Finding a great slice of pizza can feel like discovering a hidden gem, especially in a vibrant place like Fayetteville, AR. Over the years, I’ve explored countless pizzerias—from cozy locally-owned spots to lively chain restaurants—and each visit has revealed something unique about the city’s pizza scene. It’s not just about cheese and crust; it’s about the atmosphere, the fresh ingredients, and the passion behind every pie. Fayetteville’s diverse options impress even the most discerning pizza lovers.
This guide aims to help you navigate the best pizza spots in town, whether you’re craving a classic slice or something more inventive. With so many choices, it can be overwhelming, but I’ve carefully selected places that stand out for their quality, flavor, and authenticity. Rest assured, whether you’re a fan of Chicago deep dish or New York-style thin crust, Fayetteville’s pizza scene has something to satisfy every palate. Dive in, and discover your new favorite pizza spot in Fayetteville, Arkansas.
Where to find the best pizza in Fayetteville, AR
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fayetteville, AR:
- Wood Stone Craft Pizza
- Bocca Italian Eatery & Pizzeria
- Geraldi’s
- Marley’s Chicago Style Pizzeria
- Tiny Tim’s Pizza
- Tim’s Pizza East
- Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
- Wood Stone Craft Pizza
- Gusano’s Chicago Style Pizzeria
- Wicked Wood Fired Pizza
1. Wood Stone Craft Pizza
Located at 557 South School Avenue, Wood Stone Craft Pizza is a locally owned gem in Fayetteville. Known for its creative pizzas and welcoming atmosphere, this pizzeria offers a delightful variety of tasty appetizers, fresh salads, and great drinks. Despite current curbside and delivery-only services, the quality and craftsmanship remain top-notch.
What sets Wood Stone apart is its commitment to quality ingredients and inventive flavors. I recommend trying their signature pizzas, which often feature unique toppings and perfectly crisp crusts. Their vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options ensure there’s something for everyone, reflecting their dedication to inclusivity and flavor. It’s a perfect spot to enjoy a slice that’s both satisfying and crafted with care.
2. Bocca Italian Eatery & Pizzeria
Tucked away at 2036 North College Avenue, Bocca Italian Eatery & Pizzeria offers an authentic taste of Italy with every dish. From house-made pastas to wood-fired pizzas, this restaurant emphasizes fresh ingredients and traditional techniques. Your dinner experience begins at 5 p.m. and lasts into the night, with a welcoming atmosphere and an extensive drink menu featuring local brews, wine, and cocktails.
What makes Bocca stand out is its commitment to quality and authenticity. I suggest trying the classic Margherita pizza topped with fresh mozzarella and basil, baked in their wood-fired oven until perfectly charred. Their house-made sauces and breads further showcase their dedication to craftsmanship, making every bite a true reflection of Italian culinary tradition.
3. Geraldi’s
Located at 20 South University Avenue, Geraldi’s has been a staple in Fayetteville for nearly thirty years. Known for its piping hot, made-to-order pizzas using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, it delivers both quality and comfort. Beyond pizza, the menu includes a variety of pasta, salads, sandwiches, and calzones, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
What makes Geraldi’s distinctive is its friendly, laid-back atmosphere and commitment to freshness. I recommend the classic pizza with their signature crust, topped with fresh vegetables and premium cheese. Their calzones are also highly recommended, offering a satisfying alternative that reflects the same dedication to quality and flavor.
4. Marley’s Chicago Style Pizzeria
Located at 609 West Dickson Street, Marley’s Chicago Style Pizzeria offers a taste of authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza right in Fayetteville. Known for its hearty, gooey pies with thick crusts and generous toppings, it satisfies those craving a substantial slice of Chicago’s iconic pizza style. The restaurant also caters to a variety of dietary preferences with vegetarian options and speedy delivery services.
What sets Marley’s apart is its dedication to delivering genuine Chicago flavors. I recommend their classic deep-dish pizza loaded with cheese, sausage, and fresh vegetables—perfectly baked and rich in flavor. Pair it with a cold drink, and you’re set for a satisfying, memorable meal that captures the essence of Chicago pizza craftsmanship.
5. Tiny Tim’s Pizza
Situated at 21 West Mountain Street, Tiny Tim’s Pizza is a cozy spot known for its friendly service and delicious pies. The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian-friendly options and is perfect for both lunch and dinner. Whether dining in or taking out, Tiny Tim’s provides consistently satisfying pizza made with quality ingredients.
