If you’ve ever found yourself in Gulf Shores with a slice-shaped longing, you’re not alone. I remember my first trip there. Sunburned and a little sandy, I wandered from the beach in search of something to satisfy my craving. I stumbled onto a local pizza joint, and let’s just say, what started as lunch soon became a ritual every time I came back to the coast. Gulf Shores has a knack for transforming even your plainest pepperoni into a beachside highlight.
Searching for the best pizza in Gulf Shores can be both a joy and a challenge. There are old favorites, hidden gems, and spots so popular you’ll wonder if they’ve been keeping a secret sauce from the rest of the world. Whether you want a classic New York-style slice, a gooey deep-dish, or a specialty creation with a Gulf twist, this guide steers you to the pizza places worth skipping dessert for. Hungry yet? Let’s dive into the very best pies the Alabama coast has to offer.
Where to find the best pizza in Gulf Shores, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Gulf Shores, AL:
- Papa Rocco’s
- Crico’s Pizza & Subs
- Papa’s Pizza Gulf Shores
- Papa John’s Pizza
- Pines Pizzeria
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Janino’s Pizza Gulf Shores
- Marco’s Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
1. Papa Rocco’s
Step inside Papa Rocco’s and you’ll know you’ve landed at a local legend. The neon sign and fun atmosphere set the tone, and the friendly staff will make you feel right at home. On my first visit, the buzz of laughter mixed with the aroma from the ovens had me hooked before I even saw the menu.
What sets Papa Rocco’s apart is their dough—crisp edges, soft in the center, and reliable every time. The classic cheese and veggie-loaded specialties always deliver, but try the Supreme if you’re after toppings piled sky high.
This spot isn’t just about pizza; it’s a true Gulf Shores gathering place where your next slice comes with a sense of tradition.
2. Crico’s Pizza & Subs
Crico’s Pizza & Subs is the kind of spot where locals mingle with sunburned visitors, each with a plate piled high. The casual, no-frills interior makes it easy to focus on what matters: the food. My first bite into their signature pie was all gooey cheese, crisp crust, and a hint of oregano. Instantly, I knew why Crico’s draws a steady crowd.
Crico’s stands out for pizza that’s always hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings. For the full experience, order a classic veggie or one of their specialty pizzas. Their cheese bread “Stix” are unforgettable—soft, cheesy, and perfect for sharing.
If you’re after a Gulf Shores staple with quick service and family-friendly vibes, Crico’s fits the bill. The taste keeps you coming back.
3. Papa’s Pizza Gulf Shores
(251) 967-4992Call
Papa’s Pizza Gulf Shores feels like a place where old traditions meet beach-town comfort. From my very first visit, the aroma of fresh-baked dough and simmering tomato sauce set the mood. There’s a sense here that every pie is made with a kind of quiet pride you can taste.
What sets Papa’s apart is its dedication to real, honest ingredients. The dough and sauce are made from scratch each day, and the cheese melts with a creaminess you won’t find just anywhere. Their history goes back decades, and each slice feels like a nod to classic pizza-making.
The Sicilian pizza, thick and hearty, is a must-try. If you like a thin, classic crust, order the New York-style. Both prove that at Papa’s, pizza is more than just a meal—it’s a tradition.
4. Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s Pizza in Gulf Shores is where reliability meets convenience. After a long day out in the Alabama sun, I once ducked in for a quick carryout and was greeted by the familiar aroma of garlic and fresh dough. The staff work quickly, and the pizzas come out piping hot every time.
Papa John’s stands out for its consistent quality and fresh ingredients. Whether you’re after the classic cheese or want something zesty like their Mediterranean Veggie, the crust always delivers a satisfying chew and a light crisp.
Order the Garden Fresh if you’re after a pie with bold, bright flavors. Their breadsticks are top-notch, perfect for dipping in that signature garlic sauce. It’s dependable pizza for any occasion, right in the heart of Gulf Shores.
5. Pines Pizzeria
Pines Pizzeria brings a cozy, casual vibe to Gulf Shores pizza cravings. The first time I stopped in, the smell of baking dough hit me before the door even fully opened. The staff are down to earth, ready to help you build your perfect pie or point you toward a local favorite.
Flexibility is the key at Pines. If you want to mix and match toppings or just grab a quick slice, they’re happy to oblige. The crust walks a great line—golden, chewy, never greasy. Try the “Garden Supreme” for a medley of fresh veggies that taste as though they were picked that morning.
