There’s something magnetic about the aroma that floats out of a pizzeria in Farmingville. Every local has a secret favorite, whether it’s the crisp, golden edge of a perfectly baked slice or the faint sweetness of a house-made tomato sauce spreading across pillowy dough. I’ve spent weekends wandering between old-school counters and bustling corner shops, trading stories with owners about their signature pies. It’s the subtle differences—a touch more garlic here, a richer fold of mozzarella there—that transform a simple meal into the talk of the table.
If you’ve ever found yourself torn between too many choices, you’re not alone. The search for the best pizza in Farmingville turns locals into loyalists and newcomers into detectives. Does a classic Margherita call to you, or does your appetite lean toward a robust Sicilian square? This guide narrows it down to the true standouts, each promising something special. Curiosity sparked? Read on. The slices ahead are worth every moment of anticipation.
Where to find the best pizza in Farmingville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Farmingville, NY:
- Primo Pizza & Restaurant
- Bruno’s Pizza
- La Roma Pizza
- Sapore Fino Pizzeria
- La Roma Pizza & Restaurant
- Pauly’s Pizza & Pasta
- Domino’s Pizza
- Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria
- Benny’s Pizzeria Inc
- Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
1. Primo Pizza & Restaurant
Stepping into Primo Pizza & Restaurant feels a bit like coming home, only this kitchen never runs out of mozzarella. You can smell the dough baking before you even reach the door. Locals have told me there’s no pizza emergency that Primo can’t fix, and after a bite of their classic Neapolitan, I believe them.
The family touch is what sets Primo apart. This spot’s been serving Farmingville for more than three decades. The staff remembers faces, and the menu gets the basics right while still surprising you. If you’re torn, order the Grandma slice—savory, fresh, and layered with just the right amount of sauce. Their pizza pops are a trusted favorite too.
For those looking for the best pizza in Farmingville, NY, Primo offers a blend of comfort and creativity, plus portions designed for sharing. It’s the kind of place you put on speed dial.
2. Bruno’s Pizza
Bruno’s Pizza is that neighborhood spot where tables fill up fast and the sound of laughter always mixes with the scent of fresh-baked dough. I once dropped in after work, planning on a quick detour, and left with a new favorite: their thin-crust Margherita. Each bite had that golden crispness that proves Bruno’s takes pizza seriously.
What puts Bruno’s a step ahead in Farmingville? It’s their commitment to both quality and comfort. The staff makes every visit easy, whether you’re settling in for dinner or grabbing a pie to go. Their menu is built around consistency—no surprises, just reliably good pizza.
If you want the best of Bruno’s, try the Sicilian slice. It’s thick, flavorful, and manages to stay light rather than dense. For a table share, the veggie pie stands out with its fresh toppings and airy crust. You’ll find yourself coming back for the familiarity—and the food.
3. La Roma Pizza
La Roma Pizza is one of those hidden gems where you get more than you expect. Tucked along Horseblock Road, it’s a spot where locals nod in recognition and the counter staff greets you with a knowing smile. When I visited, the casual buzz paired well with the unmistakable aroma of fresh basil and melting cheese.
The crust here is their quiet signature—thin and crisp with just the right touch of chew. Beyond their generous slices, La Roma stands out for their simple, well-balanced sauces, which never overpower the toppings. The cheese blend tastes both rich and surprisingly light.
If you’re after a classic experience, go for their plain slice or the white pie. Both showcase how quality ingredients transform a pizza from good to memorable. It’s a reliable bet whenever you crave something honest and satisfying.
4. Sapore Fino Pizzeria
+1 631-732-6000
Sapore Fino Pizzeria sits just off Horseblock Road and has mastered the art of blending tradition with something refreshingly new. The first time I grabbed a seat, a regular leaned over and told me, “Don’t skip the veggie slice.” She was right—between the perfectly roasted vegetables and the cheese that stretches but never overwhelms, it’s a slice worth remembering.
This pizzeria keeps its crusts light and flavorful, a rare feat in Farmingville. Every topping feels hand-selected, and the sauce has a subtle tang that stands out. Sapore Fino’s balance between texture and taste shows real craft.
If you’re feeling a bit adventurous, try their white pizza topped with spinach and ricotta. The combo highlights fresh ingredients and lets the dough shine. For anyone looking for a pizza spot that’s both welcoming and just a little unexpected, Sapore Fino delivers.
5. La Roma Pizza & Restaurant
When I think of reliability in Farmingville, La Roma Pizza & Restaurant always tops the list. There’s an easy warmth to the place—plenty of seating, wheel-friendly access, and a staff that takes time to chat about what’s hot from the oven. It’s not just another pizza joint; it’s the kind you remember for the details.
Their classic cheese pizza is a staple, with a crispy crust and generous layer of perfectly melted cheese. The sauce leans slightly sweet, which sets it apart from others in town. The blend of cheeses never overwhelms, keeping each bite deliciously balanced.
