Finding the best pizza in Fargo, ND is a quest that deserves more than a quick online search. With every block holding a different story—and a new aroma—choosing where to start can seem impossible. Fargo’s pizza scene is a blend of wood-fired wonders, perfect crusts, and neighborhood favorites. I still remember the first time I wandered into a downtown shop on a freezing night, only to find warm slices and good company. What started as curiosity turned into ritual; Fargo’s pizza joints made cold winters a little friendlier.
If you’ve ever stood in the biting North Dakota wind, dreaming of a slice that’s hot, cheesy, and unforgettable, you’re not alone. The local favorites here are more than just places to grab a meal. They’re destinations, each with its own charm and loyal following. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or creative new toppings, you’ll find something for every craving. Ready to discover the slices the locals crave and debate about after hockey games? That’s what you’ll find right here.
Where to find the best pizza in Fargo, ND
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fargo, ND:
- Blackbird Woodfire
- Rhombus Guys
- Deek’s Pizza
- Spicy Pie Downtown
- Blaze Pizza
- Pizza Ranch
- Duane’s House of PIzza
- Sammy’s Pizza and Restaurant
- Spicy Pie
- Papa Johns Pizza
1. Blackbird Woodfire
Blackbird Woodfire sits at the heart of downtown Fargo, where the scent of smoky crust signals comfort. Step inside and you’re greeted by warm lighting, buzzing chatter, and the sight of pizzas crisping in a red-hot wood oven. The first bite always brings a perfect balance—airy dough, charred spots, and thoughtfully sourced toppings.
What makes Blackbird stand out is how it turns simple ingredients into something memorable. The local greens, cheese, and house-made sauce create a flavor you don’t forget. For a classic Fargo taste, the Margherita is a must; bright tomatoes and buttery mozzarella hit all the right notes.
Try the Honey Badger for a twist—its mix of sweet and spicy is tough to beat. Blackbird’s attention to detail shows up in every pie.
2. Rhombus Guys
See Menu
Rhombus Guys brings a quirky energy to downtown Fargo’s pizza lineup. The space has a funky charm, big windows, and a rooftop patio made for lingering summer evenings. I remember sitting with friends, tasting the wild flavor combos and realizing pizza here feels like an event, not just a meal.
What sets Rhombus Guys apart is the menu’s creative streak. You’ll find bold, unexpected toppings and playful pizza names throughout. For first-timers, the T-Rex delivers a robust bite, while the Backpacker tempts with fresh vegetables and cheese layered just right.
If you want to mix it up, order a half-and-half pie and get the best of both worlds. Bring your appetite and your curiosity—this place rewards both.
3. Deek’s Pizza
Deek’s Pizza is that reliable spot in Fargo where you know the pizza will hit the spot—no matter the hour. With their quick delivery and welcoming vibe, late nights spent working or hanging with friends are always better with a Deek’s box around. The crust is hand-tossed and sturdy enough for serious toppings, but never too heavy.
It’s the sauce that really does it, with a secret mix of herbs and spices that stays memorable long after the last slice. I still recall those midnight study sessions that magically improved once the pepperoni and cheese pies arrived, piping hot.
Order their signature hand-tossed cheese or veggie pizza for that classic Deek’s experience. Their cheesy breadsticks are always a hit on the side.
4. Spicy Pie Downtown
Spicy Pie Downtown is one of those places where Fargo’s energy truly shines. From the hand-tossed dough to the generous toppings, each slice feels like it’s made just for you. The first time I stepped in, I picked a seat by the window and watched Broadway go by while savoring a cheesy triangle straight from the oven. The crust crackled just enough, and the savory sauce packed a punch.
This spot stands out not just for its bold pizzas, but for the chance to build your own masterpiece. The range of fresh toppings means you never run out of new combos to try. Taco pizza here has its own following—spicy, cheesy, and loaded with flavor.
Looking for hearty, made-to-order pizza? This is where to start.
5. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is the answer when you crave something fast but refuse to sacrifice flavor. The first time I visited, I was floored by how much control you get—one moment, you’re picking toppings among rows of fresh veggies and cheese, the next, your creation vanishes into a blazing oven. Just a few minutes later, it returns hot and crisp, every detail just how you pictured it.
What makes Blaze Pizza stand out is the freedom and speed. You get over 30 ingredient choices—from classic to quirky—and the service never drags. Even the pickiest eaters are covered.
If you want the chef’s recommendation, try the Veg Out. It’s loaded with vibrant vegetables and has a perfect roasted finish. Or build your own—either way, you’ll get Fargo’s fastest artisanal pie.