What makes Tiny Tim’s stand out is its inviting atmosphere and attention to detail. I highly suggest trying their specialty pizza, topped with fresh vegetables and flavorful cheese, which captures the essence of a well-crafted, comforting pizza. Their focus on flavor and freshness makes it a favorite among locals looking for a dependable, tasty slice.
6. Tim’s Pizza East
Located at 1813 East Mission Boulevard, Tim’s Pizza East is known for its friendly service and tasty, made-to-order pizzas. It’s a go-to spot for locals seeking a casual dining experience with vegetarian-friendly options, serving lunch and dinner with table service or takeout. The inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for families and groups.
What makes Tim’s stand out is its consistent quality and attention to detail. I recommend trying their classic pizza topped with fresh vegetables and flavorful cheese, which perfectly reflects their focus on quality ingredients. Their commitment to satisfying every slice makes it a top choice for satisfying, dependable pizza in Fayetteville.
7. Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville
Located at 1460 East Augustine Lane, Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville offers a vibrant and creatively inspired dining experience. Known for its stone-baked pizzas, wings, salads, and craft beers, it’s a popular spot for both casual outings and special gatherings. You can dine in, relax on the patio, or enjoy curbside and delivery options. Their lively atmosphere and seasoned staff make every visit enjoyable.
What makes Mellow Mushroom stand out is its eclectic decor and commitment to quality. I recommend trying their signature pizza, topped with fresh ingredients and innovative flavor combinations, embodying their motto of a ‘Higher Order of Pizza’. With vegan and gluten-free options available, it caters to a variety of dietary preferences while maintaining a high standard of taste and presentation.
8. Wood Stone Craft Pizza
Situated at 3619 North Mall Avenue, Wood Stone Craft Pizza is a local favorite known for its inventive approach to pizza. The restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere with table service and takeaway options, making it perfect for both casual dining and quick bites. Their emphasis on quality ingredients shines through in every dish.
What truly makes Wood Stone stand out is its creative menu and expert craftsmanship. I recommend trying one of their signature pizzas, topped with fresh, locally sourced ingredients and cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven. Their attention to detail and dedication to flavor make it a top choice for pizza enthusiasts in Fayetteville.
9. Gusano’s Chicago Style Pizzeria
Located on Steamboat Drive, Gusano’s Chicago Style Pizzeria has been a local staple since 2008, known for its hearty Chicago-style deep dish and thin crust pizzas. Its family-friendly setting makes it a perfect spot for after-school outings or weekend gatherings. Ample seating and parking ensure a comfortable experience for large groups, especially during Razorback game days.
What sets Gusano’s apart is its authentic Chicago pizza craftsmanship combined with friendly service. I recommend ordering their classic deep-dish pizza, loaded with generous cheese, savory toppings, and baked to perfection. It captures the rich, satisfying flavors of Chicago’s pizza traditions, making it a must-try for both locals and visitors seeking a hearty, quality slice in Fayetteville.
10. Wicked Wood Fired Pizza
Nestled on West Dickson Street, Wicked Wood Fired Pizza offers a fiery twist on classic pies. Known for their authentic wood-fired baking process, they create pizzas with a distinctive smoky aroma and crispy crusts. The lively atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for locals seeking flavorful, high-quality pizza in Fayetteville.
What makes Wicked stand out is its commitment to traditional techniques and fresh ingredients. I recommend trying their signature wood-fired Margherita, topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a perfectly blistered crust. This dish exemplifies their dedication to quality, offering a memorable taste of authentic Italian-inspired pizza with an American flair.
More Things to Try in Fayetteville, AR
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza place in Fayetteville, AR?
A: The best spot depends on your taste, but popular options include Wood Stone Craft Pizza for inventive crusts, Marley’s Chicago Style Pizzeria for hearty deep-dish, and Geraldi’s for classic Italian flavors.
Q: Are there vegan or gluten-free pizza options in Fayetteville?
A: Yes. Many restaurants like Mellow Mushroom and Wood Stone Craft Pizza offer vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free crusts, ensuring options for various dietary needs.
Q: Do Fayetteville pizza places offer delivery?
A: Most do, including Gusano’s Pizza, Tim’s Pizza East, and Marley’s Chicago Style Pizzeria. It’s best to check specific restaurant websites or call to confirm delivery areas and hours.
Q: What are popular types of pizza in Fayetteville?
A: Classic options include thin crust New York style, Chicago deep-dish, and wood-fired Neapolitan. Many places also serve creative, specialty pies with unique toppings.
Q: Are there family-friendly pizza spots in Fayetteville?
A: Absolutely. Restaurants like Geraldi’s and Gusano’s are kid-friendly, with spacious setups and diverse menus that cater to all ages.