Pizza in Emmitsburg, MD, is something of a local legend. Whether you’re hungry after a day at the mountain or you’re just craving something bubbling from a brick oven, the small-town pizzerias work serious magic with dough and sauce. Over the years, I’ve discovered that the best pies aren’t about fancy toppings or Instagram moments—they’re about that first bite when the crust snaps and the cheese stretches just right. That’s a feeling you don’t forget.
Finding the right spot can feel like a quest. Each place here has its own character, from family-run corners to the familiar chains you know. If you’re searching for the perfect slice, you’re in the right place. I’ve scouted the local favorites and unsung heroes, so you can dive straight into the real flavor of Emmitsburg without wasting a meal on dull pizza. Trust me, your next favorite slice could be just around the block.
1. Carleo Italian Pizza
Carleo Italian Pizza sits quietly on Silo Hill Road, but the aroma pulls you in before you reach the door. My first visit was on a drizzly Tuesday—yet the dining room buzzed with regulars. There’s something about the crispy edge on their thin crust that keeps people coming back.
Carleo isn’t flashy, but the pies here have heart. Order the Margherita or the Vegetarian, and you’ll see what I mean. The cheese gets just the right amount of stretch, and the tomato sauce tastes like it simmered all afternoon. They also offer efficient delivery if you prefer your pizza at home.
The friendly staff treats you like a neighbor, and you can tell the kitchen is run by people who care about flavor. Skip the chains—Carleo has the local touch.
2. Pizza Hut
Anyone who’s popped into Pizza Hut on South Seton Avenue knows the vibe—easy, familiar, and filled with that unmistakable scent of rising dough. I’ve made plenty of last-minute stops here after a long drive, often drawn in by memories of classic slices. The staff always keeps things efficient, even if it’s the weekend rush.
The Stuffed Crust pizza never disappoints. There’s a reason it’s a classic: that melty core of cheese levels up the experience. If you’re eating with family or friends, grab a large Supreme for the best balance of toppings and a reliably crispy crust.
You get the reliability of a chain, but in Emmitsburg, that means quick service and consistent flavor. Pizza Hut remains a go-to for comfort food cravings.
3. Stavros Pizza
(301) 447-6767Call
Stavros Pizza on Main Street feels like a piece of old-school Emmitsburg, with a big front window that lets you watch the world go by while your order bakes. My last visit was a spontaneous lunch, and Stavros delivered one of the crispiest, cheesiest pies I’ve had in town. You can tell they care about freshness here—the aroma hits you as soon as you step inside.
Go for their Signature Cheese Pizza if you want to taste the basics done right. The crust has a golden crunch and there’s a gentle balance between sauce and cheese. If you’re feeling adventurous, the Veggie Pizza piles on plenty without losing that classic flavor.
Stavros makes pizza with a real sense of local pride. Parking is easy and the service is always friendly—perfect for a no-fuss meal.
4. Rocky’s New York Pizza
Rocky’s New York Pizza brings a city slice to small-town Maryland. I wandered in on a Friday night, drawn by the promise of classic New York-style pizza without the traffic or crowds. There’s a friendly, relaxed vibe—locals chat over big slices while families tuck into wide, foldable pies.
Their Thin-Crust Cheese Pizza really nails it with that signature snap. Each slice holds up to plenty of toppings, so the Veggie or White Pizza are great picks if you want to branch out. Everything arrives hot, fresh, and ready to fold, just as you’d expect from an honest New York-inspired spot.
Service is quick and the space is easygoing—the kind of place that’s perfect for a laid-back meal or picking up a pie on your way home.
5. Pizza Leone
Pizza Leone on Waynesboro Pike feels like a hidden gem just outside Emmitsburg. My first trip there was pure curiosity and ended with an empty pizza box in the back seat. There’s a comforting charm here that makes you want to stay a bit longer, even after you’ve finished your meal.
Their Classic Cheese and Margherita pies stand out for their light, chewy crust and perfectly melted cheese. If you crave something more unique, try the Bianca—a white pizza that pairs a delicate garlic base with fresh mozzarella. Every pizza balances flavors well, without overdoing it.
Parking is never a hassle and the place is always welcoming. Pizza Leone’s simple, well-executed pizzas make it a repeat destination for anyone nearby.
