Finding the best pizza in Fairview, NY is not just about a perfect crust or bubbling cheese, though both matter. It’s the search itself that turns hungry days into memorable ones, and every box opened becomes a gateway to neighborhood gems—with each slice competing for your attention. After years of swapping recommendations, sampling dough at odd hours, and even risking a few burnt tongues, I’ve learned Fairview hides a wide range of flavors you won’t want to miss.
I can still recall watching a pizzaiolo hand-toss a pie, the air rich with the scent of toasty bread and fresh basil. It didn’t need a parade of fancy toppings to win me over—just old-school skill and a little Fairview charm. This guide covers cozy classics and creative newcomers alike, handpicked from local chatter and lived experience. If you crave thin crust, crave a chewy bite, or daydream about a towering pie, you’re in the right place. Let’s dive into the pizza scene that makes Fairview worth every detour.
Where to find the best pizza in Fairview, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Fairview, NY:
- Emiliano’s Pizza
- Pizza Mia
- Marco’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Little Caesars Pizza
- Pavese’s Pizza
- D D’s Pizza
- Bella Amici Pizza
- Big Guy Pizza
- Tony’s Pizza Pit
1. Emiliano’s Pizza
Emiliano’s Pizza isn’t just any corner joint; it’s the place everyone in Fairview seems to know. Family-owned for over twenty years at 111 Main St, this pizzeria stands out with its generous hospitality and time-tested recipes. I once stopped by late on a chilly night, and their staff greeted me like an old friend. One bite of their classic cheese pie—golden and perfectly chewy—made it easy to see what all the local buzz is about.
What makes Emiliano’s special is the balance: crisp, flavorful crust, a sauce with just enough zing, and cheese that melts to stretchy perfection. You’ll also find creative pies, but sticking with their sausage or veggie pizza showcases what they do best—simple, real ingredients, made right.
Don’t miss the homemade calzones. They’re pillowy and packed, great for a meal on the go or when you want something a bit different. For anyone craving warmth, comfort, and a slice of Fairview tradition, Emiliano’s delivers every time.
2. Pizza Mia
Pizza Mia, tucked into Bridgeview Plaza, is the place you visit when you want your pizza without any fuss—just good flavor and quick, friendly service. On my last stop, my order was out before I even had time to scroll through my messages, and the first bite was all crunch and savory cheese.
Affordability and consistency are where Pizza Mia shines. Whether you pick up a plain cheese or try their classic margherita, you get the same crisp crust and a sauce that never overpowers. There’s something refreshing about simple, quality pizza done right every time.
If you’re feeling adventurous, ask for their veggie pie. With a generous spread of fresh toppings, it lets the dough speak for itself—airy, yet sturdy. Pizza Mia is for those who like tradition and value, both at the same table.
3. Marco’s Pizza
(845) 204-9880Call
Marco’s Pizza on Raymond Ave combines the comfort of a family spot with a dash of gourmet attitude. The moment you step inside, there’s a whiff of freshly baked dough and a steady hum from regulars who know their pizza. On one visit, a single slice of their signature pie—hot from the oven, topped with bright tomato sauce and bubbling cheese—made me pause mid-conversation to focus on every bite.
Marco’s earns its reputation with inventive choices alongside classic favorites. The white pizza, dotted with garlic and ricotta, is a standout, mellow yet rich, while the Sicilian boasts a pillowy base with crisp edges.
Not just about pizza, their pasta and sandwiches draw a crowd, but trust the regulars and try a specialty slice. At Marco’s, balance and fresh flavors are never in short supply.
4. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at 4274 Albany Post Rd may be a familiar face, but there’s comfort in its reliability and speed—especially on nights when dinner needs to arrive before your favorite show. I’ve dashed in for a quick carryout and watched as my order was prepped, baked, and boxed with clockwork precision, never sacrificing that cheesy pull on the first slice.
What sets Domino’s apart is the customizable menu. The thin, New York style crust is a nod to city tradition, while the Handmade Pan brings a soft, buttery bite that can stand up to every topping you crave. They also do a mean veggie pie, for those seeking something fresh and light.
The Parmesan Stuffed Crust is a local favorite, and makes a solid choice if you’re after something a bit more indulgent. Domino’s lives up to its promise of convenience, quality, and value, every time.
5. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on Main St is where affordability meets speed, a lifesaver when hunger hits and patience runs thin. I’ve swung by for a Hot-N-Ready deal more times than I’d like to admit—each time, grabbing a fresh pie without ever waiting in line.
The secret is in the consistency. The crust is always soft at the center, with a golden crunch at the edge, and the sauce tastes pleasantly tangy. Cheese here is always plentiful, stretching with each bite.