6. Pizza Ranch
Pizza Ranch has a way of making pizza night feel like a small-town celebration. The warm, buffet-style service brings back memories of birthday parties and family dinners stretched over heaping plates. My first visit was for a quick lunch, and I ended up lingering, drawn in by the steady hum of conversation and the parade of fresh pies arriving from the kitchen.
It stands out for its variety and big, open dining space—perfect for families or groups. Their thin-crust veggie pizza has great balance without being heavy, and the classic cheese is crowd-pleasing.
Don’t skip the sweet Cactus Bread at the end. Even if you come for the pizza, that soft slice sprinkled with cinnamon sugar is a memorable finish.
7. Duane’s House of PIzza
Duane’s House of Pizza is pure Fargo tradition. Walking in, there’s a sense of nostalgia—this is the kind of spot that’s been woven into family stories for years. My introduction to Duane’s was an after-game stop; that first slice, golden and loaded with molten cheese, set the standard high for comfort food in the city.
This place stands apart for its thin, crackly crust and the way toppings nest into a gooey layer of cheese. The Lunch Special is always a smart move—generous slices paired with a salad make for a satisfying midday fix.
If you ask locals for a recommendation, many will say go for the classic cheese or veggie. At Duane’s, simple isn’t boring—it’s perfection.
8. Sammy’s Pizza and Restaurant
Sammy’s Pizza and Restaurant has a quiet charm that’s become a staple on Broadway. This place has that old-school dining room feel—think red-checkered tables and friendly, unhurried service. My first visit was on a snowy night; the welcoming warmth inside and the rich aroma of pizza baking made the city outside seem miles away.
Sammy’s stands out for recipes passed down for generations and a focus on thin, crisp crust. Their veggie special bursts with seasoned vegetables and gooey cheese, making it a crowd favorite.
If you love classics done right, the cheese and tomato pie is as comforting as it gets. There’s something special about pizza prepared with care and tradition in every slice.
9. Spicy Pie
Spicy Pie at 52nd Ave brings the spirit of the original downtown hangout to Fargo’s south side. The vibe here is casual and upbeat, making it a top pick for a quick bite or casual meet-up. My first visit felt like joining a local tradition, with regulars swapping stories over huge, foldable slices.
What sets Spicy Pie apart is the focus on quality—the dough is hand-tossed, and you can taste the care in every bite. The Taco pizza is a top pick, loaded with fresh veggies and that signature tangy sauce.
Build your own if you’re feeling inventive. Here, customization isn’t just allowed—it’s encouraged, so every visit can be a fresh experience.
10. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on 19th Avenue North is a familiar face for anyone in Fargo craving a classic delivery experience. It’s a staple for game nights and last-minute gatherings, known for that golden crust and signature sauce. I remember grabbing a slice during a late-night move with friends, surprised at how fresh and light the dough tasted even after a busy day.
What makes Papa Johns unique is the focus on quality ingredients—every pie feels reliably fresh and consistent. The Garden Fresh pizza is a standout for its mix of bright, crisp veggies and gooey cheese.
Try the thin crust if you want something lighter, and if you’re ordering for a group, the large Original Cheese never disappoints. There’s comfort in knowing each pizza arrives just as you expect.
More Things to Try in Fargo, ND
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Fargo, ND?
Some of the most talked-about spots include Blackbird Woodfire, Rhombus Guys, Deek’s Pizza, Spicy Pie, and Pizza Ranch. Each offers their own spin on classic and creative pies.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Fargo?
Definitely. Many restaurants like Blaze Pizza, Rhombus Guys, and Blackbird Woodfire have strong vegetarian and vegan menus. You’ll find plant-based cheese and a variety of veggie toppings at most top spots.
Which pizza places in Fargo have gluten-free options?
Several Fargo pizzerias, including Rhombus Guys, Blackbird Woodfire, and Blaze Pizza, offer gluten-free crust choices. It’s always smart to call ahead if you have dietary needs.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Fargo?
Spicy Pie, Deek’s Pizza, and Rhombus Guys are favorites for late-night slices. Check their hours as they can change depending on the day and season.
What’s a must-try pizza in Fargo?
Locals rave about the Margherita at Blackbird Woodfire, the T-Rex at Rhombus Guys, and the Taco pizza at Spicy Pie. These reflect local tastes and each restaurant’s unique style.
Can I order pizza delivery in Fargo?
Absolutely. Many places like Deek’s Pizza, Papa Johns, Blaze Pizza, and Pizza Hut offer reliable delivery across town. Online ordering is quick and simple at most locations.
Is there a good spot for pizza with kids or groups in Fargo?
Pizza Ranch, Sammy’s, and Space Aliens Grill & Bar are especially family-friendly, with roomy spaces and crowd-pleasing menus. Perfect for parties or casual gatherings.