Pizza is more than a meal in Goshen, NY; it’s practically an art form. On my own dough-fueled quest through Goshen, I’ve sampled my way from classic corner shops to brick oven bistros, searching for the perfect slice. The range is surprising: some spots lean old-school with chewy crusts and molten cheese, while others toss in inventive toppings or secret sauces their Italian grandmothers would approve of. Along the way, I’ve discovered that the right pizza can shift the whole mood of your day.
If you’ve been circling the same few takeout menus and wondering if you’re missing out, you’re in the right place. This honest guide gathers everything you need: my top picks for the best pizza in Goshen, plus what sets each one apart. Whether you crave a foldable slice or a full sit-down feast, you’ll find options for every taste—no unnecessary drama, just seriously good pizza. Let your cravings lead the way.
Where to find the best pizza in Goshen, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Goshen, NY:
- Village Pizzeria
- Amore’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
- Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie
- Carlos Cucina Restaurant & Bar
- Olympic Pizza
- Redendo’s Pizza Restaurant
- Pizza Hut
- Goshen Place
- Sorrentos Pizzeria
- Brother Brunos
1. Village Pizzeria
Village Pizzeria on Greenwich Ave is a classic neighborhood favorite, where the sound of the oven door and the scent of bubbling cheese stretch right to the sidewalk. The first time I walked in, a friendly greeting and that telltale aroma told me I was in for a treat.
This spot stands out for its commitment to fresh ingredients and well-balanced flavors. The crust is perfectly golden and has just the right bite, setting the stage for every slice. You can always expect fast, friendly service and the kind of atmosphere that makes you want to linger.
Order the Margherita if you want to experience Village Pizzeria’s true style—their tomato sauce is zesty and fresh, and the mozzarella is rich without overwhelming the palate. Their veggie pizza also shines, piled high with crisp, colorful toppings. For a dependable pizza night in Goshen, Village Pizzeria never disappoints.
2. Amore’s Pizzeria and Restaurant
Amore’s Pizzeria and Restaurant on West Main Street pulls off that rare combination of cozy, casual dining and standout pizza. The first time I stopped by, the buzzing lunch crowd and friendly counter staff made a simple slice feel like a special occasion.
What sets Amore’s apart is their dough—pillowy in the center, crisp at the edges, with a homemade flavor that shows real attention to detail. Add in a robust sauce and generous, quality toppings, and every bite delivers comfort with a flourish.
If you’re unsure what to order, their White Pizza is a classic: creamy ricotta, just the right amount of garlic, and a delicate blend of cheeses. For something a little heartier, try their veggie-loaded pizza, which stays crisp even under all that color and heft.
3. Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie
Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie delivers a simple, no-nonsense slice that gets right to the heart of what makes pizza great. On my first visit, I noticed the steady stream of regulars—a quiet endorsement that spoke louder than any review.
The charm here is in the details. Their tomato pie boasts a sweet, bright sauce layered thick over a chewy, golden crust, topped modestly so each flavor stands out. It’s the kind of pizza that tastes like it’s been perfected over generations.
Order a classic Tomato Pie if you want the purest taste of the house specialty: tangy tomatoes, a light touch of cheese, and that unforgettable crust. For anyone hungry for nostalgia and comfort in every bite, this is the local staple you can count on.
4. Carlos Cucina Restaurant & Bar
Carlos Cucina Restaurant & Bar brings a stylish touch to Goshen’s pizza scene, blending classic Italian comfort with a modern, welcoming atmosphere. From my first meal here, I noticed how the kitchen’s attention to presentation and flavor made every plate memorable, even before the first bite.
There’s a warmth to the place, and it’s not just from the oven. Service is attentive without being overbearing, making it easy to settle in and savor each course. The pizza emerges crisp, generously topped, and bubbling at the table—impossible to ignore.
Go for the Margherita or Primavera pizzas. These pies have a stellar showing of fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil or vibrant array of grilled vegetables. Each slice reflects Carlos Cucina’s balance of bold flavor and fresh, quality ingredients—classic Italian, with a distinct Goshen flair.
5. Olympic Pizza
Olympic Pizza is the kind of local spot where every regular has a favorite table and nobody ever seems in a hurry to leave. My earliest stop here was on a gray afternoon, when the aroma of fresh-baked dough out on Main Street tugged me right through the door.
Reliability is Olympic Pizza’s signature. The crust has that winning balance—crispy along the edges and tender in the center—which speaks to years of careful practice behind the counter. The staff treat you like you’ve been stopping by for years, whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth.
If you aren’t sure where to start, try their classic cheese pizza or a garden vegetable slice. Both capture the familiar and comforting flavors that keep locals coming back. Olympic’s pies feel lovingly crafted, perfect for simple cravings or easy-going nights out in Goshen.
6. Redendo’s Pizza Restaurant
(845) 294-7787Call
Redendo’s Pizza Restaurant has a way of making weeknights feel like a celebration, without coaxing too much out of your wallet. My first visit was for a quick bite between errands, and I left wondering why I hadn’t stopped in sooner—friendly staff and piping hot slices are standard here.
