Searching for the best pizza in Fort Myers is like embarking on a delicious treasure hunt. With so many options, each slice tells a story, from crispy crusts to tangy sauces and fresh toppings. As a pizza enthusiast, I’ve tasted my way through this vibrant scene, discovering gems that not only satisfy cravings but also showcase local creativity. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous with toppings, there’s something for everyone in this sunny slice of paradise.
This guide will lead you through some of the top pizzerias in Fort Myers, each promising a unique experience. Get ready to find your new favorite spot, whether you’re dining in, grabbing a slice on the go, or enjoying a cozy dinner with friends and family. Let’s dive into this mouthwatering journey and explore what makes each pizza place stand out in its own right. The perfect pie awaits you.
Where to find the best pizza in Fort Myers, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fort Myers, FL:
- Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza
- Downtown House of Pizza
- Nino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Fine Folk Pizza
- Amore Brick Oven Pizza
- Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria
- Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria McGregor Blvd
- Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria
- Blue Moon Pizza
- Poppy’s Pizza
1. Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza
Stepping into Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza in Fort Myers feels like entering a 1930s speakeasy—complete with vintage décor and a warm, lively atmosphere. The moment I walked in, the scent of coal-fired ovens instantly made my mouth water. It’s the kind of place where every bite tells a story.
What makes Capone’s stand out is their commitment to coal-fired perfection—delivering pizzas with a perfectly crisp, slightly charred crust that’s hard to find elsewhere. Their attention to detail and fresh ingredients ensure each dish is memorable.
I highly recommend the Margherita Pizza—simple, yet bursting with flavor thanks to fresh mozzarella, basil, and that unbeatable crust. For something unique, try the White Pizza with ricotta and spinach—a creamy, satisfying choice.
2. Downtown House of Pizza
At Downtown House of Pizza, the aroma of freshly baked New York-style pizza fills the air, drawing in both locals and visitors. This cozy, locally owned pizzeria allows you to watch skilled pizza makers craft hand-tossed dough right from the big front window, enhancing the experience. The atmosphere buzzes with energy, making it a perfect spot to unwind.
What sets Downtown House of Pizza apart is its extensive menu that caters to every craving, including specialty pizzas, calzones, and even local craft beers on tap. You can enjoy a slice while soaking in the lively downtown vibe from your window seat.
Don’t miss the Classic Pepperoni Pizza, which embodies their excellent hand-tossed technique, or the Veggie Stromboli for a hearty vegetarian option. Pair your pizza with a local draft beer for a truly satisfying meal.
3. Nino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
For over 45 years, Nino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant has been a cherished landmark in Fort Myers, drawing pizza lovers from across Southwest Florida. The Ciancimino family continues to uphold the traditions that make this restaurant a gem. Walking in, you feel the warmth of family hospitality alongside the enticing aroma of mouthwatering Italian dishes.
Nino’s stands out with its rich history and a menu that celebrates authentic New York-style pizza. The expanded dining area and full cocktail bar create the perfect setting for a night out or a family gathering.
Be sure to order the Meat Lovers Pizza for a hearty taste that highlights their perfect crust and generous toppings. For a lighter option, try the Vegetarian Pizza, featuring fresh vegetables and a zesty sauce that perfectly balances flavors.
4. Fine Folk Pizza
Located in a welcoming space, Fine Folk Pizza is a delightful addition to Fort Myers’ pizza scene, known for its artisanal approach to crafting pizzas. From the moment I stepped in, the relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients and a passion for quality.
What truly sets Fine Folk apart is their unique flavor combinations and dedication to inclusivity. They cater to various dietary preferences, offering vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options without sacrificing taste.
I recommend trying the Truffle Shuffle Pizza, a savory blend of truffle oil, mushrooms, and mozzarella that elevates the standard pizza experience. For a refreshing choice, the Fig and Prosciutto Pizza balances sweetness and saltiness beautifully.
5. Amore Brick Oven Pizza
Every visit to Amore Brick Oven Pizza feels like a celebration of authentic Italian flavors. Nestled in Fort Myers, this pizzeria takes pride in its traditional brick oven, creating pizzas with beautifully charred crusts and rich toppings. The welcoming ambiance and attentive service make it the perfect spot for any meal.
What distinguishes Amore is their focus on quality and freshness. Each pizza is crafted with care, ensuring that even the simplest ingredients shine. The extensive menu also accommodates various dietary needs.
I recommend the Margherita Pizza, which beautifully showcases their hand-stretched dough and fresh basil, or the Buffalo Chicken Pizza for something with a kick. Both options highlight their commitment to exceptional pizza-making.
6. Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria
When in search of authentic Italian cuisine, Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a must-visit in Fort Myers. This charming eatery offers a wide selection of hand-tossed pizzas, fresh pasta, and hearty salads, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. My first visit left a lasting impression, with flavors that transported me straight to Italy.
What sets Pizza Pub apart is their unwavering commitment to authenticity. Each pizza is made to order, ensuring the perfect blend of flavors and textures. The friendly atmosphere and dedicated staff only enhance the experience.
For a classic choice, the Margherita PizzaPasta Primavera complements their pizza offerings for a complete meal. Both dishes reflect their dedication to quality and tradition.
7. Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria McGregor Blvd
For over 20 years, Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria McGregor Blvd has been delighting the taste buds of Fort Myers residents. The moment you walk in, the inviting aroma of fresh-baked bread greets you, hinting at the quality that defines their entire menu. My visit was marked by a warm ambiance and friendly service, making it a true dining experience.
