There’s something about the sea air in Eureka that makes pizza taste even better. I remember finding my way through the backstreets on a foggy evening, hungry after a hike in the redwoods, chasing the scent of tomato sauce and wood-fired crust. Eureka’s pizza scene is as varied as the town’s history, and the choices will surprise you.
Locals are loyal to their favorites, and newcomers get lost in the options. Whether you want chewy Neapolitan slices, crisp-edged pan pies, or the satisfaction of a take-and-bake special, Eureka delivers. If you’re wondering where to begin, this guide will point you straight to the places worth your time—and appetite. Someone’s always debating which spot comes out on top, but one thing’s for sure: excellent pizza is never far away on the North Coast.
Where to find the best pizza in Eureka, CA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Eureka, CA:
- Brick & Fire Bistro
- Paul’s Live From New York Pizza
- Babe’s Pizza & Pasta
- Diver Bar and Grill
- Smug’s Pizza
- The Madrone Brick Fire Pizza & Taphouse
- Round Table Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- MOD Pizza
- Manzanilla
1. Brick & Fire Bistro
Stepping into Brick & Fire Bistro is like finding Eureka’s hidden pizza haven. The gentle glow of the wood-fired brick oven pulls you in. I’ve sat close enough to watch dough stretch and bubble, knowing I was in for something special.
The crust here sets the standard—perfectly chewy with just the right hint of woodsmoke. Their Margherita tastes as good as it looks, fresh basil and bright tomato landing on a pillowy base. If you’re feeling adventurous, try one of the seasonal specials; they use local ingredients that capture the region’s character.
The charm doesn’t stop at pizza, but ordering anything else feels almost like you’d miss out. Brick & Fire’s pies set the bar for pizza in Eureka.
2. Paul’s Live From New York Pizza
If nostalgia had a crust, it would taste like Paul’s Live From New York Pizza. Walking in, you can’t miss the unmistakable aroma of New York-style slices—thin, sturdy, perfect for folding. I once stopped by on a rainy afternoon and ended up staying for two extra slices, just for the experience.
Paul’s wins over locals and travelers with hearty portions and that classic, tangy red sauce. The cheese stretches for days, and their veggie options stack high and satisfying. For a true test of their skill, try the Veggie Deluxe or stick to a cheese slice; either way, the crust holds up.
It’s pizza that’s easy to crave—straightforward, satisfying, and always hot out of the oven.
3. Babe’s Pizza & Pasta
If you know, you know: Babe’s Pizza & Pasta is the go-to spot when you want hearty slices and a crowd-pleasing environment. I once grabbed a booth here after a long drive—the pizza came out piping hot, the staff didn’t rush, and it felt like home.
What sets Babe’s apart is their ultra-generous toppings—they don’t skimp, and every bite proves it. The House Special loads on veggies and cheese until the slice practically needs two hands. Their crust is a nice middle ground: soft in the center, with a golden, crunchy edge.
If you’re in the mood to share, their large pies easily feed a group. You won’t regret ordering extra for later.
4. Diver Bar and Grill
Diver Bar and Grill might surprise you if you think it’s just another local eatery. I slipped in with friends for dinner one night, expecting the usual, and found a calm vibe paired with some of the cheesiest pizza around.
Their crust is soft with a subtle crisp edge, and the sauce gives every bite a little tang. The veggie pizza stands out—the roasted peppers and mushrooms come layered high, and the cheese is always perfectly melted. It’s the kind of comfort food that makes conversation linger.
If you’re after a place with good energy and hearty, well-made pizzas, Diver’s is worth a visit. Portions are generous, and nobody leaves hungry.
5. Smug’s Pizza
Smug’s Pizza is a local legend that doesn’t try too hard—it doesn’t need to. I wandered in after an afternoon at the waterfront, craving something simple but memorable. Smug’s delivers old-school counter service and solid, satisfying pies every time.
Their crust has a nice chew and a subtle flavor that never distracts from the toppings. For a true Smug’s experience, go for their Veggie Supreme: loads of mushrooms, olives, peppers, and that generous sprinkle of cheese. Each slice has a well-balanced ratio of sauce to topping, so nothing overwhelms.
It’s the kind of spot where locals chat while waiting on slices, and you’ll want to grab a seat by the window if you can.
