Finding the best pizza in Fort Wright, KY isn’t a casual stroll through your phone’s map app. It’s a satisfying adventure, a journey that rewards the persistent with golden crusts, tangy sauces, and endless cheese pulls. I’ve tasted my way down Madison Pike and through side streets, comparing bubblings crusts and skilled local hands. There’s something special about slipping into a warm booth, catching the scent of fresh pizza, and realizing you’ve uncovered a true hidden gem.
Whether you crave simple pepperoni or something piled high with garden veggies, Fort Wright’s pizza spots tell their own stories—every slice is a bit different, and some manage to surprise when you least expect it. This guide isn’t guesswork. It draws from real visits, careful notes, and more than a little trial by mozzarella. If you’ve ever finished a slice and immediately wanted just one more, you’re in the right place. The best pizza in Fort Wright is out there, and the next slice might become your new favorite.
1. Garzelli’s Grinder & Pizza Co
(859) 331-8585Call
Garzelli’s Grinder & Pizza Co sits in the heart of the Silverlake Shopping Center, drawing in regulars and newcomers with its inviting, unpretentious charm. The staff here care about good pizza as much as friendly service—each visit feels like being welcomed by an old friend.
What puts Garzelli’s in a league of its own is the crust: light, crisp, and made fresh every day. Their signature pizzas have a perfect balance of cheese and sauce that doesn’t overwhelm. If you ask locals, they’ll point you toward the classic cheese or the meat-lovers as must-tries.
Don’t skip the grinders either; the oven-toasted hoagies are a close rival to the pizza. When I stopped in after a long day, the first bite convinced me why this spot deserves a place near the top.
2. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Madison Ave always delivers when you’re craving consistent quality and reliability. I remember grabbing a fresh, piping hot pie after a late night, the aroma alone making it impossible to wait until I got home.
What sets Papa Johns apart is their signature sauce and fresh-baked crust. They don’t skimp on cheese, and the toppings are always generous. The pizzas leave your hands a little cheesy and your cravings completely satisfied.
If you’re placing an order, go for the Classic Pepperoni or the Garden Fresh pizza. Both showcase the bright sauce and pillowy dough. Their cheese sticks also make a worthy side, capturing that same reliable flavor that keeps regulars coming back.
3. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Winston Ave is more than just a quick dinner solution. It’s the spot locals trust when a craving for cheesy, classic pizza hits at any hour. I’ve dropped by for late-night pick-ups, and it’s never taken long before that familiar blue-and-red box is in hand.
Domino’s stands out for its crispy, foldable thin crust and the sheer variety of options. If you want comfort, their Handmade Pan pizza delivers an extra fluffy yet golden edge every time.
The Parmesan Stuffed Crust is one order you won’t want to share, and their Veggie pizza packs bright flavors without feeling heavy. Looking for something lighter? A thin-crust Garden pizza does the trick, and always lands hot and fresh.
4. Angilo’s Pizza
Angilo’s Pizza on Pike St manages to mix tradition with distinct, local personality. This place feels like stepping into a cozy, familiar nook, with smells of baking crust greeting you at the door. Family-owned and run since 1962, there’s a real sense of pride baked into every pie they serve.
I’m always drawn to their classic cheese pizza, paired with a house-made crust that has just the right amount of chew. Angilo’s signature sauce is a not-too-sweet, herby layer that pulls everything together, and it’s clear that this recipe has been handed down—there’s character in every bite.
Their veggie pies are also a good pick, satisfying and loaded without being too heavy. If there’s time, I pick up a hoagie as well. It’s a throwback experience you don’t get everywhere else.
5. Donatos Pizzeria
(859) 578-0077Call
Donatos Pizzeria on Buttermilk Pike brings a satisfyingly crisp and flavorful approach to pizza that stands out from the ordinary. You can taste the attention to detail—from the thin, golden crust to the even spread of toppings on every slice.
I’ve stopped in for the signature Edge to Edge® Pepperoni and never left disappointed. Every bite offers a generous portion of topping and just enough cheese to balance things out. Donatos doesn’t let the toppings fall short or let the flavor get lost.
If you’re in the mood for something a bit lighter, the Veggie pizza is a sure bet—fresh ingredients and that famous ultra-thin crust keep things crispy. This is the kind of spot that gets pizza right every single time.
