozzarella with fresh basil, creating flavors that transport you straight to Naples. The Veggie Pizza here pops with color and tastes garden-fresh.
Enotria is the place to relax and enjoy an authentic meal made with care. If you want a true taste of Italy in Harford County, this is a must-visit spot.
5. Bella Pizza
(410) 836-8100Call
Bella Pizza on Conowingo Road is a local favorite—and for good reason. This family-owned spot has been serving Bel Air for two decades, and you can feel that legacy the moment you step in. My own memories involve friends, laughter, and slices that never disappoint.
What sets Bella apart is their reliable thin-crust pizza, baked to just the right crispness with a flavorful sauce you’ll crave again and again. They keep it simple, generous with cheese and toppings, and always serve it up hot and fresh.
Order the thin-crust cheese or veggie pizza—both showcase Bella’s commitment to quality and tradition. It’s the place you visit for real, comforting pizza that never tries too hard to impress. It just does.
6. Tamberino’s Pizza & Subs
Tamberino’s Pizza & Subs has the kind of cozy, no-nonsense vibe that always draws a loyal crowd. The aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese takes me right back to weekend afternoons, sharing a pie after a local ball game. Their pizzas are hearty, never skimpy with toppings, and always served piping hot.
What really makes Tamberino’s shine is their commitment to the classics. Every pie arrives with a crisp edge and a soft, flavorful center—perfect for anyone who loves traditional pizza done right. Their sauce is tangy, their cheese is generous, and the crust holds up until the last bite.
Try their cheese or vegetable pizza for the purest expression of Tamberino’s cooking. It’s local, comforting, and exactly what a solid neighborhood pizza joint should be.
7. Lami’s Pizza & Subs
Lami’s Pizza & Subs on South Tollgate Road is a local favorite, and a place I found almost by accident one rainy afternoon. I went in for a slice and left convinced I’d found one of Bel Air’s best-kept secrets. The friendly staff and warm, golden pizza counter set the stage for a meal that’s both relaxed and memorable.
Lami’s stands out for its fresh dough, hand-tossed daily, and creative approach to traditional pies. The Mediterranean menu influences add something special if you want more than the usual. Their Vegetarian Pizza is a crisp, hearty winner—generous toppings, tangy sauce, and just the right amount of cheese, all on a chewy crust that holds up all the way through.
Lami’s delivers on freshness, flavor, and friendly service, making it a must-try for anyone looking to shake up their pizza routine in Harford County.
8. Pizza Boli’s
Pizza Boli’s in Bel Air feels like it’s always buzzing, no matter what time you stop by. I first tried their pizza during a late-night study session; the hot, cheesy slices gave me just the boost I needed. There’s a friendly pace to this place, with staff quick to remember returning customers.
What makes Pizza Boli’s stand out is the wide range of fresh toppings and halal options. Their crust is slightly thicker and airy, with a satisfying crunch that holds up well under layers of cheese and vegetables. My personal favorite is the Veggie Lover’s Pizza, which packs in roasted peppers, mushrooms, and olives for a punch of flavor and color.
Pizza Boli’s is perfect for group orders and anyone in Harford County seeking bold, satisfying pizza made with care.
9. Buontempo Brothers Restaurant
Buontempo Brothers Restaurant gives Main Street real character. The old-school family vibe makes every meal feel like a celebration, whether you’re out with friends or rounding up a team after the big game. My own visits are filled with laughter, shared slices, and pizzas that never stay untouched for long.
This spot stands apart for its classic, New York-inspired pizzas. The pies are large, the crust foldable and chewy, and the toppings always fresh. Order the Cheese Pizza to appreciate the balance between silky mozzarella and their signature sauce, or go for their simple Veggie Pizza, which really lets the garden-fresh produce shine.
Buontempo Brothers is where you go for that nostalgic, family-style pizza night that always leaves you satisfied. It’s casual, consistent, and beloved in Bel Air for good reason.
10. Ledo Pizza
Ledo Pizza in Bel Air is that kind of place where the pizza shape itself becomes part of the experience. Square slices, crisp edges, and a surprisingly buttery crust make every order a little different from the others in town. I was charmed the first time I tried their pizza during a lunch break—one slice quickly became three.
What sets Ledo apart is their commitment to that signature crust and bold, zesty sauce. Each square is generously topped, and the cheese stretches with every pull. Their Veggie Pizza stands out for its bright flavors and perfect ratio of fresh toppings to crust. For a classic treat, the Cheese Pizza never fails.
Ledo Pizza captures comfort and creativity all at once. It’s the go-to when you want something both familiar and a little unexpected in Harford County.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best local pizza spots in Harford County?
You’ll find a mix of family-run gems and big names here. Tutto Fresco, Buontempo Brothers, and Ledo Pizza are highly recommended for their fresh takes, classic style, and unique flavors. Each spot has devoted fans for a reason.
Are there any pizza places with vegetarian options?
Absolutely. Most local pizzerias, including Pizza Boli’s, Lami’s Pizza & Subs, and Ledo Pizza, offer delicious vegetarian pies loaded with fresh toppings.
Do Harford County pizza places offer delivery and takeout?
Yes, almost every spot from Papa Johns to Tamberino’s and independent places like Bella Pizza offer both delivery and takeout. It’s easy to order online or by phone.
Can I find halal pizza in Harford County?
Yes, Pizza Boli’s and Lami’s Pizza & Subs both offer halal pizza options. Just ask when you order to make sure your preferences are met.
What is a must-try local specialty pizza?
Try Tutto Fresco’s Margherita or the Veggie Pizza at Ledo for a real taste of what makes Harford County pizza stand out. Square crust at Ledo is a local favorite too.
Are there spots good for large groups or parties?
Buontempo Brothers and Pizza Hut are great for groups. Many places offer party trays and can handle larger orders if you call ahead.