There’s something about the aroma of pizza floating through the streets of Florence, AL that just grabs you. Maybe it’s the blend of freshly baked crust or the way the cheese bubbles at the edges, but finding the best slice here feels less like a search and more like a happy adventure. If you love that first bite—where the flavors hit just right—then you’ll want to know where I’ve found the real standouts.
Florence may be known for its music roots and riverfront views, but its pizza scene is seriously underrated. I spent a few weekends following the trail from buzzing local favorites to the spots you drive past day after day, trying every style from thin and crispy to hearty deep-dish. Trust me, not all pizzas are created equal in this town. This list narrows down the places where the slices speak for themselves, and where every topping is given special respect. Ready to find out who makes the best pizza in Florence? You might discover a new favorite before you’ve finished reading.
Where to find the best pizza in Florence, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Florence, AL:
- The Pie Factory
- Ricatonis
- Lil Capones Italian Bar and Grill
- Godfather’s Pizza
- The Rising Crust Pizza and Hops
- Pizza Chef
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Cicis Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
1. The Pie Factory
Step into The Pie Factory and you get the feeling that pizza is more than just food—it’s a craft. This casual spot in downtown Florence has a knack for combining tradition with bold, new flavors. Whether you’re a classic cheese lover or in the mood for something more daring, you’ll find a pie that grabs your attention.
What really sets The Pie Factory apart is its creative menu and attention to detail. The crust is that perfect mix of chewy and crisp, easily holding a wild variety of fresh toppings. If you want a real taste of Florence, order the “Sweet Heat”—its balance of savory and spice is a local legend.
With plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options, everyone can find something to crave here. Table service is relaxed but attentive. For a laid-back dinner or a lunch that feels special, this place won’t let you down.
2. Ricatonis
Ricatoni’s is a fixture on Court Street, where the scent of baking dough pulls you in long before you reach the door. The moody lighting and brick walls make every meal here feel like a special occasion, even on a regular Wednesday night. It’s the sort of place that feels alive, always buzzing—perfect for a casual dinner or late-night craving.
Their thin-crust pizza is a big reason Ricatoni’s stays packed. The dough, made fresh daily, has just the right balance of crunch and chew. My go-to has always been the Margherita, topped with sweet tomatoes and fresh basil. You can taste the care in every bite.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free eaters will all find easy options here. The menu welcomes groups large and small, and service never feels rushed. For pizza with character and a side of Florence charm, Ricatoni’s is a must.
3. Lil Capones Italian Bar and Grill
With its cozy booths and vintage mobster touches, Lil Capones Italian Bar and Grill brings a little old-school flair to Florence. There’s a friendly energy here, with staff who seem to know half their customers by name. You can tell Lil Capones takes pride in serving up comfort food with personality.
Their pizza is all about a hearty, hand-tossed crust and toppings piled on thick. It’s the sort of pie you need two hands for. The Veggie Pizza stands out, loaded with fresh peppers and mushrooms—proof that simple can taste amazing when it’s done right.
It’s a solid pick for lunch or dinner when you want a break from downtown’s bustle. If you like a warm, welcoming feel and pizza that satisfies, Lil Capones won’t disappoint.
4. Godfather’s Pizza
Godfather’s Pizza on Mall Road feels like stepping into a retro pizza parlor, where nostalgia meets serious flavor. The atmosphere is laid-back, with booths perfect for sharing a meal with friends or family. There’s a simplicity here that makes the focus all about the food.
Godfather’s thick, chewy crust is a classic in Florence, and they don’t skimp on the cheese or sauce. The Veggie pizza is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with crisp peppers, onions, and ripe tomatoes over a satisfying base. Every slice promises a balanced bite—it’s not just hefty, it’s hearty.
If you want a place where pizza is the main event, Godfather’s delivers. Stop in for lunch or wind down with a cozy dinner. It’s a tradition worth repeating.
5. The Rising Crust Pizza and Hops
The Rising Crust Pizza and Hops brings fresh energy to the Florence pizza scene. This spot has a cool, modern vibe with friendly table service that makes you want to stay a while. I’ve lingered over meals here with friends, sampling their inventive pies and catching up—each visit feels both lively and relaxed.
The magic at Rising Crust is in the dough—airy, flavorful, and baked just right to offer a gentle crunch. Their “Garden Delight” pizza is a smart pick; it’s loaded with fresh spinach, tomatoes, and mushrooms, making each bite bright and memorable.