6. Fratelli’s
(301) 271-0272Call
Fratelli’s on Frederick Road is one of those spots where local chatter and the smell of fresh pizza blend together. I dropped in after a nearby hike, and the welcoming atmosphere hit the spot almost as much as the food. There’s a genuine small-town feeling you don’t get everywhere.
Their New York-Style Cheese Pizza is a must-try—the slice is big, foldable, and comes with a nice tang in the sauce. They also nail the Veggie pizza, layering on peppers, mushrooms, and olives in the right proportions.
If you want pizza that’s hearty without being heavy, Fratelli’s delivers every time. The service is always friendly, and you’ll leave planning your next visit.
7. Rio 7 Pizza Shop
(717) 785-1075Call
Rio 7 Pizza Shop sits quietly in Blue Ridge Summit, but don’t let its low profile fool you. The first time I wandered in, I expected something ordinary. What I got was a hot, substantial pie packed with flavor and freshness. Rio 7 knows how to make pizza that feels homemade without cutting corners.
Their Cheese and Veggie pizzas both shine, thanks to a satisfyingly chewy crust and a bright, savory sauce. You can taste the care in every bite. The menu is simple, making it easy to find a new go-to favorite on each visit.
This shop offers a laid-back setting and friendly service. If you appreciate a straightforward, tasty pizza, Rio 7 delivers every time.
8. King’s New York Pizza
(717) 794-1339Call
King’s New York Pizza on Buchanan Trail East is a classic neighborhood joint that delivers reliability with every order. My first slice here was a spur-of-the-moment decision after a long day, and the generous fold of a classic New York-style pizza didn’t let me down. The no-fuss atmosphere feels right, whether you’re flying solo or gathering a group.
Their Cheese and Veggie pizzas stand out, with a thin yet sturdy crust that walks the line between crisp and chewy. Toppings are always fresh, and the sauce has a mild sweetness that works in every bite. If you’re craving something more, their Sicilian-style pies bring extra thickness and comfort.
Service is quick and the portions are generous. For pizza that gets the New York basics just right, King’s is a local staple.
9. Tommy’s Pizza
Tommy’s Pizza, just up the road in Gettysburg, has earned a devoted following since 1973. My last trip there reminded me why. The place buzzes with families and locals digging in to pizza that manages to please just about everyone. Their pies are always hot out of the oven, with that unmistakable aroma of fresh dough and cheese.
Their Classic Cheese Pizza is a crowd-pleaser, sporting a firm, golden crust and a tangy sauce that hits the spot. If you’re with a group, the veggie pizza delivers variety and color, layering on fresh toppings without turning soggy. Tommy’s also offers a full menu, but it’s the pizza people remember most.
This is the place for classic flavors done right—try it once and you’ll know why people keep coming back.
10. La Bella Italia
(717) 334-1978Call
La Bella Italia on York Street brings a taste of Italy to Gettysburg, and it’s a local favorite for good reason. My first meal there surprised me—fresh, house-made bread and a warm, comfortable vibe set the stage before the pizza even hit the table. It’s a spot where homemade still means something.
Their classic Cheese Pizza is a staple, with a thin, flavorful crust and plenty of gooey, perfectly browned cheese. If you’re after something a little different, their Margherita pizza boasts a fresh tomato flavor and aromatic basil that stand out.
The menu is big, but the pizza shines brightest. La Bella Italia brings real Italian comfort to every slice—simple, satisfying, and well worth the stop.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Emmitsburg, MD?
Top choices include Carleo Italian Pizza, Stavros Pizza, Pizza Hut, and a handful of local gems within a short drive. Each brings its own style—from classic New York thin crust to hearty pies dusted with fresh herbs.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Emmitsburg?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, like Carleo Italian Pizza and La Bella Italia, offer a variety of vegetarian options, so you can enjoy a flavorful pie topped with fresh vegetables and plenty of cheese.
Can I get pizza delivery in Emmitsburg, MD?
Most major spots, such as Pizza Hut and Carleo Italian Pizza, offer delivery and takeout. Call ahead or check their websites to order straight to your door.
Is there a place for quick, family pizza nights around Emmitsburg?
Yes. Pizza Hut and Domino’s are known for speedy service, but local favorites like Stavros Pizza are well suited for casual family dinners with plenty of seating.
Who serves New York-style pizza near Emmitsburg?
You’ll find tasty New York-style slices at places like King’s New York Pizza and Rocky’s New York Pizza. Both deliver the iconic thin, foldable crust and generous cheesy stretch that define the style.