Pizza cravings tend to strike at unexpected hours. One ordinary Tuesday evening in Evanston, I found myself wandering under the glow of vintage streetlights, chasing the scent of bubbling cheese and simmering sauce. That’s when I realized Evanston isn’t just a college town or a lakeside outpost—it’s a quiet champion in the pizza game. Whether it’s a crisp, chewy crust or a thick layer of molten mozzarella that draws you in, the city puts its own spin on classic pies and inventive creations alike.
Choosing where to get your next slice can feel like a quest, especially when every block has its loyalists and hidden gems. I’ve tasted my way through deep-dish legends, Neapolitan corners, and neighborhood staples, skipping the hype and savoring only what’s truly worthwhile. Here’s a list that goes beyond tired recommendations—a rundown rooted in real slices, real flavors, and a dash of Evanston character. Get ready to meet the best pizza spots in town, from crowd-pleasers to under-the-radar favorites.
1. Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria
Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria isn’t just a spot; it’s a rite of passage for anyone serious about pizza in Evanston. The downtown location fills up fast, and for good reason. When you walk in, the scent of melting cheese and rich tomato sauce pulls you straight to your table.
The deep dish here sets the bar for all others. Their famous Buttercrust does something rare: every bite stays firm and buttery, never soggy. It’s layered with their bright, zesty tomato sauce and stretchy mozzarella that somehow defies gravity. Order the classic deep dish with spinach or the veggie special if you want something unforgettable.
Lou Malnati’s makes its pizza with a care that borders on obsession—each pie is a showcase of Chicago tradition and Evanston pride.
2. Union Pizzeria
Union Pizzeria sits in a converted warehouse, where it blends cool industrial style with cozy, wood-fired aromas. The dining space buzzes with energy, especially on weekends. It’s the kind of spot you duck into after a show or a long walk by the lake, looking for something special.
Their thin-crust pizzas have a light, crisp chew that puts bland dough to shame. Each pizza comes out blistered at the edges, with fresh, flavorful toppings. The Margherita—simple but bold with fresh basil—is proof that quality ingredients steal the spotlight here.
The Funghi pizza, loaded with roasted mushrooms and fontina, is earthy and addictive. Union Pizzeria doesn’t just serve pizza; it delivers personality in every slice.
3. Sarpino’s Pizzeria
Sarpino’s Pizzeria is Evanston’s answer to late-night cravings. The smell of a fresh-baked pie arriving at your door past midnight is its own kind of luxury. I remember ordering during a marathon study session—delivery was quick, the pizza still hot, and it saved my group from meltdown mode.
What sets Sarpino’s apart is the sheer reliability and range. You get the same satisfaction at 2 a.m. as you do for lunch. The crust strikes the right balance between chewy and crisp, while the sauces are flavorful without overpowering.
The Mediterranean pizza is a winner, loaded with fresh veggies and tangy olives, while their cheese pizza is comfort food at its best. Sarpino’s makes sure you won’t go hungry, whatever the hour.
4. Trattoria D.O.C.
Trattoria D.O.C. brings a genuine slice of Italy to Evanston’s Main Street. The welcoming feel starts with the staff, who treat you like an old friend. During my last visit, warm sunlight poured through the windows and the aromas of slow-rising dough filled the air—a little reminder of the Italian coast.
Their pizzas focus on purity of flavor and top-tier ingredients. The classic Margherita shines with its bubbly edges and perfect balance of tomato and mozzarella. If you like your pie fragrant, try the Pizza Vegetariana—roasted vegetables on a smoky, charred crust.
Everything at Trattoria D.O.C. feels intentional, from imported olive oil to produce that tastes garden-fresh. Here, you’ll find Italian tradition delivered with charm and heart.
5. Panino’s Pizzeria
Panino’s Pizzeria is one of those neighborhood places where comfort is just as important as flavor. It’s welcoming, unpretentious, and the staff get to know your go-to order if you’re a regular. I first stopped in on a chilly day and the warm, cheesy aroma was the perfect antidote.
Their pizzas strike that rare middle ground between thick and thin, with a crisp edge and a soft, flavorful bite. Panino’s keeps things simple but never bland—each pizza benefits from a tangy sauce and a generous layer of cheese.
Their Garden Veggie pizza stands out, loaded with fresh peppers and mushrooms, while the classic cheese is always a safe (and satisfying) choice. Panino’s is reliable, relaxed, and always tasty.
6. Union Squared
Union Squared specializes in something you don’t see every day in Evanston—Detroit-style pizza. My first visit here was almost accidental, but the square, caramelized-edged pies quickly won me over. The cozy spot feels made for sharing slices with friends or grabbing an easy takeout night.
