Pizza in Greenville, NC, isn’t just about crust and cheese—it’s a local ritual, stitched into Friday nights, campus traditions, and community cravings. Whether you’re a long-time resident or just passing through, finding the best slice here means navigating a mix of old-school joints and innovative newcomers. What makes the search exciting is the diversity—from thin crusts with charred bubbles to deep-dish pies that don’t skimp on sauce. I once ducked into a modest-looking corner shop on a rainy afternoon and left with the best tomato-basil slice I’ve had in years. No fuss. Just flavor.
This guide breaks down Greenville’s top pizza spots—not based on buzz, but actual experience, local reputation, and consistency. No filler, no false hype. Just a clear look at the places that do it right. Whether you’re after that perfectly melted mozzarella stretch or something bold with unexpected toppings, you’re in the right place. Let’s dig into the spots that truly define pizza in Greenville, one slice at a time.
Where to find the best pizza in Greenville, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Greenville, NC:
- Michaelangelo’s of Greenville
- Mellow Mushroom Greenville
- Pizza Hut
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Inn
- Michaelangelos Pizza
- Manhattan Pizzeria
- Luna Pizza Cafe
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
1. Michaelangelo’s of Greenville
Michaelangelo’s of Greenville is more than a pizza spot—it’s a neighborhood staple. Located in University Commons, it blends authentic Italian flavor with the charm of a local joint. The décor is understated, but the focus is all on the food. I stopped in after a long day and found the quiet ambiance perfect for a solo slice-and-think session.
Their hand-tossed pizzas are consistently fresh, flavorful, and balanced. The crust has that golden crisp edge, while the sauce tastes slow-simmered, never rushed. Their “Deluxe Pizza” is loaded without being overwhelming—an ideal choice for variety seekers. Vegetarian options are well-prepared and rich in flavor.
Service is friendly and fast, and prices sit in the comfortable mid-range bracket. If you’re near campus or craving that classic feel with dependable quality, Michaelangelo’s won’t disappoint. It’s the kind of place that doesn’t need flash to stay relevant.
2. Mellow Mushroom Greenville
Mellow Mushroom Greenville isn’t your average pizza chain. With psychedelic art on the walls and a laid-back, creative vibe, it turns every meal into a memorable experience. I stopped in with a few friends after a game, and the energy in the space matched our post-win mood perfectly—casual, colorful, and just weird enough to be cool.
Their signature spring water crust gives every pie a chewy, flavorful bite. I recommend the “Kosmic Karma” or the “Veg Out” for standout flavor combinations that are both inventive and satisfying. Both options showcase how Mellow balances freshness with flair.
Vegetarian-friendly, locally owned, and packed with personality, this spot nails the intersection of comfort food and culinary character. It’s a place that sticks with you—not because it tries too hard, but because it doesn’t have to.
3. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Greenville Blvd SE is a familiar name, but this location delivers more than just brand recognition. It’s a go-to for dependable, quick service and consistent flavor. I’ve grabbed carryout here more times than I can count—especially when the craving hits late and options are slim.
The Original Stuffed Crust® remains a standout, offering that satisfying cheese pull with every bite. If you’re ordering for a group, the “Supreme” or “Veggie Lover’s” pizzas strike a good balance of flavor and crowd-pleasing appeal. The crust is always crisped just right, and the sauce leans sweet without overpowering.
Located near Greenville Mall, it’s convenient for a quick bite or a casual dinner. While it may not be artisanal, it’s reliable—and sometimes, that’s exactly what you need.
4. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Dickinson Ave is a reliable choice when craving quick, satisfying pizza. Their diverse menu caters to all tastes—from thin, foldable New York Style slices to hearty Handmade Pan pies. I once ordered during a busy weekend; the delivery was prompt, and the hot, cheesy pizza made the wait worthwhile.
For a classic, I recommend the “Deluxe Pepperoni” or the “Veggie Pizza.” Both showcase Domino’s commitment to flavor, with fresh ingredients and a crispy crust. The Parmesan Stuffed Crust offers an extra indulgence for cheese lovers, adding a signature touch that reflects their focus on quality.
With unbeatable deals and a variety of side options like wings and pasta, Domino’s near you offers great value. It’s perfect for those nights when a good slice needs to be quickly within reach.
5. Pizza Inn
Pizza Inn on S Memorial Dr offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a focus on classic American-style pizza. Known for their generous buffets and fresh ingredients, it’s a great spot for both quick bites and sit-down meals. I once stopped by with a group of friends, and the variety kept everyone happy—from veggie lovers to meat enthusiasts.
Their signature Buffet features a rotating selection of pizzas, salads, and desserts, making it perfect for those who want to sample multiple flavors. For a personalized touch, their “Build Your Own Pizza” lets you craft exactly what you crave, reflecting their versatile, family-oriented approach.
