Pizza in Fort Collins isn’t just a dinner plan—it’s a little adventure across crispy crusts, gooey cheese, and secret recipes tucked into every slice. Whether it’s a quick bite after a hike, late-night eats with friends, or a sit-down pie under string lights, this city proves its slices deserve more attention than its famous beer. I’ve wandered through downtown, ducked into tiny pizzerias, and even braved campus hangouts that promise a “life-changing” cheese pull. When it comes to picking the best pizza here, there’s no shortage of contenders, only clever takes and local legends.
If you’re searching for that perfect pie—thin crust or deep dish, classic margherita or offbeat combos—you’re in for a treat. This guide isn’t just another list. I’ve sampled, compared, and chatted with regulars from every place that takes its dough seriously. Keep reading, and you’ll find the local favorites, the creative toppings, and the no-fuss classics that make Fort Collins a proper pizza town.
1. Totally 80’s Pizza
Totally 80’s Pizza is what happens when a pizzeria decides to build its whole vibe around neon nostalgia and a soundtrack you secretly know by heart. It’s less a pizza place and more a pop-culture playground, with walls decked in era memorabilia and arcade games humming in the corner.
The pizza itself doesn’t just look good—it delivers with chewy crusts and plenty of cheese. Their veggie pie is a standout, loaded with fresh toppings that never feel like an afterthought. You can pay by the slice or grab a whole pie if the crew is hungry.
The arcade classics and upbeat 80s playlist make it impossible not to smile. Whether you’re here for lunch or dinner, Totally 80’s Pizza keeps it simple, fresh, and fun.
2. Beau Jo’s
Beau Jo’s feels like a rite of passage in Fort Collins, especially if you’ve never tried true Colorado-style pizza. The first time I walked into their Old Town spot, the scent of fresh dough and honey hit me—the crust here is hand-rolled, soft inside, and just a little sweet. That extra touch of local honey in the dough isn’t a gimmick—it’s what makes the pizza so memorable.
Their specialty mountain pies are piled high, designed for sharing (and for those who appreciate leftovers). Don’t skip the veggie combo or the classic Margherita, both of which showcase how generous Beau Jo’s gets with toppings without making things soggy.
For anyone needing gluten-free or vegan options, they deliver without sacrificing taste. Order a pie, save a slice of that sweet edge for last, and dip it in honey—locals swear by it.
3. Slyce Pizza Co
Slyce Pizza Co is where you go in Fort Collins when you want options—serious, wild, and classic ones. You can walk in for a single, giant slice or split a full pie if you’re with friends. Their display case is always packed with creative choices, from classic cheese to slices stacked with unexpected veggies.
On my last visit, I went adventurous and tried their Mac & Cheese pizza—a local favorite. The crispy bottom and indulgent toppings make it satisfying in a way that most late-night slices can’t match.
If you’re a purist, their Margherita is as fresh and bright as it gets. Slyce works hard to keep things fast, but the quality always shines through. Perfect for those downtown nights when only something hot and fresh will do.
4. Jj’s Bar & Grill Wood Fire Pizza
JJ’s Bar & Grill Wood Fire Pizza feels like a local favorite you only share with close friends. Tucked away on the south side, this spot combines neighborhood bar energy with the smell of wood-fired dough wafting from the oven. The pizzas come out perfectly crisp, lightly charred, and packed with real flavor thanks to the wood fire—no shortcuts here.
The classic Veggie Pizza is always a win, layered with fresh toppings and a crust sturdy enough to support every bite. I still think about their Margherita, the mozzarella bubbling with a touch of wood smoke, every time pizza comes to mind.
JJ’s shines at dinner, but lunch is just as laid-back and friendly. If you love pizzerias where the staff remembers your order, you’ll fit right in.
5. Oregano’s
Oregano’s wears its Chicago roots proudly, bringing a slice of big city flair to Fort Collins. Every visit feels a little like a party, with friendly servers who seem genuinely happy to share their favorites. The moment you sit down, you get the sense that Oregano’s takes comfort food seriously but keeps the vibe relaxed.
What makes Oregano’s stand out is its deep-dish pizza. Each pie is packed with rich tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and heaps of veggies if you want to keep it classic. Their crust holds up to the weight, never soggy, always golden.
If you’re short on time, the thin crust is crisp and fast. Chicago-style or quick slice, Oregano’s makes it simple to feel at home—and hungry for more.
6. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza on Centre Ave gives you all the control. Here, you’re the mastermind behind every slice, loading your pizza with as many fresh toppings as you like—all for one price. The thrill is in watching your creation come together right in front of you, fired up to perfection in minutes.