6. Riverfront Pizza
Riverfront Pizza on W 3rd St offers a local flavor that’s hard to find anywhere else in the area. There’s a fun, laid-back vibe at the new sports bar, perfect for sharing a few pies with friends or catching a game while you dine.
Riverfront’s real claim to fame is the variety. From tried-and-true options to unexpected favorites like the Taco Pizza and Ranch Pizza, every menu pick brings something extra. The crust leans toward classic comfort—sturdy, golden, and made to hold its generous helping of toppings.
No visit is complete without a specialty pizza. The BBQ Pizza combines smoky notes with gooey cheese and just enough tang to keep things interesting. Riverfront Pizza knows how to make a casual meal memorable with simple, big flavors and a welcoming atmosphere.
7. Fatty Patty’s Pizza
(859) 261-4267Call
Fatty Patty’s Pizza on Main St is a local favorite for a reason: unpretentious, quietly confident, and generous with the toppings. When I stopped by, the spot felt inviting—like you’re in on a neighborhood secret every time you order.
Fatty Patty’s crust is satisfyingly chewy, perfect for anyone who appreciates a heartier bite. Their sauce uses a well-balanced touch of herbs, never overshadowing the other flavors, and the cheese is always plentiful.
The real magic here is in the specialty pies. Try the Supreme Pizza or go simple with a cheese pizza that’s anything but basic thanks to the attention to quality. This place is ideal if your pizza cravings lean toward rich, classic flavors and filling portions.
8. Salvadore’s Pizzeria
Salvadore’s Pizzeria on Dixie Hwy has quietly perfected its craft since 1972, focusing on scratch-made dough and quality ingredients. The warm, inviting setup makes every meal feel like a special event, even when you’re just grabbing takeout.
I once picked up a build-your-own pizza kit for a family night, and the process was as much fun as the result—fresh, fully customizable, and packed with flavor. Their crust is light but sturdy, and toppings taste fresh because nothing is pre-packaged.
Try the classic cheese or make your own creation. Salvadore’s is all about simple, honest food made right. It’s the kind of place where quality is obvious from the first bite, and you’ll want to linger a little longer at the table.
9. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza on Old Taylor Mill Rd highlights a commitment to tradition with a bit of neighborhood warmth you don’t always find in a chain. One stop here and you understand their focus on quality—dough made fresh daily, a unique three-cheese blend, and sauce that’s stayed the same since 1978.
I’ve stopped in for a quick bite and walked out convinced that their Deluxe Pizza is a must. Loaded with veggies and perfectly seasoned meats (all halal-friendly), every slice tastes like it’s made to order. The cheese pull alone is worth the trip.
If you’re a fan of lighter fare, the Garden Pizza puts their fresh veggie chops on full display. It’s easy to see why Marco’s wins over both purists and adventurous types—every pizza feels like an upgrade to your regular night in.
10. Rusconi Pizza
Rusconi Pizza sits just across the river in downtown Cincinnati, but it’s a quick drive that’s worth every mile for fans looking for standout pizza near Fort Wright. When I visited, the inviting atmosphere and downtown energy made grabbing a pie feel like a night in the city.
Rusconi’s shines with its handcrafted dough and creative topping choices. The Margherita Pizza highlights fresh basil, bright tomato sauce, and a delicate blend of cheese—simple, direct, but done exceptionally well.
If you’re searching for something different, try the Veggie Pizza stacked generously with market-fresh toppings. Rusconi’s always balances flavor with freshness, turning a familiar dish into a memorable meal. It’s a spot you’ll return to when you want reliable quality and a touch of urban flair.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are available in Fort Wright, KY?
You’ll find everything from thin and crispy New York-style to thick, hearty pan pizzas. Several places also offer classic hand-tossed and veggie-forward options for lighter fare.
Are there pizza places in Fort Wright with gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Yes, most local spots and larger chains have gluten-free crusts and vegetarian pizzas, often made with fresh ingredients and plenty of topping choices.
Which pizza places offer delivery in Fort Wright?
Many, like Domino’s, Papa Johns, Marco’s, and local shops such as Riverfront Pizza, provide both delivery and carryout options to suit your schedule.
Where can I find the best local, non-chain pizza near Fort Wright?
Locals swear by small shops like Garzelli’s Grinder & Pizza Co for something with a more personal touch. These spots often feature unique specialties and friendly service.
Do any Fort Wright pizzerias offer family or group deals?
Almost all major pizza places and many local joints run specials on large pizzas or group combos—ask when you call or check online menus for the best value.