Few things rival the joy of a piping hot pizza, especially when you’re in Galveston, the Texas Gulf Coast gem. This city isn’t just about historic charm or sandy beaches; its local pizzerias bring their own kind of magic. After sampling slices across town, I discovered that each spot adds a distinct twist, whether it’s a family recipe with perfectly chewy crust, a wild topping combination, or the sort of sauce that makes you pause between bites just to appreciate it.
Finding the perfect pizza in Galveston isn’t a myth—it’s a journey, and each stop promises something special. Whether you’re chasing the nostalgia of a cozy Italian eatery or craving a quick bite after strolling the Seawall, Galveston’s pizza scene delivers. If you’ve ever wondered where to get that ideal blend of cheese, sauce, and crust in this breezy island city, get ready. The best slices are closer than you think.
Where to find the best pizza in Galveston, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Galveston, TX:
- Mario’s Seawall Italian & Pizzeria
- Mama Teresa’s Flying Pizza
- Papa’s Pizza
- Mario’s Ristorante
- Grotto Ristorante
- Mario’s Pizza
- Russo’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen – Galveston
- Gino’s Italian Restaurant
- Sharky’s Tavern
- Papa Johns Pizza
1. Mario’s Seawall Italian & Pizzeria
Sitting across from the waves at Mario’s Seawall Italian & Pizzeria feels like pulling up a chair in a coastal Italian village. This is Galveston’s oldest Italian restaurant, blending tradition with unbeatable seaside views. The scent of baking dough lures you in before you even see the menu.
What always sticks with me is the chewy, saucy brilliance of their signature pizzas—the crust is crisp along the edges but soft enough in the center to fold. Mario’s doesn’t play around with toppings; each bite is loaded and balanced. Try the Margherita or the classic Mario’s Special. There’s something timeless about the way they layer fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and herbs.
If you’re seeking a slice that captures coastal charm and old-world flavor, Mario’s Seawall is hard to beat.
2. Mama Teresa’s Flying Pizza
Mama Teresa’s Flying Pizza has a way of making you feel like you’ve stumbled into a slice of Italy right in downtown Galveston. The place buzzes with an easy warmth—think checkered tablecloths, laughter, and the occasional flying dough in the open kitchen. Every visit reminds me why this spot is a local favorite.
The pizzas here lean toward the classic, but never feel ordinary. Each crust comes out golden and lightly chewy, thanks to their slow-rise dough. I always recommend the Flying Combination Pizza; it’s loaded with a rich blend of veggies, savory beef, and stretchy mozzarella. It’s all about flavor packed into every bite.
If you love your pizza generous, fresh, and full of energy, Mama Teresa’s serves slices that sing with Italian flair.
3. Papa’s Pizza
Stepping into Papa’s Pizza on the Seawall has the feel of a true family gathering. The Smecca family’s recipes have filled the air with the smell of fresh, hand-tossed dough for almost five decades. There’s a casual energy here that I find instantly comforting, whether you’re popping in for a quick lunch or a late-night snack after a walk along the shore.
What sets Papa’s apart is the dedication to tradition. Their pizzas are never rushed—each one gets that ideal amount of oven time for a crispy yet tender crust. The Papa’s Special is my go-to; it layers crisp vegetables, savory beef, and an addictive house sauce in a way that never disappoints.
For reliable, classic pizza done right, Papa’s delivers every time.
4. Mario’s Ristorante
Walking into Mario’s Ristorante feels like stepping into an easygoing Italian oasis. Family photos fill the walls, and the friendly buzz makes it clear this place is a local staple. I remember my first visit; the aroma of baking crust and simmering tomato sauce lured me right to a cozy booth.
New York-style pizza is their pride. Each slice has a thin, crisped base with just the right chew. The Vegetarian Pizza stands out for its vibrant, fresh toppings, while classic cheese always satisfies. Mario’s leans on quality ingredients and that unmistakable homemade flavor in every bite.
If you’re after a spot with personality and pizzas that taste like Sunday dinner, this is your stop.
5. Grotto Ristorante
Grotto Ristorante inside the San Luis Resort sets the bar for elegance on the Galveston pizza scene. The warm lighting and classic décor create a relaxed, romantic mood perfect for an evening out. My last visit began with a window seat and ended with me wishing for a bigger appetite.
Pizza here is artful—thin crust, slightly charred, and topped with the freshest ingredients. The Margherita Pizza captures everything Grotto does well, from punchy tomato sauce to creamy mozzarella. You’ll taste garden-fresh basil on every slice.
