Finding the best pizza in Fayetteville, NC, is a delightful journey through a city that takes its Italian roots seriously. Over the years, I’ve tasted slices from a variety of places, and each has its own unique charm—from thin-crust perfection to hearty, cheesy pies. Fayetteville’s pizza scene offers both classic favorites and inventive creations that cater to every craving. It’s no surprise that locals are passionate about their pizza; after all, good pizza isn’t just food—it’s an experience.
Of course, not all pies are created equal, and choosing the right spot can feel overwhelming with so many options. That’s where I come in. With a keen eye for quality and a palate that appreciates genuine flavors, I’ve mapped out the top pizzerias in Fayetteville. So whether you’re craving traditional Italian-style pies or something with a modern twist, this guide promises to steer you toward the very best slices the city has to offer.
Where to find the best pizza in Fayetteville, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fayetteville, NC:
- Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
- MOD Pizza
- Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant
- Brooklyn Pizza
- Elizabeth’s Pizza
- Pizza Palace Restaurant
- Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Pierros Italian Bistro
- Old Chicago
- Cicis Pizza
1. Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville offers a unique dining experience with its creatively inspired stone-baked pizzas. Located at 301 N McPherson Church Rd, this spot is perfect for enjoying a meal in a vibrant atmosphere, whether you’re dining indoors or relaxing on the patio. The menu caters to a variety of dietary preferences with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.
What sets Mellow Mushroom apart is its commitment to quality and creativity. Each pizza is crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring a delightful blend of flavors in every bite. The Funky Q. Chicken Pizza, with its BBQ chicken, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese, is a must-try and perfectly embodies the restaurant’s inventive approach to traditional dishes.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville promises a memorable experience with its warm service and delicious menu offerings. Be sure to pair your meal with one of their craft beers or cocktails to complete your visit.
2. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza Fayetteville, nestled along Skibo Road, turns every visit into a personalized experience. With over 40 fresh toppings and a flat price for any combination, this spot is built for creative pizza lovers. The team behind the counter—the MOD Squad—brings real energy and care to each handcrafted pie.
What makes MOD stand out is its flexible menu and consistent quality. Whether you prefer a cauliflower crust or a classic gluten-friendly base, the freedom to design your own pizza is refreshing. I’ve crafted some surprising combinations here, and they always nail it. The Mad Dog—featuring red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, and ground beef—is a solid starting point if you’re after something bold and balanced.
Alongside your custom pizza, their crisp salads and vegan-friendly options make MOD Pizza approachable for everyone. For fast, flavorful pies that cater to your taste without compromise, MOD gets it right.
3. Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant
Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant brings a slice of tradition to Fayetteville with its cozy, family-run atmosphere and classic Italian fare. Tucked into Walter Reed Road, this spot has become a local favorite for those who appreciate hearty portions and warm hospitality. The setting is relaxed, making it ideal for both casual dinners and family gatherings.
What makes Little Italy stand out is its dedication to authentic flavors. The pizzas are generously topped and baked to a golden finish. I still remember my first bite of their Little Italy Special—a loaded pie with fresh vegetables and savory meats that struck the perfect balance of texture and taste.
For something comforting, try the Spaghetti Little Italy Style or the Chicken Stromboli. These dishes reflect the kitchen’s commitment to quality and tradition. With vegetarian-friendly options and attentive service, Little Italy delivers a consistently satisfying experience.
4. Brooklyn Pizza
Brooklyn Pizza on Ramsey Street captures the authentic spirit of New York with its pizza offerings and warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its tasty, generously topped pies, this spot caters to both lunch and dinner crowds looking for a quick, satisfying meal. The restaurant also features convenient delivery and takeout options, making it easy to enjoy their signature slices at home.
I recall trying their classic New York-Style Pepperoni Pizza. The crust was perfectly chewy, and the cheese had that rich, gooey texture unique to Brooklyn-style pies. It’s clear they focus on quality ingredients and traditional techniques, which makes every bite memorable.
Beyond pizza, Brooklyn Pizza offers vegetarian options and a friendly, efficient service team. For a taste of authentic Brooklyn-style pizza in Fayetteville, this place is a reliable and flavorful choice.
5. Elizabeth’s Pizza
Elizabeth’s Pizza has earned a reputation as Fayetteville’s go-to for authentic Italian flavors, combining superior ingredients and time-honored techniques. With over 30 years of experience, this family-friendly restaurant focuses on creating hand-crafted meals that reflect passion and tradition. Its welcoming atmosphere makes it ideal for a relaxed lunch or dinner.
During my visit, I enjoyed their classic Margherita Pizza, with its fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and perfectly melted cheese—an experience that truly reflects their commitment to quality. Every bite showcases their focus on freshness and attention to detail.
From hearty pasta dishes to flavorful salads, Elizabeth’s Pizza combines tradition with personal care. If you’re seeking genuine Italian pizza in Fayetteville, this spot delivers consistent excellence every time.
6. Pizza Palace Restaurant
If you’re in Fayetteville, NC and craving authentic Italian flavors, Pizza Palace Restaurant on Hope Mills Rd is a must-visit. This cozy, family-owned spot has a warm, welcoming vibe that makes you feel right at home the moment you walk in.
What sets Pizza Palace apart is its commitment to quality and tradition. The menu is packed with classic Italian dishes, but it’s their hand-tossed pizzas that really shine. The crust is just the right balance of crispy and chewy, topped with rich sauce and fresh ingredients.
During my visit, I tried the Veggie Pizza—loaded with mushrooms, peppers, olives, and onions. It was a flavorful, satisfying option that truly showcased their fresh toppings. For a hearty bite, try their Cheese Pizza—simple, but incredibly well done.
Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, Pizza Palace delivers comfort, flavor, and family-style hospitality every time.
7. Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria
Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria offers an authentic taste of Italy right in Fayetteville. Located at 2711 Raeford Rd, this women-owned and veteran-owned establishment features real wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas crafted by a VPN-certified chef. Each dish is made from scratch, from pastas to desserts, ensuring genuine flavors in every bite.
During my visit, I was captivated by their Margherita Pizza, with its perfectly blistered crust, fresh basil, and rich tomato sauce—a true representation of Neapolitan tradition. The attention to detail and quality ingredients elevate the dining experience.
Gusto also hosts exciting events like the Grand Tour of Italy dinners and offers cooking classes, making it more than just a restaurant. For an authentic and memorable Italian meal, Gusto Napoletano stands out as Fayetteville’s premier destination.
8. Pierros Italian Bistro
Nestled in the heart of downtown Fayetteville, Pierros Italian Bistro blends rustic charm with a touch of upscale flair. The exposed brick walls and vintage hardwoods set the tone for a cozy yet refined dining experience. Whether you’re seated in the main bistro or upstairs at the Sky Lounge, the ambiance feels thoughtfully curated.
What sets Pierros apart is its balance of tradition and creativity. Their wood-fired pizzas are a highlight—thin, crisp, and generously topped. The Classic Margherita is a must-try, with its vibrant tomato base and fresh basil, while the Pierro’s Special layers savory vegetables and premium cheese in perfect harmony.
Service is attentive, and the menu caters to a range of dietary needs with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. It’s a spot that invites you to linger.
9. Old Chicago
Old Chicago on Skibo Road offers a lively atmosphere perfect for casual dining. Known for its diverse menu and welcoming vibe, it’s a favorite for families and friends looking for a satisfying meal. The restaurant carefully accommodates dietary preferences with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options.
What makes Old Chicago stand out is its wide variety of pizzas, crafted with quality ingredients. I recommend trying their Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza, which features a thick, flaky crust loaded with savory toppings—a true Chicago classic. Alternatively, the Thin Crust options are equally delicious for a lighter bite.
Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Old Chicago provides flavorful food and friendly service, making it a reliable choice for pizza lovers in Fayetteville.
10. Cicis Pizza
If you’re craving endless pizza and family-friendly vibes, Cicis Pizza in Fayetteville is a must-visit. Located at 7760 Good Middling Dr, this spot offers a budget-friendly buffet that never skimps on flavor. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh-baked pizza welcomes you like a warm hug.
On a recent visit, the staff greeted us with smiles, and the buffet was constantly refreshed with hot, delicious options. The Mac & Cheese Pizza was surprisingly satisfying—a fun twist that shows Cicis’ creative side. Their Zesty Pepperoni and Spinach Alfredo pizzas are flavorful favorites, perfect for any pizza lover.
Don’t miss the fresh salad bar and cinnamon rolls for dessert. At Cicis, it’s not just a meal—it’s a fun experience.
More Things to Try in Fayetteville, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best halal pizza places in Fayetteville, NC?
While not all pizza restaurants may be halal-certified, some local spots offer halal-friendly options or allow customizations to avoid non-halal ingredients. Check with restaurants like Petra Pizza or local Mediterranean-style eateries that may serve halal pizza or offer suitable alternatives.
2. Are there any pizza places in Fayetteville that offer vegetarian options?
Yes! Most pizza restaurants in Fayetteville, including national chains like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and local spots like Brooklyn Pizzeria, offer a variety of vegetarian pizzas. You can also customize your own pizza with fresh veggie toppings and cheese.
3. Which pizza places in Fayetteville offer delivery?
Many pizza places offer delivery through apps like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub, as well as through their own websites. Popular delivery options include:
– Marco’s Pizza
– Papa John’s
– Domino’s
– Brooklyn Pizzeria (limited delivery areas)
4. Where can I find New York-style pizza in Fayetteville, NC?
For authentic New York-style pizza, check out:
– Brooklyn Pizzeria
– Elizabeth’s Pizza
– Napoli Pizzeria
These spots are known for their thin, foldable slices and rich flavor.
5. Are there any pizza restaurants in Fayetteville that offer gluten-free crusts?
Yes! Restaurants like Mellow Mushroom and Domino’s Pizza offer gluten-free crust options. Always double-check with the staff to ensure your dietary needs are met.
6. What are some family-friendly pizza spots in Fayetteville?
Great options for families include:
– Mellow Mushroom – fun atmosphere and diverse menu
– Cici’s Pizza – affordable buffet with kid-friendly choices
– Pizza Hut – familiar and consistent experience
7. Can I find any pizza buffets in Fayetteville?
Yes! Cici’s Pizza is well-known for its all-you-can-eat pizza buffet, offering a variety of classic and custom flavors, pasta, and desserts.
8. What are the most popular local pizza restaurants in Fayetteville, NC?
Some local favorites include:
– Brooklyn Pizzeria – known for its authentic NY-style slices
– Elizabeth’s Pizza – Italian-American menu with great pizza
– Napoli Pizzeria – cozy spot with handmade dough and fresh ingredients
9. Are there places to get pizza late at night in Fayetteville?
Yes, several pizza restaurants stay open late, especially on weekends. Options include:
– Domino’s (open until midnight or later)
– Papa John’s
– Some local spots on delivery apps may also offer late-night service.
10. How can I avoid haram ingredients when ordering pizza?
To avoid haram items:
– Skip pork-based toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and bacon
– Choose vegetarian or seafood options
– Ask for halal meat if available
– Double-check sauces and ingredients (avoid alcohol-based or pork-derived items)