Conveniently located and known for good service, Pizza Inn delivers reliable quality that keeps customers coming back. It’s a comfortable choice when craving hearty, satisfying pizza in Greenville.
6. Michaelangelos Pizza
Tucked into the heart of downtown, Michaelangelos Pizza on E 5th St is a local favorite for good reason. It’s the kind of place where the crust is always crisp, the sauce has just the right tang, and the cheese stretch is photo-worthy.
What sets Michaelangelos apart is its no-frills, flavor-first approach. The vibe is casual, the service is quick, and the pizza? Consistently solid. I once dropped in after a long day, and their classic cheese slice hit the spot—simple, hot, and satisfying.
If you’re unsure what to order, go for the Veggie Deluxe or the Michaelangelo’s Special. Both are loaded without being overwhelming, and they showcase the kitchen’s knack for balance and freshness.
Affordable, reliable, and rooted in local charm, Michaelangelos Pizza is a Greenville staple worth knowing.
7. Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria on Evans St offers a cozy spot for classic New York-style pizza with a local twist. Fresh ingredients and traditional techniques make each pie satisfying and dependable. I visited on a busy Saturday night, and despite the crowd, the staff kept the service prompt and friendly.
Their thin-crust pizza is a highlight, delivering that perfect crunch with a slightly chewy interior. I recommend the “Manhattan Special” or “The Big Apple,” both packed with flavorful toppings that reflect their commitment to authentic style.
Affordable and consistently good, Manhattan Pizzeria is a go-to for a reliable pizza experience that tastes like a slice of New York right in Greenville.
8. Luna Pizza Cafe
Tucked away on S Pitt Street, Luna Pizza Cafe brings authentic Neapolitan flavor to Greenville with hand-stretched dough and an 800-degree brick oven that delivers serious character. The space balances warmth and simplicity, perfect for a casual dinner or quick lunchtime escape.
During my last visit, I tried the Margherita pizza. The crust was beautifully blistered, soft in the center, and crisp at the edges—proof of their brick oven technique. Their “Luna Original” is also a standout, with balanced flavors and just the right amount of char.
What sets Luna apart is its consistency and attention to detail, especially in how each pizza is made to order. If you’re after something thoughtful and unpretentious, Luna Pizza Cafe delivers.
9. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on E 10th Street delivers exactly what its reputation promises—no-frills, fast, and consistently satisfying. For those who value speed and simplicity, it’s hard to beat the convenience of their Pizza Portal® pickup or no-contact delivery.
I dropped in on a weekday evening and picked up their signature Hot-N-Ready Classic Pepperoni. The crust had that slightly chewy bite, and the pepperoni was surprisingly flavorful with a crisp edge. It’s not gourmet, but it hits the mark when you’re craving something honest and warm.
What sets Little Caesars apart in Greenville is their commitment to value. Dough is made fresh daily, and the blend of 100% mozzarella and muenster gives the cheese a mellow richness.
Try the Thin Crust Pizza if you want something crisp and light. It’s a welcome twist and offers a nice contrast to the typical deep-dish fare around town.
10. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza at Belvoir Corner Stop offers a straightforward, flavorful option for pizza enthusiasts in Greenville. Made with fresh ingredients and customizable toppings at no extra charge, it’s a reliable choice for quick, satisfying meals.
During a recent visit, I ordered their classic cheese pizza, which was simple but well-executed—golden crust, gooey cheese, and a balanced sauce. For those seeking variety, creating a personalized loaded pizza with all your favorite toppings is easy and budget-friendly.
What makes Hunt Brothers stand out is its commitment to flexible, no-hidden-charge toppings. It’s perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner when you want a pie that’s both fresh and satisfying without fuss.
If you want a versatile, customizable slice, their thin crust or original crust options deliver great value and flavor in Greenville.
More Things to Try in Greenville, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Greenville, NC?
A: The best pizza spot depends on your taste, but popular options include Michaelangelo’s for classic flavors, Luna Pizza Cafe for authentic Neapolitan, and Mellow Mushroom for an eclectic vibe.
Q: Are there vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Greenville?
A: Yes, many places like Luna Pizza Cafe and Mellow Mushroom offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly pizzas loaded with fresh vegetables and dairy-free cheese options on request.
Q: Does Greenville have pizza delivery?
A: Absolutely. Chain restaurants like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars provide quick delivery or pickup services, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Q: Are gluten-free pizzas available in Greenville?
A: Some pizzerias, including Luna Pizza Cafe and Mellow Mushroom, offer gluten-free crusts for those seeking gluten-free options.
Q: What are the average prices for pizza in Greenville?
A: Prices typically range from $8 to $20, depending on the size, toppings, and restaurant. Chain options tend to be more budget-friendly, while specialty and artisanal pizzerias may cost a bit more.