Navigating the world of pizza in Florence, SC can be both exciting and overwhelming. Having spent years exploring local eateries and savoring their specialties, I can confidently say that the city offers a surprising variety of options that cater to all tastes. From thin-crust classics to inventive wood-fired pies, Florence’s pizzerias hold something for everyone—whether you’re craving a quick bite or a sit-down feast.
What sets Florence apart is its commitment to quality and authentic flavors, ensuring that each slice delivers a memorable experience. This guide is crafted to help you discover the best pizza spots in town—places where tradition meets innovation and every bite is worth savoring. Dive in to find your next favorite pizza joint and enjoy the true taste of Florence, South Carolina.
Where to find the best pizza in Florence, SC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Florence, SC:
- Domino’s Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza
- Mellow Mushroom Florence
- Primo Pizza
- Fox’s Pizza Den
- Pizza Hut
- Stefano’s Pizza Restaurant
- Papa John’s Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
1. Domino’s Pizza
Nestled on Pamplico Highway, Domino’s Pizza in Florence is a reliable choice for those seeking satisfying, hot pizza on the go. Having ordered from their location many times, I appreciate how consistently they deliver fresh, flavorful slices. Their variety ensures every craving is met, whether it’s a classic New York-style thin crust or a hearty Handmade Pan pizza.
What sets Domino’s apart is their commitment to value and convenience. Their special deal on two medium, two-topping pizzas for $6.99 each makes it easy to enjoy quality pizza without overspending. For a true taste of their approach, try the Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza—rich, cheesy, and satisfying. Pair it with a salad or wings for a complete meal that reflects their dedication to flavor and freshness.
2. Marco’s Pizza
Located on South Cashua Drive, Marco’s Pizza in Florence stands out for its commitment to authentic Italian pizza. Having sampled their offerings, I can attest that their dough is made fresh daily, resulting in a truly flavorful base. Their unique three-cheese blend and secret sauce recipe have kept fans coming back since 1978.
What makes Marco’s special is its focus on quality ingredients and traditional methods. I recommend trying the Deluxe Italian Pizza—it’s a perfect balance of savory toppings and crisp crust that exemplifies their style. For a hearty, satisfying meal, pairing it with their signature pasta or a family-sized sandwich makes for an enjoyable, true-to-Italy dining experience right in Florence.
3. Mellow Mushroom Florence
Located on Dunbarton Drive, Mellow Mushroom in Florence offers a vibrant, creative take on pizza. I’ve enjoyed their unique stone-baked pies, which are beautifully crafted and full of bold flavors. Their menu extends beyond pizza, featuring fresh salads, wings, and craft beers, making it perfect for a relaxed dining experience or takeout.
What makes Mellow Mushroom stand out is its commitment to quality ingredients and inventive toppings. I recommend trying their Kerro Tuscan Pesto Pizza—a delightful combination of fresh pesto, mozzarella, and house-made toppings that embodies their creative spirit. Whether dining in or ordering for home, it’s a place that elevates pizza to a higher culinary level in Florence.
4. Primo Pizza
Located on David H Mcleod Boulevard, Primo Pizza in Florence offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with consistently good pizza. Having enjoyed their simple yet flavorful pies, I appreciate their focus on traditional recipes combined with quality ingredients. Their menu features a variety of options suited for all tastes.
What makes Primo Pizza stand out is their commitment to delivering a satisfying experience without over-the-top embellishments. The Classic Margherita Pizza is a highlight—crisp, fresh, and perfectly balanced. For a hearty meal, their specialty pizzas showcase how well they blend tradition and flavor, making it a reliable choice for pizza lovers in Florence.
5. Fox’s Pizza Den
Situated on 2nd Loop Road, Fox’s Pizza Den in Florence offers a family-friendly environment with a diverse menu that extends beyond traditional pizza. I’ve enjoyed their generous portions and friendly service, making it a reliable spot for both dine-in and takeout. Their menu showcases a blend of Italian, European, and American flavors.
What sets Fox’s apart is their emphasis on variety and quality. For a truly satisfying meal, I recommend the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which combines spicy and savory flavors, or their classic Cheese Pizza for a straightforward, well-made slice. Their commitment to good value and a broad selection makes this a go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts in Florence.