If you haven’t tried their classic Cheese or Veggie pizzas, start there. For a little extra comfort, the Stuffed Crust delivers plenty of cheesy goodness. With Little Caesars, value doesn’t mean compromise, making it a go-to for busy days or a quick family meal.
6. Pavese’s Pizza
(845) 691-8446Call
Pavese’s Pizza on Vineyard Ave is one of those small-town spots that has the feel of a local secret. Tucked away in Highland, it’s the kind of pizzeria where the scent of fresh dough hits you before you even open the door. My favorite memory: dropping in before a long drive and getting a steaming slice, folded perfectly for travel.
What makes Pavese’s shine is their commitment to classic flavors and generous portions. Every pie comes out with a thin, crisp base and a balance of sauce and cheese that doesn’t drown the crust.
Their classic Cheese pizza is a proven crowd-pleaser, while the veggie pie piles on the flavor with fresh toppings. Pavese’s delivers full flavor and genuine charm with every slice, and keeps folks coming back for more.
7. D D’s Pizza
(845) 452-1754Call
D D’s Pizza on Hooker Ave is the sort of no-nonsense spot where the menu is simple and the flavors are direct. My last visit felt like stepping into a neighborhood tradition—quick service, laughter at the counter, and the comfort of knowing every pie is made fresh right behind the register.
What sets D D’s apart is its old-school approach. The crust is always thin with a crispy edge, and the cheese and sauce blend in each bite. There’s a certain “one more slice” quality that makes it hard to stop at just one.
Try their traditional Cheese or opt for the veggie. D D’s delivers classic New York style pizza with local heart, a favorite for regulars and newcomers alike.
8. Bella Amici Pizza
(845) 834-3222Call
Bella Amici Pizza on US Highway 9W brings a sense of warmth from the first visit. This Highland staple has mastered the art of the friendly greeting, which seems to carry over into their pies. I remember my first order—a classic cheese pizza, handed over with a smile, crisp and bubbling as promised.
Their crust is thin and balanced, with just enough chew to complement the tangy sauce and generous cheese sprinkle. Each pizza feels like it’s made with patience and real care.
For a satisfying meal, try the Margherita or their veggie specialty—each bites fresh and full of flavor. Bella Amici stands out for its attention to detail and genuine community vibe, always making guests feel right at home.
9. Big Guy Pizza
(845) 691-2500Call
Big Guy Pizza on Vineyard Ave is the spot for anyone who believes there’s no such thing as too much pizza. The portions here live up to the name—I remember once splitting a supersized pie with friends, and we still had leftovers for lunch the next day.
Hearty, classic, and satisfying, every pizza has that golden-browned edge and a solid base that can hold up to a mountain of toppings. Their plain cheese is always a winner, but the veggie pizza piles it on without losing that crisp bottom crust.
Feeling hungry? Order their extra-large specialty pie for a real feast. Big Guy Pizza is about abundance, comfort, and the kind of pizza that invites everyone to the table.
10. Tony’s Pizza Pit
(845) 471-4110Call
Tony’s Pizza Pit on Main St feels like a little slice of old-school comfort in the heart of Poughkeepsie. Whether you pull up a chair or grab a takeout box, there’s always a sense that you’re part of the regular crowd here. I once ducked in on a rainy afternoon, only to be greeted by the aroma of fresh dough and a counter lined with pizza just out of the oven.
Tony’s stands out for its balance of flavor and value. The cheese pizza comes crisp, with a sauce that’s just the right side of tangy. There’s never skimping on the cheese or fresh toppings.
Give their margherita or classic veggie pizza a try for that perfect, simple slice. Tony’s Pizza Pit is all about hometown warmth, quick service, and pizza that leaves you happily full.
More Things to Try in Fairview, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Fairview, NY?
Some favorites are Emiliano’s Pizza, Marco’s Pizza, Tony’s Pizza Pit, and Bella Amici Pizza. Locals love the range of styles, from classic NY thin crust to hearty Sicilian slices.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options in Fairview?
Most pizzerias, including Domino’s, Pizza Mia, and Pavese’s Pizza, offer veggie pies topped with fresh vegetables. Just ask for their selection or request extra veggie toppings on your favorite pizza.
Which places are best for quick pizza takeout?
Little Caesars Pizza, Domino’s, and Big Guy Pizza are well-known for speedy service. Their Hot-N-Ready and quick carryout pizza options make last-minute meals a breeze.
Are there family-friendly pizza spots in Fairview?
Yes, spots like Marco’s Pizza, Emiliano’s Pizza, and D D’s Pizza all offer a laid-back atmosphere and generous slice options, making them perfect for family dinners or gatherings.
Do any local pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts?
Some chain locations such as Domino’s often have gluten-free crusts available. Always call ahead to confirm options and avoid cross-contamination if you have gluten sensitivities.