6. The Madrone Brick Fire Pizza & Taphouse
The Madrone Brick Fire Pizza & Taphouse offers the kind of casual, lively spot that draws you right in. I met some friends here on a whim and ended up impressed by both the crust and the craft beer lineup.
Their brick oven method gives the crust those irresistible charred bubbles and a deep, smoky flavor. The Margherita is a must—the sauce is fresh, and the basil finish feels like summer. For a bolder option, try their roasted veggie pizza, which piles on seasonal produce without ever skimping on cheese.
If you enjoy pairing slices with local brews, Madrone makes it easy. The relaxed atmosphere and top-notch pizza mean you’ll probably linger longer than planned.
7. Round Table Pizza
Round Table Pizza may be a familiar name, but the Eureka location brings its own charm. I’ve stopped in with a group after a long day, and it’s the reliable spot where everyone finds something they like.
Their dough is fluffy inside with a crispy edge, and the toppings come loaded. You can’t miss the King Arthur’s Supreme—packed with veggies and perfectly melted cheese, it’s both classic and satisfying. Their veggie options are particularly flavorful and never skimp on quality.
It’s a welcoming place for a casual meal, and you’ll see families grabbing slices and friends splitting pies well into the evening. Round Table’s consistency always delivers.
8. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s might be a big name, but in Eureka, it’s the reliable answer for a late-night craving or an easy weeknight dinner. I’ve ordered here when deadlines stack up, and the delivery always lands fast and hot.
Customization is where Domino’s shines. Whether you lean toward the Handmade Pan for its fluffy texture or stick with the classic Thin Crust, every pie arrives just the way you want it. The Veggie pizza is always colorful and loaded, while the cheese stretches satisfyingly with every bite.
Value deals make it easy to grab extra for tomorrow. If consistency and speed matter to you, Domino’s delivers every time in both senses.
9. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza on Broadway gives you the wheel when it comes to pizza. I stopped in with friends, and each of us built our own pie; no one left disappointed. The experience is about picking exactly what you want, without limits or hidden fees.
You can load up on as many fresh veggies, cheeses, and sauces as your heart desires. The classic MOD crust bakes up thin and crispy, without overpowering the toppings. If you’re after something lighter, their salads use the same array of customizable ingredients.
Try the “Maddy” as a base and go wild from there. For picky eaters, adventurous types, and everyone between, MOD is Eureka’s playground for pizza.
10. Manzanilla
+1 707-407-0351
Manzanilla is where Mediterranean flavors meet the comfort of a well-made pizza. I wandered in for lunch and was struck by the mix of color and aroma—something you don’t find every day in Eureka. The menu brings a new spin to familiar pizza, combining spices and herbs you might not expect.
The flatbread-style pizzas are the real standout. Crisp at the edges, easy to share, and topped with roasted vegetables and vibrant sauces, each bite tells its own story. The Vegetarian pizza, loaded with olives and peppers, became my instant favorite.
If you crave something different but still want the coziness of pizza, Manzanilla’s creative approach might just win you over.
More Things to Try in Eureka, CA
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of pizza is Eureka known for?
Eureka offers a range of pizza styles, from classic New York thin crust to wood-fired artisan pies. Many local spots take pride in fresh, creative toppings, and you’ll find everything from chewy, hand-tossed slices to crisp, thin-crust options.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Eureka?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias in Eureka, including Brick & Fire Bistro, MOD Pizza, and Manzanilla, offer excellent vegetarian options and vegan-friendly choices, such as dairy-free cheese or plant-based toppings.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Eureka?
Yes, several places—like MOD Pizza and Brick & Fire Bistro—offer gluten-free crusts so everyone can enjoy a slice. Just ask when you order, as options can vary.
What’s the best pizza place for a group or family dinner?
Round Table Pizza and Babe’s Pizza & Pasta are both popular for groups. Their large pies, spacious seating, and friendly atmosphere make them great picks for families or gatherings.
Do any pizza places in Eureka stay open late?
Domino’s is a reliable choice for late-night cravings, delivering until the evening hours on most days. Always check current hours, as they can shift seasonally.
Is there anywhere in Eureka where I can build my own pizza?
MOD Pizza is known for its build-your-own approach. Load up your pie with as many toppings as you like, all for one price. This spot is especially popular with anyone who loves to customize their meal.