The magic starts with the crust: airy, chewy, and crowned with a golden cheese edge that crackles with every bite. Sauces lean into tangy rather than heavy, keeping each slice light on its feet.
The Four Cheese or Veggie Detroit are local legends, with bubbly toppings layered corner to corner. Union Squared gives pizza lovers something distinct—impossibly fluffy dough and flavor combinations you’ll crave long after you leave.
7. Gigio’s Pizzeria
Gigio’s Pizzeria has an old-school charm you feel as soon as you walk in. The bright red booths and fast-moving counter remind you this is a place for pure, simple pizza enjoyment. I once stopped by on a whim and found myself coming back for the laid-back vibe and fast service.
Gigio’s pizza is all about classic, oversized slices and thin, foldable crusts—ideal when you want a bite on the move or a quick lunch with friends. Their cheese and veggie slices are loaded with fresh toppings and never skimp on flavor.
Try the Veggie Special if you like a loaded pie, or stick to the cheese slice for timeless appeal. Gigio’s does familiar, fast, and flavorful without any fuss.
8. Carmen’s Pizzeria
Carmen’s Pizzeria is the sort of place people remember from childhood and bring their own families back to. The inside is friendly and unpretentious, making it perfect for leisurely dinners and catch-up conversations. My most memorable visit was late on a snowy night, and the bustling dining room felt like the heart of Evanston.
Carmen’s stands out for its variety—choose from pan, stuffed, or traditional crusts. No matter the style, the crust is always golden and holds up to plenty of cheese and toppings. The sauce strikes a balance between tangy and rich, making each bite crave-worthy.
The spinach and veggie pizzas capture Carmen’s commitment to hearty comfort food, and the classic cheese never disappoints. This is pizza that feels both familiar and special.
9. Dave’s New Kitchen
Dave’s New Kitchen is the kind of low-key spot you wish you’d discovered sooner. It has a family-run feel—nothing fussy, just hearty food and cheerful faces behind the counter. The first time I stopped in, the staff greeted me like an old friend and talked me through their best pizza options.
The pizza here is defined by its homemade touch, especially their thin, crisp crust and a sauce with a gentle sweetness. Toppings come in generous heaps, but never drown out the base flavors.
The spinach-tomato and veggie combos are fresh, bright, and filling, showing off Dave’s knack for making vegetables the star. Pizza from Dave’s New Kitchen delivers real comfort, every time.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Foster Street is Evanston’s favorite standby for fast, affordable slices. Some nights, you just need efficient delivery and a consistent pie—and Domino’s delivers both, rain or shine. On college game nights, it’s the box you see at every get-together, and the familiar taste is dependably comforting.
What makes Domino’s stand out is the range of crust and topping options. You can go for the thin New York Style, classic Hand Tossed, or the thick Handmade Pan—each with its own fan base. Their pizza always arrives hot and gooey, exactly as expected.
The Veggie pizza, loaded with colorful peppers, onions, and mushrooms, is a popular choice. Domino’s takes care of cravings with zero fuss and plenty of flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are most popular in Evanston?
Evanston covers all the bases—from deep dish classics at Lou Malnati’s to Detroit-style at Union Squared and thin-crust options all over town. There’s truly something for everyone’s pizza preference.
Are there any good pizza spots with vegetarian or vegan options?
Most top pizzerias in Evanston—like Trattoria D.O.C., Dave’s New Kitchen, and Union Pizzeria—offer plenty of vegetarian (and often vegan) choices. Even chains like Domino’s have several veggie pies, so nobody needs to miss out.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Evanston?
Yes, many local spots offer gluten-free crusts. Lou Malnati’s, Union Pizzeria, and Trattoria D.O.C. stand out for their gluten-free options. Just ask when you order to make sure your choice is right for your needs.
Which pizza places deliver late at night in Evanston?
Sarpino’s is the go-to for late-night pizza, with delivery running deep into the night. Domino’s also stays open late, making them both reliable choices for those after-hours cravings.
Where should I go for a quick pizza lunch in Evanston?
For a speedy bite, try Gigio’s or Panino’s—both offer quick service and big flavor. Domino’s is also fast and convenient for takeout or delivery near campus or home.
Is there a place to get authentic Italian pizza in Evanston?
Yes, Trattoria D.O.C. brings authentic Italian flavors with wood-fired pies and fresh ingredients. It’s a great stop for those craving traditional Italian pizza without leaving town.