Navigating the vibrant pizza scene in Fort Pierce, FL reveals a surprising variety of flavors and styles. Over years of exploring local eateries, I’ve discovered spots where every slice tells a story—whether it’s a classic Margherita or a creative, gourmet topping combination. This city isn’t just about pizza; it’s about finding that perfect balance between crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and cheese that melts just right.
As someone who appreciates both tradition and innovation, I understand what makes a pizza truly stand out. Fort Pierce offers a hospitality-filled atmosphere with pizzerias that master the art of making pizza something memorable. If you’re searching for the very best, this list highlights places that deliver quality, authenticity, and a memorable slice. Let’s explore where to get the most satisfying pizza in Fort Pierce, FL.
Where to find the best pizza in Fort Pierce, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fort Pierce, FL:
- Goodfella’s Pizza
- Nino’s Italian Restaurant Lakewood Park
- Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Pappy’s Pizza
- Piehole Wood Pizza
- Votino’s Pizza Kitchen
- The Crafted Pie
- AJ’s Pizza Subs and Wings
- Frank & Al’s Pizza
- Loutina’s Pizza
1. Goodfella’s Pizza
Located at 1008 Seaway Drive, Goodfella’s Pizza is a go-to spot for authentic, no-frills pizza in Fort Pierce. During my visits, I’ve appreciated their simple yet flavorful approach—nothing overly complicated, just great ingredients crafted with care. The friendly atmosphere makes it easy to enjoy your meal whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout.
What sets Goodfella’s apart is its dedication to quality and tradition. Their classic pies, like the Margherita or Pepperoni, showcase a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and melty cheese. If you’re craving a true taste of Fort Pierce pizza, trying their family-sized specialty pizzas is a must. It’s a place where consistency and passion shine through with every slice.
2. Nino’s Italian Restaurant Lakewood Park
Nino’s Italian Restaurant in Lakewood Park, located at 5018 Turnpike Feeder Road, offers a welcoming atmosphere with a focus on authentic Italian flavors. During my visit, I was impressed by their diverse menu and the warm, attentive service. It’s a place that caters to a variety of dietary needs, providing vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, making everyone feel at home.
What truly makes Nino’s stand out is their commitment to quality and tradition. Their wood-fired pizzas and handcrafted sauces reflect genuine Italian standards. The Margherita or Veggie Pizza are standout choices, showcasing fresh ingredients and a perfectly crisp crust. For an authentic Italian pizza experience in Fort Pierce, Nino’s delivers with consistent excellence.
3. Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Located in the heart of downtown Fort Pierce at 222 Orange Avenue, Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria offers a cozy, old-school vibe that’s hard to resist. On my first visit, I was drawn in by the aroma of fresh dough and herbs wafting from the kitchen. The staff treats you like family, and the setting feels like a neighborhood staple.
What makes Lorenzo’s special is its dedication to traditional Italian recipes. Their Thin Crust Cheese Pizza is a standout—simple, yet packed with flavor. The crust is crisp, the sauce is rich, and the cheese is perfectly melted. For something heartier, the Vegetarian Pizza is loaded with fresh toppings and never feels heavy.
If you’re after a slice that feels both familiar and elevated, Lorenzo’s delivers with charm and consistency.
4. Pappy’s Pizza
Located at 6945 Okeechobee Road, Pappy’s Pizza offers a family-friendly environment with a focus on classic favorites. My visit was memorable because of their warm service and the aroma of freshly baked pies filling the air. It’s a spot that feels inviting whether you dine in or opt for delivery.
Pappy’s stands out for its *consistently flavorful* pies and generous toppings. The Supreme Pizza is a popular choice, loaded with meats, vegetables, and gooey cheese—delivering a satisfying, well-balanced flavor. For a lighter option, the Veggie Pizza showcases fresh ingredients atop a crispy crust.
If you seek authentic, hearty pizza in Fort Pierce, Pappy’s is a dependable pick that rarely disappoints.
5. Piehole Wood Pizza
Piehole Wood Pizza doesn’t just feed hungry beachgoers—it makes them linger. Tucked along South Ocean Drive, this neighborhood pizza pub blends casual charm with wood-fired finesse. The atmosphere feels like something out of a coastal weekend: laid-back, but never lazy.
The crust tells the story. Crisp at the edge, slightly chewy within, and kissed by smoke. Go with the classic Margherita if you’re testing fundamentals—or dive into their Veggie-loaded specialty pies, which strike a flavorful balance that’s surprisingly bold without being overwhelming.
Staff here are genuinely welcoming. It’s not just customer service—it feels like they care whether your dinner’s memorable. Locals often return for the consistency, and visitors tend to wish Piehole shipped nationwide.
