Looking for the best pizza in Gaithersburg, MD isn’t just about cheese and crust. It’s about finding that spot where the sauce tastes like a secret, the toppings are placed with real care, and even plain slices disappear in seconds. I’ve wandered across Gaithersburg, fueled by hunger and a belief that every neighborhood hides at least one pizza gem. After trying everything from coal-fired masterpieces to classic carry-outs, I’m convinced this town has a pie for every mood and moment.
It’s easy to fall in love with pizza when you get a taste of bold local ideas and crisp, flavorful bites. Some spots serve up creative takes, others stick to basics, but all have a loyal crowd that swears theirs is the best. I’ve sampled, savored, and compared, paying attention to the details so you won’t waste time figuring out where to go on a Friday night. Whether you’re hunting for a quick lunch or a slice that’s worth driving across town, you’ll find the right pick here.
Where to find the best pizza in Gaithersburg, MD
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Gaithersburg, MD:
- Coal Fire Pizza
- California Pizza Kitchen at Washingtonian Center
- Giuseppi’s Pizza Plus
- Ledo Pizza
- Paisano’s Pizza
- Starvin Marvin Pizza Shop
- &pizza
- Manhattan Pizza & Pasta
- Domino’s Pizza
- Milano’s Pizza and Pasta
1. Coal Fire Pizza
Coal Fire Pizza on Main St makes every pie feel like a step up from the usual. Their crust comes out blistered and chewy from the coal-fired oven, carrying a smoky flavor that can’t be faked. I remember sitting by the window, catching the aroma before my fork even touched the plate. The mood is casual enough for a quick lunch, but the details on their pizzas invite you to linger.
The build-your-own option is a standout. You get three choices of sauce—signature, spicy, or classic—and a lively selection of vegetarian toppings. Still, the Margherita shines brightest. The cheese bubbles just right, and the basil is always fresh. If you want pizza that feels both elevated and familiar, this place sets the bar.
2. California Pizza Kitchen at Washingtonian Center
California Pizza Kitchen at Washingtonian Center knows how to turn classic pizza on its head—without making it complicated. Sitting under the soft lighting with a view of the lake, I found the vibe lively but still relaxed. The menu stretches beyond ordinary, with creative pies and choices for all diets.
The California Veggie Pizza is packed with color, and the crust carries just the right amount of snap. For anyone looking for plant-based or gluten-free options, their flexible menu impresses. I’d also recommend the Wild Mushroom pizza, surfaced with earthy richness and thoughtful combinations that show real care in the kitchen. If inventive, reliable pizzas are your thing, this spot deserves attention.
3. Giuseppi’s Pizza Plus
Giuseppi’s Pizza Plus brings the feel of a classic neighborhood spot to Kentlands Blvd. I stopped in once for a quick bite but ended up staying longer, drawn in by the aroma and friendly buzz. Their pizzas are hearty, with golden crusts and generous layers of cheese, proving that comfort sometimes comes in a box.
The Veggie Lovers pizza is a winner, loaded with fresh peppers, onions, and mushrooms that actually taste garden-fresh. Traditionalists swear by the cheese and tomato, where the tangy sauce balances out the smooth mozzarella. If you want pizza that feels familiar yet a bit special, this pizza shop gives you just that—straightforward, satisfying, and always consistent.
4. Ledo Pizza
+1 301-740-3351
See Menu
Ledo Pizza is a local favorite that takes the idea of pizza and literally squares it. The first time I tried their signature rectangle slices, I realized it wasn’t just a quirky shape; it was a great excuse for those crispy edges and chewy middles. You feel like you’re getting extra in every bite. The vibe at Montgomery Village is relaxed, making it easy to settle in with family or friends.
The highlight is their classic Veggie Pizza, stacked with bright peppers, mushrooms, and onions over a sweet sauce and melt-in-your-mouth cheese. The crust is thin, flaky, and never greasy. If you’re looking for a pizza joint that blends nostalgia with comfort, Ledo hits the mark. Go for the square slices, stay for the reliable flavor.
5. Paisano’s Pizza
Paisano’s Pizza captures a slice of New York right on Muddy Branch Rd. Stepping in, the aroma of fresh dough sets an inviting tone, and you can see why neighbors keep coming back. My first memory there involved a table full of friends, plenty of laughter, and pizzas disappearing before the second round of drinks.
