Craving pizza in Everett can become a real quest. I’ve spent evenings making my way through different pizzerias, captivated by ovens glowing behind the counter and the scent of fresh dough drifting through the air. Once, waiting for my order at a packed local spot, I realized that picking the right pizza isn’t just about toppings or cheese pulls—it’s about knowing where passion meets flavor.
Everett’s pizza scene bursts with diversity, blending classic old-school slices and inventive pies with local flair. Some places serve up hand-tossed, New York-style creations, while others focus on thick, chewy crusts loaded with quality ingredients. This guide pulls together the standout picks—the hidden gems, beloved institutions, and quick-stop chains that locals secretly rate. If you want your next pizza night to be worth it, read on.
1. Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria
You’ll smell the pizzas before you spot the turn-of-the-century brick storefront downtown. Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria brings genuine New York flavor to Everett, right down to the crisp, foldable crust. The first time I ate here, the classic Margherita impressed me—fresh basil, just-melted cheese, and that signature chewy bite.
What stands out is their commitment to consistency. Each pizza arrives piping hot, with a sauce that packs just enough tang and no skimping on toppings. It’s the kind of place where locals swap stories over slices after a game or long week.
Order the “Wise Guy” or the simple cheese pizza. Both showcase the magic that happens when quality dough and restraint meet. These pies are as close to New York as you’ll find in Snohomish County.
2. Acropolis Pizza & Pasta
Acropolis Pizza & Pasta feels like a neighborhood secret you wish you’d found sooner. The family-run vibe is authentic—think laughter in the kitchen, and that warm greeting as you step in. I once dropped by for a quick lunch and ended up lingering over a slice and their perfectly tangy tomato sauce.
The homemade sauces here set Acropolis apart. Each pizza brims with character, the dough baked just right and the mozzarella stretching on every bite. It’s a place where the menu knows no shortcuts and the recipes mean something to those serving you.
Try the Acropolis Special Pizza if you want a taste of what makes this spot beloved. Their vegetarian options are solid too, ideal for mixed-company outings. Simple, hearty, and done right—this is classic comfort with local flair.
3. Major League Pizza
Major League Pizza comes with personality and flavor to spare. The first time I visited, big-screen games played overhead while my friends debated which quirky pizza to share. With baseball-themed décor and a friendly buzz, it feels like the city’s living room—relaxed yet never dull.
The menu here is unapologetically playful. From inventive topping combos to pun-heavy pizza names, creativity is the norm. Slices arrive loaded and piping hot, and the staff help you pair your pie with sides if you ask.
For a bold choice, try the “Big Hurt” pizza. It’s a hearty lineup of veggies and cheese on a perfectly crisp base. If you want all-star variety, build your own. This spot knocks every visit out of the park.
4. Romio’s Pizza & Pasta
Romio’s Pizza & Pasta offers a laid-back slice of comfort right in downtown Everett. My last visit was on a rainy afternoon, and the friendly staff made it easy to settle in and warm up with a slice and a side salad. The place echoes Italian family traditions, from checkered tablecloths to the aroma of fresh-baked dough.
This spot is known for generous portions and consistency. Every pizza brims with fresh toppings and gooey cheese, striking the right balance between classic and creative. Service is prompt, and they keep the atmosphere easy-going whether dining in or grabbing takeout.
The Veggie Delight is a solid first order, with plenty of flavor piled high. Or, go for a simple cheese or Margherita to appreciate the dough and sauce on their own terms. Either way, Romio’s delivers comfort that sticks around long after the last bite.
5. Giorgio’s Pizza & Spaghetti House
Giorgio’s Pizza & Spaghetti House has been a local mainstay since the early ‘80s, and stepping inside always feels like joining a family dinner. My first time here, I was met with the scent of bubbling cheese and freshly baked crust, and a staff quick with friendly table service.
What makes Giorgio’s shine is their focus on fresh, quality ingredients. Pizzas come out with tender crusts and toppings you can taste in every bite. The kitchen’s attention to detail shows through in every dish, from dough to final drizzle of sauce.
Order the Giorgio’s Special if you want a classic loaded pie. The combination of veggies and cheese reflects everything the restaurant does best—balance, flavor, and a sense of tradition that runs deep with every slice.
6. A Pizza House
A Pizza House feels like the kind of place that locals keep in their back pocket. On my visit, it was buzzing with regulars grabbing lunchtime slices and families debating toppings. There’s a relaxed, friendly atmosphere that doesn’t try too hard—just solid pies and plenty of smiles.