Whether you stop by for a quick bite or hang out for dinner, The Rising Crust’s mix of creative pizzas and easy atmosphere will keep you coming back.
6. Pizza Chef
Pizza Chef is a local favorite that keeps things straightforward and satisfying. The unassuming storefront hides a kitchen that knows its way around dough and sauce. I’ve grabbed takeout here on the way home—every time, those first few bites remind you that comfort food doesn’t need a big fuss.
What makes Pizza Chef stand out is their commitment to consistency and flavor. Each pizza comes out with a golden crust that’s soft inside and lightly crisp on the outside. Their Veggie pizza is generously loaded, a hit with anyone in the mood for a flavorful, meatless pie.
This is the place for those craving honest, well-made pizza. Dine in, have it delivered, or pick up takeout—it’s simple, good, and always hits the spot.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Mall Road is that dependable choice when you want no surprises, just consistently tasty pizza. After a long day, there’s something especially comforting about that familiar green box and the aroma of their classic pies. Pick-up is quick, and delivery always arrives hot—which I’ve come to appreciate more times than I’ll admit.
Papa Johns stands out for its soft, chewy crust and signature tomato sauce with a gentle tang. The Garden Fresh pizza is a great way to taste the freshness they promise, packed with peppers, onions, and crisp vegetables. Each slice feels balanced and satisfying.
It’s perfect for family nights or low-key gatherings. If you want a classic pizza that never disappoints, Papa Johns does the trick every time.
8. Cicis Pizza
+1 256-765-2424
Cicis Pizza offers something you don’t always find in Florence: a pizza buffet that lets you pick and choose as much as you like. It’s the spot for group lunches and family dinners where everyone wants something a little different. I’ve lost count of the times I’ve swung by for a quick slice and ended up staying for another round.
The main appeal at Cicis is variety—there’s always a new combination to try, and the staff keeps the pizzas coming hot and fresh. Their Veggie pizza, with plenty of peppers and mushrooms, is always a safe bet. And if you want something specific, they’ll make it for you on the spot.
If you want a casual, wallet-friendly meal that keeps the options open, Cicis is an easy pick. Go for the buffet and let your cravings decide.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Darby Drive is many people’s go-to for pizza that shows up on time and never lets you down. I’ve used their easy online ordering after a long week, and the process always feels smooth and fast. If you want your meal exactly how you like it, Domino’s gets it right every time.
Their thin-crust and Handmade Pan pizzas are crowd favorites, thanks to a crust that’s crisp without being dry and plenty of melty cheese. Their Pacific Veggie pizza combines roasted veggies and a tasty tomato base, making it a standout choice for anyone looking to go meatless.
With late hours and consistent quality, Domino’s is perfect for those nights when you want good pizza with zero hassle. It’s comfort food for any day of the week.
10. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Cox Creek Parkway is a familiar beacon for anyone seeking a classic slice. I’ve ducked in before movie nights and big game days, drawn by the glow of that red roof and the promise of mouthwatering pizza. There’s something a little nostalgic about a place that’s been a staple for years.
Pizza Hut’s pan pizzas deliver on that famous buttery crust—crisp along the edges, soft in the middle, and reliably cheesy with each bite. Their Veggie Lover’s is always generous with toppings and gives that satisfying, loaded feel without being heavy.
It’s hard to argue with the comfort of the classics. With quick service and lots of menu variety, Pizza Hut is a staple for pizza fans who want old favorites made right.
More Things to Try in Florence, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Florence, AL?
Some favorites include The Pie Factory, Ricatonis, Lil Capones Italian Bar and Grill, and The Rising Crust Pizza and Hops. You’ll also find solid options at well-known chains like Papa Johns and Domino’s.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza choices in Florence?
Yes, many spots such as The Pie Factory, Ricatonis, and Cicis Pizza offer vegetarian pizzas, and some provide vegan or gluten-free options so everyone can have a slice.
Which pizza place in Florence is best for families?
Cicis Pizza is popular for family dining thanks to its buffet, while Pizza Hut and Godfather’s Pizza offer laid-back atmospheres and menu variety that suit all ages.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Florence?
Absolutely. The Pie Factory and Ricatonis both serve gluten-free pizza crusts. Be sure to mention any dietary needs when you order for the best experience.
Is delivery available from local pizzerias?
Most pizzerias in Florence, including Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Chef, offer delivery. Many places also provide online ordering and takeout for convenience.