If you appreciate pizza that understands its own flavor profile, Piehole Wood Pizza is a must-stop in Fort Pierce.
6. Votino’s Pizza Kitchen
Votino’s Pizza Kitchen feels like stepping into a slice of Fort Pierce’s past—comfortable, local, and no-frills in the best way. It’s the kind of place where regulars nod at staff and no one rushes your order. The pepperoni pizza here is crisped to perfection with a flavor-rich sauce that leans slightly sweet, balanced nicely with the cheese melt.
Try the mushroom and green pepper pie if you’re looking for something simple but satisfying. There’s a clarity to the flavors that shows they care more about quality than flash. Dough isn’t overly thick, but has bite.
I once stopped by on a warm afternoon just to grab a slice—and stayed for two. That’s Votino’s charm. It grows on you quickly.
Votino’s Pizza Kitchen quietly earns its spot among Fort Pierce’s pizza staples.
7. The Crafted Pie
Located at 130 N 2nd Street, The Crafted Pie combines the casual charm of a brew pub with the comfort of well-crafted pizza. I enjoyed their inviting atmosphere and the variety that goes beyond just pizza—perfect for a relaxed lunch or dinner. Ordering online made it easy to enjoy their offerings at home, blending convenience with quality.
Their signature pies stand out for their creative toppings and perfectly baked crusts. The Margherita or BBQ Chicken Pizza both reflect their commitment to quality ingredients and balanced flavors. The addition of salads and pasta makes it a versatile spot for different tastes, all while maintaining a friendly, community-focused vibe.
For an authentic, satisfying experience that captures the essence of Fort Pierce’s local flavor, The Crafted Pie is a reliable choice.
8. AJ’s Pizza Subs and Wings
Tucked into a modest plaza on US Highway 1, AJ’s Pizza Subs and Wings delivers more than just a quick bite—it offers a warm, local experience. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted with genuine smiles and the kind of hospitality that feels rare these days.
What sets AJ’s apart is its versatility and consistency. While their menu spans from gyros to calzones, the pizza is the real draw. The classic cheese pizza is a testament to simplicity done right—crispy crust, tangy sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. For something heartier, the Meat Lovers Pizza showcases their generous portions and bold flavors.
Whether you’re grabbing lunch or settling in for dinner, AJ’s blends comfort food with a neighborhood vibe that keeps locals coming back.
9. Frank & Al’s Pizza
Frank & Al’s Pizza feels like stepping into Fort Pierce’s pizza roots. It’s not flashy, but the flavors speak louder than the décor ever could. Tucked off US Highway 1, it’s where many locals go when they’re craving comfort in a pie.
The experience is warm and laid-back. I still remember biting into their pepperoni pizza—thin crust, a generous layer of cheese, and just the right spice kick from the sauce. They’ve been doing this since 1971, and it shows in their consistency.
For something bold, try the Frank & Al’s Special. It’s stacked with fresh toppings and baked to a perfect crisp, reflecting their commitment to keeping pizza simple and satisfying.
It’s not just food—it’s a piece of Fort Pierce tradition wrapped in melted cheese and good memories.
10. Loutina’s Pizza
Since 1991, Loutina’s Pizza has been a neighborhood staple in Lakewood Park. The family-run business emphasizes quality, using only the finest ingredients like 100% Grande cheese. Their commitment to freshness shows with sauces and dough made daily, ensuring each pizza is top-notch.
My personal experience highlights their New York-style pizza, featuring a crispy crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings. The balance of flavors and texture makes every bite satisfying.
For a must-try, order the Veggie Deluxe or their classic Cheese Pizza. Both reflect Loutina’s dedication to authentic taste and quality that keeps locals coming back year after year.
More Things to Try in Fort Pierce, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some of the best pizza places in Fort Pierce, FL?
A: Some top-rated options include Goodfella’s Pizza, Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria, and Pappy’s Pizza. Each offers unique flavors and styles, from classic margherita to hearty specialty pies.
Q: Do most pizza places in Fort Pierce offer delivery or takeout?
A: Yes, many local pizzerias like AJ’s Pizza Subs and Wings, and The Crafted Pie, provide convenient options for delivery and takeout, making it easy to enjoy quality pizza at home.
Q: Are there vegetarian or gluten-free pizza options available?
A: Absolutely. Places like Nino’s Italian Restaurant and Votino’s Pizza Kitchen offer vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free choices, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Q: What’s the typical price range for a pizza in Fort Pierce?
A: Most pizzas range from $10 to $20, depending on size and toppings, making them a great option for casual dining or a quick, satisfying meal.
Q: Are there any family-friendly pizza spots in Fort Pierce?
A: Yes, restaurants like Frank & Al’s Pizza and Votino’s Pizza Kitchen are known for their welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family meals.