Finding good pizza in Emeryville is almost an art. This city sits at a culinary crossroads—close enough to taste flavors from across the Bay, but small enough that word about new restaurants gets around fast. I’ve sampled doughy slices in roadside huts, picked up late-night pies from strip mall joints, and tucked into more upscale creations with just the right char on the crust. It’s surprising how each spot delivers something a little different, even when the ingredients seem almost the same.
If you think all pizza is created equal, Emeryville will prove you wrong. Some places draw serious crowds with classic New York-style pies. Others pile on inventive toppings or sneak in a dash of local flavor. Whether your tastes run to chewy, crispy, thin, or thick, there’s real satisfaction in discovering your personal favorite. I’ve combed through every hot slice, so you don’t have to. Ready to see where the best pizza in Emeryville is hiding? The list ahead is your one-stop guide.
1. Arthur Mac’s Little shack
Arthur Mac’s Little Shack feels like Emeryville’s best-kept pizza secret. The vibe is laid-back and every visit brings a steady stream of regulars—always a good sign. The wood-fired oven is the star here, producing pizzas with a bubbly, charred crust that’s got just the right amount of chew.
The Margherita stands out for its simplicity and fresh basil, while the Funghi is perfect for mushroom lovers. Both pies come loaded with flavor, and there’s a clear care taken with each ingredient. If you like a hint of heat, the Spicy Honey pizza brings together sweet and savory in a balanced way.
Arthur Mac’s doesn’t try to do too much; they just do pizza right. It’s a place to relax, grab a slice, and enjoy the company.
2. Roba’s Pizza Cafe
Roba’s Pizza Cafe is the definition of a local favorite—friendly, unpretentious, and always ready with a warm smile. The space is compact, but the flavors feel big. Here, the dough is hand-tossed, with plenty of options for vegetarians and traditionalists alike.
The spinach and feta pizza brings a bright, tangy twist, while the vegetarian combo stacks on fresh veggies without skimping on taste. Every slice delivers just the right amount of crunch and tenderness. The staff never rushes you, and ordering takeout is hassle-free for busy days.
Roba’s stands out for its consistency and welcoming charm. It’s the kind of place that turns a regular meal into something to look forward to.
3. Rotten City Pizza
Rotten City Pizza keeps things straightforward but never boring. The counter-style setup brings back memories of grabbing a quick slice in NYC, yet here, it comes with West Coast freshness. Every visit, I end up debating between trying something new or sticking to the classics.
The mushroom truffle pizza is a standout, loaded with earthy flavor and a dose of umami. Their white pie delivers creamy ricotta and garlic that feels both light and indulgent. There’s no pretension, just good pizza with quality ingredients and a crust that strikes the balance between crisp and chewy.
Rotten City is the spot to satisfy a true pizza craving, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a box to go.
4. Arizmendi Bakery & Pizzeria
Arizmendi Bakery & Pizzeria offers a unique Emeryville experience, especially for those who lean toward vegetarian options. I always look forward to their rotating daily pizza—each day brings a new combination of vegetables, cheeses, and herbs, always baked on a perfectly crisp sourdough crust.
If you stumble in on a day with roasted potatoes and rosemary, count yourself lucky. Their cornmeal crust is another highlight, adding a subtle crunch with every bite. Everything feels homemade and thoughtfully sourced, from the dough to the produce.
Arizmendi stands out with its fresh, inventive pies and cozy, bakery-style atmosphere. It’s a spot that makes you want to linger, one slice at a time.
5. Pizzeria mercato
Pizzeria Mercato reimagines classic Neapolitan pizza with a touch of California flair. Walking in, you immediately notice the buzz—open kitchen, aromas of baking dough, and friendly staff guiding you through the menu. The fusion of old and new is clear in every pie they serve.
The Margherita is a must, with bright tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella on a pillowy, leopard-spotted crust. Their Verdura Pizza, brimming with roasted vegetables and fresh herbs, highlights how well Mercato balances tradition and creativity. Both reflect a careful use of top-quality ingredients and smart technique.
This is the place to visit when you want something classic yet unexpected, in a setting that matches the energy of Emeryville itself.
