Looking for the best pizza in Floral Park, NY turns into quite an adventure the moment you step onto Tulip Avenue or wander the side streets. This corner of Long Island doesn’t settle for mediocre pies; it’s a place where families debate the merits of thin crusts, and every shop claims their sauce is the secret. You’ll spot groups huddled in glowing storefronts on any night, arguing about which crust reigns supreme, fork poised, ready to settle things the only way that matters: another bite.
Personally, after chasing slices throughout the neighborhood—sometimes late at night, sometimes for lunch breaks—I can tell you, this area knows pizza. Expect classic New York folds, Sicilian cubes, and the occasional menu wild card. If you’ve ever wanted to settle the debate over which pizzeria deserves your loyalty, stick around. What follows is a guide grounded in real experience, local buzz, and more than a few taste tests. The search for great pizza in Floral Park is shorter than you think—if you know where to look.
Where to find the best pizza in Floral Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Floral Park, NY:
- Ciros Of Floral Park Inc
- Village Pizzeria
- Hi-Class Pizza
- Vaccaro’s Pizzeria & Trattoria
- Bellerose Famous Pizza
- Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
- Tiberio Inc.
- Kiran Pizza Express
- Ciros Pizza
- Italian Affair Pizza & Restaurant
1. Ciros Of Floral Park Inc
Ciros Of Floral Park Inc takes the classic neighborhood pizzeria up a notch. With cozy seating and a casual vibe, it’s the spot where locals linger for extra slices. The service feels like being invited into someone’s home—one reason regulars keep coming back.
What makes Ciros stand out is their dough: it’s got that perfect snap and chew, every time. The cheese pulls, the sauce balances sweetness with spice, and you can see why their pies fly out the door.
If you’re not sure what to order, go for the classic Margherita or their signature Sicilian slice. Each bite captures what real New York pizza should taste like—rich, aromatic, and just a little addictive.
2. Village Pizzeria
Village Pizzeria sits right on Tulip Ave, but its roots reach deep—thanks to the same family who started the original Umberto’s of New Hyde Park. This spot radiates warmth and gets busy fast, but service always feels personal. Every slice has that classic New York fold and flavor.
The signature here is their Sicilian pie: golden-edged, airy, and with a hidden depth from a slow-rise dough. Their Grandma slice has a loyal following for its rustic, garlicky punch and crisp bite.
Feeling adventurous? Their specialty pies, like Broccoli Rabe and White Pizza, always spark curiosity. Village Pizzeria is a must for anyone craving pizza crafted with history and genuine flair.
3. Hi-Class Pizza
Hi-Class Pizza is a friendly old-school spot that delivers on its name without any fuss. The inviting aroma hits before you even step inside, and you’ll catch families grabbing lunch or folks sneaking in for a quick dinner. Service is fast, and there’s an effortless charm to the way they do things here.
Each pizza is made with care, featuring a crust with a subtle crisp and toppings always loaded just right—not soggy, never skimpy. The sauce leans savory, with a hint of sweetness, making every bite balanced and satisfying.
Start with the Neapolitan round pie if it’s your first visit—it sets the standard for what Hi-Class does best. Hi-Class Pizza reflects everything that neighborhood pizza should: generous, consistent, and always on point.
4. Vaccaro’s Pizzeria & Trattoria
Vaccaro’s Pizzeria & Trattoria balances neighborhood charm with a broad menu, making it a go-to for locals who want more than just a quick slice. It’s hard not to relax here, whether waiting for takeout or settling in for dinner. The staff keeps things moving, and the kitchen turns out pies with impressive speed and consistency.
The real treat is their wood-fired pizza, which brings a subtle smokiness to the crust. The Margherita stands out, with fresh mozzarella and basil that really showcase the classic flavors. Even the plain cheese slice is clearly crafted with care.
If you’re ready to try something a little different, the Veggie pie here comes loaded with crisp vegetables and just the right amount of cheese. Vaccaro’s is perfect when you want pizza with a little extra character.
5. Bellerose Famous Pizza
Bellerose Famous Pizza is one of those places that keeps things simple—and gets it right every time. Its classic menu draws a steady stream of locals, all drawn by the promise of a no-frills, satisfying pie. The energy inside is always relaxed, and it’s easy to see why so many make this their pizza stop.
Their hand-tossed crust is the real star, thin yet sturdy, holding just enough sauce and cheese for the perfect bite. Everything tastes fresh, and you can tell they value consistency.
For a true sample of their style, try their regular cheese or go for the white pizza with a ricotta finish. Bellerose Famous Pizza captures the spirit of neighborhood pizza done right.
6. Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc sits just outside Floral Park but feels right at home in any local pizza roundup. Stepping inside, you’ll find a family-friendly vibe and a menu rooted in tradition. The chefs here blend old-school recipes with local ingredients, so every pie comes out with personality and depth.
Their signature slice starts with a handmade dough, airy yet crisp, topped with a sauce that hints at fresh herbs. Whether you’re here for lunch or dinner, you’ll notice their pizzas compete with the best in the area.
Try their Margherita or the Veggie Lover’s pie—they reflect Genovese’s balance of quality and classic flavors. Genovese Pizzeria is where lasting favorites meet a few modern touches, all coming together in a cozy spot you’ll want to revisit.
7. Tiberio Inc.
(516) 775-0612Call
Tiberio Inc. is tucked along Tulip Ave, making it a convenient stop for Floral Park pizza seekers. The feel here is classic: cozy booths, friendly conversations, and pizza served hot without pretension. It’s the type of place you stumble into once and end up coming back to on instinct.
What sets Tiberio apart is their crust—always golden and never greasy, it plays the perfect foundation for a range of fresh toppings. Their sauce leans more savory, adding a taste that feels refreshingly simple.
The plain cheese slice is reliable, but their veggie pie gives you an extra layer of flavor, crispness, and color. Tiberio Inc. checks all the boxes for authentic, no-nonsense pizza in a laid-back setting.
8. Kiran Pizza Express
(516) 616-0110Call
Kiran Pizza Express may not have the flashiest exterior, but it quickly earns a spot on your list once you’ve tried a slice. This place always feels upbeat, whether you’re popping in for lunch or grabbing dinner to go. The kitchen turns out pies with a focus on freshness and quick service.
The best part about Kiran is their versatile crust, which finds the sweet spot between crispy edges and a soft center. The sauce-to-cheese ratio is thoughtfully balanced, so the flavor never feels muddled.
Classic cheese or their veggie pizza are both strong contenders, showing off Kiran’s straightforward, no-nonsense approach. Kiran Pizza Express is the choice if you want reliable quality without any fuss.
9. Ciros Pizza
Ciros Pizza delivers what every neighborhood pie shop should—bold flavor, familiar faces, and a menu that repeats the classics for a reason. Walk in and you’ll probably spot a regular or two catching up over a hot slice. The staff remembers names, and the aroma is always spot-on.
The crust here deserves special mention: never too thick, just enough give, and perfectly charred underneath. Ciros keeps their toppings fresh, and they never skimp on the cheese.
If you want the real experience, choose a classic plain slice or venture for their white pizza, which is both rich and mellow. Ciros Pizza stands out for consistent quality and a touch of old-school charm that’s hard to beat.
10. Italian Affair Pizza & Restaurant
(718) 352-4428Call
Italian Affair Pizza & Restaurant blends hometown comfort with a dash of old-world tradition. The laid-back atmosphere makes it a great choice for family dinners or quick lunches. Service is welcoming, and you’ll sense right away why this spot has loyal regulars.
Their pizza features a crisp, golden crust paired with a tangy sauce that strikes a nice balance—not too sweet, never bland. Every ingredient tastes fresh, which is something you notice bite after bite.
Test the waters with their plain slice, or dive into a veggie pie that really lets their produce shine. Italian Affair Pizza delivers consistency, reliable flavor, and the kind of neighborhood charm you want from your favorite pizzeria.
More Things to Try in Floral Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some of the best pizza places in Floral Park, NY?
Some standout options include Ciros Of Floral Park Inc, Village Pizzeria, Hi-Class Pizza, and Vaccaro’s Pizzeria & Trattoria. Each offers a different twist on classic New York-style pizza, with loyal neighborhood followings.
Where can I find the best Sicilian pizza in Floral Park?
Village Pizzeria has gained a reputation for its thick, golden-edged Sicilian slices. Ciros also serves a Sicilian pie that’s worth a try if you love this style.
Do local Floral Park pizzerias offer vegetarian or veggie pizza?
Absolutely. Most shops—including Ciros, Vaccaro’s, and Italian Affair Pizza—offer veggie pies made with a mix of fresh toppings and classic sauces.
Is delivery available from Floral Park pizza restaurants?
Yes, many local spots provide delivery and takeout. It’s always a good idea to check each pizzeria’s website or call ahead to confirm service areas and timings.
What pizza styles are popular in Floral Park?
New York thin crust, Sicilian, Grandma, and specialty pies are all local favorites. Most pizzerias will have a few signature options highlighting their take on these classics.