What keeps Redendo’s busy is its dependable, consistent flavor. The crust is slightly firm with a nice chew, and the sauce is tangy in a way that doesn’t overpower. It all feels satisfyingly homemade, with every pie served up fresh and quick.
You can’t go wrong with their plain cheese pizza, but I recommend the veggie or mushroom slice if you’re after a bit more variety. These pies let the quality of their ingredients really show, offering hearty portions that suit any low-key lunch or dinner in Goshen.
7. Pizza Hut
(845) 294-2777Call
Pizza Hut in Goshen might be a recognizable name, but there’s something comforting about knowing exactly what you’re going to get. My first visit here was after a local game night, when a group of us piled in without a reservation and left with satisfied cravings and plenty of leftovers.
This location offers that familiar, reliable experience—from the cozy booths to the warm, cheesy slices—that makes it an easy choice for families and casual meetups. Staff get the orders right fast, and there’s a friendly blend of efficiency and warmth that fits busy nights out.
If you crave a classic, their Pan Pizza delivers buttery, thick crust and generous toppings, especially the Veggie Lover’s or Cheese Lover’s variety. Each slice feels nostalgic and a little indulgent—perfect when you want comfort on demand in Goshen.
8. Goshen Place
Goshen Place sits quietly on West Main Street, but don’t be fooled by its low profile—this spot delivers a distinctly homemade twist on pizza that surprises newcomers. My first bite here was at a lunchtime rush, greeted by that unmistakable scent of fresh-baked crust mingling with a hint of sweetness from the bakery side.
The appeal of Goshen Place lies in its dual identity. While you’re waiting for your pizza, the display of sweets tempts you from behind glass, adding a unique charm to the experience. Everything here tastes a little more personal, with crusts baked to a gentle golden finish and toppings spread generously but thoughtfully.
The classic cheese pizza is a sure bet—soft, chewy, and just the right amount of sauce. For something memorable, try their vegetable pie, which shows off the kitchen’s talent for balance and fresh flavor. It’s an inviting spot for a relaxed lunch or a quick, tasty pick-me-up.
9. Sorrentos Pizzeria
Sorrentos Pizzeria brings a no-fuss, neighborhood vibe that’s easy to appreciate, whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through. My visit during a bustling dinner rush proved why people keep the booths filled—every slice arrives hot and full of flavor.
What sets Sorrentos apart is their blend of crisp, flavorful crust and a tangy tomato sauce that doesn’t overpower. There’s a homemade feel to the cheese-to-sauce ratio, and you can taste the consistency in every bite. Friendly service and brisk counter action only add to the charm.
The Veggie Pizza here is a reliable classic, loaded up and fresh, but don’t overlook their plain cheese if you’re craving something simple and satisfying. Sorrentos makes pizza the way it should be—unpretentious, generous, and just right for any casual meal in Goshen.
10. Brother Brunos
Brother Brunos in Chester is a favorite pit stop for anyone willing to roam just beyond Goshen for a memorable pizza. My first time there, I paused at the display case, debating between the comforting classics and a few inventive specialty pies—decisions, decisions.
This spot stands out for its range. Whether you love your pizza classic or crave something with roasted vegetables or a swirl of rich ricotta, they have you covered. It’s all about hefty slices, bubbling cheese, and a golden crust that holds up bite after bite.
Try the White Pizza or the Veggie Lovers. Both crowd-pleasers, they show off Brother Brunos’s approach: quality ingredients, creative flair, and a generous hand with the toppings. From casual slices to full-on feasts, you’ll find plenty worth coming back for.
More Things to Try in Goshen, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find late-night pizza in Goshen, NY?
Most pizzerias in Goshen close by 10 p.m., but a handful of spots offer extended hours on weekends. Call ahead—especially on Fridays and Saturdays—to check closing times at places like Village Pizzeria or Pizza Hut. For the real night owls, nearby towns might have more choices.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Goshen?
Absolutely. Nearly every pizzeria and restaurant, from Olympic Pizza to Sorrentos and Carlos Cucina, serves vegetarian pies with fresh veggies and classic cheese. You’ll find plenty of flavor and creativity on most menus.
Which Goshen pizza place is best for families?
Goshen is known for its family-friendly pizzerias. Pizza Hut, with its casual seating and quick service, is a go-to for kids, while places like Redendo’s and Village Pizzeria offer cozy atmospheres and great options for sharing.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Goshen?
Several local favorites carry gluten-free crusts—just ask when placing your order. Larger spots like Pizza Hut and some independent places periodically offer these options, though selection can vary.
Do Goshen, NY pizza restaurants offer delivery?
Yes. Many, including Amore’s and Carlos Cucina, provide both delivery and takeout for maximum convenience. Hours and delivery zones may vary, so it’s wise to call first or check their website for details.