For something with a twist, the veggie pizza pairs bright green peppers and mushrooms with that trusted La Roma dough. If you want a pizza experience that’s consistently good, La Roma delivers every time.
6. Pauly’s Pizza & Pasta
Pauly’s Pizza & Pasta is the place I go when I want pizza that’s not afraid to try something new. Their menu’s loaded with unique specialty pies alongside the classics, so the hardest part is picking just one. I once gave in to curiosity and ordered their mac and cheese pizza, which turned out to be creamy, cheesy, and surprisingly memorable.
What sets Pauly’s apart is the generosity of the toppings and the clear care put into their dough. Each slice is hearty, the crust chewy but never tough, and every bite feels handmade. Their family recipes show up in the taste, whether you pick a veggie pie or a plain cheese slice.
Looking for a crowd pleaser? Try their white pizza topped with ricotta and fresh spinach. It’s comfort food the Farmingville way—familiar, filling, and friendly.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza is the answer when late-night cravings or last-minute gatherings strike in Farmingville. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve relied on their quick delivery to save a spontaneous game night. The consistency is hard to match—every pie arrives hot, with a familiar flavor that always hits the spot.
Domino’s stands out for its array of crust options. Whether you’re a fan of thin and crispy or prefer the doughy comfort of their Handmade Pan, there’s something for every mood. The deal on two medium two-topping pizzas is a local go-to for group orders.
My pick? The Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza. It’s cheesy, golden, and a step away from the usual. For reliable, wallet-friendly pizza in Farmingville, Domino’s makes convenience taste pretty good.
8. Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria
Goomba Johnny’s Pizzeria is the kind of spot where you get the sense everyone’s treated like family. I first ordered from here for a big family dinner, and the delivery was prompt—the pizzas arrived hot and packed with flavor that made the table go silent after the first bite.
What separates Goomba Johnny’s is their focus on big, satisfying pizzas built for sharing. From the sauce to the crust, there’s consistency in every order. This is the place you call for a party or a packed house on a Friday night.
For something special, try the Grandma pie. The crust is crisp around the edges, with a savory sauce that balances beautifully with fresh basil. Whether you’re new in town or a regular, Goomba Johnny’s always delivers on taste and hospitality.
9. Benny’s Pizzeria Inc
(631) 467-6622Call
Benny’s Pizzeria Inc is the kind of place that’s easy to drive past but tough to forget once you’ve had a slice. My first visit was a spur-of-the-moment lunch stop, and I was impressed by how quickly the staff got my order just right, no fuss or frills—just real pizza done well.
Benny’s stands out for its friendly vibe and below-average prices. The crust here is thin with a gentle crunch, and every slice is topped generously, so you get that classic New York fold without skimping on cheese or sauce. You know you’re tasting something made with care.
If you’re not sure what to get, go for a plain cheese pie. It’s simple, classic, and the best way to taste why locals keep coming back to Benny’s.
10. Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta has a charm that’s hard to find in bigger restaurant chains. I stopped by one rainy afternoon and found the relaxed atmosphere perfect for an unhurried meal. Their menu goes well beyond pizza, but it’s the pies that keep customers coming back.
The secret here is freshness—everything tastes bright and made to order. The sauce is tangy with a hint of sweetness, and the crust manages to be crisp without losing tenderness. Even a basic Margherita slice feels elevated due to the quality of the ingredients.
If you want a local specialty, the eggplant pizza is a standout. It’s flavorful without being heavy, and the cheese stretch alone is worth the visit. Cafe Gia delivers comfort food with an authentic touch, right in Medford’s Sunshine Square.
More Things to Try in Farmingville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top pizza places in Farmingville, NY?
Farmingville is home to a strong mix of local favorites like Primo Pizza & Restaurant, Bruno’s Pizza, La Roma Pizza, Pauly’s Pizza & Pasta, and Sapore Fino. Chains like Domino’s are also reliable if you need pizza in a pinch. Each spot has its own loyal fans for good reason.
Do these pizzerias offer vegetarian pizza options?
Yes, almost all of Farmingville’s pizza spots serve classic and specialty vegetarian options. Most offer Margherita, veggie, and white pies with various fresh toppings.
Are there any gluten-free pizza options in Farmingville?
Many pizzerias now offer gluten-free crusts. It’s a good idea to call ahead and confirm availability at your preferred location.
Which pizza place delivers fastest in Farmingville?
Domino’s is known for its speedy delivery, but many local pizzerias like Primo and Goomba Johnny’s do their best to keep up, especially during peak times.
Which pizzerias in Farmingville have seating for groups?
Places like La Roma Pizza & Restaurant, Bruno’s Pizza, and Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta have ample seating. These are good choices if you’re bringing friends or family.