6. Pizza Hut
Located on Irby Street, Pizza Hut in Florence is a familiar name for those craving classic American-style pizza. I’ve ordered from here multiple times, appreciating their consistent quality and friendly service. Their menu offers hearty options for every member of the family, including wings, pastas, and desserts.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is their signature Original Stuffed Crust Pizza, delivering cheesy goodness with every bite. For a more traditional choice, the Meat Lovers® Pizza showcases their generous toppings and flavorful crust. Whether for delivery or carryout, Pizza Hut remains a dependable spot for satisfying your pizza cravings in Florence.
7. Stefano’s Pizza Restaurant
On South Irby Street, Stefano’s Pizza Restaurant has been a cornerstone of Florence’s culinary scene since 1988. I’ve enjoyed their hand-tossed pizzas, which exemplify authentic Italian craftsmanship, combined with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Their menu is rich with Sicilian dishes and American favorites, reflecting a true blend of heritage and flavor.
What sets Stefano’s apart is their dedication to quality ingredients like imported meats, fine cheeses, and robust Italian seasonings. The Chicken Parmigiana is a classic favorite, but for a true Italian experience, try their Gnocchi Riscoprita. Each dish offers a taste of Italy that’s both hearty and authentic, making Stefano’s a must-visit for fans of traditional Italian cuisine in Florence.
8. Papa John’s Pizza
Located on Cherokee Road, Papa John’s Pizza in Florence emphasizes quality ingredients and a commitment to delivering a superior pizza experience. I’ve ordered from here several times, always impressed by their consistent freshness and flavorful toppings. Their signature sauce truly sets their pies apart.
What makes Papa John’s distinctive is their focus on premium ingredients, from freshly made dough to quality toppings. For a classic choice, try their Extravaganza Pizza, packed with meats and vegetables, or a simple Cheese Pizza for a satisfying, no-frills option. Whether for a family meal or a quick order, Papa John’s provides a dependable, tasty option in Florence.
9. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Located inside Oakland Grocery, Hunt Brothers Pizza in Florence offers a convenient and customizable pizza experience. I’ve enjoyed their wide selection of fresh toppings, which are included at no extra charge, making it easy to craft the perfect pie.
What sets Hunt Brothers apart is their commitment to quality and flexibility. For a simple yet satisfying choice, the Classic Cheese Pizza is a reliable favorite. If you like to get creative, assembling your own masterpiece with unlimited toppings truly highlights their “All Toppings No Extra Charge” promise. Perfect for a quick, flavorful meal, Hunt Brothers provides a solid option for pizza lovers in Florence.
10. Little Caesars Pizza
On 2nd Loop Road, Little Caesars Pizza in Florence is known for its quick service and affordable prices. I’ve ordered their hot-N-ready pizzas a few times, appreciating the convenience and consistent quality. Their focus on fast, basic pizza options makes them a reliable choice for a casual meal.
What stands out about Little Caesars is their signature ExtraMostBestelling Pepperoni Pizza, offering a generous amount of quality toppings at a great value. For a quick, satisfying bite, their Classic Cheese Pizza or deep dish options reflect their reputation for speedy, no-fuss pizza delivery. It’s perfect for when time and budget are top priorities.
More Things to Try in Florence, SC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best restaurant for authentic Italian pizza in Florence, SC?
A: Stefano’s Pizza Restaurant is known for its hand-tossed pies, imported ingredients, and traditional Sicilian dishes, making it a top choice for authentic Italian pizza.
Q: Which pizza places in Florence offer the best deal or discounts?
A: Domino’s frequently has promos like two medium, two-topping pizzas for $6.99 each. Keep an eye on specials from other chains like Papa John’s and Little Caesars for budget-friendly options.
Q: Are there vegetarian pizza options in Florence?
A: Yes, most places like Mellow Mushroom and Fox’s Pizza Den offer vegetarian-friendly pies, salads, and toppings to suit different preferences.
Q: Can I get gluten-free pizza in Florence?
A: Some locations like Pizza Hut and Mellow Mushroom provide gluten-free crusts, but it’s best to call ahead and confirm availability.
Q: What local pizzerias are family-friendly?
A: Primo Pizza, Stefano’s, and Fox’s Pizza Den are known for welcoming environments suitable for family outings.