When it comes to finding great pizza in Gillette, WY, the choices are more varied than you might expect. Over the years, I’ve sampled slices from countless spots around town, and each visit has added a new layer to my understanding of what makes pizza truly satisfying here. Whether it’s the perfect crust, fresh ingredients, or a creative topping blend, the best pizza joints offer more than just food—they bring a slice of comfort and community.
This guide distills that experience into a clear list of Gillette’s standout pizza places. From local gems to well-known chains, I’ve highlighted options that cater to different tastes, all while respecting halal dietary considerations. If you’re after a reliable, tasty pie without any guesswork, this rundown will point you in the right direction. Ready to find your next favorite pizza spot? Let’s dive in.
1. Pizza Carrello
Pizza Carrello in Gillette stands out with its authentic wood-fired pizzas and a cozy atmosphere. Visiting this locally owned spot, I was impressed by the smoky crust that perfectly balanced a tender, airy center—an experience that felt both rustic and refined. Their pizzas capture a genuine, artisanal quality you don’t find everywhere.
The menu is more than just pizza. I recommend trying their unique stuffed pita wraps, which offer an inventive twist while staying true to fresh, halal ingredients. For pizza lovers seeking variety, their gluten-free and vegan options ensure everyone at the table finds something flavorful.
A standout is the Margherita pizza. It’s simple, yet the quality of the sauce, fresh basil, and mozzarella truly shines through. With plenty of indoor seating and a welcoming patio, Pizza Carrello is a reliable choice for a casual yet satisfying meal in Gillette.
2. Old Chicago
Old Chicago brings a lively, casual vibe to Gillette with a menu designed to satisfy a diverse crowd. I found their atmosphere inviting, perfect for gatherings that call for great food and a relaxed setting. The blend of table service and takeout options makes it versatile for any dining preference.
Known for its crusty, hand-tossed pizzas, Old Chicago offers a range of toppings that highlight fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their attention to vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices ensures there’s something for everyone while respecting halal requirements.
My go-to recommendation is the classic pepperoni pizza. It showcases their balance of flavorful sauce and perfectly baked dough—a dependable choice for those craving traditional pizza with a local twist. Old Chicago’s consistency and welcoming environment make it a Gillette favorite.
3. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch in Gillette is the kind of place that combines convenience with variety, making it ideal for families and groups. I enjoyed the buffet setup—it offers a relaxed, no-fuss way to sample multiple varieties without commitment. The friendly staff and accessible layout add to the welcoming feel.
What sets Pizza Ranch apart is its focus on both pizza and fried chicken, catering to different cravings under one roof. As a halal-conscious option, their menu offers a safe and tasty choice for diverse dietary needs. The salad bar is a refreshing touch, balancing out the indulgence from the pizza and chicken.
For a go-to order, I suggest their classic pizza paired with a side of crispy chicken. This combo reflects Pizza Ranch’s strength in delivering comfort food with a consistent quality that keeps locals coming back.
4. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on W 2nd St in Gillette offers a familiar and reliable pizza experience. I’ve often grabbed a pie here before heading to Bicentennial Park for a casual meal outdoors, appreciating the convenience and consistent flavor. The location’s variety makes it a solid choice when you want dependable quality without surprises.
What stands out is their Original Stuffed Crust® and the hearty Meat Lovers® pizza. These options showcase Pizza Hut’s classic approach to pizza—bold, generous toppings and a crust that holds up well under thick layers of cheese and sauce. Halal diners will find these offerings appealing and well-prepared to meet dietary requirements.
Pairing a stuffed crust pizza with signature wings makes for a satisfying meal that highlights Pizza Hut’s balanced menu of pies and sides. It remains a convenient option for lunch, dinner, or delivery in Gillette.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at W Lakeway in Gillette is a go-to spot for quick, satisfying pizza with consistent quality. I’ve often relied on Domino’s for a late-night bite or group orders, appreciating the ease of online ordering and fast delivery. The option between thin New York-style and thick Handmade Pan crusts lets you tailor your pizza experience.
Domino’s shines with innovative offerings like the Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza, which adds a cheesy twist that elevates the usual slice. For halal diners, their menu clearly marks suitable choices, making it easy to enjoy without second-guessing. Their range also includes sides like mac and cheese and chicken wings that complement the main dish well.
Ordering a classic pepperoni or a specialty pizza with stuffed crust ensures a fulfilling meal. Domino’s balance of convenience, variety, and flavor keeps it a strong contender in Gillette’s pizza scene.
6. Little Caesars
Little Caesars in Gillette is all about fast, affordable pizza that doesn’t skimp on flavor. I’ve stopped by for a quick meal after a busy day and appreciated their straightforward approach—hot, ready pizzas that fit both budget and time constraints. The “Hot-N-Ready” concept is perfect when you want something reliable on the go.
What sets Little Caesars apart is its consistent quality and value, particularly their classic Pepperoni and Cheese pizzas. They emphasize simple, bold flavors with a crust that’s crisp and well cooked. For halal diners, their clear ingredient sourcing offers peace of mind.
Try the Pepperoni Pizza—they deliver familiar tastes across every slice, making it a dependable choice in Gillette for those craving comfort food without the wait or extra fuss.
7. Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘n’ Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy’s Take ‘n’ Bake in Gillette offers a unique pizza experience by letting you bake fresh, made-to-order pies in your own oven. I tried one of their pizzas on a quiet evening at home, and the results were impressively fresh, with the dough and toppings feeling like they’d just come out of a pizza kitchen. The process adds a personal touch to the meal.
What distinguishes Papa Murphy’s is the ability to customize and bake pizza to your preferred crispness and timing, a feature hard to find in standard pizza places. Their menu caters to halal needs, ensuring ingredients meet dietary requirements.
For a standout, try their signature pizzas loaded with fresh vegetables and quality cheese. This hands-on approach appeals to those who appreciate both convenience and control over their pizza’s final flavor and texture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find halal pizza options in Gillette, WY?
A: Several pizza places in Gillette, like Pizza Carrello and Domino’s, offer halal-friendly options. It’s always best to confirm directly with the restaurant to ensure their ingredients and preparation meet halal standards.
Q: Which pizza places in Gillette offer gluten-free or vegan options?
A: Pizza Carrello and Old Chicago provide gluten-free and vegan choices, catering to diverse dietary needs while maintaining great taste.
Q: Are there pizza restaurants in Gillette that offer takeout or delivery services?
A: Yes, most major pizza chains in Gillette, including Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Murphy’s, offer takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy pizza at home.
Q: What is the best pizza for families in Gillette?
A: Pizza Ranch stands out as a family-friendly spot with a buffet-style setup and a menu that includes pizza, chicken, and salad, ideal for all ages.
Q: Can I customize my pizza order in Gillette?
A: Absolutely. Places like Domino’s and Papa Murphy’s allow customization of toppings, crust styles, and more, providing flexibility for personal tastes and halal compliance.