If you want classic Italian flavors without sacrificing style or comfort, Grotto Ristorante’s pizza will impress without overcomplicating what’s already perfect.
6. Mario’s Pizza
Mario’s Pizza on Termini Road feels like a true neighborhood gathering spot. The vibe is casual and the staff seem to know plenty of folks by name. Whenever I visit, I’m reminded why this pizzeria’s history stretches back to 1967.
There’s real pride in how each New York-style pizza comes together here. Expect a golden, deck-oven crust with just the right amount of chew. Their Vegetarian Pizza is loaded with bright, fresh vegetables and savory mozzarella, a great showcase for their commitment to quality ingredients.
For a relaxed meal that tastes like tradition, Mario’s Pizza feels like coming home—plus, the sea breezes and generous slices don’t hurt either.
7. Russo’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen – Galveston
There’s something inviting about Russo’s New York Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen right by the water. The kitchen bustles with energy and the aroma of baking dough always draws me in. Russo’s take on pizza is a tribute to New York—thin, crisp edges and a foldable crust that holds up under plenty of toppings.
What makes Russo’s stand out is the dedication to scratch-made everything. Their New York Village Pizza is a top pick, loaded with peppers, onions, olives, and melty mozzarella, creating that perfect classic flavor. Gluten-free and vegan options are also available, so no one is missing out.
Whether you dine in or grab a late-night slice, Russo’s consistently delivers quality and that unmistakable big city attitude.
8. Gino’s Italian Restaurant
Gino’s Italian Restaurant is the kind of place where comfort is found in every corner and every bite. It’s easy to feel like a regular, even on your first visit. Warm hospitality, a low-key setting, and the smell of freshly baked dough set the stage for a relaxed meal.
The pizzas at Gino’s are a local secret—simple, sturdy, built with family recipes and fresh ingredients. The Gino’s Special Pizza stands out with its generous layer of veggies and gooey cheese; it’s a great introduction to their no-fuss style. Crispy but never dry, every bite feels intentionally crafted.
If you’re after classic flavors and an old-school pizzeria experience, Gino’s delivers the kind of cuts that keep people coming back.
9. Sharky’s Tavern
At Sharky’s Tavern, pizza takes center stage in the best kind of way. The wood-fired oven gives every pie a smoky, crisp crust that you just can’t fake—each bite has a hint of char and real depth of flavor. It’s the perfect match for Sharky’s laid-back, music-filled vibe. Live performances add a buzz to every meal, making this spot feel like a hangout and a hidden gem rolled into one.
I’m always drawn to their unique creations. Try the Plato’s Pie, loaded with basil pesto, kalamata olives, garlic, and feta. Every slice is a burst of zesty, Mediterranean flavor. The menu features something for everyone, with thoughtful combinations and creative twists on classics.
Come for the tunes; stay for the pizza that’s anything but ordinary.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Galveston’s Seawall is a go-to for straightforward, satisfying pizza when you want consistency and quick service. There’s something comforting about knowing exactly what to expect—hot, fresh pies with reliable quality, every single time. My favorite visits are when I’m grabbing a pie to share with friends on the beach.
The highlight here is always the dough—soft with a touch of sweetness, and never greasy. The Garden Fresh Pizza is a crowd-pleaser, layered with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and ripe tomatoes. The ingredients feel fresh and the flavors hold up whether you order delivery or pick up on the way home.
If you want a predictable, tasty slice or shareable pizza night, Papa Johns does the job without fuss.
More Things to Try in Galveston, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Galveston, TX?
You’ll find everything from classic New York-style thin crusts and authentically Italian pies to creative, wood-fired specials and deep-dish options. There’s plenty for every taste and craving.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Galveston?
Most local pizzerias offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly pizzas. Ask about specific toppings or cheese alternatives; many places are happy to customize your order.
Which Galveston pizza spots deliver?
Major chains like Papa Johns, Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and some locally-owned spots such as Russo’s New York Pizzeria provide delivery. Check with your chosen restaurant for coverage and any delivery minimums.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Galveston?
Several places, including Mario’s Seawall, Russo’s, and Grotto Ristorante, offer gluten-free crusts. Always double-check ingredient details if you have allergy concerns.
Is late-night pizza available in Galveston?
A few places, like Russo’s and Papa’s Pizza, offer late-night hours. Domino’s and Pizza Hut also tend to stay open later for your late cravings.
What’s the best place for pizza with a view in Galveston?
Mario’s Seawall and Grotto Ristorante both pair great pizza with Gulf-front or poolside views, making your meal a little more memorable.