Their Paisano’s Veggie Pizza proves what fresh toppings can do. The crust is classic—thin, with just the right bite—while the sauce tastes homemade. Paisano’s keeps things friendly with quick service and flexible options for custom pies. If you crave a pizza that blends tradition and taste, this is the spot where you won’t leave disappointed.
6. Starvin Marvin Pizza Shop
Starvin Marvin Pizza Shop belongs on the must-try list for lovers of no-nonsense, tasty pies. Tucked on Frederick Ave, this place has a laid-back feel where orders come fast and hot. My best memory here was grabbing a late slice after a long day and being surprised at how fresh everything tasted, even at closing time.
The real draw is their Cheese Pizza—simple, satisfying, and packing a perfect crust-to-sauce ratio. They don’t overthink the recipes, and that’s what makes each bite genuine. The veggie options also hold their own, stacked with crunch and flavor. For a pizza shop that always hits the spot without fuss, Starvin Marvin offers exactly what you hope for in a local favorite.
7. &pizza
&pizza feels like a breath of fresh air on Crown Park Ave. Their approach flips the traditional pie on its head, with oblong shapes and a make-your-own model that’s fun and fast. My first visit left me hooked, mostly for the wild array of veggie toppings and creative sauces lining the counter.
If you’re the type who wants something outside the usual box, build your own vegetarian pizza and pile on everything from pickled onions to roasted broccoli. The signature Maverick (minus haram items) wins for its bold blend of flavors and chewy, beautifully blistered crust. Here, pizza is a canvas, and every order feels personal, proving why &pizza leads the new-school scene in Gaithersburg.
8. Manhattan Pizza & Pasta
Manhattan Pizza & Pasta feels like a slice of New York tucked right into Gaithersburg. The restaurant is no-frills but welcoming, with the aroma of sauce and bubbling cheese greeting you at the door. My last visit turned into an impromptu feast, with friends insisting we try just one more unique pizza off the menu.
The Garden Special pizza stands out for its lively mix of veggies and classic, foldable crust. The cheese stretch is perfect, and the balance of tangy sauce and fresh toppings hits all the right notes. If you want a pizza spot that does traditional pies well but isn’t afraid to experiment, Manhattan Pizza & Pasta is worth a visit.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Flower Hill Way is the go-to for anyone who loves a quick, reliable pie. Whether you’re picking up or having it delivered, they keep things efficient and consistent. I’ve relied on this spot for last-minute dinners and spontaneous movie nights, and the pizza always shows up hot and exactly as ordered.
The Hand-Tossed Veggie Pizza stands out for its hearty toppings and satisfyingly soft crust. If you like experimenting, their Build Your Own option lets you stack on all the veggies you want. Domino’s stays relevant with deals that keep your wallet happy and a menu you can trust. It’s classic, dependable pizza—perfect for no-fuss cravings.
10. Milano’s Pizza and Pasta
Milano’s Pizza and Pasta brings a cozy, old-school Italian warmth to Shady Grove Rd. Walking in, you’re greeted by the scent of fresh dough and slow-simmered sauce. My favorite memory comes from a family dinner, where sharing slices led to animated debates about which pizza was best.
The Milano Special Veggie Pizza is a clear favorite—loaded with a medley of bell peppers, onions, olives, and mushrooms, all on a thin, golden crust. The cheese melts just right, mingling with their zesty sauce, and each slice feels satisfying without being heavy. For anyone seeking pizza with a homemade feel and genuine flavor, Milano’s delivers a memorable pie, time after time.
More Things to Try in Gaithersburg, MD
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Gaithersburg for dine-in?
Coal Fire Pizza, California Pizza Kitchen, and Gentleman Jim’s Restaurant offer great dine-in experiences with friendly service and flavorful pies.
Are there any vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Gaithersburg?
Yes, many spots like &pizza, California Pizza Kitchen, and Ledo Pizza feature vegetarian and vegan pizzas, with plant-based toppings and dairy-free cheese available.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Gaithersburg?
California Pizza Kitchen and &pizza offer customizable gluten-free crusts and toppings, making them popular with gluten-sensitive diners.
Which pizza place in Gaithersburg is good for takeout?
Domino’s Pizza, Giuseppi’s Pizza Plus, and Milano’s Pizza and Pasta are known for quick, reliable takeout service and consistently fresh pizza.
What’s unique about pizza in Gaithersburg?
The pizza scene blends classic East Coast flavor with creative new twists—from coal-fired crusts at Coal Fire to loaded veggie pies at local favorites like Paisano’s and Starvin Marvin.