Citrola’s stands out due to its commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, which elevates every dish. Their house-made bread truly sets them apart, especially in their subs and dinner rolls.
I highly recommend the Buffalo Chicken Pizza for a flavorful kick, or the classic Cheese Pizza that showcases the perfect balance of crust and sauce. Each bite reflects their dedication to quality and tradition.
8. Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria
At Citrola’s Italian Grill & Pizzeria, the delightful experience of enjoying authentic Italian cuisine is palpable from the moment you step in. This family-operated restaurant has been serving award-winning dishes for over 20 years, making it a beloved choice for both locals and seasonal visitors. During my visit, the atmosphere buzzed with friendly chatter, enhancing the overall dining enjoyment.
What really makes Citrola’s stand out is their attention to quality and service. They take pride in creating a warm, welcoming environment while delivering consistently delicious food.
I highly recommend the Meatball Pizza, which combines flavorful, homemade meatballs with a vibrant sauce, or the Vegetarian Pizza packed with fresh veggies, showcasing their dedication to quality ingredients.
9. Blue Moon Pizza
At Blue Moon Pizza, casual dining transforms into a delightful culinary experience. This full-service restaurant captures the essence of creativity with its diverse menu, which features specialty pizzas, fresh salads, and inspired sandwiches. My visit was marked by a vibrant atmosphere and attentive service, making it the ideal spot to relax with friends or family.
What sets Blue Moon apart is its commitment to offering something for everyone, including vegan options and gluten-free pizza. Their passion for quality shines through in every recipe.
I recommend trying the Mango Habanero Chicken Pizza for a sweet and spicy flavor explosion, or the classic Margherita Pizza, which perfectly balances fresh ingredients and a chewy crust—showcasing their dedication to exceptional pizza.
10. Poppy’s Pizza
+1 239-689-5660
See Menu
Poppy’s Pizza is a slice of New York culture right in Fort Myers, with a 70-year-old Brooklyn recipe that’s been winning hearts for ages. The moment I stepped in, the tantalizing smell of hand-tossed pizza cooked to perfection in a brick oven filled the air. This cozy spot is a local favorite, known for its genuine flavors and inviting atmosphere.
What makes Poppy’s stand out is their dedication to quality ingredients. They use Grande cheese complemented by the finest meats and freshest veggies, which sets their pizzas apart.
I recommend the Poppy’s Special Pizza, loaded with an array of toppings, or the Buffalo Wings tossed in their secret sauce—heralded as the best in town. Each bite reflects their commitment to authenticity and flavor.
More Things to Try in Fort Myers, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Fort Myers, FL?
Some top-rated pizza spots in Fort Myers include:
– Grimaldi’s Pizzeria – Known for its coal-fired, brick oven pizzas.
– Downtown House of Pizza (DHOP) – A local favorite for New York-style slices.
– Fine Folk Pizza – Famous for creative toppings and halal-friendly options.
– Pizza Fusion – Offers organic ingredients and gluten-free crusts.
2. Are there any halal pizza places in Fort Myers?
Yes, Fine Folk Pizza and Pizza Pazza offer halal-friendly options. It’s always a good idea to call ahead and confirm their current halal offerings.
3. Who delivers pizza late at night in Fort Myers?
Some pizza places that offer late-night delivery include:
– Downtown House of Pizza (DHOP) – Open until 2 AM on weekends.
– Domino’s and Papa John’s – National chains with extended hours in some locations.
Use apps like Uber Eats or DoorDash to check real-time availability.
4. Where can I find vegetarian pizza in Fort Myers?
Most pizza places in Fort Myers offer vegetarian options, including:
– Mellow Mushroom – Popular for its variety of veggie toppings.
– Pizza Fusion – Known for healthy, organic, and fully vegetarian pizzas.
– Fine Folk Pizza – Offers customizable vegetarian pies with fresh toppings.
5. Are there any gluten-free pizza options in Fort Myers?
Yes! Several pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts, including:
– Pizza Fusion – Specializes in gluten-free and organic pizzas.
– Mellow Mushroom – Offers a gluten-free crust with a range of toppings.
– Fine Folk Pizza – Known for accommodating dietary needs.
6. What’s the most popular pizza style in Fort Myers?
New York-style and Neapolitan pizzas are among the most popular. However, wood-fired and artisan-style pizzas are also gaining popularity in the area.
7. Are there any pizza places near Fort Myers Beach?
Yes! A few popular options near the beach include:
– Rude Shrimp Co. Pizza – Known for beachside vibes and tasty pies.
– Ray’s Pizza – A convenient stop near the beach with classic offerings.
8. Can I find pizza buffets in Fort Myers?
While not as common, you can find pizza buffets at places like:
– CiCi’s Pizza – Offers an all-you-can-eat buffet with various crusts and toppings.
– Local Italian restaurants may offer buffet-style lunch specials—check their websites or call ahead.
9. Are there any pizza places with outdoor seating in Fort Myers?
Yes, many pizzerias offer outdoor or patio seating, including:
– Fine Folk Pizza
– Downtown House of Pizza
– Mellow Mushroom – Known for its fun outdoor ambiance.
10. What are some family-friendly pizza restaurants in Fort Myers?
Great spots for families include:
– Mellow Mushroom – Colorful decor and a kid-friendly menu.
– Fine Folk Pizza – Offers fun pizza-making experiences for children.
– Uncle Rico’s Pizza – A casual spot with large portions, perfect for sharing.