6. Pizza Amigos
Pizza Amigos is the neighborhood go-to when you want pizza with no drama—just solid slices and fast, friendly service. The menu is straightforward but keeps locals coming back, especially at lunchtime. I’ve popped in for a quick bite, only to be pleasantly surprised by the variety offered here.
The Mediterranean pizza shines with its mix of spinach, olives, and feta, delivering fresh flavors that go beyond the ordinary. Their Veggie Delight is another favorite, stacked with crisp bell peppers and juicy tomatoes. The crust is reliably thin and never greasy, making each slice a clean, satisfying snack.
Pizza Amigos stands out for consistency and value—a reliable choice when you want a fresh pie without the wait.
7. Honor Kitchen
Honor Kitchen blends upscale comfort with a playful, modern twist. The restaurant’s stylish interior and lively bar create the kind of space that feels perfect for sharing a meal with friends or relaxing after work. I find myself coming back for their inventive small plates, which always include creative pizzas.
The Mushroom & Truffle Oil pizza deserves special attention. Earthy, rich, and made with fresh herbs, it’s a standout among local offerings. Their Margherita is also excellent—classic, with vibrant tomato sauce and bubbling mozzarella over a chewy, golden crust. Both pies echo Honor Kitchen’s approach: familiar dishes made surprisingly new.
Honor Kitchen stands out by mixing sophistication with comfort food favorites, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Emeryville.
8. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza in Emeryville is all about speed and affordability. Some days, all you want is to grab a hot pizza and go, and this spot makes that possible every time. I’ve found it’s perfect for quick pickups on busy evenings or casual gatherings where you need a crowd-pleaser fast.
The classic Cheese or Veggie pizzas are always ready, hot, and generously topped, making them great options when you don’t want to wait. The crust manages to be soft inside with a bit of crunch on the edges—simple, but satisfying.
Little Caesars stands out for its consistency and value, offering straightforward pies that hit the spot without breaking the bank.
9. California Pizza Kitchen
California Pizza Kitchen is the place to go when you’re after pizza that’s a little out of the ordinary. This Emeryville location brings the signature CPK style: a casual, lively setting and pizzas that lean inventive without being fussy. I’ve enjoyed sitting with friends by the windows, sharing a few different pies over long conversations.
The California Veggie pizza stacks on fresh bell peppers, mushrooms, and crunchy broccoli, all over a perfectly golden crust. Their Sicilian pizza offers bold flavors and a sophisticated style if you want something different from the usual fare.
California Pizza Kitchen stands out by taking classic ideas and giving them a creative, California spin, making every bite memorable.
10. Pizza My Heart
Pizza My Heart captures the spirit of California by offering pizza that’s both approachable and fresh. The Emeryville spot keeps things unfussy, yet there’s a visible attention to quality. It’s become my choice for a quick slice that still feels like a treat after a long day.
The Big Sur pizza packs spinach, garlic, and artichoke hearts onto a golden crust for a satisfying bite. Their Vegetarian is another winner—loaded with colorful, crisp veggies that bring out the best of each ingredient. There’s always a buzz of activity, making it as popular for a casual meal as for a quick lunch stop.
Pizza My Heart stands out for fresh flavors and plenty of variety, keeping every visit just a little different.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Emeryville for dine-in experiences?
Rotten City Pizza and Honor Kitchen both offer inviting atmospheres, perfect for a sit-down meal. Both serve pizzas straight from the oven to your table.
Which spots in Emeryville deliver pizza?
Most major names like Domino’s, Pizza Rustica, and Pizza Amigos offer delivery, as do specialty places such as Arizmendi Bakery & Pizzeria and Little Caesars.
Are there vegetarian-friendly options for pizza in Emeryville?
Absolutely. Arizmendi Bakery & Pizzeria, California Pizza Kitchen, and Roba’s Pizza Cafe are all known for creative vegetarian pies packed with fresh ingredients.
Where can I find pizza by the slice in Emeryville?
Rotten City Pizza and Pizza My Heart both serve pizza by the slice, making them great stops for a quick bite on the go.
Do any pizza places in Emeryville cater to large groups or events?
Yes. California Pizza Kitchen, Lanesplitter Berkeley, and Round Table Pizza can accommodate larger parties and offer catering options. It’s smart to call ahead for bigger gatherings.