With carry-out, delivery, and a few cozy tables, Pines Pizzeria is a go-to for anyone craving comfort and customization. The pizza does the talking here, and it always says “fresh.”
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Gulf Shores is where speed meets satisfaction. One evening after a late beach walk, I ordered a pan pizza for pickup. Not only was it ready in minutes, but each slice came loaded with bubbling cheese and a crust that had just the right amount of crunch.
Domino’s stands out for its consistency, creative options, and great value. The menu stretches from thin-crust New York style to the fluffy Handmade Pan, so you can always find a favorite. Their robust tracking app even takes the guesswork out of timing.
Try the thin-crust veggie pizza if you like plenty of flavor without feeling weighed down. Ultimate customization and reliable quality keep Domino’s on the favorites list for both locals and visitors.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Gulf Shores brings a sense of nostalgia for anyone who grew up with red-roof memories. I’ve ducked in with friends after a day at the pier, and there’s always a warm booth and that unmistakable aroma of fresh dough and herbs.
Pizza Hut stands out for its classic flavors and family-friendly atmosphere. The crust, whether pan or thin, always delivers on texture, and the cheese is generous and melty, just like you remember.
The Veggie Lover’s pizza is a top pick, loaded with crisp, fresh toppings. For something extra comforting, add a side of breadsticks. Here, the familiar taste and cozy vibe make for an easy, satisfying meal right in the heart of Gulf Shores.
8. Janino’s Pizza Gulf Shores
Janino’s Pizza Gulf Shores is where the big slices and beachside views make for an unbeatable combo. My first time there, I noticed right away the dough was something special—airy but sturdy enough to support a generous heap of toppings.
Janino’s thrives on authenticity, sticking to a family recipe that keeps locals coming back. The sauce brings a subtle sweetness, and every cheese pull reminds you just how fresh the ingredients are.
Opt for the New York Style by the slice if you’re feeling classic, or try a signature specialty pie for something bolder. Each pizza has the unmistakable snap of a true New York crust, setting Janino’s apart in Gulf Shores.
9. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza in Gulf Shores knows how to do Italian-style pizza right. My first Marco’s pie was a revelation—the crust was pillowy with a slight crunch, and the aroma of their signature sauce was hard to resist. You could taste the freshness in every bite.
Marco’s stands out with its daily house-made dough and unique three-cheese blend. That cheese and their time-tested sauce recipe give each pizza unmistakable flavor and a gooey, golden finish.
The Deluxe pizza, loaded with veggies and that signature cheese blend, is an easy favorite. If you’re looking for classic Italian style with a Gulf Shores twist, this is your spot for reliable comfort and plenty of choices.
10. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza is known for making pizza an easy, grab-and-go option in Gulf Shores. The first time I grabbed a pie from here, it was after a long day at the beach. Quick, hot, and satisfying, it was proof that good pizza doesn’t need to be complicated.
What sets Hunt Brothers apart is their made-to-order pizzas and the ability to customize every pie without extra fuss. You can pile on as many toppings as you like for one simple price, which is perfect for families or groups who each want something different.
Their classic crust pairs well with a variety of veggie toppings. If you’re looking for speedy service and the promise of a fresh, personalized pizza, Hunt Brothers Pizza makes it easy to satisfy any craving.
More Things to Try in Gulf Shores, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Gulf Shores for families?
Many pizza spots in Gulf Shores are family-friendly, but Papa Rocco’s, Crico’s Pizza & Subs, and Pizza Hut tend to be top choices for a casual atmosphere and menu variety.
Are there any pizza places in Gulf Shores offering gluten-free options?
Several chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut offer gluten-free crusts. It’s always best to call ahead and check with local spots regarding cross-contamination policies.
Can I find pizza delivery services in Gulf Shores?
Absolutely. Domino’s, Marco’s, Papa John’s, Crico’s, and several others provide delivery. Most local places also offer online ordering for added convenience.
Which pizza places in Gulf Shores have the best vegetarian options?
Try Janino’s Pizza for veggie-loaded New York-style slices, or Marco’s Pizza for specialty options like their Garden pizza. Most spots will let you customize with a range of fresh toppings.
Is there a spot for pizza-by-the-slice in Gulf Shores?
Yes, Janino’s Pizza and Pines Pizzeria both serve pizza by the slice, so you can sample a few different styles or grab a quick bite on the go.