This spot’s charm is its balance between classic and creative. Slices are firm yet chewy, with a crust that stands up to generous portions of cheese and sauce. The staff move quickly, happy to share suggestions if you’re undecided.
Try the Supreme or a veggie-loaded pie to sample their best work. Both showcase A Pizza House’s talent for delivering big flavor in straightforward form. If you want your pizza night to be both easy and satisfying, this spot gets it right.
7. Amante Pizza and Pasta
Amante Pizza and Pasta sits right on Hewitt Ave and brings a bright, Italian-inspired energy to downtown Everett. I dropped by one evening and was welcomed by the cozy, inviting dining room and the scent of herbs wafting from the oven. The staff move with energy and seem genuinely happy to see regulars return.
What makes Amante shine is its balanced blend of classic and modern takes on pizza. Everything is made-to-order with plenty of vegetarian options, and they never rush quality. Crusts are golden, with just enough crunch, and sauces taste fresh every time.
The Amante Veggie pizza is a standout—colorful, loaded, and perfect for sharing. Or try a Margherita to taste the quality of their basics. Consistency and care put Amante high on the local pizza radar.
8. Silverlake Pizza & Pasta
Silverlake Pizza & Pasta is the kind of neighborhood spot where comfort comes first. The dining room feels relaxed and open, and it didn’t take long for a fresh, bubbly pizza to land at my table when I visited. There’s a sense that everything is made with genuine care, from dough to sauce.
This place stands out for its hearty portions and customizable pizzas. Their crust is on the chewier side, offering a satisfying bite that holds up under generous toppings. The kitchen leans into Italian classics but still welcomes creativity if you want to build your own.
Order a classic veggie pizza or try their signature Silverlake Special. Both showcase a great mix of flavors, and their simple approach highlights the quality ingredients. It’s pizza made for easygoing nights and regulars who know the menu by heart.
9. Culaccino Pizzaria
Culaccino Pizzaria brings a modern twist to traditional Italian pizza in a bright, welcoming space at Murphy’s Corner. My last visit was a weekday dinner, and within minutes, the server brought out a pie that looked (and tasted) like it belonged in a family Italian kitchen. There’s a lot of pride in each detail, from dough prep to how toppings are arranged.
Where Culaccino shines is its innovative menu and emphasis on fresh ingredients. Even staples like Margherita or Veggie pizza get a lift from the kitchen’s creativity and the quality of produce. It’s family-owned, so you get hospitality alongside your meal.
Try the namesake Culaccino Pizza or a custom build if you’re in the mood to experiment. Each bite balances familiar flavors with just enough surprise—proof that this spot respects tradition without being tied to it.
10. South Lake Pizza
South Lake Pizza is a local favorite for those craving hearty, reliable pies on Everett’s east side. I grabbed takeout one evening and was struck by how fresh the toppings tasted—even after a car ride home, the pizza was still piping hot.
The crust here is thick, fluffy, and just the right amount of chewy. You get generous helpings of cheese and classic toppings, never skimping on flavor or portion size. This is the kind of pizza built for family movie nights or game-day feasts.
Order the South Lake Special or a veggie supreme for a taste of their signature style. Each slice lands somewhere between comfort food and celebration, with locally-loved attention to every detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza places in Everett offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Many pizzerias in Everett, including Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria, Acropolis Pizza & Pasta, and Amante Pizza and Pasta, have strong vegetarian or vegan choices. Ask for plant-based cheese or just load up on veggies for a meat-free meal.
Who serves the best New York-style pizza in Everett?
Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria is known for its classic New York-style pies: large slices, foldable crust, and just the right amount of tang in the sauce.
Where can I find pizza delivery in Everett?
Plenty of spots deliver throughout Everett, including Major League Pizza, South Lake Pizza, and major chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns. Local spots also often offer delivery via third-party apps.
Are there any family-friendly pizza places in Everett?
Yes. Silverlake Pizza & Pasta, Romio’s Pizza & Pasta, and Giorgio’s Pizza & Spaghetti House all offer cozy, casual rooms perfect for groups and families. Many offer children’s menus or smaller portion sizes.
What’s the best pizza for a crowd or party in Everett?
For gatherings, Papa Murphy’s Take ‘n’ Bake and Major League Pizza are good bets, thanks to their big menu and generous party sizes. Local pizzerias are happy to take large orders with a call ahead.