I’ve mixed and matched endless combinations, but a favorite move is piling on mushrooms, olives, and roasted red peppers for a pie that always hits home. MOD’s gluten-friendly crusts and vegan cheese make it easy for all eaters to join in.
If you’re in a rush, MOD’s speedy service delivers on flavor and convenience. For anyone who craves variety, this spot never gets old.
7. Otto Pint
Otto Pint is where wood-fired pizza and good company come together in south Fort Collins. The airy, modern space with lots of patio seating makes it easy to settle in for a leisurely meal. Otto Pint stands out for its creative, veggie-packed topping combinations and crusts with just the right crispness and chew.
Their Roasted Mushroom pizza has become my go-to, balancing earthy flavors with a dose of fresh greens. If you want something bright and light, the Arugula & Shaved Parmesan pizza never disappoints.
Options for vegan and gluten-free diners mean everyone leaves happy. Whether you’re sharing with friends or flying solo, Otto Pint makes every slice a conversation starter.
8. Krazy Karl’s Pizza
Krazy Karl’s Pizza is something of a cult classic in Fort Collins, especially for those who like their pies big, bold, and loaded. The laid-back vibe feels a bit like a college hangout, but the food’s flavor is anything but casual. Where Krazy Karl’s shines most is in its epic topping combinations and dough that’s pillowy yet holds up well for a second slice, or even breakfast the next day.
Their Veggie Supreme is a personal favorite, stacked high with mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes, and olives. After a long day, nothing hits quite like grabbing a few cheesy garlic breadsticks on the side.
Always fast, always hot, and always generous with toppings—Krazy Karl’s lives up to its name, in all the right ways.
9. Pizza Casbah
Pizza Casbah is that rare slice shop where the portions are as generous as the flavors. Late nights wandering through Fort Collins have led me to Casbah’s counter more than once, drawn by the aroma of pizza fresh from the oven. The New York-style crust—thin yet sturdy— sets Casbah apart in a city packed with options.
If you like to experiment, order a huge slice and pile it with veggies. Their Mediterranean pizza, with bold seasonings and fresh toppings, keeps regulars coming back. The menu is huge, so even picky eaters leave satisfied.
For a quick bite between classes or a laid-back dinner with friends, Pizza Casbah sets the bar high for both value and flavor.
10. Krazy Karls Pizza
This Krazy Karl’s on Elizabeth Street is legendary among students and night owls alike. After long study sessions or late-night hangs, I’ve lost count of the times a hot box from here has saved the day. What makes this Krazy Karl’s special is the sheer size of their slices and the creative topping combos you won’t find just anywhere.
The Veggie Pie is a top pick, layered with mushrooms, olives, peppers, and a melt that holds up, whether you’re grabbing a single slice or a full pie. Their crust strikes a perfect balance—soft enough to fold, but never soggy.
Fast delivery and late-night hours mean satisfying pizza cravings is never out of reach. Krazy Karl’s has truly earned its loyal following in Fort Collins.
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Fort Collins?
Fort Collins loves variety, but you’ll notice a lot of New York-style and Colorado-style pizzas. The city is full of crisp thin crusts, fluffy hand-tossed pies, and even unique honey-sweetened dough—thanks to Beau Jo’s.
Are there good vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Fort Collins?
Absolutely. Most local spots, like Otto Pint, Pizza Casbah, and Oregano’s, feature great vegetarian pies, and some offer vegan cheese and plant-based toppings. MOD Pizza and Beau Jo’s also have gluten-friendly and vegan options.
Where can I get late-night pizza in Fort Collins?
Slyce Pizza Co, Krazy Karl’s, and Pizza Casbah all keep their ovens hot into the late hours. They’re favorites for night owls, students, and anyone needing a late bite.
Do any places serve gluten-free pizza in Fort Collins?
Yes, several restaurants cater to gluten-free diners. MOD Pizza, Otto Pint, and Beau Jo’s all offer gluten-free or cauliflower crust options, so you won’t miss out on any flavor.
What’s the must-try local specialty pizza in Fort Collins?
Try a Colorado-style “mountain pie” with honey in the crust at Beau Jo’s, or go big with Krazy Karl’s Veggie Supreme. For pizza with a twist, the roasted mushroom pie at Otto Pint gets a lot of local love.
Are there pizza places near Colorado State University?
Many. Krazy Karl’s (Elizabeth Street), Pizza Casbah, and Slyce Pizza Co are popular with students for their proximity and huge slices.